Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish my DCs' primary school would stop putting on Newsround every day?

188 replies

minkfondant · 16/11/2021 18:20

Every class at my DCs' school seems to watch Newsround on a daily basis. Today my 8yo came home excitedly saying "A taxi blew up! It was so cool."

On previous occasions, they've come home telling me about things like George Floyd's murder including graphic details of how he was killed and North Korea possibly having nuclear weapons. 10yo asked if I think we'll have WW3 caused by North Korea.

We deliberately avoid watching news with them around, because so much of it is alarming for people who haven't yet got adult perspective on things. News TV is deliberately curated to make it as arresting and attention-grabbing as possible, and obviously concentrates more on the bad stuff than anything else.

Can't they just have a childhood before they're confronted with the dark sides of human nature?

AIBU to wish the school would leave Newsround out of the lesson plans?

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 16/11/2021 22:52

@Cam77

A big part of what’s wrong with the modern world is we’re obsessed with Big Stuff that’s happening 1000s of miles away and which the vast majority of us have virtually zero understanding of the complexities and context: Israel/Palestine, gun crime in the US, the war on drugs, the rise of China, poverty in Africa, etc etc. Aside from a shake of the head and a “how terrible” this stuff is meaningless to 90% of adults and 10x meaningless to children. We need people to start thinking locally and understanding and connecting with issues in our own towns and country first. That’s what primary school should be for - not worrying about North Korean nukes, global meltdown and the middle east.
This attitude pisses me off.

Its not a question of one or the other.

If you haven't learn how what happens in China, affects what happens in your neighbour in the last two years, I do despair.

It is important we know about both local and international issues.

Thing is I don't see much rush to support local news or newspapers by those who think localism is more important than internationalism.

I've banged on about the importance of local issues over the last few years precisely because I recognise there is a problem.

It doesn't stop me from also knowing we have to see the big picture too.

Ultimately kids will be exposed to the Big Bad World out there. I'd rather this happened in a controlled way from a young age.

DS watches at school every day. He loves it. He is only Y2 so younger than most on this thread by the sound of it. He is inspired by stories about volcanos cos they are exciting and its sparking interest. Newsround often has a lot of fluffy stories or stories about geography or history rather than stuff about Big Bad things. It also has stories about things closer to home - but you'd know that if you watched it occassionally or talk to your kids about what they see on it.

Sherrystrull · 16/11/2021 22:50

@rrhuth

I don't know about in other schools but we have it on at snack time.

My view is that having background TV news instead of just space to chat to your friends is a step backwards for kids.

I'd rather my class were eating and drinking in snack time so they can then move onto other things. They can achieve this more effectively watching a short educational programme. If they are encouraged to talk then snack time takes at least double the time. I use this time to do instant intervention with individuals after a lesson. It works brilliantly and then the children can go out at break time and chat and play.
Siameasy · 16/11/2021 22:44

I used to enjoy Newsround and current affairs at that age but I do feel the 24/7 news on a constant loop thing we seem to have today is unnecessary

You’re also not morally superior just because you’re obsessed with the news and it’s fine to switch off from it all. I regularly do as I often can’t be arsed with it.

Hesma · 16/11/2021 22:39

My DD (9) watches new around at school. I think it is important for her to be aware of what is going on in the world in an age appropriate manner

BogRollBOGOF · 16/11/2021 22:32

I used to put Newsround on for my then 8-9yo but stopped shortly before the first lockdown as he was becoming very anxious about Covid and was high risk for being susceptible to OCD behaviours or health anxiety. That doesn't mean he was kept in total ignorance, and he's been updated as cases peaked, rules changed etc, but we've kept to brief headlines of what's happening and avoided the mawkish reptition of news outlets/ current affairs.

I'm also not a great fan of the BBC's editorial on issues like "the climate crisis". That doesn't mean I shelter DS from environmental issues, or think that change of habits isn't worthwhile, but the "climate crisis" is often presented in a simplistic, narrow angle that ignores other slants of environmental change/ damage. Some children can also struggle with anxiety over large crises that they have little influence in.

Newsround is far from inherently bad, but different children do have different trigger points and the way Newsround can be used in a classroom can make it difficult to filter sensitive topics and debrief through areas causing distress.

Other areas of the curriculum may broach into difficult topics but school gives notice on likely books/ topics. The nature of current affairs removes that opportunity to brief parents and give them chance to give feedback in preparation.

00100001 · 16/11/2021 22:26

@Bananabrush

I agree with you and I don’t think the news represents ‘reality’ in a way that’s helpful for adults or children, even if it’s age appropriate. I don’t follow current affairs myself because I find a daily account of all the bad things that happen in the world is terrible for my mental health. Human beings are designed to live in small communities - that is the scale that is comprehensible to us. Knowing about everything that happens everywhere, with no power to influence what happens, is of no use to us. If something really important is happening, you find out via word of mouth anyway and can investigate further if you’re interested. I would be happy with my kids seeing newsround occasionally but I don’t see why they have to be signed up to this constant news culture.
Newsround is hardly a new concept...it's been around daily for decades...
TokyoSushi · 16/11/2021 22:17

We're the complete opposite, we have the news on all the time and my DC (8 & 10) love a good current affairs discussion! Perhaps I'm turning them into mini news geeks!

Bellfor · 16/11/2021 22:13

I don't think my eyes can roll that far back

RedToothBrush · 16/11/2021 22:13

Good god you are unreasonable.

Kids need to learn about the world around them. Including the bad bits. General knowledge is a massively important thing.

You should not shield kids from the news. Not when its deliberately aimed at this age group.

I utterly despair of anyone who actively going out of their way to avoid the news.

Its an essential life skill to know what the fuck is going on beyond your front door and netflix.

Landof · 16/11/2021 22:11

News round is a fantastic way to show children what is happening in a factual child friendly way. Your child would find out about this stuff anyway and it's far better for them to learn through a reliable source than from Jimmy on the playground.

Cici22 · 16/11/2021 22:09

Do you think shielding them from the world will stop them from finding things out? Very Naive parenting from you. The show is made for kids!

Sirzy · 16/11/2021 22:04

Another bonus of watching the news in this way with discussion in class afterwards means children are exposed to different views which should help build critical thinking skills. In tne home children will only be exposed to the views of those in the home so may not learn to question things in the same way.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:57

@Bellfor

80 minutes out of the 1950 minutes they are at school a week? No, it's not a lot. And it's well worth it if it sparks debate. And ticks off some off the English NC too! (Oracy)
Well, yes, I can see it would 'tick off' some stuff - that is why it is being done no doubt!
TatianaBis · 16/11/2021 21:56

@DrBlackbird

Well apparently YABVU OP, but I’m in your corner. My DC would get so distressed by what was on Newsround, but guess they’re just meant to suck it up buttercup and realise that they live in sh*t times. Not allowed a childhood any more dontcha know. Hmm
Some kids are very sensitive. My middle son was very worried by the constant Covid news, but he’s interested in politics in general.

The responses on the thread are rather ironic given the general grasp of news and current affairs on these forums.

Bellfor · 16/11/2021 21:54

80 minutes out of the 1950 minutes they are at school a week? No, it's not a lot. And it's well worth it if it sparks debate. And ticks off some off the English NC too! (Oracy)

UndertheCedartree · 16/11/2021 21:47

I'm not sure if you know what Newsround is? It is a children's programme on CBBC not adult news. From what you've said it would seem good that these topics are being talked about so your 8 yo can learn that a taxi blowing up is not 'cool' in the slightest. Perhaps you need to talk about the real world a bit more as he seems to lack empathy.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:47

[quote Bellfor]@rrhuth have you ever actually watched newsround with a ks2 class? You can't not end up with discussion! It's the way the program is produced.

If there really was absolutely zero discussion fair enough, but in that kind of environment I would guarantee newsround would be the least of the issues with the school/teaching & learning. [/quote]
You only get discussion if there is time allowed for discussion.

I do not believe that can be the case - 5 x 8mins for the programme = 40mins/week, if they do 8 mins discussion too, it would be 80mins/week - that is a LOT for newsround.

That is my point - if they did one per week and did it properly then great.

edwinbear · 16/11/2021 21:45

Oh dear, I think I’ve been parenting wrong. DC (9 & 12) have grown up with the ‘proper’ 6pm news on every night. I’d assumed given its on at 6pm, it was considered suitable. They seem perfectly well adjusted but I’ve obviously not thought this through properly Hmm

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:44

@Tillymintpolo

I watch it in registration with my year 7’s and we have a discussion before they go to lessons
These questions only apply if you do it every day - our school has a different thing each day, one of which is news, but if you do do it everyday:

How do you feel about the research that says too much focus on news increases anxiety and depression in young people?

How do you prevent the news affecting the kids in your class who have these problems?

DrBlackbird · 16/11/2021 21:44

Well apparently YABVU OP, but I’m in your corner. My DC would get so distressed by what was on Newsround, but guess they’re just meant to suck it up buttercup and realise that they live in sh*t times. Not allowed a childhood any more dontcha know. Hmm

Bellfor · 16/11/2021 21:44

@rrhuth have you ever actually watched newsround with a ks2 class? You can't not end up with discussion! It's the way the program is produced.

If there really was absolutely zero discussion fair enough, but in that kind of environment I would guarantee newsround would be the least of the issues with the school/teaching & learning.

coconutmonkey · 16/11/2021 21:42

That seems a bit of a strange comment. It's not about hiding what's going on in the world from children, they hear about things within their families, from each other etc and these things naturally come up in discussion with them. There are also many times where it's appropriate to teach specific key events or link back to stories which have been prevalent in the news. The trouble I have found with Newsround is that more often than not, there is a clear bias which we as adults can discern and then think critically about. Children take it more at face value and aren't as critical of what they're viewing. This goes for social media/YouTube too. We should be teaching them to think critically about the media they're taking in. I would much rather allow them to discuss issues which they're interested in and consider different viewpoints, discuss sources of information and how to become discerning news viewers.
But anyway, that's clearly worrying. I forgot that teachers are merely supposed to fill children up as if they were empty, impressionable vessels.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:42

[quote Grida]@rrhuth how would you teach current affairs in a better way? Bearing in mind the people who make newsround spend their working day researching and producing their content so that it is interesting and appropriate for primary age children. It takes up 7-8mins of class time. Planning and preparation has to take less time than the actual teaching otherwise teachers wouldn’t have time to be in the classroom. I don’t think I could do it better than Newsround.[/quote]
@Grida I taught secondary so my experience with this age is limited, but I would prefer my kids to have had 1 x 40 mins on one episode + pupil engagement than 5 x 8 mins of just watching newsround.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 21:38

@Bellfor

If done everyday with little teacher involvement is not great. They would be better doing one decent session per week. Watching it won't be achieving much and they won;t be spending much time each day talking about it.

Of course kids should do news stories, but watching newsround every day is either perfunctory or is taking up a lot of time in the week.

Tillymintpolo · 16/11/2021 21:37

I watch it in registration with my year 7’s and we have a discussion before they go to lessons