Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people buy animals that can’t afford to keep!

211 replies

Poppets14 · 16/11/2021 17:01

Exactly that!

My friend has just spent 2.5k on a french bulldog. She’s just been ranting at me about the cost of vet treatment (I work for a vet)

She’s moaning that the vaccinations flea and worm treatment has come to £100

So she’s happy to give a breeder 2.5k without blinking an eye but to spend £100 on health care is a problem!

Not sure what response I want really. I get so cross about people spending thousands on puppies and then moaning about the cost of vet treatment!

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 17/11/2021 12:05

@trumpisagit

I think it's that the NHS in comparison, makes it feel like healthcare is free. It's a bit of a shock to pay £40 for a course of antibiotics for a guinea pig, or £12 a month for flea and wormer. That's what it costs though and YANBU
Agreed. I always point this out to people. My trust itemises the cost of things on the A&E discharge notes. Though indict know if the patient sees it. It's something like £20 for a set of obs. My vet. also gives itemised bills. My cats have run up bills of £22k. I thought a laparotomy and a week of intensive care for my cat , was quite good value for £5k!
Champagneforeveryone · 17/11/2021 11:52

[quote Tarne]Unfortunately you will be in for a shock if you rely on pet insurance.

Most have a clause in them where they don't pay out for repeat requests or if the same issue re- occurs.

It is better to set up a saving account and put in it the amount you would have paid monthly for an insurance policy.

That way you have a pot of £ for any eventuality which does not have clauses or restrictions and you get to keep the ££ if your pet is problem free.

In addition to your own saving plan you will need separate third party insurance which you can get for £25 a year for no matter how many dogs you own.

This small nominal annual fee is the cheapest way of getting third party insurance if your dog causes an accident ( gets out onto the road etc).

By joining the Dogs Trust you get this cover and shelter for your dogs if you pass away.

www.dogstrust.org.uk/get-involved/membership/[/quote]
I felt like this until recently, now I would say it's a dangerous piece of advice unless you're extremely financially comfortable.

We routinely stopped insuring our dogs at aged 9 or 10, reasoning that there was a limit as to what we would put them through. We'd never been caught out until our last old boy who cheerfully racked up almost £2k of bills in his final 5 days, before dropping dead anyway.

Fortunately we did have savings for our pets and we keep an emergency credit card as well. Even so it was frightening to see just how fast the costs spiralled. We decided at that point that we would continue with the subsequent insurance policies as long as we could humanly afford it Confused

DuchessAnnogovia · 17/11/2021 11:33

IMO if you welcome a pet into your home, then you must be prepared to make sure it's fed properly with decent food, it's needs are met, and understand that vet treatments can be very expensive! As soon as we got our dog we arranged for medical insurance and a pet plan.

CSIblonde · 17/11/2021 07:39

@Allsortsone .... Argh, it's Animed not Vetmed !!

CSIblonde · 17/11/2021 07:30

@Allsortsone, I get the flea treatment & wormer from Petsathome: deliverered to you for £4 a month. Vetmeds also do similar service at similar price. ( I'll come back if I got their website name wrong but I'm pretty sure it's right). Both sites have a wide choice of cat & dog flea stuff & worming tablets. I always shop around online for pet stuff , it's way cheaper than the vet.

StillWalking · 17/11/2021 07:23

I have a dog and a (currently lame) horse.

The bill for getting horsey’s bad leg diagnosed was well into 4 figures and climbing, for follow up visits and treatments. My horse vet (different vet from the dog vet) charges £75 just to show up at the stables: it’s an expensive business.

I think people look at the NHS as a model and so have absolutely no real idea how much drugs, surgical dressings etc actually cost. Vets charge full price for these things, and for their time on top. Keeping animals is an expensive business and if you’re going to struggle with costs, don’t get one. (Especially not a horse!)

Galacticat · 17/11/2021 06:36

What you have to remember when you are complaining about the cost of medication is that these are set by the supplier. A big Vet group can buy in bulk and so the drugs are cheaper, a small independent can't buy in large quantities and so it costs more. And that's not before the supply issue that's happening at the moment.

We have to import a lot from Europe as we are also farm vets. Its frustrating for us too and each day we will end up with a ton of abuse as people expect us to be a charity and refuse to pay bills .

I also do insure claims and I have a whole day where I only deal with this. I'm chasing clients for excess payments, payments for anything the insurance company won't cover, chasing up the insurance company payments etc . I can see why some vets charge admin fees as its a job in its own right.

Tarne · 17/11/2021 06:35

Likewise all horse and pony owners should have BHS membership for third party cover, legal helpline
etc and also start their own saving plan www.bhs.org.uk/membership

Tarne · 17/11/2021 06:26

Unfortunately you will be in for a shock if you rely on pet insurance.

Most have a clause in them where they don't pay out for repeat requests or if the same issue re- occurs.

It is better to set up a saving account and put in it the amount you would have paid monthly for an insurance policy.

That way you have a pot of £ for any eventuality which does not have clauses or restrictions and you get to keep the ££ if your pet is problem free.

In addition to your own saving plan you will need separate third party insurance which you can get for £25 a year for no matter how many dogs you own.

This small nominal annual fee is the cheapest way of getting third party insurance if your dog causes an accident ( gets out onto the road etc).

By joining the Dogs Trust you get this cover and shelter for your dogs if you pass away.

www.dogstrust.org.uk/get-involved/membership/

lurker69 · 17/11/2021 06:25

@SixteenCakes not all vets deal with small rodents but if you phone around you can find one, my 2 year old hamster had a costly trip a couple of days ago for an eye infection, 2 lots of oral meds and 1 pissed off hamster at having to take it!

Footprintsinthegrass · 17/11/2021 06:20

I used to work for a vet a while ago and the amount of outstanding bills from horse owners was ridiculous. So many of then bounced around different vets leaving huge unpaid bills. I remember a woman calling with horse colic, begging us to send someone 40miles away (out of our usual catxhment), we explained the horse wasn't registered with us and to call her vet, round and round we went with her until we found out she owed thousands to more than one vet and had been very sneaky registering under different names. The vet went out in the end because he wouldn't let the animal suffer, he made her pay £50 up front but thats all he saw

DetMcNulty · 17/11/2021 05:45

My boy was a rescue, so didn't cost me much up front, but as he's so big all his ongoing vet bills are super expensive. He's also very accident prone, and eats anything, so has had over $26k in surgeries, and has allergies that cost $300 per month (never mind his foodbill). Luckily we do have good insurance, which is also not cheap, but does lessen the blow when he's eaten some poisonous nuts and needs his liver saving. I don't know how most could cough up those sums if no insurance.

Allsorts1 · 17/11/2021 05:07

@Hippychicken1 that’s good :) I know there are some better bred ones out there and I have hope that breeders will start trending away from the extreme flat face to get more balance in the breed.

Allsorts1 · 17/11/2021 05:05

@CSIblonde do you mind sharing where you get your flea stuff online? Ours is £50 a month from the vet!

Hippychicken1 · 17/11/2021 04:29

@Allsorts1
Not all french bulldogs are unhealthy
Mines almost 2 and apart from being castrated recently he only goes to the vet every six months to be weighed for his ongoing flea & worming treatment
He’s not overweight, no allergies, no breathing problems a good example of what the breed should be like

Allsorts1 · 17/11/2021 03:54

I shudder at people with French bulldogs - they have so many health problems. Also boggles my mind when people get really huge dogs - they must be so expensive to feed well!

We chose our dog because they are a generally low health problem breed, and a medium size that only costs around £8-12 a week to feed on really high quality raw food. People don’t seem to think of additional factors beyond trendiness or looks.

But I also have much empathy because it’s extremely easy to get caught up in the emotion of it all when choosing a puppy (and also I think I might have just lucked out that the breed I was most attracted to was a healthy standard faced breed).

More education is key I think - maybe a campaign comparing lifetime health outcomes of well bred dogs vs brachycephalic (flat faced) dogs.

Cameleongirl · 17/11/2021 03:37

My dog was adopted so we paid basic fees to acquire him, but we’ve just paid US$1,300 for a dental cleaning, a minor ailment that needed antibiotics and a year’s supply of tick/flea/heart worm medication.😟. He had his annual checkup and some vaccination earlier this year, I can’t remember what they cost.

So no, pets ain’t cheap and you need to think carefully before committing to one!

Saoirse82 · 17/11/2021 03:17

Even with pet insurance it can still be costly to have a pet. Our dog has a problem with his eyes meaning his face absolutely stinks unless he has 4 weekly injections costing £62 a go, he's only 2 so it's likely on injections alone it'll cost us £10,000 over his life time. Then he's groomed every 4 weeks costing £20-30 each time. And that's before you factor in the typical costs of a dog and standard vets bills, even we didn't think it would be so costly to be dog owners but he's family so what can you do 🤷‍♀️. But it's ridiculous for your friend to pay out crazy money for a dog prone to health problems and then complain about a pretty minor vets bill. It's absolutely cruel to get a pet an not provide adequate health care for them. They ought to be more strict about who can own animals, its a lifetime commitment.

salsmum · 17/11/2021 02:58

Please don't tar all bulldog owners with the same brush... we had our beautiful
bully for just 2 years, we knew she had dwarfism and we are long standing bulldog owners albeit staffies that lived to a ripe old age of 16 years each so well experienced in that field. Although our baby came from a top breeder once her disabilities were apparent breeder put pups into this rescue, because of her dwarfism etc we could not insure her (!The rescue said), we knew her condition was life limiting but following a routine vets visit she collapsed and died at home from a massive heart attack ( aged 3) just an hour after returning from the vets. We're no wealthy but we're prepared too spend our last £1 on her vets fees if needed and our other rescues too. Yes bulldogs are a specialist breed and with any breed thorough research is needed before buying.

AnnieSnap · 17/11/2021 02:49

@tillytoodles1

Some vets are money grabbers though. My cat had fleas so I rang the vet for Advocate and she said I'd need an appointment to see the vet first. I replied that the cat was fine, I just needed the stuff. She said that the cat had to he weighed so I asked her couldn't she do that. She could. I got the stuff, treated the cat and she's fine.
The British Veterinary Association requires registered vets to have seen an animal within 6 months if they are to prescribe anything for it. So telling you the pet had to see the vet before they supply Advocate wasn’t money grabbing. They were constrained by the rules of their professional body!

Vet’s do vary though of course. When my lovely aforementioned Standard Poodle had cancer at the age of 11-years-old (I forgot to mention that in my previous list of illness and injuries). She had surgery and did well. It pretty much always comes back in dogs though and I was fairly sure (based on Vet’s advice and previous experience) that she would have a year of decent health before it did. I told my vet that as she would be old by then, this was the one and only surgery. After that it would be palliative care only until she was too uncomfortable/distressed/in pain. She actually had 18 months, which was great. When she developed another tumour, my vet agreed with my decision and said she’d do the same if it was her dog. Then I moved house and vet practice to my current one. The Vet I always try to have my animals see, is fabulous and agreed with me. One time though, I had to take my lovely girl to see the senior partner and he tried (and failed) to persuade me to put her through more surgery. The occasional money grabbers invariably own the practice concerned.

FlowerArranger · 17/11/2021 02:47

I don’t have insurance for my animals because, my calculations over many years have confirmed to me that it’s more cost effective not too.

This is probably true for most pets, and it is my choice too.

Sadly, many Brits have little awareness of the true cost of healthcare. Vets are self-employed and need to make a living. The cost of running a medical practice, whether it's for humans or animals, is enormous.

Any sensible person who buys a car will plan ahead for when it needs replacing. Similarly, anyone who gets a pet should think ahead and plan for the final years of its life as these will be the most expensive.

My lovely cat cost me very little for the first 17 years of her life. Yearly check-up and vaccinations, plus the odd course of antibiotics if she got into a fight with the local tom. Her 18th year probably cost as much as the previous 17 years combined. But she was worth every penny.

AnnieSnap · 17/11/2021 02:25

I don’t have insurance for my animals because, my calculations over many years have confirmed to me that it’s more cost effective not too. I’ve had dogs and cats for 40 years and more recently hens (who also get taken to the vet if they are ill). Because I have two Siamese Cats and two Poodles (over the last 20 years, before that a Rottweiler, a Weimaraner and two Siamese), I’d have to insure 4 of them and they are all mainly healthy (bought from tested lines). So it’s impossible to judge which one will needs veterinary treatment. One of my Standard Poodles (sadly, no longer with me) was termed the bionic dog, as she had metalwork for a leg injury, ligament surgery, she had Gastric torsion (at midnight, so the emergency vet). She had emergency major surgery, had her stomach stapled to to her ribs to prevent it happening again. She wasn’t expected to survive and was in intensive care for two days. There were expensive bills for all these procedures, but taking account of the excesses and climbing monthly premiums as she got older, it still cost me less than insurance would have done over those years! I could afford to pay for large bills out of the blue though, for anyone who can’t, insurance is a must surely.

It is disgusting, not to mention stupid, for people on modest incomes to pay thousands for a trendy puppy, without the ongoing means to take care of it properly. That said, some that can afford a vet’s bill seem to take issue with having to pay one though. I know someone who has 5 cats and bought an expensive puppy in lockdown. Then one of her cats became ill, needing treatment and she set up a Go Fund me page to get others to pay for it! She and her partner work full time and lead a nice, if relatively modest lifestyle (two cars, meals out, holidays), but don’t see vet’s fees as their own responsibility! 🤷‍♀️

MangoSeason · 17/11/2021 01:41

@LittleDandelionClock

WTF is this obsession with French Bulldogs FFS? Hmm

Is it just so they can say they spent £2.5K on a fucking DOG? Why not just get a mongrel? Why is it always expensive dogs? And then, (as you say @Poppets14 they moan about the upkeep.)

Vet bills are extortionate, and we have been stung this year with our cats. Put me off having pets for good. Vet fees for dogs are fierce.

I know a local French Bulldog breeder. We live in the tropics. For more than half the year, the temp doesn’t dip below 20 degrees c, even at night. He breeds a brachycephalic breed in the tropics and sells them for an unbelievable sum to people who usually also live in the tropics. It is madness and extremely cruel to have a brachycephalic breed in the tropics.

Sometimes he sells them to people 1000s of kilometres away. In Australia, airlines ban the transport of brachycephalic breeds so it is a horrific multi day road trip for these barely weaned pups. 😡

flirtygirl · 17/11/2021 01:26

Not all pets cost lots of money. Worming can be done very cheaply if you shop around. I know many people whose pets have not cost them a fortune.

On silly breeds which suffer inherent illnesses:
Dumb people make dumb choices, so those buying those type of breeds, you would wonder....

I also don't agree with cancer treatments and expensive treatments for old pets or seriously ill pets with not much chance of survival, why do people pay out thousands? They had a choice for a ethical death.

I also think this way for humans let alone pets. I don't understand why those who are 80 or 90 would bother go through cancer treatment or other painful treatment. I would personally opt to be made and kept comfortable till death. I see this as more ethical.

I would not subject myself to this, let alone my aging much loved pet.

But not everyone thinks like me.

Champagneforeveryone · 17/11/2021 01:15

Following on from my earlier post, I do think prices have shot up beyond what most people would have expected. Some years ago I had 5 dogs, we are far more financially secure now and the thought of what they would cost now makes me feel quite unwell.

And with thanks to the posters who have listed what their pets cost each month. I've just had a rough tally of ours and it's rather shocking Wink