Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people buy animals that can’t afford to keep!

211 replies

Poppets14 · 16/11/2021 17:01

Exactly that!

My friend has just spent 2.5k on a french bulldog. She’s just been ranting at me about the cost of vet treatment (I work for a vet)

She’s moaning that the vaccinations flea and worm treatment has come to £100

So she’s happy to give a breeder 2.5k without blinking an eye but to spend £100 on health care is a problem!

Not sure what response I want really. I get so cross about people spending thousands on puppies and then moaning about the cost of vet treatment!

OP posts:
DaisyWaldron · 18/11/2021 07:02

I really want a dog, and look longingly at the rescue greyhound websites, but we can't afford the insurance costs, so a dog will have to wait until the children have grown up and started supporting themselves.

Gohugatree · 18/11/2021 06:57

As pp have pointed out, the perception of keeping animals alive in old age has changed over the years and I do sometimes think we intervene medically more than is helpful to our pets.

Once insurance becomes commonplace, prices start to increase - for anything where insurance is involved, not just for animals.

The worst thing I ever saw at a vet surgery was a lout who'd brought a 'status' dog in for some extensive treatment, funded by PDSA, who started abusing the receptionist when she pointed out the PDSA collection tin and said they'd appreciate a donation, however small.

Cissyandflora · 18/11/2021 06:47

@Astrak

My new-to-me cat gifted himself to me. He arrived, looking very much the worse for wear. Scrawny, bedraggled and very loud. He's still loud, but looking good. Insured to the hilt. Ditto the horse. They're my best mates. They get the best of everything. I sometimes go without food, but they never will.
You’re great. My type of person
Tumbleweed101 · 18/11/2021 06:43

My dog just had an op that cost more than I get paid each month. I had to pay up front then claim on insurance so it can be a problem. Financial circumstances have changed since we got her 12yrs ago. She also needs a second op that won’t be covered by insurance now so I will find that a massive strain on finances.

Regular costs should be factored in to having pets it’s the unplanned ones that cost a months wages that are tricky to deal with. Looking through the receipt some things seems excessively expensive, especially the drugs/medication ones rather than those involving the vets skill.

FawnFrenchieMum · 18/11/2021 06:40

We have a Frenchie rescue, honestly they have a the absolute best personalities. He was 3-4 when we reduced him but we fully researched the coat first. His insurance is ridiculous per month but we knew that before taking him on. We make sure he has the best food for his breed etc. He’s actually really fit for a flat faced dog (loved to play with his whippet friends!). So far we’ve only paid for his annual boosters and for him to be castrated (could have claimed this back from the rescue but didn’t bother).

We would love to rescue a second but we can’t comfortably afford the insurance for a second so can’t.

I regularly volunteer to help out with transport and fundraising for Frenchie rescues though as lots of them come in because owners can’t afford to give them the care needed.

Cissyandflora · 18/11/2021 06:38

@nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut

I spent a tenner on a hamster and over 200 on vet care when he got sick. Sadly he never recovered and was put down after a day on oxygen and fluids. Do I regret it? No, and I'd do it again. I made a commitment when I bought him that I would care for him and that includes medical treatment when needed. I loved him and never would have let him suffer.

If you can't afford the medical care or insurance, don't buy the animal.

This is so lovely to read. I’m exactly the same. Once I make a commitment to care for a pet I’m all in. Food, medical support, anything and everything it needs.
ViceLikeBlip · 18/11/2021 06:29

It's particularly awful when people seem to have more money for blingy accessories than they do for actual veterinary care for the animal.

That said, I don't judge people who make the decision not to shell out for very costly treatment to keep an animal going for a few more months. I think it's perfectly acceptable (I mean it's sad-I'm not a monster! But still, acceptable) to have an animal put to sleep following a terminal diagnosis.

Anotherhill · 18/11/2021 06:15

[quote AnnieSnap]@Cameleongirl DH and I have had Rabies vaccines for travelling in India, but no, we don’t have rabies in the UK. An advantage of living on a relatively small island.[/quote]
And hopefully will stay that way, although with the huge amount of dog imports I fear it may just be a matter of time.

Another vet here, and would like to clarify a few things.
Regarding price increases - 25 years ago we used to have 5 minute appointments -we’d literally have time to glance at the pet, dish out medication ( often antibiotics+/-steroids) and write up notes. Now we have 15 minute appointments, 30 minutes in lockdown and still 30 minutes for certain things that require more time.
We have always had to do extra training, which tells us what we should be doing for certain conditions. Someone complained about blood pressure monitoring -it’s good practice especially in older cats with other conditions. So a vet who is doing good work is basically getting criticised.

Happychicken1 - you obviously love your dog, but please don’t feed antlers or they’ll end up with broken teeth.

Regarding not insuring - You may be able to afford a one off issue of ££2000, but are you in a position of affording say £250 a month if you end up with a dog with several treatable conditions?

People who complain about dental work - dentals are always done last - so a long dental will encroach into lunchtime. The vet won’t get paid any more if they take out lots of teeth, but they may lose a chance to sit down to eat. Vets don’t take teeth out unless they need to come out. Regarding insurance for dentals - lots of policies do cover them, so check with your policy. They will often insist on the dental work being done within a set time of you having been told about it though, so don’t wait to get it booked in.

Simonjt · 18/11/2021 05:34

@TheBullfinch

A lot of new owners also dont realise that pet insurance doesnt cover everything. Dental treatment and tooth extraction/general anaesthetic/anti-biotics etc.. You can easily pay a few hundred a year for insurance plus thousands on top of that before you even get to food and boarding costs. Boarding is £10 a night here and food is around £15 - £20 a week.
Poor quality insurance doesn’t cover dentals, decent insurance does.
AnnieSnap · 18/11/2021 01:51

@Cameleongirl DH and I have had Rabies vaccines for travelling in India, but no, we don’t have rabies in the UK. An advantage of living on a relatively small island.

Cameleongirl · 18/11/2021 01:06

@AnnieSnap. Really? I genuinely didn’t know that, I didn’t have a dog when I lived in the UK, I’m only familiar with American dog ownership! I wish we didn’t have rabid wildlife here, but we do. Last month, a dog walker was attacked by a coyote in some local woods…the poor man had to have anti-rabies shots, his dog was fine as he’d already been vaccinated.😂

idiotmagnet · 18/11/2021 00:27

@shouldistop

I wish they would ban the breeding of these poor flat faced dogs that struggle to breathe. Its awful to listen to them gasping for breath.
Watched in disbelief as two of these were wheeled passed me in a double buggy the other day. I heard them before I saw them because they were gasping for breath. My greyhound barely recognised them as being of the same species...
AnnieSnap · 18/11/2021 00:12

@Cameleongirl

Not to mention rabies, they need that every three years. I’m not risking having a rabid dog in the house!
That’s not a thing in the UK
Cameleongirl · 17/11/2021 23:25

Not to mention rabies, they need that every three years. I’m not risking having a rabid dog in the house!

Pawprintpaper · 17/11/2021 23:13

“A dog has built up immunity to boosters by average age 6
Just a money making scheme by vets.
Waste of money“

This is incorrect - immunity to parvovirus and distemper lasts much longer but immunity to leptospirosis only lasts around 12 months, is not reliably indicated by serology and is the most common disease out of those we vaccinate for, which we actually see…. Oh and is also communicable to humans, and can be fatal.

So dogs mixing with other dogs or having potential access to rats do need annual vaccinations

HTH

XenoBitch · 17/11/2021 23:11

@scaevola

Was discussing this with my sibling today at how vets must earn a shit tonne of money because people have to pay for it

Average income for a vet is around £50k (range £40-70k)

Doctors are paid considerably more - once qualified and starting specialist training, it's £40-55k, consultants £85-115k. Salaried GPs £62-94k

Not just that, the money that you pay at the vets does not go into their pocket. It pays for all the staff, equipment, rent, maintenance etc. I would think that about 50p of a consultation actually makes it into an individual vet's pay packet, probably less.
scaevola · 17/11/2021 22:52

Was discussing this with my sibling today at how vets must earn a shit tonne of money because people have to pay for it

Average income for a vet is around £50k (range £40-70k)

Doctors are paid considerably more - once qualified and starting specialist training, it's £40-55k, consultants £85-115k. Salaried GPs £62-94k

fleurbelle · 17/11/2021 22:37

@Sloth66

Why buy these trendy designer dogs that have been bred to have numerous awful health issues?
Because some of us rescue them.
middleager · 17/11/2021 22:37

YANBU.
I have one cat. At one point I had three, all rescue, but sadly no longer here.
I'd love more cats and a dog, but can't justify the living costs. We both work full time.

Yet I have a friend who pleads poverty (yet has top phones, full Sky package, eats out several times a week, big holidays etc) but has various cats, rabbits, dogs, including designer breeds from puppy farms. The pets eat the finest food and the cost must be astronomical.

She previously gave away her dogs, yet bought more and writes sanctimonious FB posts.
I wish humans could be vetted for suitability.

Another friend lives on a main road. Previous cats run over. She now has several new kittens.

fleurbelle · 17/11/2021 22:29

[quote Hippychicken1]@Allsorts1
Not all french bulldogs are unhealthy
Mines almost 2 and apart from being castrated recently he only goes to the vet every six months to be weighed for his ongoing flea & worming treatment
He’s not overweight, no allergies, no breathing problems a good example of what the breed should be like[/quote]
Yay!
I'm glad.
Happy to hear this from a fellow Frenchie mum.

fleurbelle · 17/11/2021 22:26

[quote Hippychicken1]@ColinTheKoala
My BMW X3 is cheaper to insure than my french bulldog 😂[/quote]
My car is too 😌

BunsOfAnarchy · 17/11/2021 22:24

I have a beautiful Dcat. My boy was pricey, I had originally set to get a kitten, then lockdown hit and prices doubled.
Managed to get him at a price and he's had 2nd vacs, castration and he's only on the 'good' food.
I never tally up the cost. Because he is a member of my family. Yes it costs but its worth it.
I saw a girl complaining at the vets about the cost of some antibiotics whilst wearing Canada Goose jacket, and those grotesque expensive trainers and lip fillers and my eyes rolled right outta my head. I'm not judging their appearance but they clearly have money for vanity, they should cough up for the health of their family pet.
Don't get a pet if you can't or won't pay for their upkeep. Simples

fleurbelle · 17/11/2021 22:24

@RAFHercules

We have a 13 year old rescue dog, he has yearly boosters and his worm meds but he's never even needed flea treatment. The cat is semi wild, just turned up one day, not chipped, vet asked if we could keep her for a few weeks to see if her owner turned up and she's still here 25 years later. Again no vet fees other than yearly vax and wormers. The vets haven't made much profit from our mongrels Wink Once the nurse did sell me a bottle of malaseb shampoo for £28 as she found a pink patch on him whilst giving him his booster, but the pink patch had vanished by the time I got him homeGrin. We donated the shampoo to a rescue centre.
A dog has built up immunity to boosters by average age 6 Just a money making scheme by vets. Waste of money
fleurbelle · 17/11/2021 22:21

She's a fucking idiot who has not done any research on the breed.

museumum · 17/11/2021 22:18

@Poppets14

It’s crazy. I work for a vet so I’m lucky to have staff discount and even with that I cannot afford a dog!

I know people that spend over £400 a month on medication. I just think people see cute dogs and want one but have no idea the cost when things go wrong!

I’ve not owned a cat or dog as an adult so am probably horribly naive but I would be shocked to find £400 a month on medication was normal!