Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people buy animals that can’t afford to keep!

211 replies

Poppets14 · 16/11/2021 17:01

Exactly that!

My friend has just spent 2.5k on a french bulldog. She’s just been ranting at me about the cost of vet treatment (I work for a vet)

She’s moaning that the vaccinations flea and worm treatment has come to £100

So she’s happy to give a breeder 2.5k without blinking an eye but to spend £100 on health care is a problem!

Not sure what response I want really. I get so cross about people spending thousands on puppies and then moaning about the cost of vet treatment!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ponoka7 · 19/11/2021 08:58

I don't think that it's just dogs. Rabbits are the cost of a small dog which is why so many are up for rehoming. I think that it's something that should be addressed in schools.
My DD'S friend took her children to the fair and came back with goldfish. My DD already had unused tank but it still cost me £15 to set it up. The friend's attitude was 'they're only fish'.

pointythings · 19/11/2021 08:57

@Heyha

But with rescue it's that age old problem of lots of people not fitting the bill- we have a rescue spaniel but that was done through 'this dog needs a home' friends. If we went to rescue now we'd be turned away from most because we have a small child and (dog savvy) cats, we don't have 6ft panel fencing all round our sizeable garden and we use a dog walker two days a week in term time when DP is in the office. The fact we've already got a dog that we've had to do a bit of rehab with and the vets would happily give references that he gets all his entitlements wouldn't cut much mustard I'm sure.
Agree that a lot of rescues, especially the big national players, have become unreasonable in their demands. My moggies come from a small local place that's much more sensible. The main condition is that if the rehoming doesn't work out, they have to come back to where they were originally rehomed from, which I think is fair. Not that it's going to happen to my two.
Heyha · 19/11/2021 08:51

But with rescue it's that age old problem of lots of people not fitting the bill- we have a rescue spaniel but that was done through 'this dog needs a home' friends. If we went to rescue now we'd be turned away from most because we have a small child and (dog savvy) cats, we don't have 6ft panel fencing all round our sizeable garden and we use a dog walker two days a week in term time when DP is in the office. The fact we've already got a dog that we've had to do a bit of rehab with and the vets would happily give references that he gets all his entitlements wouldn't cut much mustard I'm sure.

Supermohican · 18/11/2021 22:04

@plominoagain

We’ve always somehow ended up with rescue animals . The cats that were abandoned by our neighbours who buggered off to Spain one January having got fed up of trying to live the good life , leaving behind dogs , cats, turkeys , you name it . One now refuses to leave the house and spends his time asleep on my daughters bed . The other two live in my neighbour’s houses , being similarly spoiled . The five problem horses I’ve taken out of the hands of people with more money than sense , over the years . The Redwings pony I’m now a guardian to . The two new ferals who alternate between hissing ferociously at me , or trying to climb on me for dinner , and who have taken to sleeping in my porch at night .

But I’ve never taken an animal on , without doing the costings first . The dogs are insured to the hilt , including dental , and I make damn sure all their jabs and checks are up to date so the insurance pays out . Likewise I know that even for two field ornaments , I’m still looking at £40 a week in feed and hay replacer mash for the toothless 43 year old , and £60 a month in feet trims , and I know that’s mates rates . Plus £40 a month in hay . I don’t scrimp because that way lies disaster .

But others do . One of my other neighbours is a horse hoarder . She has 10 animals on 2 acres of land . She does nothing with them . I know they haven’t had their feet looked at in over 6 months , because she’s blacklisted by every farrier for miles for not paying her bills . Likewise our local hay merchant doesn’t drop the hay till he’s got the cash in his hand. And yet she professes to be an expert , with about a dozen dogs too .

And yet her kids breakfast is Weetabix and water because she can’t afford milk . I’ve fed her kids more lately ( my dcs are friends and they come to visit ) than I think she has . Did I report her to social services . Yes I bloody well did and I don’t care if she finds out . She should lose the animals and look after those poor kids .

It makes me feel ill seeing perfectly lovely animals in need of rescue overlooked for pedigree animals. Mine are all rescues too. My local park is awash with cockerpoos in Burberry harnesses.
plominoagain · 18/11/2021 22:01

We’ve always somehow ended up with rescue animals . The cats that were abandoned by our neighbours who buggered off to Spain one January having got fed up of trying to live the good life , leaving behind dogs , cats, turkeys , you name it . One now refuses to leave the house and spends his time asleep on my daughters bed . The other two live in my neighbour’s houses , being similarly spoiled . The five problem horses I’ve taken out of the hands of people with more money than sense , over the years . The Redwings pony I’m now a guardian to . The two new ferals who alternate between hissing ferociously at me , or trying to climb on me for dinner , and who have taken to sleeping in my porch at night .

But I’ve never taken an animal on , without doing the costings first . The dogs are insured to the hilt , including dental , and I make damn sure all their jabs and checks are up to date so the insurance pays out . Likewise I know that even for two field ornaments , I’m still looking at £40 a week in feed and hay replacer mash for the toothless 43 year old , and £60 a month in feet trims , and I know that’s mates rates . Plus £40 a month in hay . I don’t scrimp because that way lies disaster .

But others do . One of my other neighbours is a horse hoarder . She has 10 animals on 2 acres of land . She does nothing with them . I know they haven’t had their feet looked at in over 6 months , because she’s blacklisted by every farrier for miles for not paying her bills . Likewise our local hay merchant doesn’t drop the hay till he’s got the cash in his hand. And yet she professes to be an expert , with about a dozen dogs too .

And yet her kids breakfast is Weetabix and water because she can’t afford milk . I’ve fed her kids more lately ( my dcs are friends and they come to visit ) than I think she has . Did I report her to social services . Yes I bloody well did and I don’t care if she finds out . She should lose the animals and look after those poor kids .

Supermohican · 18/11/2021 21:39

Definitely seen posters on here refusing to take small animals like hamsters to the vet.

Supermohican · 18/11/2021 21:38

@Hodgehog

We need a licence to own any live animal. As posts here have shown people who seem otherwise to have a degree of sense with other animals don’t think or realise smaller animals need proper care and medical treatment too.
Yes, completely agree. The animals suffer, particularly those bought from puppy farms and BYB.
DirtyBlonde · 18/11/2021 21:27

Sorry to frivol, but does that mean someibe from the DEFRA will come and remove unlicensed headlice?

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 17:30

@Hodgehog

We need a licence to own any live animal. As posts here have shown people who seem otherwise to have a degree of sense with other animals don’t think or realise smaller animals need proper care and medical treatment too.
A hamster tax? I have heard it all now.
AnnieSnap · 18/11/2021 17:28

I agree with @Jayne35 that licenses for dogs. All they would be is a useless tax on responsible dog owners.

Jayne35 · 18/11/2021 16:20

I agree that people should think more seriously about the cost of owning a dog, I don't think licenses would help though as it would only be the responsible owners that bothered to get one - and they are already aware of the costs, have had dog training lessons and have insurance. It wouldn't be policed so would be pointless.

We have a dog, bought as a puppy during lockdown for £1.3k, but it's our third dog and we are aware of the expense (apart from it's our first cocker spaniel and I didn't realise how much grooming they need!)

Hodgehog · 18/11/2021 15:16

We need a licence to own any live animal. As posts here have shown people who seem otherwise to have a degree of sense with other animals don’t think or realise smaller animals need proper care and medical treatment too.

HereticFanjo · 18/11/2021 13:33

@Poppets14

Exactly that!

My friend has just spent 2.5k on a french bulldog. She’s just been ranting at me about the cost of vet treatment (I work for a vet)

She’s moaning that the vaccinations flea and worm treatment has come to £100

So she’s happy to give a breeder 2.5k without blinking an eye but to spend £100 on health care is a problem!

Not sure what response I want really. I get so cross about people spending thousands on puppies and then moaning about the cost of vet treatment!

Your friend is an idiot. The end.
Nandiniti · 18/11/2021 13:33

I feel strongly that a licence should be reintroduced for pet (at least dog and cat) ownership. I don't know exactly what that would look like or what exemptions there might be, but it might put a stop to the stupidity of idiots buying animals they don't understand and can't afford, AND buying/training an animal as a trophy or a weapon.

There should be a bloody entrance exam too.

pastypirate · 18/11/2021 13:26

It's crazy. We chose a cocker partly for breed strength and hardiness - looking at common health issues was part of the prep for getting another dog!!

VioletCreams · 18/11/2021 13:22

Omg! Yes!

I too work in a vet and we see so many Frenchies, all with problems requiring surgeries such as BOAS, Spinal issues, puppies with fractured elbows, etc. Some do have decent insurance but the rest have either no insurance or have gone for the cheapest of the cheap policies that have a £1000 policy limit. Totally enrages me!! I don’t understand why they buy a dog that costs £2.5k+, not insure it and then complain about costs!

pastypirate · 18/11/2021 13:17

It's not just the health care it's the babysitting. I have a dog who got kicked out of doggy day care because he doesn't like puppies so I have to fit my working hours around him.
At least he comes on holiday with me.

The bunny goes to a small animal hotel which is a v reasonable £3.50 a night but the nearest one is 45 minutes away.

Champagneforeveryone · 18/11/2021 13:12

A case in point here, DDog1 managed to get himself tangled up in some barbed wire yesterday.

£127 and no serious ill effects later, we will cancel going out for lunch on Sunday in lieu of the vets bill, but no big deal. It's too small to claim on his insurance but is still a chunk out of our monthly budget which thankfully we are able to absorb. Completely unexpected though and utterly unavoidable

pastypirate · 18/11/2021 09:45

Yanbu. I have a spaniel who is v cheap to run after his initial £800 outlay - he has a flea and working programme and jabs I think it's £14 a month. He is never ill.

The bloody rabbit....has cost me far more over a shorter period and we are getting another one in the new year and they are getting fecking insured the little buggers. If you didn't know rabbits are at high risk of gi stasis when their gut packs up. If I call the vet they will drop everything to see my bunny due to high risk of death!!

I knew the op would be about a French bulldog before I even opened it.

LucentBlade · 18/11/2021 09:38

Almost 30 years ago I worked in a public library for a few years before I went off to University. My hamster had an issue with her eye, she ended up having eyedrops and they cost about £20 which was loads then. My boss let me keep her under the counter at work for a couple of days so I could keep watch over her. When she eventually died a few months later she was buried in the garden of the library as I had no garden and lived in a little flat. When her sister died the following year, they were Russian dwarf hamsters so were a pair she joined her. My boss was pretty amazing overall.

It’s very hard administering eyedrops to a hamster.

Pawprintpaper · 18/11/2021 09:18

Another foible of the pet owning public I have observed (particularly those without long term insurance cover) is the difficulty accepting that animals get conditions that cannot be cured, only managed. Most people accept that their own medical conditions might be chronic (asthma, eczema, rheumatoid arthritis etc) but moan when their animal improves on treatment and relapses when the tablets finish, despite every effort to manage their expectations.

Also, the willingness of (most) human patients to accept lots of scans and blood tests to get a definitive diagnosis for their own medical condition, but expect vets to diagnose everything under the sun by giving a lump a squeeze or running one simple blood test.

And thirdly the disconnect between the fact that serious illnesses are typically difficult and expensive to treat, and also tend to have a worse prognosis. Therefore, unfortunately, there is sometimes an inverse relationship between the cost of treatment and the likelihood of success. Although some treatments/operations are absolutely joyful in the amount of difference they make, so it’s not a reason to be pessimistic, but definitely something clients need to be counselled about and understand before consenting go treatment.

Glenthebattleostrich · 18/11/2021 09:12

I did a full financial breakdown of how much my pooch would cost.

Puppy adoption fee £275 (more because she was a cute puppy! We originally went to meet a staffie but she was reserved when we got there)
Insurance £30
Food and treats £150
Dog walker £200
pet sitter £20 (for when we are out for more than 2 hours, she doesn't like being alone but will happily sleep in my bed with the lovely teen downstairs watching TV!
flea and wormer £10
jabs, vet check and general other stuff £250 ish a year

We got her at 10 weeks, she broke her leg at 16 weeks costing us £2000 over what insurance would pay. The rescue offered to take her back but there was no way we were giving her up. She is our responsibility and we happily take care of her.

I really don't understand people who don't care for their pets.

Our guinea pigs cost is a bloody fortune and we had to go 100 miles to a specialist vet because they are such useless delicate fluffballs. I'm pretty sure their house cost more than my first flat, it was certainly a similar size 🤣

Orangesox · 18/11/2021 08:33

YA most definitely NBU! People are mostly idiots when it comes to practicalities of pet ownership. We waited 11 years to get a pup after our last family dog died; our last dog drained our finances due to intractable epilepsy and we didn’t want to be in the position again that we had to decide between the dogs medication and blood tests, or eating that week.

I have been accused of “gatekeeping” before when I’ve suggested to a close friend that they couldn’t afford a new dog when they asked me to look over the sums, all animals need more than the bare minimum of the cheapest available food and hoping that they don’t need any veterinary treatment… it shouldn’t take a genius to work that out. The actual purchase is the cheapest part, regardless of how “designer” the animal is.

hettie · 18/11/2021 07:19

Dunno....doggo is a money pit (but we knew that and luffs him anyways)... Actually I do kind of know..Put simply lots and of people are poor consequential thinkers, they dont plan ahead or consider consequences. I actually think this is a national issue (something in our gene pool)? We don't as a nation tend to be very good at long term planning ... It's like everything takes us by surprise (the impacts of an aging population, lack of investment in education and training or infrastructure...the consequences of telling the very close very large trading block that we don't want frictionless trade....I could go on but you get the picture....)

saleorbouy · 18/11/2021 07:10

YANBU
Most people don't do the maths before purchasing a pet.
Feeding a dog £3 a day is over 1K a year. Add on vaccinations, flea treatment, grooming and kennel/ dog minding it's easily another £500-1k.
It's the naivety of the want over the reality,my MIL bought a pooch for 1.2k and months later needed to be bailed out for her own life expenses she " couldn't afford" the lack of logic infuriated me.