Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 'jumping' is a bit naff for a year 2 PE lesson

113 replies

orangechairs · 16/11/2021 16:51

My DD had PE today. She's 6 and in year 2. Her PE lesson was jumping. Doing a quarter turn, half a turn and a full turn jump. Then they jumped in pairs. She said that's all they did for the full PE lesson. They did some jumping to music, but mostly the teacher telling them what jump to do. Some on their own and some in pairs.

I asked one of the other parents and her child also said the same, so I think it's correct. I also think it's pretty reflective of their general PE lessons. (My 4 year old says they just run around outside during his PE lesson, which is what they basically do most of the time in reception anyway).

Is this what a year 2 PE lesson is? It just seems a bit basic to me. I thought they'd be learning how to play a sport in year 2, or inside doing some more movement type classes. I remember at infant school we climbed up the walls, ran along benches, climbed ropes and jumped over the vault in PE lessons, like a mini obstacle course. Or we were learning actual sports.

Please help me and share what your year 2 child does in a PE lesson!

This is state school BTW. But I am interested to hear what all year 2 PE lessons are like, state and private.

YABU - jumping is a perfectly normal PE lesson for year 2

YANBU - jumping is not a good PE lesson for year 2.

OP posts:
1forAll74 · 16/11/2021 18:47

Jumping, was usually incorporated with other types of movements in PE lessons, it seems a lazy way to go about teaching PE.

CallMeRisley · 16/11/2021 18:46

@womaninatightspot

Our school does a daily mile where they all run laps of a track which also sounds a bit naff.
bmcmedicine.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12916-018-1049-z
ldontWanna · 16/11/2021 18:44

@orangechairs they might be used to physical activity which is great. However, can they do it accurately,safely,properly? In a controlled way? Correct start and landing position?

withsexypantsandasausagedog · 16/11/2021 18:44

Jumping can encompass many different skills and activities. At Year 2 you can't teach them to play a sport in one lesson. You have to build up lots of different skills in order for them to be able to play a particular sport so this may well have been one of many lessons to help them learn these skills.

junebirthdaygirl · 16/11/2021 18:43

If children don't learn basic moves how can they play sports. Have you seen rugby players jump for a ball or basketball players jump to score? You would be surprised at how many children who cannot jump/ hop etc. Children don't run around outside as much as they used to so specific teaching is needed.
You must be closely monitoring your child's day if you know what happens in PE each time. My 3 dc were just happy to be moving and doing something different. I never had any idea of what they did unless the came home full of enthusiasm. That level of suspicion of your child's teacher is not good..just trust them .

Maybe look up the content of the PE curriculum for that age . I am in lreland so can't comment on that .

soundsystem · 16/11/2021 18:39

@Hortonhearsadoctorwho

In my experience over multiple state schools that age group is usually multi sports. So different sports each week to work on working as a team, catching and throwing skills, balance skills etc jumping sounds a bit odd.
Yep, multi sports for my Y2 (state). Thus week was basketball.
ShaneTheThird · 16/11/2021 18:39

Yabu sounds like a normal fun pe lesson at that age. Jumping is healthy keeps them active, it's teaching listening skills and coordination and team work. Don't see a problem at all.

orangechairs · 16/11/2021 18:36

@unknownstory

Look up physical literacy. If kids don't master the basics before age 7, they are much more likely to never master a sport. Huge numbers of 6 year olds can't jump. They can't get their feet off the floor. Huge numbers can't catch a ball so can never master netball or similar later. Huge numbers can't walk a mile a day. High % of Yr4-6 kids can't pull them selves out of a swimming pool. Without mastering the basics you are hindered for life. So yes it's fine if that's what's needed
Thanks for this perspective, that's really interesting and not something I was aware of. As a fairly sporty (but definitely 'average ability') family we do quite a lot of physical activities such as park run and family boot camps (outdoor exercise in the park). So my kids are used to a lot of physical Movement. I understand others might not be so thank you.
OP posts:
womaninatightspot · 16/11/2021 18:32

Our school does a daily mile where they all run laps of a track which also sounds a bit naff.

orangechairs · 16/11/2021 18:29

@ChittyChittyBoomBoom

Ks1 teacher here…it’s absolutely a standard lesson for y2 children. PE in ks1 mainly focuses on fundamental skills, with actual games and rules being taught in ks2.

It’s not ‘just’ jumping, of course. Toddlers can do that! But they will be taught to do standing jumps, running jumps and jumping from a height. This involves keeping knees soft for a safe landing and also the correct transfer of weight. They will then work on improving their technique and take these skills into ks2 when they play games.

Ok this is great info, thank you!! Sounds my like my DD had a good lesson then.
OP posts:
orangechairs · 16/11/2021 18:27

@WheelieBinPrincess

You’re right, at that age they should be bussed to the local Olympic sized swimming pool and coached in freestyle diving.

What you’ve described is totally fine for a six year old PE session. Is your daughter in an independent school by any chance…?

No she's in a state school, which I clearly stated in my OP
OP posts:
CallMeRisley · 16/11/2021 18:22

@Bananabrush The reason a higher proportion of Olympians come from private schools is more down to the extra-curricular opportunities that come from having financially stable and generally interested parents. I teach in a state primary and we endeavour to give pupils as many opportunities and experiences of different sports as possible, but curricular PE, even with coaches and smaller classes on offer in private schools is never going to be enough. So for example an external tennis coach was delivering a half term’s worth of lessons to my Year 2 class. He spoke to me about how one boy in particular really stood out as having a natural knack in the sport, and he gave me information and leaflets about local tennis clubs. This was a deprived area, and although I sung the boy’s praises and passed on the information to his Mum, she didn’t take him- be it financial constraints, childcare of other kids in the family, or just a general lack of interest. Parents of a private school pupil approached in a similar way would be more likely to nurture any natural talent spotted, take the kid to a club, buy them the equipment, practice with them at home. Of course there are exceptions but that’s the usual situation.

Sweettea1 · 16/11/2021 18:22

Dd6 does tries something different each week they have tried gymnastics, rounders, dance, an other games. Dd loves PE and would be furious if all they done is jump.

EdenFlower · 16/11/2021 18:20

I work in a Y2 class and jumping is a skill that is taught explicitly. There are plenty in the class that can't move in a controlled way. They are taught how to land on the balls of their feet, how to jump from one to two feet, how to jump and turn and how to jump over objects. Next week might be balancing and then moving in different ways, building up to a simple dynastic routine at the end of the half term.

They don't really teach sports as such in year 2- they are only 6! It's more skills based and then using skills in paired work or small teams and games. The may learn basic skills like batting, throwing, catching, kicking and controlling a ball. They might play simplified versions of cricket, tag games, or relay games.

Dizzyhedgehog · 16/11/2021 18:18

Oh, I don't teach at a state primary.
We'll also start to use the equipment at a later stage. Mine love using the rings and the beams and everything...

Dizzyhedgehog · 16/11/2021 18:16

I'm teaching gymnastics to 6-year-olds tomorrow. They'll be rolling around on the floor for most of the lesson...Last lesson, they tried to stand in different ways without falling over. (We did individual and partner balances.)
I probably wouldn't be doing simple turns for the entire lesson, but ours is over 2 hours long.

unknownstory · 16/11/2021 18:14

@Bananabrush the gulf between state & private yes means eg in hockey / tennis / fencing / cricket etc there are more private high performers.
Bank of mum & dad also normally pays for extra coaching, 1-2-1 lessons, travel, kits etc etc etc
It's certainly not just due to the school

Fordian · 16/11/2021 18:13

@Bananabrush

PE is generally crap in state primaries. There is a reason a high proportion of Olympians come from private schools. So if you're in state, sorry, that's the situation we're in. If you're paying you should definitely expect more.

I agree entirely.

School sport in state schools is massively underfunded and not taken seriously.

unknownstory · 16/11/2021 18:07

Look up physical literacy.
If kids don't master the basics before age 7, they are much more likely to never master a sport.
Huge numbers of 6 year olds can't jump. They can't get their feet off the floor.
Huge numbers can't catch a ball so can never master netball or similar later.
Huge numbers can't walk a mile a day.
High % of Yr4-6 kids can't pull them selves out of a swimming pool.
Without mastering the basics you are hindered for life.

So yes it's fine if that's what's needed

unknownstory · 16/11/2021 18:02

@Bananabrush

PE is generally crap in state primaries. There is a reason a high proportion of Olympians come from private schools. So if you're in state, sorry, that's the situation we're in. If you're paying you should definitely expect more.
All kids including private ones need to master jumping
Purplepjs · 16/11/2021 17:45

Sorry, typo… ‘yabu’ answers

Purplepjs · 16/11/2021 17:44

Just to add to the wealth of other ‘ya I’ answers; this lesson also covers some maths objectives for ks1 with quarter/half/whole turns and clockwise/anti clockwise etc. And may have been planned as a practical maths lesson, disguised as PE. Sounds good to me!

Atla · 16/11/2021 17:42

I can remember being mortified in primary school as we had to do a lame dance to 'walk of life' by dire straits.

Atla · 16/11/2021 17:41

Two words: over invested.

Jumping great for balance and coordination, listening and following instructions. Totally fine. I have a DD in P2 and asked her what she does in PE, she said 'standing around then sitting rolling or climbing' so God alone knows what that was about.

scunner · 16/11/2021 17:40

Games and PE should be taught by specialist teachers. In state schools it is unusual to have a specialist come in and teach each year group.
In the private sector, Games and PE are taught by qualified coaches/teachers who have excelled in their sport. Pre-Prep children (Year 1and 2) will have a PE lesson but will also do Hockey/TAG Rugby/ Football/Netball in winter and Athletics, Cricket and Rounders in summer. A weekly swimming lesson is also part of the timetable and not all schools have a private pool. The difference between both sectors in sport is staggering and I always feel annoyed at how short changed many state school children are regarding sport. I have had children attend both state and private.