Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say a crash HAS to go through insurance

190 replies

Chelyanne · 16/11/2021 10:41

So on the school run and bang... a woman reversed out in to the side of our car.
She asked me if we could not involve insurance and she'd pay for the damage (passenger door, rear wing, rear bumper, side trim and alloy all have visible damage). I said no it has to go through insurance and she left in a huff leaving me with no contact details, I did get a pic of her numberplate on and we have dash cams front and rear too. No injuries to me or 5 kids in the car, she had an adult passenger and they both looked okay too.

Do you think I was being unreasonable saying no to her?

OP posts:
sillysmiles · 16/11/2021 11:51

If both parties agree, it is perfectly acceptable not to go through the insurance. But if you don't agree to that then that's up to you.

Pazuzu · 16/11/2021 11:49

Report to the police. Sounds like she's uninsured frankly.

Then report to your insurer.

Shade17 · 16/11/2021 11:48

She's probably got a big excess.

Which she won’t have to pay on a third party claim

OldTinHat · 16/11/2021 11:47

You absolutely must go through insurance. When this happened to me in the exact same circumstances, the other driver was trying to give me cash there and then. I refused. Turns out she had no license, it wasn't her car and therefore obviously not insured. She was arrested and taken to court. My insurers had to pay for repairs and she had to spend the next two years paying me weekly to reimburse me the cost of my excess.

ijustwannabepartofyoursymphony · 16/11/2021 11:47

DH had this with a man who lived in our black of flats several years ago. Clearly had sight issues as had 'parked' his car by driving it into the side of DH's then eventually stopping when he hit the wall at the back. He didn't consider he'd been in an accident, he hadn't even noticed.

DH left and note and he came round to our flat and told DH he'd get his mate to fix it (it was an Audi with full Audi Service History and DH wanted it fixed properly by a registered garage not the mate of some bloke who can't even tell he's crashed into a car and a wall).

DH said no and he screamed at him. It ended up going to court, FFS. DH won because we'd taken photos which clearly showed the paint from this man's car all up the side of DH's.

People are weird. Claim on the insurance.

eightlivesdown · 16/11/2021 11:47

You should go through insurance for big damage, and it will probably increase your premium even though you weren't at fault.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 16/11/2021 11:46

Absolutely not unreasonable. I had a similar situation and refused. In the end it was really expensive as it needed a respray on the door so I needed 3 days of a hire in addition to the cost of fixing the damage. I think the woman who wanted not to go through insurance in my case did not understand the damage she did. Plus I was entitled to (and too) compensation as she smashed up my legs which were painful and badly bruised for a few days (she drove into the car door slamming it into my shins).

Gertrudetheadelie · 16/11/2021 11:44

@Wombat49 that is playbook what happened to me. Low external damage was a bugger to repair in a modern car and there was damage to other car systems from a tiny knock so the bill ended up being quite high. Too high, apparently Hmm.

I think with modern cars with amazing crumple zones and lots of technology, you can't always predict how much a repair will be and so if they are inclined to be, it is easy for them to be appalled by the price and thus refuse payment.

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 16/11/2021 11:43

My SIL had something similar - t-boned by a teenager who’s dad said I’ll sort it out pls don’t tell I sure insurance etc. He took her car to a dodgy garage and stripped it! Then offered her half the value in cash! Ended up going through the police and getting lawyers involved. Do your self a favour - report to the police and insurers. I was hit and made a claim against the other driver - my premiums did not go up.

ColinTheKoala · 16/11/2021 11:42

@notangelinajolie

Be aware though, your premiums will probably go up if you go through insurance, even if it's not your fault.
Yes - and this is also why she doesn't want to go through her insurance.

I would be slightly suspicious as to why she would be keen to keep a significant accident away from insurers not really - just because she knows her premiums will go up and it is probably cheaper just to pay for the damage.

The whole motor insurance model in the UK is a nonsense.

user1497207191 · 16/11/2021 11:42

YANBU. When a car bumped into me years ago, the woman wanted to have it repaired privately without insurance, then when I provided her with quotes from authorised insurance body shops, she said they were too expensive and she said her husband had a "friend" who knew someone, and I naively took it to her hubby's friend who was a back street garage. The job he did was awful, and you could clearly see where it had been repaired and re-painted as it was so shoddy. The guy was a big aggressive guy and just fobbed me off when I mentioned the finish, so I didn't pursue it. But I vowed never again!

girlmom21 · 16/11/2021 11:40

@SW1amp

Unfortunately, your premium will probably go up if you do it through insurance Mine went up £300 when someone scraped the side of my car, while it was parked outside my house Angry

If that’s potentially an issue for you, I would give her 7 days to pay, and then go to insurance

With dashcam footage, she is unlikely to be able to wriggle out of it at a later date but don’t leave it too long

You have to notify your insurer within 24 hours
mummydoingamasters · 16/11/2021 11:38

You should report but you don't have to claim through them. As the on fault party, I would advise you too though. Sounds like she's possibly got a few claims and her insurance is high because of it.

Not your issue though really

Wombat49 · 16/11/2021 11:33

Definitely through insurance as they won't like the quotes for that amount of damage and there may be internal damage too.

They'll then argue. If they can drive off, they were never going to just pay up.

MadeForThis · 16/11/2021 11:33

I would report asap. Before she somehow claims it was your fault. Does she know you have a dashcam?

StopGo · 16/11/2021 11:33

I'd actually report that to the police as she has 'failed to stop and exchange details' You can do it online.

SoupDragon · 16/11/2021 11:33

we did the form, sent it to insurance and everything was smooth sailing

In the U.K. you simply notify your insurance company.

amatsip · 16/11/2021 11:31

You really have to go through insurance every single time sometimes some people are injured so won’t feel the pain for a day or so, they will struggle to claim for injuries or treatment if not reported adequately. It can be a legal minefield if you havent reported your insurance company and leave you open to all sorts of repercussions.

EnidFrighten · 16/11/2021 11:30

YANBU

My car looked like it had had a minor scrape when parked on the road. Next MOT it turned out it must have been pushed against the kerb and the suspension arm had cracked, making it dangerous to drive. All you could see from outside was a small scrape.

MilduraS · 16/11/2021 11:30

I'd probably agree for something minor like a wing mirror. Stupidly even when the fault is with the other person premiums go up so minor claims can be expensive for both parties. The damage you describe sounds too big though and I'm sure once a quote comes through she would try to haggle so I'd get on to your insurers pronto. They can find her insurers through a database with just her number plate.

grey12 · 16/11/2021 11:30

@SW1amp

Unfortunately, your premium will probably go up if you do it through insurance Mine went up £300 when someone scraped the side of my car, while it was parked outside my house Angry

If that’s potentially an issue for you, I would give her 7 days to pay, and then go to insurance

With dashcam footage, she is unlikely to be able to wriggle out of it at a later date but don’t leave it too long

That is not a bad point. Something to consider
ThatsNiiice · 16/11/2021 11:29

Leaving the scene of an accident without giving details or calling the police is an offense in itself isnt it??!

SW1amp · 16/11/2021 11:27

Unfortunately, your premium will probably go up if you do it through insurance
Mine went up £300 when someone scraped the side of my car, while it was parked outside my house Angry

If that’s potentially an issue for you, I would give her 7 days to pay, and then go to insurance

With dashcam footage, she is unlikely to be able to wriggle out of it at a later date but don’t leave it too long

HarrietsChariot · 16/11/2021 11:27

You have to both notify your insurers regardless of whether the claim is through them. She is entitled to pay for the cost of fixing things herself, if you think about it her insurance company would be quite happy not to have to pay out even though it was her fault.

She drove off without leaving her details so you should also go to the police about it. It is an offence not to exchange name and contact details. (It's not obligatory to give insurance details at the time of the accident - just name and contact.)

DraigFach · 16/11/2021 11:26

Report to your insurance because you have to. It's part of the terms of your insurance that your report any collisions whether you're at fault or not...not doing so nullifies your insurance and could lead to you having difficulty obtaining insurance in the future.

Just make sure you make a note of the date and details of the incident because you'll need to declare this on all insurance applications for the next 5 or so years. Reporting non-fault issues hasn't increased my premiums, but remembering the dates is a nuisance (first was someone driving into the back of me at a roundabout that was full of traffic, other was them ploughing into my parked car that dash cam helpfully recorded).