Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say a crash HAS to go through insurance

190 replies

Chelyanne · 16/11/2021 10:41

So on the school run and bang... a woman reversed out in to the side of our car.
She asked me if we could not involve insurance and she'd pay for the damage (passenger door, rear wing, rear bumper, side trim and alloy all have visible damage). I said no it has to go through insurance and she left in a huff leaving me with no contact details, I did get a pic of her numberplate on and we have dash cams front and rear too. No injuries to me or 5 kids in the car, she had an adult passenger and they both looked okay too.

Do you think I was being unreasonable saying no to her?

OP posts:
Nasturs · 16/11/2021 12:27

The only times I have known people agree to this, it has turned into a nightmare with the other party questioning bills etc.

RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:27

@sillysmiles

Assuming both parties have insurance, and notify their insurers as they are required to do, what advantage do both get from not involving insurers? In other words, if their is no crooked motive on either side, why would anyone not involve insurers?

To avoid a premium increase and loss of NCB?

Why would the premium increase and loss of NCB be different for a reported accident with no claim compared to a no-fault claim where 100% of costs were recovered?

(I believe reported not-at-fault accidents for which you do not claim do affect what you pay in future. Your NCB may be unaffected, but your future premiums may be higher than they would have been otherwise.)

Otherpeoplesteens · 16/11/2021 12:26

[quote daimbarsatemydogsbone]@Otherpeoplesteens

You win today's award for shoehorning hatred of the UK and expressing the superiority of the EU into the least relevant thread, well done.[/quote]
Well, I actually had a serious crash when I was driving a Portuguese registered vehicle which didn't belong to me, in Spain, when I was hit by a German. No common language between anyone at the scene.

The form made it dead easy, as did the insurance stickers in the window. In this instance the EU arrangements simply were superior.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 12:26

But your insurance is going to recover the money from theirs, of from them, supposedly, so there is no difference to how much your insurance has to shell out, so should be no difference in the effect on your premiums. The only time your insurance is going to shell out more if you claim is if their insurance doesn't pay (because they aren't insured) and they won't pay (in which case it would have been a bad move to have trusted them to pay you directly)

No, with a private repair when Mrs Smith has crashed into Mrs Jones, Mrs Smith pays for the repairs to Mrs Jones' car directly. Neither insurance company has to pay anything. Mrs Smith's premiums will probably still go up, because her insurer now sees her as higher risk, but not as much as they would have done if her insurer had paid for repairs. Mrs Jones' premiums usually don't increase. If it goes through insurers, Mrs Jones may see her premiums go up or lose her NCD, even though Mrs Smith caused the accident.

So, on paper, it's to the advantage of both parties. But the reality can be messier.

RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:20

It's because a notification only (no outlay required by the insurer) won't usually increase your premium - or at least not as much as if the insurer has to shell out - especially if the other driver has admitted liability.

But your insurance is going to recover the money from theirs, of from them, supposedly, so there is no difference to how much your insurance has to shell out, so should be no difference in the effect on your premiums. The only time your insurance is going to shell out more if you claim is if their insurance doesn't pay (because they aren't insured) and they won't pay (in which case it would have been a bad move to have trusted them to pay you directly.)

sillysmiles · 16/11/2021 12:19

Assuming both parties have insurance, and notify their insurers as they are required to do, what advantage do both get from not involving insurers? In other words, if their is no crooked motive on either side, why would anyone not involve insurers?

To avoid a premium increase and loss of NCB?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/11/2021 12:18

This is making me wonder if maybe she is not insured

You and me both
It may be that she's just worried about the premiums or it may not, but while DIY can work for very small incidents I wouldn't even consider it for the kind of damage you've described

EmKayEm · 16/11/2021 12:18

She has driven off without providing details.
The police will be on her for that alone.
Always go through insurance, you never know what will come back later.

RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:15

Get it fixed privately and bill me, rather than using the insurer's recommended service.

Why would they ask for that?

Ilovemyshoppingtrolley · 16/11/2021 12:13

I insisted it went through the insurers after a much less kind of impact, what seemed a really nice middle aged lady had no insurance.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 16/11/2021 12:11

She's very likely uninsured or has a history of RTCs where she is at fault if she's trying to avoid going through insurance

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 12:11

@Otherpeoplesteens

You win today's award for shoehorning hatred of the UK and expressing the superiority of the EU into the least relevant thread, well done.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 12:10

Assuming both parties have insurance, and notify their insurers as they are required to do, what advantage do both get from not involving insurers? In other words, if their is no crooked motive on either side, why would anyone not involve insurers?

It's because a notification only (no outlay required by the insurer) won't usually increase your premium - or at least not as much as if the insurer has to shell out - especially if the other driver has admitted liability.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 12:08

I think you are a bit confused. (Or maybe it's me.) When someone says they "don't want to go through insurance" it means they don't want you to contact your insurance company to ensure your car is fixed. They want you to trust them to fix your car instead of trusting your own insurance company. Even if they do pay up, this only makes sense for both if both are intending to keep their premiums down by fraudulently hiding the accident from their insurance companies. When someone asks "not to go through insurance" they are asking you to collude in fraud for the mutual benefit of both

Not necessarily. They can mean:
(1) Don't tell your insurance company - breach of your contract (policy) with them and potentially fraudulent - never agree. Or
(2) Get it fixed privately and bill me, rather than using the insurer's recommended service. Depending on the terms of your insurance policy, this may be allowed and it's not fraudulent (as long as you don't then lie about the cost of the repair). But it does involve trusting the other driver more than may be wise.

Warblerinwinter · 16/11/2021 12:08

@DraigFach

Report to your insurance because you have to. It's part of the terms of your insurance that your report any collisions whether you're at fault or not...not doing so nullifies your insurance and could lead to you having difficulty obtaining insurance in the future.

Just make sure you make a note of the date and details of the incident because you'll need to declare this on all insurance applications for the next 5 or so years. Reporting non-fault issues hasn't increased my premiums, but remembering the dates is a nuisance (first was someone driving into the back of me at a roundabout that was full of traffic, other was them ploughing into my parked car that dash cam helpfully recorded).

Agree with this…as I get older I loose track of time…was that 5 years ago or 7 years ago etc Learnt my lesson and now have notes in my files
RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:07

@sillysmiles

If both parties agree, it is perfectly acceptable not to go through the insurance. But if you don't agree to that then that's up to you.
Assuming both parties have insurance, and notify their insurers as they are required to do, what advantage do both get from not involving insurers? In other words, if their is no crooked motive on either side, why would anyone not involve insurers?
Ariela · 16/11/2021 12:06

Make sure you put it through insurance, and if you've any school run people witnessed be sure to include them, as well as your dash cam evidence (the fact she hit the rear quarter of your car is neither here nor there) otherwise the lady will be saying you waved her out and drove on so damaging your car on hers. Or something.

Seabea · 16/11/2021 12:04

I'd never not go through insurance, been bitten by that one before. Its relying on them to actually be decent and pay up, ensure the work is done to a proper standard and not well I'm only paying £100 as my mate will do it, and it's an awkward position as if they don't pay up retrospectively reporting to insurance is obviously frowned upon as its part of the terms that you report all accidents. Premiums don't actually rise that much if the worst is not substantial.

userno53627 · 16/11/2021 12:04

doesn't have to go through insurance if she was willing to pay the expense herself. She shouldn't have drove off regardless.

SleighBells21 · 16/11/2021 12:03

I work for insurance.
No matter what you need to tell your insurance company.
If you wanted to sort yourselves it would be a notification only.
But I would advise to always claim, let your company deal with it for you.
The amount of people I speak to who have tried to sort it out themselves and they get shot in the foot because the third party decides to not comply and their are left with a beat up car.
Great you have dash cams.

RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:02

@araiwa

Why would you think that you can tell her how to pay to get your car fixed. It's up to her if she pays it or gets her insurance to pay for it. She doesn't have to claim off her insurance if she doesn't want to. Insurance companies both need to be informed of incident but how she pays is up to her
I think you are a bit confused. (Or maybe it's me.) When someone says they "don't want to go through insurance" it means they don't want you to contact your insurance company to ensure your car is fixed. They want you to trust them to fix your car instead of trusting your own insurance company. Even if they do pay up, this only makes sense for both if both are intending to keep their premiums down by fraudulently hiding the accident from their insurance companies.

When someone asks "not to go through insurance" they are asking you to collude in fraud for the mutual benefit of both.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 12:01

Another nope from me. We had a similar accident. Did report it to our insurance but agreed to consider a private repair as the car that hit me belonged to a neighbour. My DH helped him by getting a friend to tow his own car for mate's rates. Our thanks were the neighbour threatening to report me to our insurers for not having declared that I use the car for work (I had). He waited till DH was out to come round and try to intimidate me - the fool 😀. Never again.

Chely · 16/11/2021 11:58

It has a large dent so will be pricey to repair.
I know from a previous crash that this level of damage is likely to be in the thousands not just a little buffing out needed. No idea if there could be more serious damage but it did feel a bit off driving it home though I was a bit shaken by it too.
I've done all my reporting, I'm not worried about insurance hikes tbh as we'll pay whatever we need to for the cover we want.
Annoyed the insurance will not give me the upgraded courtesy car we pay extra for because they don't have her contact details.

BiLuminous · 16/11/2021 11:54

@sillysmiles

If both parties agree, it is perfectly acceptable not to go through the insurance. But if you don't agree to that then that's up to you.
As someone who worked in this field I'd not advise this...many times I would see people agreeing to settle it out of insurance, then they'd end up claiming because what they thought was minor damage wasn't when they got to the garage. It'd then transpire that it wasn't reported at the time and this then goes against what is written in the agreed terms of the insurance... it also just generally causes more conflict.
mam0918 · 16/11/2021 11:53

If she left without exchanging details then isn't it a hit and run?

It maybe that she doesn't actually have insurance in which case she is a danger to everyone and needs to be reported.