Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say a crash HAS to go through insurance

190 replies

Chelyanne · 16/11/2021 10:41

So on the school run and bang... a woman reversed out in to the side of our car.
She asked me if we could not involve insurance and she'd pay for the damage (passenger door, rear wing, rear bumper, side trim and alloy all have visible damage). I said no it has to go through insurance and she left in a huff leaving me with no contact details, I did get a pic of her numberplate on and we have dash cams front and rear too. No injuries to me or 5 kids in the car, she had an adult passenger and they both looked okay too.

Do you think I was being unreasonable saying no to her?

OP posts:
BorsetshireBanality · 16/11/2021 12:59

Inform Police with 24 hours of the accident.

TollgateDebs · 16/11/2021 12:56

All accidents / incidents should be reported to insurers and the police, if only for an incident number. Then let insurers sort it out. I handled claims for a large company and reported everything and believe me some third parties really go to town when they think a big company is involved, so really important to ensure the details of an incident established right from the beginning.

DebbieG71 · 16/11/2021 12:56

you weren't unreasonable at all. You don't know this person, you don't know their background and indeed their honesty credentials. if it were the other way round you would assume someone asking for your insurance details the rationale move. you go gal.

Lou98 · 16/11/2021 12:54

@araiwa

Why would you think that you can tell her how to pay to get your car fixed. It's up to her if she pays it or gets her insurance to pay for it. She doesn't have to claim off her insurance if she doesn't want to. Insurance companies both need to be informed of incident but how she pays is up to her

This isn't true. I used to work for a big insurance company in the UK in motor claims - the OP can decide to settle privately if she wishes but legally still needs to inform her insurance company even if she doesn't wish to claim.

If the OP does want to claim through the insurance though then the third party doesn't get a say, OP's insurance company will deal directly with the TP's insurance company

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 12:54

YES it would have definitely have helped in this case. Because how the accident happened is written down, any injuries or damage is written down, all info from all parties is written down and SIGNED by all parties. So the other person wouldn't "just leave" without filling in and signing the form. Otherwise you call the police

So having a super duper EU form would have stopped the other person just fucking off - OK then - the paper in those must have amazing magical powers.

Toddlerteaplease · 16/11/2021 12:54

I've had two minor bumps. Both times neither of us wanted to go through insurance. We settled up amicably. Fortunately both times the other party were really nice.

Jossbow · 16/11/2021 12:52

You do have to report the fct that you have been involved in an accident, you dont HAVE to persue a claim through them.

Given thatshe has driven off without giving you details, you wont have much of a choice

grey12 · 16/11/2021 12:50

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Well, I actually had a serious crash when I was driving a Portuguese registered vehicle which didn't belong to me, in Spain, when I was hit by a German. No common language between anyone at the scene.

Not an issue in this case so utterly irrelevant.

The form made it dead easy, as did the insurance stickers in the window. In this instance the EU arrangements simply were superior.

Not an issue in this case so utterly irrelevant.

@daimbarsatemydogsbone I was the one who brought the EU form up

YES it would have definitely have helped in this case. Because how the accident happened is written down, any injuries or damage is written down, all info from all parties is written down and SIGNED by all parties. So the other person wouldn't "just leave" without filling in and signing the form. Otherwise you call the police

NautaOcts · 16/11/2021 12:50

I should add in at least one of the situations, the damage was my fault and it was the other driver who asked it I was happy to sort it privately rather than through insurance.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 12:49

@RandomLondoner

No, with a private repair when Mrs Smith has crashed into Mrs Jones, Mrs Smith pays for the repairs to Mrs Jones' car directly. Neither insurance company has to pay anything. Mrs Smith's premiums will probably still go up, because her insurer now sees her as higher risk, but not as much as they would have done if her insurer had paid for repairs. Mrs Jones' premiums usually don't increase. If it goes through insurers, Mrs Jones may see her premiums go up or lose her NCD, even though Mrs Smith caused the accident.

It's only fair that Mrs Smiths premiums don't go up as much as they otherwise would, because she's save her insurance company the cost of repairs. Overall, it's not clear, and goes against economic logic, that Mrs Smith is any better off.

In any case, we don't care about her, it's Mrs Jones that matters.

Mrs Jone's will only lose her NCB if her insurance company doesn't recover costs. In the scenario we're supposed to beleive that the other party can be trusted to pay, so supposedly this is a non-issue.

Mrs Jones will probably have increased premiums, but why would her premiums increase more in scenario (a) no-claim, no cost to her insurance company, than in scenario (b) no-fault claim in which insurance company recovers 100% of costs, so no cost to the insurance company. Either way, her insurance company is out nothing. Either way, her premiums will probably increase.

That might seem logical, but it isn't correct, because insurers use both: (a) frequency of claims and (b) value of claims

to predict future losses and therefore to calculate premiums.

So (a) is unaffected by a private repair (assuming it's reported to the insurer, as it should be), but (b) is affected.

UhOhOops · 16/11/2021 12:48

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

YANBU - report her to Police 101 for leaving the scene without exchanging details. They won't be interested or do anything but it will at least be recorded. Then tell your insurers.
Yup.
NautaOcts · 16/11/2021 12:47

I’ve done it privately a few times with no issues. Get a few quotes and take it from there.
Altho now she hasn’t given you details you won’t be able to, and your premiums will probably go up

RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:46

OP’s insurance WILL increase even if the claim is settled in full by the other party’s insurers. It didnt used to be this way many years ago, but it is now.

Yes I know. It will probably also increase if she reports an accident that she doesn't claim for. Do you have any reason to believe it will increase more for a claim that costs the insurance company nothing than for a non-claim that costs the insurance company nothing?

In both scenarios, the cost to the insurance company is the same, and their perception of how risky the OP is to ensure must change by the same amount, because it's the same accident with the same cost to them in both scenarios.

muddyford · 16/11/2021 12:45

As the other woman left without leaving her details, you should inform the police as she left the scene of an accident.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 12:45

Her renewal insurance was £100 higher than if she’d not had the claim. I rang the insurers to query it, and yes, that’s how insurance works. Even non fault claims bump up prices. Absolutely wrong and unfair, but that’s how they work

Insurers work off probability. If you have had one accident, even if it isn't your fault, you are statistically more likely to have another. The accident tells the insurer that you are in a higher risk group. Take the OP - she does a school run, so she is more likely to have another crash involving another SR parent than someone who never drives in rush hour near a school.

Of course this feels unfair, but the alternative is someone who is lower risk bearing more of a share of the cost. If insurance is a pool of £100 from 10 drivers, should every driver pay £10 into the pool? Or should drivers 1, 2, and 3, who are at higher risk of crashing, pay £15 each and drivers 4-10, who are at low risk, pay £7.86 each?

Drivers 1-3 and 4-10 are going to have different opinions on which is fair!

kirinm · 16/11/2021 12:43

@RandomLondoner

There is absolutely no legal basis on which you can force her to make a claim against her own insurance company.

You have the wrong insurance company. OP was not insisting on contacting other persons insurance, they were insisting on contacting their own.

Ah! Well yeah fair enough.
RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:42

There is absolutely no legal basis on which you can force her to make a claim against her own insurance company.

You have the wrong insurance company. OP was not insisting on contacting other persons insurance, they were insisting on contacting their own.

SusieBob · 16/11/2021 12:38

Unless it's a bump that literally can be sorted with a bit of T-Cut always go through your insurance. You have the licence plate; that's all you need to get the ball rolling.

PuppyMonkey · 16/11/2021 12:38

Presume you at least got the registration OP?

KerryWeaver · 16/11/2021 12:36

@ChloeCrocodile

why doesn't the UK have an incident report form like other countries??!!

Because it is really easy to inform the police anyway.

Ha, ha. Since when?
RandomLondoner · 16/11/2021 12:35

No, with a private repair when Mrs Smith has crashed into Mrs Jones, Mrs Smith pays for the repairs to Mrs Jones' car directly. Neither insurance company has to pay anything. Mrs Smith's premiums will probably still go up, because her insurer now sees her as higher risk, but not as much as they would have done if her insurer had paid for repairs. Mrs Jones' premiums usually don't increase. If it goes through insurers, Mrs Jones may see her premiums go up or lose her NCD, even though Mrs Smith caused the accident.

It's only fair that Mrs Smiths premiums don't go up as much as they otherwise would, because she's save her insurance company the cost of repairs. Overall, it's not clear, and goes against economic logic, that Mrs Smith is any better off.

In any case, we don't care about her, it's Mrs Jones that matters.

Mrs Jone's will only lose her NCB if her insurance company doesn't recover costs. In the scenario we're supposed to beleive that the other party can be trusted to pay, so supposedly this is a non-issue.

Mrs Jones will probably have increased premiums, but why would her premiums increase more in scenario (a) no-claim, no cost to her insurance company, than in scenario (b) no-fault claim in which insurance company recovers 100% of costs, so no cost to the insurance company. Either way, her insurance company is out nothing. Either way, her premiums will probably increase.

CloverField · 16/11/2021 12:31

Somebody drove into the back of my car, broke into tears said they didn't want to go through insurance as they had already had one crash. I took details and number plate, etc and waited till I got home to make a decision. My car was quite damaged front and back as they forced my car into an object so I went through insurance. When it got to the repair centre it ended up costly as it had all sorts of unknown (to me) damage so I was so glad I went through insurance.

kirinm · 16/11/2021 12:30

There is absolutely no legal basis on which you can force her to make a claim against her own insurance company. The OP is legally entitled to make a claim against her but it is up to her whether she informs her insurer.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 12:29

Well, I actually had a serious crash when I was driving a Portuguese registered vehicle which didn't belong to me, in Spain, when I was hit by a German. No common language between anyone at the scene.

Not an issue in this case so utterly irrelevant.

The form made it dead easy, as did the insurance stickers in the window. In this instance the EU arrangements simply were superior.

Not an issue in this case so utterly irrelevant.

Namechangehereandnow · 16/11/2021 12:29

random … OP’s insurance WILL increase even if the claim is settled in full by the other party’s insurers. It didnt used to be this way many years ago, but it is now.

My dd was involved in a non fault accident. The other insurers paid for everything (injury, car damage, car hire), my daughters insurers paid out nothing and her ncb was not affected. It went on her policy as a non fault claim.

Her renewal insurance was £100 higher than if she’d not had the claim. I rang the insurers to query it, and yes, that’s how insurance works. Even non fault claims bump up prices. Absolutely wrong and unfair, but that’s how they work.