Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you live in a house where there had been a murder?

387 replies

1988TBT · 16/11/2021 07:18

Just that really… DP and I looking at buying a second property to rent out. It’s underpriced and chain free… because 18 months ago the husband murdered his wife in one of the bedrooms. It’s put me off a good amount but DP is still keen to go ahead with the sale and says there will be lots of people that won’t want t rent it but it won’t put EVERYONE off. Would it put you off?

OP posts:
Practicebeingpatient · 16/11/2021 08:29

The only difference between that house and any other house is that you know a murder was committed there. Murders and suicides could have happened in any other property or in any other plot of land but weren't reported or detected. So I'd ignore any woo stuff about ghostly presences. People have been living and dying on this tiny island for countless millennia and it isn't wall to wall ghosties.

If it's a good price and you do it up to the appropriate local standard it will rent out. For every nervous soul who knows about the murder there will be half a dozen other people who don't know or know and don't care.

RedskyThisNight · 16/11/2021 08:28

Wouldn't bother me and surprised that it would put so many people off.
The only difference with this house and any other is that you know some of its history. In other houses women and children may have been abused, there may have been sexual assault, there may have been slow lingering deaths by natural causes. Would these all be fine if you didn't know about them?

PomegranateQueen · 16/11/2021 08:26

Depends what the rental market is like where you live. Where I live, there are 30+ applicants for each rental, so if I were in your position I would invest in it.

SpookyScarySkeletons · 16/11/2021 08:25

@wtaf37

I have to ask those of you who said you wouldn't live in such a house - Why not??

I mean, there is no such thing as ghosts, nor, presumably, is the murderer still living there. And unless you live in a new build that you were the first to move into, how much do you know about the lives of the people who lived in your house previously? Why knows what went on under your roof? Just because it didn't make the papers, doesn't mean stuff didn't happen; child deaths, old people dying at home in their beds, domestic violence, abuse of domestic staff...
The list is endless!

I am a bit woo sorry!

But my main reason would be that it would always be in my head, I wouldn't be able to not think about it. I also believe that homes where that sort of thing has happened retain a bit of the sadness.

Nothing has gone on under my roof - we bought it before they had even finished building it.

PickupaPenguin8 · 16/11/2021 08:25

There is no way I could live in a house where there had been a murder of suicide.

Clawdy · 16/11/2021 08:22

I know most older properties will have rooms where somebody died, and I've no problem with that. But no, I couldn't live in a house where a murder had taken place. It would be in my head every time I entered the room, especially at night.

Spiceup · 16/11/2021 08:22

I'd buy it to live in if it was cheap enough, but I'd be worried it wouldn't be good as an investment property.

TheMarzipanDildo · 16/11/2021 08:21

No I couldn’t do that. I’m not a woo person at all but I would find it all too sad.

AlandAnna · 16/11/2021 08:20

No I don’t think I could live there. But agree a renter desperate to find the right place at fair price might feel differently.

Itsnotover · 16/11/2021 08:19

No I wouldn't.

LowlandLucky · 16/11/2021 08:18

There was a woman murdered in a council flat in my local town, council left it empty for 13 months then rented it out again. Private rent around the corner from my Dad was rented out again within a few months after the last occupant had lain dead in the house for 4 days. In the very room i am sitting in now an old man died in his chair and wasn't found until the next day. Buy the house, you won't have a problem renting it out.

mrsbitaly · 16/11/2021 08:17

Absolutely not. This isn't someone who just passed peacefully this was someone who was murdered. I know its just a house but I genuinely couldn't sleep at night knowing someone suffered so much in those rooms.

ThinWomansBrain · 16/11/2021 08:16

it wouldn't put me off.

I suppose you need to think about it in the context of the area?
Small village with not a lot of movement - it will be "that house" for a long time.
Larger city with a transitory population - will be forgotton sooner, potential renters will be from outside the area and not know about the recent history.

Meruem · 16/11/2021 08:16

It’s true it won’t put everyone off but if someone views 2 very similar properties, one of which is yours, why would they choose the murder house over the other?

I think it depends what the rental market is like in your area. If there’s a lack of properties to rent then yes go for it. But if it sits there empty then it’s a false economy.

Icebreaker99 · 16/11/2021 08:14

Sounds like the start of an ITV three parter.

I'd go in and spend some time in the room and see how I felt, can always get the local priest in to bless it if you like it but feel a bit uneasy.

Srettel · 16/11/2021 08:14

If you google the address, does the murder come up?

WhatsWrongWithMyUsername · 16/11/2021 08:12

Sorry the not legally required to tell people if not asked is buying/ selling, no idea about renting.

FAQs · 16/11/2021 08:12

It would depend who received the funds from the sale, I’d have an issue with my money going to a man who murdered his wife.

KaptainKaveman · 16/11/2021 08:11

@stonebrambleboy

I'd buy it redecorate and ask the local priest to bless the house.
Same here.
TheLovelinessOfDemons · 16/11/2021 08:11

It would depend on the feeling I got from the house. Even the least woo people can get feelings from places.

wtaf37 · 16/11/2021 08:10

I have to ask those of you who said you wouldn't live in such a house - Why not??

I mean, there is no such thing as ghosts, nor, presumably, is the murderer still living there. And unless you live in a new build that you were the first to move into, how much do you know about the lives of the people who lived in your house previously? Why knows what went on under your roof? Just because it didn't make the papers, doesn't mean stuff didn't happen; child deaths, old people dying at home in their beds, domestic violence, abuse of domestic staff...
The list is endless!

52andblue · 16/11/2021 08:09

@purlsandhooks not in Scotland they don't (or I was very unlucky).
My first married house (2001) was bought not knowing reason for sale was previous couple were a murder suicide in the main bedroom sadly.
The house was fine though.
2nd house is 'haunted' according to neighbours. There IS something off here. Now Divorcing.

WhatsWrongWithMyUsername · 16/11/2021 08:09

I did. It was about 3 years after the murder. I knew before I bought it (but didn’t know when I put the offer in, it might have impacted my decision then).

The guy was in prison and would be for some time. It was sadly a domestic, he had a gun. If it was a random murder and they’d not caught the murderer I absolutely wouldn’t have bought it (being a single woman living alone). I also wouldn’t have liked it if I knew he could be walking past.

My next door neighbour (who was also new) heard people talking about it as they walked past and was disappointed it wasn’t his house! So not everyone would be put off.

You are absolutely not legally required to tell anyone anything about the house, only to answer questions honestly. Caveat emptor (not sure if I’ve spelled it right!). There was a court case going on when I was selling my house, about a really horrific murder and the buyers hasn’t been told, but it was upheld in the sellers’ favour.

When I bought my next house I remember saying to a colleague at least there’d not been a murder in it, and he said “how do you know…?” - fair point!

icedcoffees · 16/11/2021 08:08

It wouldn't bother me at all.

DiscoStusMoonboots · 16/11/2021 08:06

A family friend bought the most amazing little terraced house in the heart of Winchester because a murder had happened there a year before. Had the house not been so heavily discounted, there was no way she could have afforded it. Sold it on about 10 years later for over double the money. I'd do it.