Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you live in a house where there had been a murder?

387 replies

1988TBT · 16/11/2021 07:18

Just that really… DP and I looking at buying a second property to rent out. It’s underpriced and chain free… because 18 months ago the husband murdered his wife in one of the bedrooms. It’s put me off a good amount but DP is still keen to go ahead with the sale and says there will be lots of people that won’t want t rent it but it won’t put EVERYONE off. Would it put you off?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YesIamTHATmum · 19/11/2021 07:06

Unless I was really into ghost hunts or horror movies I'm not by the way then no it would be off putting.

leatherboundbooks · 18/11/2021 23:09

I looked up the house of the mother of someone I used to be friendly with , having seen that she'd gone into a home, googled the address and there had been a murder maybe 30 or 40 years before they moved there, it hapened in a room where sometimes people slept if there were visitors, they absolutely didn't know [and I felt no bad vibes in that room either]

CrankyFrankie · 18/11/2021 21:14

We looked at a (massively reduced, beautiful) house that the, er, atypical EA announced had been repossessed as soon as we walked into it. Put me right off and I couldn’t see past it for the whole viewing. Recent murder?!? Can’t see myself stepping foot over the threshold 😬

JadeTrinket · 18/11/2021 20:02

This thread has reminded me of how some student housemates and I once had to leave our rental mid-academic year (because it had been condemned as unsafe for human habitation! Long story!) and ended up taking over the lease of a beautiful, rundown Georgian house from some medical students who were mysteriously eager to leave. I think after we’d signed but before we’d moved in, one of the medics had a fit of conscience and told me they were leaving because they thought the house was haunted — that when any of them were alone in the house, at a certain point on the stairs they felt a choking, dragging pressure on their throats, which they linked to someone having supposedly hanged themselves there on the stairs in the past. We said ‘Oh’ and moved in anyway.

And had a lovely untroubled period there, with lots of cheer and excellent parties, snd no phantom hangings. People found it amusing that a bunch of hard-headed medics had been spooked, while us arty types (English Lit, two Fine Arts, one drama student) were completely untroubled.

Skysblue · 18/11/2021 19:27

Nope

KittenKong · 18/11/2021 18:06

I wouldn’t - but not because I’d be scared, but because I would be reminded of the dreadful things that happened to those young men, how scared and desperate they must have been, how they probably were crying for their mums...

FindingMeno · 18/11/2021 17:39

I wouldn't want to live there.

LovelyIssues · 18/11/2021 17:37

I personally don't think I could, but then again I am a complete wimp when it comes to anything "ghosty" and bad omens

JumperandJacket · 18/11/2021 16:35

Dennis Nilsen’s flat is near us. It turns up on Rightmove every couple of years, always at least £100k under the market rate. No idea whether it ever gets sold.

Harls1969 · 18/11/2021 16:32

I would think a lot of us who live in properties over 50 years old have absolutely no idea what might have happened previously or how many people have died in our homes. However, I think if I knew someone had been murdered, I'd get a serious case of the willies. Especially in the middle of the night, but I do have an active imagination and there are probably plenty who won't be bothered/would relish it

FrankGrillosWrist · 18/11/2021 16:24

I've had a good think about this as I was browsing recently & I saw a property going for a song. If you rent it out you will have to inform your tenants of this. I definitely wouldn't want to live there, but someone will no doubt get off on it.

PineappleWilson · 18/11/2021 16:11

Our next door neighbour's house was cheap because a previous occupant attempted to kill his wife. Police on the door step etc. and the guy is now in prison. If you went into the house now, you wouldn't know. They've completely redecorated and there's no strange atmosphere at all. I might raise an eye at buying a second house to make an income from it when a non-home owner could get it at a knock down price and get on the property ladder, but the murder shouldn't put you off buying per se.

Thisisnotreallymyname · 18/11/2021 16:01

I couldn’t live in it myself. But - yes I could buy it and let it out, not sure what that says about me tbh 😐

WellHereWeGoAgain · 18/11/2021 15:26

The thing is, we never know what's happened in any of the houses we live in. People could have been murdered, or taken their own lives etc and we wouldn't always necessarily know. If you really like the house, then go for it.
What a sad and tragic thing to have happened there. But you can move in and make new, happier memories.

me109f · 18/11/2021 15:14

I lived in a rented house in York that I later found out had been the scene of a domestic murder. Did not bother me at all, but if people are sensitive they may avoid it.
My sister and her husband live in a very old cottage and during renovation, a baby skeleton was found in a wall. She was very matter of fact about it and did not seem bothered. This was not unusual for an 18th century building. She is still living there over 40 years later.

DebHagland · 18/11/2021 09:50

If you are looking at it as a rental property and you can use the history as leverage to drop the price I would buy it.
You are not going to be living there so I don't see what the problem is.
There will be a few renters that would be put off, but most renters are more interested in the price, how nice the accommodation is decorated, facilities and location.
If its a student area they wont give a damn.

ILoveToads · 18/11/2021 08:53

I would worry about when I came to re-sell, but personally I wouldn't mind living there.

Dibbydoos · 18/11/2021 08:17

Buy it and have the house blessed so perspective tenants if the ask feel some comfort. With cost saving you can offer slightly lower rent too. Good luck.

Kteeb1 · 18/11/2021 08:09

Well everyone is going to think im a right weirdo but I rented a property years ago where the back bedroom was always really cold. It was my kids Room and he started getting nightmare and then refused to sleep in it which wasn't like him. The cat wouldn't go in it either. When we came to leave it the agent guy mentioned that a women had been murdered there. I genuinely didn't know when I was in it. Probably a coincidence but it proper freaked me out. So yes it would put me off.

jontyl · 18/11/2021 07:44

Stick a red plaque on the wall outside and charge viewings with a guide. Joking...

wertheppl · 18/11/2021 07:34

I wouldn't like the live in it BUT if it were all newly renovated and I liked it I would be very tempted. More so if renting as properties are in high demand and usually not all modern and new looking inside. Go for it I'm sure you'll find a tenant no bother. Even if you have to price is £50 per month lower than others (you probably won't need to) that alone will get you a tenant.

Goatinthegarden · 18/11/2021 03:26

I’m not at all woo and don’t believe in ghosts. But I often wonder about previous residents of my home and hope they were happy in the house.

I would be really sad to think of someone suffering in the house I called home. If a woman was murdered, there were probably many episodes of domestic violence there as well.

I wouldn’t be able to put those thoughts out of my head.

Shasha17 · 18/11/2021 02:41

It would put me off because every time I was in that bedroom, all I'd be able to think about was the fear and pain of that woman, the terrifying anger of her husband, etc. Or as I walked up the stairs to bed I'd wonder about the fateful night she walked up those stairs to bed and what she was thinking or if she had a clue what was about to happen to her or if she was scared etc. But I

  1. watch too many horror films and
  2. have a very overactive imagination on the one hand, and
  3. also spend a lot of time wondering about people from history who would have been in the same places as me and how they thought and felt etc - I'm a keen historian and I think this trait comes from this. So a combination of these three things makes it a hard no from me!

One of my best friends would be affected in a different way, she's very 'woo' and would be put off by negative energy left behind after such a traumatic and tragic event.

My second best friend wouldn't be at all bothered, probably. Very practical. Might even consider it a good thing if it reduced the price of the house and made it a better investment!

So I think it all depends on you as a person.

If you feel bothered now, though, then don't go through with it. It's a BIG thing to regret, a house buy!

Mamanyt · 18/11/2021 01:37

Well, I'm a witchy old thing, so I would buy it and immediately sage the entire thing...that said, I immediately sage ANY home I'm moving into.