Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waited in hospital since 10pm to see out of hours gp. It's now 2am. Do I give up and go home?

455 replies

GrrrlPwr · 16/11/2021 02:03

There's 5 people ahead of me in the queue. Receptionist has no idea how long they will all take.

Do I go home and plead my GP for an appointment tomorrow?

Feel so stupid to have waited so long and to go home. But I ache so much. I need to go to bed

OP posts:
wildthingsinthenight · 16/11/2021 11:54

@SarahJeffers341

I would not wait in hospital with tonsilitis… I am sure it’s horrible but not an emergency. If you have a GP you can fill out an online form and they should call you back.
There speaks someone who has never had severe tonsillitis. I was hallucinating and wanted to die. It began affecting my breathing.
endofagain · 16/11/2021 11:41

The French system is very good. It sounds similar to the German system. Everyone pays a level of insurance based on their income, you pay up front for consultation and then claim back a chunk of it. You can choose your own GP, you can usually get your scan/Xray/blood test at the same consultation, often in the same building. You can self refer for things like physio. The physiotherapist can usually arrange Xrays and scans. Women's health clinics are run by specialist nurses who can prescribe, arrange scans, blood tests etc. It sounds pretty comprehensive.
Personally I would prefer that system than tax and NI for a poor service.

LakieLady · 16/11/2021 11:36

[quote girlmom21]@user1497207191 but they can also do 3 phone appointments in the time it'd take to do one face to face appointment. It means once you go for the face to face they already know exactly what you're there for so that saves time too.

It also prevents the issue of everyone running late or the people sitting in the surgery all day who pounce on doctors without appointments, and means doctors don't have to waste time on people who don't actually need to see a doctor [/quote]
And that's why I prefer it. I can sit in the comfort of my own home, getting on with my work, and just speak to the doc when they ring.

I don't need to pay £2.60 to park for 20 minutes near my house, either, or sit in the waiting room panicking that my appointment will take me over the time I've paid for.

LakieLady · 16/11/2021 11:28

There's public and private healthcare insurance from what I remember, public is 14.6% of an employees gross salary, half paid by the employer. Everyone must have some form of health insurance by law. It seems to work very well. If on unemployment benefits you pay nothing

I'd love to know how the private insurance works. I hate the idea of the US system, where your cover can run out before your treatment has ended, and people have to pay massive "co-pays". And where people are trapped in jobs because their insurance is part of their employment package, and they've developed a condition that won't be covered if they have to switch to a new provider.

Medical bills were the biggest single cause of bankruptcy in the US, and may still be.

Do OAPs have to pay for private health insurance in Germany, too, OP?

That would be the bit that would worry me. I'm past retirement age, but still working. When I give up work, my income will be just above the level at which I would qualify for means-tested benefits. There's no way I could afford to pay for private health insurance, and probably wouldn't qualify for state help.

Having paid tax and NI for nearly 50 years, I'd be a bit resistant to having to fork out for health insurance now, when I'm most likely to need expensive treatment.

Aliveandkicking23 · 16/11/2021 11:24

Tonsillitis can quickly turn into quensey which is life threatening.
My DD had this at 29. It was growing as you looked at it.
The Doctor in A&E slit it without anesthetic as she was struggling to breathe.

Vapeyvapevape · 16/11/2021 11:23

@endofagain we had similar, everyone decamped to the ‘good’ surgery who are now overwhelmed with new patients and the service has declined rapidly.

LittleDandelionClock · 16/11/2021 11:22

@CloseYourEyesAndSee

Don't you have a GP you are registered with? They can give you an appointment today? Also are you sure It’s bacterial? Tonsillitis can be viral which won't respond to antibiotics.
This. ^ Tonsillitis needs antibiotics. Call your GP, and ask for anti biotics.

Sorry you ae really poorly. Hope you feel well soon @GrrrlPwr

Tubs11 · 16/11/2021 11:18

If you're in England and you've had tonsillitis previously and were prescribed antibiotics Dr should be able to give you prescription over the phone. This was my experience anyway. You were wise to go home, you'd have been there for hours as it's low on the ME list

ilovesooty · 16/11/2021 11:01

@HesterShaw1

This is dreadful.

I know this was the plan all along but it really is time for the NHS to be dismantled. It's completely dysfunctional.

I've a feeling the government are relying on the electorate thinking that.
LakieLady · 16/11/2021 11:00

she DIDNT GO TO A&E

Is this the new "cancel the cheque"? Grin

MauraandLaura · 16/11/2021 10:58

Ah OP that sounds dreadful. I hope you get sorted soon. Flowers

user1497207191 · 16/11/2021 10:57

@ThePoisonousMushroom

Don’t forget we also pay a lot for the NHS… via our taxes. It isn’t free. It’s just free at the point of use.
Exactly, and the free at the point of use is why "some" NHS staff treat their patients badly with the attitude of "it's free so you should think yourselves lucky" however bad the service they provide.

There's also very little "real" competition between providers despite Blair/Brown who massively increased the "competition" aspect to try to improve service. It simply doesn't work when in reality, for a lot of services, there is no competition at all. It's like the railways where different companies were supposed to improve services by competition which is a failure in real life because for a lot of services, there simply wasn't any competition.

LakieLady · 16/11/2021 10:56

[quote user1497207191]@LakieLady

Ime, first thing in the morning is the worst time to try and get through. My surgery switchboard opens at 8 or 8.30 (can't recall which), and you'll be waiting an hour to speak to anyone if you ring then. It's as though everyone's trying to get through first thing. I find that if I can leave it until 9.30 - 10, there's only 3 or 4 people in front and I get through pretty quickly.

Trouble is that in a lot of GP surgeries, all the appts have gone by 9.30, and you're just told to phone back "tomorrow at 8am". That's the real problem - GP surgeries being inflexible, not offering online booking, only booking appts for the same day, etc.[/quote]
Yes, I'm a bit mystified as to how my surgery is always able to give me a same-day telephone appointment. But they do!

I once got the telephone call after 7pm though, maybe they just stay there till they've worked through the list.

ThePoisonousMushroom · 16/11/2021 10:52

Don’t forget we also pay a lot for the NHS… via our taxes. It isn’t free. It’s just free at the point of use.

HesterShaw1 · 16/11/2021 10:51

Have just been reading about it. DP is German and his dad has had a lot of health issues the last couple of years. The care he's received sounds very good, on the whole.

I say "sounds" because DP hasn't been able to see them in person for two years, but that's by the by :(

Cornettoninja · 16/11/2021 10:51

How are you feeling today @GrrrlPwr? I do hope you’ve managed to at least speak to someone.

Brainwave89 · 16/11/2021 10:51

Tonsillitis is a good example of hugely painful condition which can take you down for days. Every few years I go down with a bout and it is hugely debilitating. I feel for you OP. An NHS needs to be able to deal with matters like this which are not life threatening, but important non the less.

WidowTwonky · 16/11/2021 10:51

@DGFB

I’d never dream of going to A&E for tonsillitis, I don’t consider it to be a life-threatening emergency. At 10pm I’d phone 111
she DIDNT GO TO A&E
endofagain · 16/11/2021 10:49

Where I live there are a couple of good practices and a really terrible one. The distance between them is about a ten minute walk. I don't know if it is the practice manager, the partners? It can't be the CCG because it is the same one.
I have advised friends and neighbours to change surgeries if they possibly can, because the care at this particular surgery is so poor.

anon12345678901 · 16/11/2021 10:47

@HesterShaw1

Germans do pay a lot from what I can gather.
There's public and private healthcare insurance from what I remember, public is 14.6% of an employees gross salary, half paid by the employer. Everyone must have some form of health insurance by law. It seems to work very well. If on unemployment benefits you pay nothing.
thebakeoffwasntasgoodthisyear · 16/11/2021 10:47

*were

thebakeoffwasntasgoodthisyear · 16/11/2021 10:46

Was it a walk in centre, or where you supposed to phone to be triaged first?

I used to work in an urgent care centre - patients had to phone and were then given a f2f appt if needed, following telephone triage by the GP. Some would just turn up hoping to be seen, and sometimes be annoyed when they had to wait their turn, as the call back time was maybe 3-4 hours.

Hope you are feeling better soon

LakieLady · 16/11/2021 10:43

@endofagain

It is really shocking that the service is so different in various parts of the country. If one NHS trust can organise an efficient blood test service with a simple online system, why can't they all do it? The difference between GP practices in my area is huge. Is it just incompetence? Poor organisation? Maybe there are some places NHS staff just don't want to work. It sounds as if a private GP consult online might be a good option. Amoxycillin costs around £4 for a 7 day course. I am so sorry OP tonsillitis is so painful.
That's a very good question, @endofagain.

I suspect that the GP shortage will vary widely in severity between areas. I know that the city near me has lost far more GPs, proportionately speaking, than the neighbouring CCG area which is a mix of rural villages and quite affluent small towns.

The city GP practices face a vastly different range of problems from those in the more rural area. There's a lot more poverty, drug and alcohol dependency, mental health issues, homelessness, substandard housing and domestic abuse in the city. Life expectancy for men is 4.5 years lower in the city. Anecdotally, I'm told that there are GP practices in the city that have security guards on the door when the surgery is open because of violence and abuse (and this was pre-Covid). They don't even have security at the pubs and bars where I live!

I know where I'd prefer to work if I was a GP, nurse or medical admin.

HesterShaw1 · 16/11/2021 10:41

Germans do pay a lot from what I can gather.

Sweetandsaltycaroline · 16/11/2021 10:41

Trouble is that in a lot of GP surgeries, all the appts have gone by 9.30, and you're just told to phone back "tomorrow at 8am". That's the real problem - GP surgeries being inflexible, not offering online booking, only booking appts for the same day, etc.

This is what our surgery is like. Even by 8.30 all the days appointments are likely to have gone, and you can't book in advance. There is literally no choice but to constantly call at 8.10am when appointments open.
I imagine it's just as shitty for the receptionists to have 500 people call all at the same time (and a number of them being frustrated when they can't get through or get an appointment) but they don't seem to have devised or found a better system!