Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my children to attend our Christmas meal?

260 replies

Worryingmama · 15/11/2021 23:55

Going to in-laws this year for Christmas Day. We have a 4 year old and a 1 year old. It’s long been in-law tradition to do Christmas dinner as a supper in the evening rather than at lunch. This was fine for the pre-grandchildren years but since we’ve had kids it has bothered me. This year with our eldest being 4 years old, it just seems to mean to have it at a time they will be in bed! In laws claim children don’t enjoy long sit down meals and it’s better to do in adult-only time. For me, even if kids need a bit of persuading to sit down for it, the Christmas meal should be a whole-family celebration.

AIBU to feel quite pissed off about this?

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2021 09:04

Good time to start having Christmas lunch at lunch time at your house. It’s a shame for children to miss out. Just speak to them. You aren’t expecting them to change times.

Kotatsu · 16/11/2021 09:03

I have such fond memories of the ridiculous chaos of Christmas lunch (far too many people in too-small a house, kids table, adults table etc)

Objectively looking back, it was insane, and I'm sure the adults wondered why they were doing it, but at the same time it was wonderful. Then supper was a calm, quiet picky bits affair (where children weren't policed at all, so we'd often just eat the biscuits!).

I think you need to consider a new tradition - although it also might be you end up having 2 dinners :) On the bright side, if your kids need feeding, at least it means you can look forward to actual food later (assuming they go to bed and you're not abandoned putting them to sleep)

Placido · 16/11/2021 09:03

YANBU Our culture is so weird that it even thinks there should be adult only time, in other cultures everyone is in included. My in laws refused to let our first DC have Christmas lunch because they wanted 'grown up food'. They wanted her to be napping upstairs instead. I said that is just fine I will mush it up, fed her, let her enjoy the day and then we didn't go back there for Christmas lunch for quite a few years. You have to stand firm against Victorian values!!!

BruceAndNosh · 16/11/2021 09:03

I couldn't eat a full Christmas dinner in the evening.
We normally have a fancy breakfast, Christmas Dinner around 3, and no need for a proper meal that evening. Cheese or leftovers if anyone wants a bite, they help themselves

Djifunrsn · 16/11/2021 09:01

I'm in 2 minds. I wonder whether a 4yo gives a crap about the meal. It's about the presents and fun for them?

That said, it is an odd idea IMO to have it so late with small kids around and if it were me, I'd have it earlier.

billy1966 · 16/11/2021 08:58

Time for a new tradition at home.

I wouldn't be up for that at all.

Things change when children arrive and in our house we ate together on Christmas day.

I would be bowing out.

Inastatus · 16/11/2021 08:58

YANBU. I think it’s time for you to create the sort of family Christmas you want your children to grow up with and remember. It doesn’t matter how many people tell you you should enjoy having a grown up meal without kids in the evening, you obviously won’t knowing that your DC are not part of it. I wouldn’t either. My 2 DC are teens now and we have always eaten Christmas dinner together.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 16/11/2021 08:56

My 2 always looked forward to their dinner as much as their gifts! And the littlest always has a leg - resulting in lots of hilarious tired babies/toddlers wielding a turkey leg over the years. We eat about 7 and have always had gifts then brekkie, snacky lunch and chocolate and then a snooze in front of a film/building lego etc for kids whilst adults cook. I wouldn't have any part of Xmas without my DC

Edenember · 16/11/2021 08:54

The Christmas meal (and indeed family mealtimes in general) are precious to me and so intrinsically part of the festivities I’d want my children there. It wouldn’t be Christmas without it, for me, so of course I’d want them there. Everyone needs child-free times but I just don’t feel the Christmas meal is one of those times, and neither, apparently you, do you.

That said I really don’t think it’s up to you to dictate changes to another households traditions - you have to be willing to start your own at home. If it were me, I’d sit down and explain to them that on accepting the invite it dawned on me how important it is for my children to be involved, and that I therefore had made the decision to have Christmas dinner at home this year. I would personally still offer to visit them at some point. They can then do with that information what they will - change the time or expect you to do your own thing.

HW1989 · 16/11/2021 08:51

I wouldn’t want a huge Christmas dinner late in to evening anyway or to be having to cook it then either. Nice to get the cooking out the way early and have all afternoon to digest. Relaxed nibbles and wine in the evening after kids are in bed.
I understand it’s their long time tradition but things sometimes have to change, I don’t think you’re being unreasonable to want to start a new tradition that suits your growing family and then it’s up to the in laws if they want to join in or see you another day.

Tulipomania · 16/11/2021 08:49

Evening Christmas Dinner used to be my family's tradition - until our DC were born.

Then my parents were happy to move it to lunchtime and it has stayed at lunch ever since, even though the DC are now adults.

OP, could your PIL be persuaded to eat an hour earlier, and you let the DC stay up later (at least the 4 year old, the 1 year old won't know any different)?

Maybe get the 4 year old to have a nap in the afternoon so they are rested for the main event.

INeedNewShoes · 16/11/2021 08:49

No 4 year old I know gives a fig about Christmas dinner

Mine does. She loves food and eating. Gathering at the table for Christmas lunch is the main event of the day in our family.

We don’t have a starter so I suppose that means it’s less drawn out than in some houses.

WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow · 16/11/2021 08:39

I don’t think either are BU tbh. If you prefer to have an earlier Christmas dinner with your dc then you can decline the invitation and do that in your own home and there would be nothing wrong with you making that decision as the parents of small dc.

The ILs however are not obliged to change what is their Christmas tradition to suit your preferences. They’ve raised their dc and have moved on to a different type of Christmas. Not every part of the day has to be small child focused anyway and I really don’t think the dc will be missing out by not sitting through a long, late meal.

Presumably they’re not expecting their guests to go all day without eating so surely there’ll be an earlier meal that will include the dc?

shouldistop · 16/11/2021 08:28

They want one kind of Christmas meal (not interrupted by children) and you'd prefer a family meal. Obviously you can't expect them to change their plans in their own home so I'd politely decline.
This is why we host Christmas at ours every year and anyone is welcome to come or not if they'd prefer. I like doing Christmas my way Grin
Most people come every year so they must like it too.

Aderyn21 · 16/11/2021 08:24

I’m with the IL’s too. I honestly think that your children will have been playing and eating all day and will be ready to sleep. They won’t be missing out because children don’t enjoy extended meals in the same way that adults do.
Christmas isn’t only for children. Adults are allowed to have nice things for themselves too.

EarlGreywithLemon · 16/11/2021 08:23

I don’t understand excluding children from family meals generally, let alone at Christmas. YANBU, they are family members and of course should eat with you at Christmas. I’d see your in laws on Boxing Day until your children are old enough to be allowed to join in.

PurpleDaisies · 16/11/2021 08:22

Plus it does seem mean to exclude children from the main meal/ festivity of the day. That’s their choice but I think I’d want to stay in my own home where children are welcome.
It’s not purposely excluding children. It’s carrying on with their king standing tradition.

Do children particularly enjoy sitting down for a meal? A lot of people are talking as if it’s going to be all gruel and coal at the parents’ house. It could be a lovely day but just without the formal sitting together for a full Christmas dinner.

Practicebeingpatient · 16/11/2021 08:21

Whatever you do, don't text them over this. Either speak to them yourself or your DH can do it. Texting doesn't allow for nuance or correcting misunderstandings. But YANBU to want a different tradition for your family.

deplorabelle · 16/11/2021 08:20

I probably would have felt the same as you when my children were really young but I am on your in laws side now. You will not enjoy Christmas dinner with two tired, overexcited small children to wrangle (and that would also be true if you had it at lunchtime). In future years it will be exciting for them to be old enough to stay up for grown up Christmas dinner and they will enjoy the novelty. A 4 year old is more likely to find it a bit of an endurance trial.

To those folk berating the inlaws for "inflexibility" and telling the OP to throw a strop and stay at home, think that one through one more time....

Spiceup · 16/11/2021 08:20

Actually, provided most of the day is child centred, that sounds like and excellent idea. Long large family dinners at my GPs were torture , soooooo boring

DraigFach · 16/11/2021 08:19

My eldest would be delighted at being excluded from the Christmas meal, my youngest would be absolutely gutted.

That for me would dictate that we'd make our own Christmas meal arrangements and politely decline the invitation. Of all the days of the year, Christmas should be about inclusion, not exclusion.

YANBU

MrsWooster · 16/11/2021 08:18

Have a childcentred Christmas at your house. The previous generation have had their chance to make Christmas’s that suit them and now it’s your turn.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/11/2021 08:17

@Dontforgetyourbrolly see I want to know where to purchase the ones who’ll meekly go to bed on cue, when adults are evidently still up and partying…

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/11/2021 08:16

I would just never have managed to have the children in bed in time to come down and enjoy it. And for a parent, it’s horrible being stuck upstairs settling children whilst everyone is having fun.

Plus it does seem mean to exclude children from the main meal/ festivity of the day. That’s their choice but I think I’d want to stay in my own home where children are welcome.

Personally I tend not to want to start big meals, drinking etc when my children are in bed - never did. Always felt like having wind down time at that point.

But that wold just be me/ my choice!

Pumpkinsonparade · 16/11/2021 08:15

So in say 3 year's time if pfb is allowed to join in are you going to be happy to send 1 of your dc to bed?
Does your dh have fond memories of Xmas with this rule?

Swipe left for the next trending thread