Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have done a PhD?

110 replies

ClaraBean · 15/11/2021 23:24

And if you have, how old were you when you started it?
I'm 42, and really feeling the urge to go back to uni and do my PhD. I'm obsessed with the idea. Will I be an old crone? Is it the most ridiculous thing you have ever heard?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2021 07:26

I started mine at 23. Hardest thing I've ever done and it took immense toll on my relationships with my partner, family and friends. Don't under estimate that aspect of it, it's all encompassing so of course it impacts beyond yourself.

I don't think it has actively harmed my employment prospects (outside of academia), but it certainly didn't help them and I think I was very lucky to have gotten the start I did in my career. The majority of the people I graduated with are still on crappy post doc contracts or are TEFLing.

If I had my time again, I wouldn't even consider doing it.

EishetChayil · 16/11/2021 07:25

I was 37 when I started. I'll be just shy of 41 when I finish.

DaisyDozyDee · 16/11/2021 07:24

I think there are advantages to starting later. I started mine at 20 and would have appreciated the opportunity more and enjoyed it more if I’d had more experience of doing something else first - both subject related experience and wider life experience would have helped.

BobbinThreadbare123 · 16/11/2021 07:15

I did mine straight after undergrad. Started at 22, done at 25. I can relate a little to the comments about being unemployable, despite not remaining in academia. Industry has either liked or totally ignored it. Education sector same (depending on the type of school). Present job likes me to have it and since it's male dominated, I stand out.

DogDaysNeverEnd · 16/11/2021 07:14

Im almost finished, I hope, doing an engineering PhD via a funded Centre for Doctoral Training which has meant about a taught MSc of modules whilst research went on (I already had an MSc). It's been very hard work! I found a PhD essentially to be an apprenticeship for an academic career, or an industrial position with a heavy research component. It's no harder per se than an MSc, but there is just so much to get through requiring masses of self motivation. It's been especially lonely during lockdowns and remote working.

If you don't need a PhD or you don't know why you want to do a PhD then I would not recommend a PhD. The age part is not the issue, plenty of mature students throughout the uni.

custardbear · 16/11/2021 07:11

I did my PhD in my 20's, I still work in university setting and many in medicine are mid career doing part time or full time phds.
It's hard, intensive and lots of work, so be prepared. Do something where you have a decent supervisor and you're really interested in the subject area and you'll be fine

mdh2020 · 16/11/2021 07:10

My husband told me I would be 50 when I finished my PhD and I said I might as well do it then as I would still be 50 without one. It’s hard work and you need to give up almost all your free time (I was working) but we’ll worth it. Choose a topic you love, are fascinated by so that you never resent the hours reading about it or researching it. My peer group was mixed and I don’t think I was the oldest. And graduation day was the best!

AgileSlug · 16/11/2021 07:04

"It makes you virtually unemployable unless you’re lucky enough to get a lecturing job at university. In the past DH has been told by employers that they’d be more likely to employ him with a 5 year prison sentence on his CV than a 5 year PhD."

Nobody has ever said it so bluntly, but I have had that experience too. Whenever I'm applying for jobs outside academia, I take my PhD off my CV and was doing voluntary work and helping out with the family business whilst raising my family. It makes me sound a humbler and kind and helpful person, modest and deferential.

Ryannah · 16/11/2021 07:04

Surely companies are happy to have a Dr on their staff list
😂😂😂
No. Lots of bosses don’t want to hire someone smarter than them in case it makes them look bad or the person gets promoted ahead of them. And they think the person will be a pain in the arse too.

Igmum · 16/11/2021 06:37

Yes. Started in my early 30s. The oldest PhD student I've ever supervised started in her early 60s and finished writing up in retirement. Good luck OP, it's a great experience

Jenjenn · 16/11/2021 06:33

I finished mine at age 27, my aunt completed hers when she was 55. What subject area are you considering? In my experience candidates entering PhD in arts and humanities candidates have a much wider age spread but for stem it really tends to be people in their early 20s.

Yusanaim · 16/11/2021 06:32

Surely companies are happy to have a Dr on their staff list.

EdmontinaDonsAutumnalHues · 16/11/2021 06:29

OP it may be that you’re not aware of the new-ish ‘Mature Study and Retraining’ board, here:

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/mature_students

MNHQ will happily move your thread for you, if you ask via the Report button.

Santastuckincustoms · 16/11/2021 06:29

Do it, if you can afford to. Remember your supervisor will probably be younger than you, that can be an issue for some (saying this as a supervisor).

I haven't experienced the unemployable situation. My Dh's work is in industry and his entire team have PhDs.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 16/11/2021 06:23

I tend to agree with @Ryannah.
I regularly recruit in IT/business change and have found that people with a very academic background (PhD, DPhil or those who have worked in academia for a long time) don't tend to be a good fit in a business environment.

I do recognise that this has now become an 'unconscious bias' for me.

Wiglio · 16/11/2021 06:10

I have one, graduated when I was 50

Ryannah · 16/11/2021 05:54

Wow, what type of industry does your husband work in?
Computing. So of course when he graduated and tried to get a job as a programmer alongside people with just a BSc, he wasn’t very successful. The same applies to any subject where the PhD isn’t absolutely essential for the job. I’m just saying think about long term job prospects because if the PhD isn’t essential it will damage your employability.

Roseandgeranium · 16/11/2021 04:11

Depends what you want to do with it. If it’s just for the love of your subject I’d say go for it! I finished mine in my early 30s but there were three people in my department doing PhDs who started aged between early 40s and early 60s.
The reason I say only do it for the love is that — depending on your field, of course, but I’m going to guess it’s something in the humanities? — the chances of you (or any other recent PhD graduate) finding a job close to home in academia is really small. There are very, very few permanent posts going in many fields, and most people have to move for work, often several times, as they take on a series of short term, poorly paid positions to gain experience before (in a minority of cases, sadly) finding permanent work which may even then be in a city they don’t especially like and/or is a long journey from friends and family. You might buck that trend, of course, but I’d advise you not to bet the farm on it.
All that being said, the process of researching and writing a thesis can be enormously satisfying, especially with the right supervisor. And being more mature is often an advantage: better time management and less inclination to waste an entire day in the library shuttling between coffee breaks with course mates, for instance. If you want to go ahead you should have a clear and highly specific idea about your research topic before applying, and you should aim to have a clear sense of what has already been published in your area so you can be clear about the knowledge gap your work would fill. Maybe you’re at that stage in your thinking already, but, if not, doing the research necessary to put your application together will likely help you determine how much you’ll love (or not) the PhD itself. Best of luck!

Fallingirl · 16/11/2021 03:58

I was 44 when I started. I did mine with the Open University, where students are older on average than elsewhere. I fitted right in, and loved it.

OhhShiny · 16/11/2021 03:47

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

ilovepuppies2019 · 16/11/2021 03:07

@Ryannah

Treat it as a hobby. It makes you virtually unemployable unless you’re lucky enough to get a lecturing job at university. In the past DH has been told by employers that they’d be more likely to employ him with a 5 year prison sentence on his CV than a 5 year PhD.
Wow, what type of industry does your husband work in? That sounds very unusual. That hasn't been my experience at all. Definitely go for it OP as that is not old to be doing a PhD at all. I did mine in my late 20s and early 30a but lots do it later. I wouldn't treat it as a hobby though as it's challenging and requires real dedication. I'd you'd like to move down the path of acedemics then you need to be focused on producing high quality research to be published. I would say it's no more a hobby than any other job is. Best of luck.
SalsaLove · 16/11/2021 03:05

I’m curious why you’re “obsessed” with the idea. Is it because you love a certain subject and want to contribute to the current research?

Dishhh · 16/11/2021 02:53

I was in my thirties - but you can do it at any age. It does require fortitude and persistence, though, and you have to be certain you really do you have a deep interest in your particular field of study. You'll be living it for some time Smile

GreenLunchBox · 16/11/2021 02:52

@Ryannah

Treat it as a hobby. It makes you virtually unemployable unless you’re lucky enough to get a lecturing job at university. In the past DH has been told by employers that they’d be more likely to employ him with a 5 year prison sentence on his CV than a 5 year PhD.
Depends on the industry, surely?
backatschool · 16/11/2021 02:49

@Ryannah

Ryannah Why?! A number of things he’s been told by employers over the years: High qualifications means high salary expectations. The job won’t be challenging enough. Won’t be happy in this job, will move on quickly to something better. High risk of insubordination, thinking he’s smarter than everyone else. Probably is smarter than everyone else, will affect the office dynamics and won’t fit in, won’t work well as part of a team, will make less educated bosses feel uncomfortable and threatened. Too steeped in the non-profit academic mindset, won’t grasp the commercial nature of the workplace. Etc.

He has a nice job now but there were a LOT of rejections simply because of the PhD. Even now he doubts his ability to switch jobs because he’ll still be judged for it.

I think this really depends on the subject. This isn't my experience at all - I work in an industry in a role that typically doesn't employ people without a PhD...
Swipe left for the next trending thread