Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have done a PhD?

110 replies

ClaraBean · 15/11/2021 23:24

And if you have, how old were you when you started it?
I'm 42, and really feeling the urge to go back to uni and do my PhD. I'm obsessed with the idea. Will I be an old crone? Is it the most ridiculous thing you have ever heard?

OP posts:
WanderleyWagon · 17/11/2021 00:28

I have a PhD, and I've supervised quite a few PhDs, and two of them were retirement age by the time they submitted their theses (both very successfully!). Don't let age stop you, but I'd second what PPs have said about the shortage of jobs - I'd be wary of doing it for an academic job, because at the moment that's a total lottery. Grim, grim job situation.

Ledition · 17/11/2021 00:24

Started Aged 34. Full scholarship, had wanted to do one for ages, was so excited and enthusiastic... Became utterly bored of my subject by the time I'd finished! And mine was actually topical and interesting to most people and not related to some obscure piece of 18th century literature. Which brings me to the worst part of undertaking a PhD - listening to others drone on about their mind numbingly dull research in meetings/conferences etc. While trying to feign interest. Honestly I only kept ploughing through for ego purposes.

Nutsaremynemesis · 16/11/2021 23:58

I did mine after my BSc so I had finished by 25. This was pretty much the norm in my department (though there were a couple of mature students). Mine is in a STEM subject. About half of us are in industry and the rest are still in academia. I had great fun doing mine and have zero regrets. It’s definitely increased my salary and I have been actively employed because I have it rather than sneered at and avoided. I never use the title dr (apart from at work) and very few people out of my work environment know I have one. It makes me cringe when someone does the whole “actually it’s dr” thing. There is a certain type of person who does think it makes them better (I’ve met a fair few). I’m sure they feel discriminated against but it probably has more to do with them being a twat than having a PhD.

The PhD itself wasn’t actually that difficult - what is difficult is ploughing on alone and putting everything you have into a three year endeavour that might not be good enough at the end of it to actually receive your PhD. That’s not meant to be scary as you’d have to be pretty unlucky for that to happen (as long as you put the work in) - but mentally it’s hard to keep pushing through the low points when it seems such a long solitary task.

The comment re a potential employer having a preference for a 5 year prison sentence over a 5 year PhD makes sense to some extent as taking 5 years to do one would be a potential red flag for me - mine only took just over 3 and I dicked about a fair bit. Obviously if it’s part time then that’s different but when I did mine every one of us were working on the PhD full time and it was all industry funded research… the only person who took four years underwent treatment for very aggressive cancer part way through which is why they took a bit longer. They got better and are now very well known (internationally) in our field :-) I’m not, I’m your typically geeky introvert, but I work in a field that has a positive impact on people so it feels worthwhile.

I’d say go for it!

Hesma · 16/11/2021 22:55

My Aunt retired from teaching then did LLB, LLM and finished PhD in her mid 70s. Go for it!

Kenneldogsrock · 16/11/2021 12:53

I’m halfway through mine at the moment and I’m 50. It’s hard doing it part time on top of work and other commitments but I’m actually enjoying it.

Butchyrestingface · 16/11/2021 12:21

@Ryannah

Treat it as a hobby. It makes you virtually unemployable unless you’re lucky enough to get a lecturing job at university. In the past DH has been told by employers that they’d be more likely to employ him with a 5 year prison sentence on his CV than a 5 year PhD.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Gahd, that made my day.

Srettel · 16/11/2021 12:14

I started mine at 45, after swithering for several years. I would have regretted it forever if I hadn't done it.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 16/11/2021 12:00

@Ryannah

Treat it as a hobby. It makes you virtually unemployable unless you’re lucky enough to get a lecturing job at university. In the past DH has been told by employers that they’d be more likely to employ him with a 5 year prison sentence on his CV than a 5 year PhD.
Nonsense. I work in a specialist field where we often sponsor people through PhD or they use their professional role as the basis for their research.

I mean, if he’s a sales manager for a mobile phone company, then maybe it wouldn’t help at all. But having a research degree in the field you work in is never going to hold you back. Universities aren’t the only places where research happens, and for my field, specialist knowledge is our currency.

TuftyMarmoset · 16/11/2021 10:46

@Ryannah

Treat it as a hobby. It makes you virtually unemployable unless you’re lucky enough to get a lecturing job at university. In the past DH has been told by employers that they’d be more likely to employ him with a 5 year prison sentence on his CV than a 5 year PhD.
I work in a civil service/government type role and loads of people where I work have PhDs. 2 people in my team of 8 alone!
TuftyMarmoset · 16/11/2021 10:38

My DP is just finishing one. He is mid twenties but there is a real mix of people in his department. A lot of people who have worked in the industry for many years and then come back to do a PhD and lots of international students of varying ages as well.
My relative also did a PhD a few years ago for fun after retiring!

Ihaveoflate · 16/11/2021 10:13

I'm 40 and started mine last year. I'm probably one of the younger of my cohort peers.

I work part-time and have a toddler, so not much free time, but I treat it like my hobby. So far, so good.

SoftSheen · 16/11/2021 10:12

I started my PhD at 23, graduated at 26. It's a brilliant thing to do if you are extremely interested in your subject. Very hard work though (at least in the experimental sciences).

IME experience a good PhD (with publications) results in plenty of job opportunities, and is a requirement in many fields such as research. Personally I work with lots of people who hold PhDs in computer science. Obviously some jobs are only available in particular locations, but you should take that into consideration when choosing your subject.

TractorAndHeadphones · 16/11/2021 10:12

@Ryannah

I find this quite surprising. Perhaps it is location-dependent? I mean Silicon Valley is absolutely full of PhDs in computer science etc. Maybe if we’d moved to London or California. But in Yorkshire it seems that small businesses (and they are mostly all small businesses) prefer not to hire someone who’s more qualified than them.

As computing/computer science degrees are quite theoretical it wouldn’t have been of much use in a front end web dev job
That was the problem I think. Lots of theory and research studies that employers didn’t care about, they just wanted programming skills. Maybe if we had moved to a city he’d have been applying for jobs that were more relevant to his qualifications. If you don’t intend to relocate then a PhD probably isn’t worth it.

Businesses like the ones you describe have no use for good programmers . IT is an annoying overhead. Like cleaning. They have old tech and all they want is someone to keep something sticky-taped together running as cheaply as possible rather than write actual good code. That is if they’re even hiring for developers and not sysadmins. If it’s the latter then It’s sort of like tech support. They don’t want to hire people who are curious, start asking questions and try to improve things. But of course they can’t tell you this so they come up with silly excuses…

However someone with a PhD could definitely get a better job - and should already know where the market for their skills are. He shouldn’t have been shocked or surprised

Doveyouknow · 16/11/2021 10:06

I started mine at 21 but there were people of all ages doing PhDs. My job is completely unrelated to my PhD so I don't use my title but I am not aware of anyone being put off by me having a PhD when I have applied for jobs. At interview people are generally interested in what it involved. I would say a PhD is really hard though

Bonnealle · 16/11/2021 10:04

Mid-20s, but I was one of the youngest. I’ve honestly never thought about people ages and being too old or too you d to do something?

JumperandJacket · 16/11/2021 09:59

I am doing one at the moment. I love it but it is hard, especially trying to juggle my research with PT work and childcare.

Although I wouldn't go as far as pp about the risks of doing a PhD, it is worth thinking about what it is you hope to get out of it before you start-

  • interest and enjoyment?
  • a valuable qualification in your existing career?
  • a new career (in academia or something else)?

All of these can be good reasons but you need to be clear and realistic. Moving into academia as a career, say, can be extremely challenging- the low pay and job insecurity which many early career researchers face are bad enough in your 20s but may be impossible if you are in your 40s with financial commitments.

My PhD will be of essentially no value in my career, although it won't be as negative as pp described- it will simply be 5 years when I wasn't doing my old job, only slightly more saleable than a 5 year career break.

None of this is to say don't do it- it's a wonderful thing to do- but you need your eyes open in terms of what you hope to gain from it. If it's just for your own interest and pleasure, that's fine.

EdmontinaDonsAutumnalHues · 16/11/2021 09:42

@Idony Repeating what I said to another poster earlier, it would be incredibly helpful if you could start a thread on the ‘Mature Study and Retraining’ board. (Link above.)

In the thread that preceded its creation I commented on the almost uncountable number of women posting on MN whose first sentence was ‘Am I too old to …”. This thought can be so utterly terrifying and induces the most painful stasis - sometimes over decades.

I’m grateful for the new board, but wish MNHQ could make more noise about the issue, all the time, everywhere.

TheKeatingFive · 16/11/2021 09:32

My industry isn't averse to phds, they're attractive to certain companies as they feel they add cachet.

However, they would be very careful when assessing the candidate at entry level. There would be concerns that the individual would not be well suited to starting at the bottom and they would want reassurance that they were prepared to do this like any other grad.

Ryannah · 16/11/2021 09:16

I find this quite surprising. Perhaps it is location-dependent? I mean Silicon Valley is absolutely full of PhDs in computer science etc.
Maybe if we’d moved to London or California. But in Yorkshire it seems that small businesses (and they are mostly all small businesses) prefer not to hire someone who’s more qualified than them.

As computing/computer science degrees are quite theoretical it wouldn’t have been of much use in a front end web dev job
That was the problem I think. Lots of theory and research studies that employers didn’t care about, they just wanted programming skills. Maybe if we had moved to a city he’d have been applying for jobs that were more relevant to his qualifications. If you don’t intend to relocate then a PhD probably isn’t worth it.

sar302 · 16/11/2021 09:08

@Ryannah I can totally believe this. I had a boss bully me relentlessly because she didn't like me, because I had a fricking masters degree. She decided that I got into the job purely because of the degree (she didn't hire me), despite the fact that I had loads of experience also. She also bullied my colleague with a masters. Her "golden girl" was a girl with a couple of A levels, who she saw as "grafting and working her way up." When this girl started doing a part-time degree in a related subject, she went on to the bullying list as well.

Some people have bizarre views of further education.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 16/11/2021 09:07

Which rubbed some people up the wrong way.

While it wouldn't bother me at all (my sister and her husband are both academic doctors) I have always worked in environments where nobody puts their academic or industry qualifications after their names. In my business environment It's no more useful to know that Mary has a PhD than John has an MSc or Freda left school after A levels.

TractorAndHeadphones · 16/11/2021 09:06

Also degrees not correlating to programming ability is a pet subject of mine as a ‘self-taught’ developer but this isn’t the thread for that 😂😂😂

TractorAndHeadphones · 16/11/2021 09:05

Also OP go for it! PhD’s have never been a negative point and I know quite a few older people doing them

TractorAndHeadphones · 16/11/2021 09:03

@teezletangler

Computing. So of course when he graduated and tried to get a job as a programmer alongside people with just a BSc, he wasn’t very successful.

I find this quite surprising. Perhaps it is location-dependent? I mean Silicon Valley is absolutely full of PhDs in computer science etc. DH went straight into working as a developer in the City after his, and it was apparently a big part of why he got an interview for that job.

I don’t know how long original poster’s DH got his PhD but it could be the type of jobs he was applying for. Or his PhD title . As computing/computer science degrees are quite theoretical it wouldn’t have been of much use in a front end web dev job compared to someone who has already built their own projects for example. Meanwhile C++ developers for financial trading systems need lots of theory, and someone from a ‘self-taught boot camp’ environment alone won’t cut it.

I suspect he didn’t apply to jobs commensurate with his qualifications

SarahAndQuack · 16/11/2021 09:02

@Ryannah

Wow, what type of industry does your husband work in? Computing. So of course when he graduated and tried to get a job as a programmer alongside people with just a BSc, he wasn’t very successful. The same applies to any subject where the PhD isn’t absolutely essential for the job. I’m just saying think about long term job prospects because if the PhD isn’t essential it will damage your employability.
This would not be true in many fields (I do know computing people can be funny about it, though, as my ex was in that field).

I did my PhD in my 20s, but knew people of all ages. Of my cohort, who finished in 2013/14, one has a permanent academic job, one (me) has had a string of temp academic jobs, one has editing and publishing and library-archivist jobs, and one works in non-academic research institute. We are not very representative TBH, but none of us ever found the PhD was a negative CV point - definitely the opposite.

I also know of people who went into publishing (again, a PhD is a plus point on your CV), civil service (not sure but she says they were polite/enthusiastic about it and they employed her, so ...), research support, education and outreach roles, obviously it's useful there.

When I apply for non-academic jobs (which I do, because frankly academic careers are a very very very very long shot), I usually put my PhD on my CV, as otherwise there'd be a gap, but I also specify that it was funded (ie., not a hobby project) and I don't use 'Dr' as my title, I use 'Ms'. I think that can be a good way of signalling that you are not going to be dwelling on your PhD and becoming a bore about how qualified you are.

I know a lot of people who I met after they completed PhDs and left academia, who work in perfectly normal, good, interesting jobs. You wouldn't necessarily know they had PhDs because it doesn't come up.

The problem is people (and there's always one), whose conversation starter is 'Hi, I'm Dave, and DID YOU KNOW I DID A PHD, ME, YES, YES, I AM A DOCTOR AND CONSIDERABLY MORE SMARTER THAN YOU'.

That is the person no one wants to employ.

Swipe left for the next trending thread