Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have done a PhD?

110 replies

ClaraBean · 15/11/2021 23:24

And if you have, how old were you when you started it?
I'm 42, and really feeling the urge to go back to uni and do my PhD. I'm obsessed with the idea. Will I be an old crone? Is it the most ridiculous thing you have ever heard?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
constance1 · 17/11/2021 21:01

I started mine when I was 31, finished when I was 35 and I was nowhere near the oldest in my cohort.

Sam020 · 17/11/2021 20:54

I tried doing one when I was 24 straight vafter my master's but picked the wrong topic (not interested in it), had no idea how to conduct research or generally what to do. I dropped out after 6 months. Tried again at age 32. This time chose the topic carefully, had learnt how vto do research and wasn't afraid to ask questions. In my case being older definitely helped.

TractorAndHeadphones · 17/11/2021 20:49

@FirewomanSam

I’m doing mine at the moment and I’m not much younger than you. It’s very, very hard and takes a lot of determination but it’s also very rewarding and satisfying. Expect enormous highs and lows, and to feel incredibly stupid a lot of the time, but otherwise go for it!

The comments about the IT industry are very interesting. My PhD is in the humanities and I work in a field where having a PhD is almost expected, and not having one severely limits your job prospects. However, I have previously worked in IT and sometimes went to university recruitment events on behalf of my company. I met a few PhD students at those who were utterly obnoxious and would come up to me to ask how much more than the stated starting salary they could expect to get, given that they were PhDs and therefore ‘worth more’. My bosses used to roll their eyes behind those students’ backs and say they would never hire anyone like that. I had no idea there was such a dim view of PhDs in the IT industry in general though!

It's entirely possible to get a PhD in Computer Science by doing less practical programming than someone who went through a 3 month bootcamp. There are quite a few jobs that pay crazy amounts for PhD's in the right specialties but for your 'average' IT job a PhD isn't more knowledgeable than someone with a BSc.

In this sense it's similar to accounting - a PhD doesn't qualify you to become a chartered accountant. In fact the more 'academic' the university for bachelor's degrees the more exams you'll have to sit as university modules tend to focus on broader themes and not the detailed technical knowledge required for the professional exams.

dinkydonky · 17/11/2021 15:56

I did one in my 20s, driven by interest rather than academic career aspirations. Plenty of older people doing them at the same time.

I'm definitely glad I did it, I enjoyed some parts of it, others not so much, but I think that's the case for anything you spend 3+ years doing. It's been far better for my career than I could have anticipated, I work in a brilliant field that I love, that pays well, it certainly hasn't put employers off in my experience.

DeepDown12 · 17/11/2021 15:41

I did my humanities PhD in my late 20s. It was a soul crushing, exhausting experience that costed me a lot (I also had to work to support myself through it). I did publish but as I went through the motions, I realized I didn't want to work in academia after all and, much like the other PP - found my PhD to be an obstacle to get a job outside academia and think-tank world. So I stayed and did a post-doc too while desperately looking for a way out.

All my jobs since (private sector) developed from a single project that landed into my lap due to a very niche set of skills that had nothing to do with the PhD... or at the very least, didn't require a PhD.

TheWhalrus · 17/11/2021 15:13

I have a PhD....I started on my 22nd birthday, finished at 25. In retrospect I was too young to get the most out of it. At the same time, I wouldn't be able to do it now (age 37). My experience was intense, not particularly pleasant and demanded a lot of weekend working. I didn't do badly in the jobs market afterwards, but mine is a life science PhD. For humanities, arts and social science PhDs life can be much harder afterwards.

bibliomania · 17/11/2021 15:10

Maybe that's something, @Redyellowblue34 - it's hard to quantify. I also have a personal writing project in mind, so maybe I could have used that time to make progress on that project and potentially even get something published. I can't honestly say if I could have used the time, money and energy in an equally (or more) constructive way or whether I would have just frittered it away.

HanukahMatata · 17/11/2021 15:06

I have a PhD. Work in public sector but not academia. In my field there are quite a few people with PhD. It certainly doesn't go against you but you can probably do just as well with a masters and then the extra years of experience will help more. Not that I regret it. I'm glad I did it (I was in my 30s). My kids were very little and it was easier and more flexible to be a student than to work full time.

SarahAndQuack · 17/11/2021 15:04

I think it's worth saying not everyone does feel a boost to their self esteem from having completed a PhD. For me, doing one was the right thing, and absolutely necessary since it's so far been how I earn my money. My, like the PP who was a bit concerned about the 'just go for it' advice, I am a bit cautious about the assumption everyone who completes a PhD feels an enormous sense of achievement. I loved quite a lot of doing my PhD, but I am disappointed in myself for how it went at the end. I never published from my thesis (which most people do, who stay in academia and work in my discipline). I have since written a book, which is the same sort of length/type of project and I am very proud of that despite knowing it's far from perfect, so I do have something to compare to.

It is perfectly possible to get to the end of a PhD and actually feel quite a lot of frustration that your pet project didn't come off as you'd hoped, or an honest sense it really isn't as good as you'd have liked.

I don't think that's necessarily a reason not to start one - just, I think, you shouldn't go into it assuming it will make you feel really proud at the end.

Redyellowblue34 · 17/11/2021 14:44

@bibliomania - but the cost value to personal development and self esteem from having completed a major project?

bibliomania · 17/11/2021 14:17

I did mine age 38-45 (part-time while working full-time). It hasn't given me a boost career-wise, to be honest. I work in professional services in a university, so it might get me a bit of respect in some quarters, but no extra money. I did it for love of the subject, but my subject area is quite fast-moving, so I already feel my knowledge is a bit dated, as I haven't kept up with the literature since I finished. It doesn't seem to have helped my employability in that sector (different field from the one I work in).

The jury is still out, but on a strict cost-benefit analysis, I'm not convinced it really paid off.

FirewomanSam · 17/11/2021 13:41

I’m doing mine at the moment and I’m not much younger than you. It’s very, very hard and takes a lot of determination but it’s also very rewarding and satisfying. Expect enormous highs and lows, and to feel incredibly stupid a lot of the time, but otherwise go for it!

The comments about the IT industry are very interesting. My PhD is in the humanities and I work in a field where having a PhD is almost expected, and not having one severely limits your job prospects. However, I have previously worked in IT and sometimes went to university recruitment events on behalf of my company. I met a few PhD students at those who were utterly obnoxious and would come up to me to ask how much more than the stated starting salary they could expect to get, given that they were PhDs and therefore ‘worth more’. My bosses used to roll their eyes behind those students’ backs and say they would never hire anyone like that. I had no idea there was such a dim view of PhDs in the IT industry in general though!

Redyellowblue34 · 17/11/2021 12:51

In the context as one poster said, it is a solitary endeavour. You don’t need to be pulling a dead weight in your supervisor. A good rapport will support and challenge a student to step out of their comfort zone.

Redyellowblue34 · 17/11/2021 12:48

Re Supervisor- the whole thing hinges on that relationship. If you don’t get each other the project is doomed. Needs to be a feeling if you’re both in this together.

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2021 10:34

It was very stressful and I would recommend picking your supervisor with as much care as you would pick a partner.

This is excellent advice.

TheKeatingFive · 17/11/2021 10:34

@ClaraBean I have this pinned up in my kitchen. Read it this morning and thought of you

I'm not trying to be very negative or anything, but I have reservations about this kind of advice. I got a lot of it before I embarked upon my PhD and I wish I hadn't. I needed more realism.

A phd is an enormous commitment. It takes years. It impacts on much more than the person doing it. I wouldn't advise anyone to do it unless they have a really clear understanding of the level commitment involved (far, far more than a masters for example) and what they realistically hope to get out of it.

Mine categorically wasn't worth it and I came very close to complete breakdown over it. Obviously others have different and more positive experiences, but that's mine.

Skeumorph · 17/11/2021 10:23

@Ryannah

Wow, what type of industry does your husband work in? Computing. So of course when he graduated and tried to get a job as a programmer alongside people with just a BSc, he wasn’t very successful. The same applies to any subject where the PhD isn’t absolutely essential for the job. I’m just saying think about long term job prospects because if the PhD isn’t essential it will damage your employability.
Nope. Both me and DH work in industries where PhDs are not madly uncommon but not unheard of - it's an asset.

Not computing so perfectly willing to concede that computing is full of blokes people with massive chips on their shoulder, but that isn't the case for grown up most industries.

Nutsaremynemesis · 17/11/2021 09:30

@ClaraBean I have this pinned up in my kitchen. Read it this morning and thought of you!

verytired42 · 17/11/2021 09:15

I have one and did it between the ages of 30 and 34. Took a bit longer as I only had three years of funding and was working full time while writing up - not a strategy I recommend. Not much in the way of career benefit - in fact significant financial hit because you don’t progress as fast clinically but it changed me and makes me better at what I do now. It was very stressful and I would recommend picking your supervisor with as much care as you would pick a partner.

FizzyTango · 17/11/2021 08:34

I’m doing one now, started when I was 29 (am 31 now). I have a couple of fellow PhD students who are 50+. We all get along, age doesn’t really matter in this context!

fourandnomore · 17/11/2021 08:17

Got mine at 25, if it’s useful in your industry great. You’re never too old. I needed one to progress but didn’t end up staying in that field and it has only ever been a positive for me, employment wise. I would agree with only doing it if you love it, it’s hard work.

scoobydoo1971 · 17/11/2021 00:57

Finished PhD at 32 on a scholarship. Had to work part-time as funding didn't cover costs of living in London. Did a few lecturing jobs, and fellowships. Started my own business at 2008, which fits with family and doesn't drain your soul like working as an academic for a University. Recommend it for anyone who can get funding. Self funding students should give long consideration to the cost-benefit in their career area. Also have a good look at the personal situation as the end-stages of a PhD can be quite time intensive if you are working alongside, or have a young family.

Snugglybuggly · 17/11/2021 00:53

@ClaraBean

And if you have, how old were you when you started it? I'm 42, and really feeling the urge to go back to uni and do my PhD. I'm obsessed with the idea. Will I be an old crone? Is it the most ridiculous thing you have ever heard?
I am a few years older than you and thinking about doing one.. go for it!
Quincythequince · 17/11/2021 00:43

Sorry, above comment was with reference to the poster querying the other poster who said people with BSc (or BASc) were more likely to get a job than a PhD

Quincythequince · 17/11/2021 00:41

I too find this very surprising.
My husband and I both have PhDsz
He works in Computing/AI/tech industry.
They don’t consider you if you don’t have at least a Master’s, and almost everyone has a PhD!
Arguably R&D in this field requires more than just basic grunt programming (which has its place absolutely) and which is reserved for those with Bachelors degrees only.

I’m almost inclined to say that nowadays as so many have a first degree, a PG degree is required to set you apart!