Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

or is it acceptable to describe people by age?

30 replies

TannyFickler · 15/11/2021 22:05

Off the back of another thread, in which I was truly surprised by the accusations of ageism at the OP for describing a type of behaviour, and noting that the people engaging in it tended to be older/old enough to be her mother. Is that ageist? Have I been ignorantly offending people all my life in this manner?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
5128gap · 16/11/2021 18:05

@Seeline

If it's the thread I'm thinking if, the OP was basically saying old women were nosey. She made this worse by saying the woman concerned was old enough to be her mother - she was 20ish- so basically lumping everyone over about 40 into the old, nosey woman category!

There is no harm in describing someone by age, if relevant to the point you are making. Just saying someone is old to reinforce some incorrect stereotype is ageist

It doesn't make it any worse that the OP was lumping women who don't consider themselves of an age to be classed as 'old' together with those who are older. Obviously to the OP all those women are relatively old. The stereotype of nosey old woman is offensive. It doesn't become more so just because it feels closer to home.
ragged · 16/11/2021 18:05

I like facts for context & interpret the information as fact unless there's no reasonable alternative interpretation. I don't mind opinions as a rule.

"female colleague" or "quite disabled" or "tall black man"= facts

"very young, pretty and slender" = opinion but not harsh ones

"Nasty old trout" = prejudice

5128gap · 16/11/2021 17:51

@Tal45

I didn't see the thread but if the thread was about old ladies taking a long time to get changed then that wasn't a stereotype. It's a fact that manual dexterity decreases with age and so it's going to become more time consuming to get changed. But if she was getting annoyed about it then that was unreasonable as obviously it is a natural decline and no ones fault.
So would you think it ok to say 'fat ladies taking a long time to get changed' on the basis that flexibility can decline with weight?
Tal45 · 16/11/2021 17:41

I didn't see the thread but if the thread was about old ladies taking a long time to get changed then that wasn't a stereotype. It's a fact that manual dexterity decreases with age and so it's going to become more time consuming to get changed. But if she was getting annoyed about it then that was unreasonable as obviously it is a natural decline and no ones fault.

Hodgehog · 16/11/2021 17:40

I saw that. Ridiculous

It’s not ageist/sexist/whatever to note your own personal experience of a situation. It might be if you said all old/female/gay people do xyz.

Vates · 16/11/2021 17:32

Opinions are like arseholes...everyone has got one!

TannyFickler · 16/11/2021 17:14

@iheartredsquirrels The whole “boomer” thing is so awful. It makes people who use that term sound very, very stupid most of the time.

OP posts:
Seeline · 16/11/2021 17:13

If it's the thread I'm thinking if, the OP was basically saying old women were nosey. She made this worse by saying the woman concerned was old enough to be her mother - she was 20ish- so basically lumping everyone over about 40 into the old, nosey woman category!

There is no harm in describing someone by age, if relevant to the point you are making. Just saying someone is old to reinforce some incorrect stereotype is ageist

TannyFickler · 16/11/2021 17:12

@5128gap It was a different thread, although I saw the beginnings of the one you referenced.

And if you're in any doubt whether reference to age is offensive, just substitute another group who experience discrimination for the age related reference, and see how it sounds then.

Whilst I am a free speech absolutist, after reading everyone’s thoughts I think I may choose to be more sensitive when referencing age in the future so as not to inadvertently upset anyone.

OP posts:
TannyFickler · 16/11/2021 17:06

@moredogsthansense I absolutely agree that “Insult OLD insult” is not acceptable.

I am wondering if age is not something people are as cautious about in this way due to the fact most of us expect to be that age one day/have been that age in the past, and therefore it’s not a static thing like, say, ethnicity.

OP posts:
5128gap · 16/11/2021 13:57

If its the thread im thinking of, the thrust of the OPs 'observation' was that older women who the OP described as 'women of a certain age' tended to wear their work lanyards in Tesco. By referencing age the OP encouraged a discussion about why these older women did this, as oppose to why some people in general do this. The reason it was off was firstly the othering of older women, as posters were encouraged to discuss 'them' and also the link between age and what OP saw as 'odd' behaviour. Naturally this led to posts with stereotypes about forgetfulness in middle sge, and even a suggestion the women were showing off that they worked ( presumably because at their age their lives were so small having a job was something to show off about)
So, was that thread ageist, absolutely. And if you're in any doubt whether reference to age is offensive, just substitute another group who experience discrimination for the age related reference, and see how it sounds then.

WeeWelshWoman · 16/11/2021 13:57

Context is everything. If someone was patronising you because of your perceived age, it makes sense to reference it. Or if you're discussing helping an elderly neighbour, young chil etc. But it's sometimes used in the same way newspapers say 'mum of three...' or 'Julie, 43,...' when it isn't relevent to the actual story/ post.

moredogsthansense · 16/11/2021 13:54

The other very common form of ageism on here is ‘old’ being used as an adjective of abuse, as in ‘daft old bat’, ‘horrible old bag’. The person being described may well have been behaving in a daft or horrible way, but that doesn’t make it ok to use ‘old’ to belittle them. I hate how lax MN is on this internalised ageist misogyny.. Of course describing age is fine when it’s relevant, just as mentioning race or disability is fine when it’s relevant.

Mum6776 · 16/11/2021 13:31

I think ageism is apparent on mumsnet. It's generally a bit dumb to lump all from any age group together and assume they have the same characteristics, views or behaviours. People vary massively.

iheartredsquirrels · 16/11/2021 13:14

There can be arseholes at any age, age does not recognise idiots such as those who call others boomer and snowflake . They can jog right off.

pigsDOfly · 15/11/2021 22:58

The ones who get all arsey because you make an apparent generalisation about over 60s, are quite happy to berate the young.

Well, there you go making an 'apparent generalisation' about over 60s.

I have in the past been know to get a trifle 'arsey' when people make disparaging generalisations about older people but, contrary to your generalisation I, as a woman well over 60, have never in my life been 'quite happy to berate the young'. It's not something I do and I don't actually know anyone personally that is happy to berate the young.

You might want to work on your tendency to make sweeping generalisations about the over 60s.

TannyFickler · 15/11/2021 22:50

@LittleDandelionClock I think I’m about her with it.

OP posts:
TannyFickler · 15/11/2021 22:50

@WhitePhantom Grin

OP posts:
WhitePhantom · 15/11/2021 22:45

@RancidOldHag "Stereotypes are usually unhelpful" - are you sterotyping stereotypes? Grin

LittleDandelionClock · 15/11/2021 22:45

@PlanDeRaccordement

There is nothing wrong with comparing generations of people or describing a person’s age, or even saying generalisations that are true like over 65s are more likely to have chronic health conditions.

It is ageist if you start going down the path of generalised value judgements. Like young people are self absorbed. Or old people drive too slow.

Insults based on age are always ageist- ie “ok, boomer” or “typical millennial”

This. ^

The way some people get so sniffy and offended on here is pathetic.

The ones who get all arsey because you make an apparent generalisation about over 60s, are quite happy to berate the young. I have seen some nasty shit said about young people on here, but God FORBID you say anything about over 60s. Hmm

So much disingenuousness on here. Hmm

ThatCampWitch · 15/11/2021 22:37

I think I was on that thread too. Elderly ladies are generally quite slow in changing rooms, so YANBU! There’s a type.

EmeraldShamrock · 15/11/2021 22:37

some people will take offence, others ignore. totally fed up with the pc brigade.
Hate this shite saying as an excuse when called out on bad behaviour.

PlanDeRaccordement · 15/11/2021 22:34

There is nothing wrong with comparing generations of people or describing a person’s age, or even saying generalisations that are true like over 65s are more likely to have chronic health conditions.

It is ageist if you start going down the path of generalised value judgements. Like young people are self absorbed. Or old people drive too slow.

Insults based on age are always ageist- ie “ok, boomer” or “typical millennial”

EmeraldShamrock · 15/11/2021 22:33

If the person generalised about a groups interest then yes it is ageist IMO.
If describing someone using an average older age bracket is okay.
Ps this is a TAAT.

LittleDandelionClock · 15/11/2021 22:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.