Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think learning how to behave around dogs should be part of the national curriculum

665 replies

Itsadogsworld · 15/11/2021 21:58

I think schools should teach children how to behave around dogs, canine body language and so on. I think it would significantly reduce the number of children that end up in A&E each year due to dogs bites. I’ve seen some dreadful behaviour in my local park where children will run up to my dog and one child was continually trying to bear hug her own dog. Children clearly aren’t being taught this at home so I think they should include it in schools. I welcome your thoughts on this.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 17:32

Dog owners can protest all they like.
If a child is bitten it is legally the owner's fault.
I've already acknowledged that.

But it's a fairly shitty, irresponsible parent who places their child in an avoidable, potentially dangerous situation on the grounds that should their child end up attacked by a dog they can say 'well the law says it's the owner's fault'.
Could you imagine talking to your child and having to say 'I didn't bother to teach you how to behave around dogs, let you charge up to any dog you wanted, and just hoped the dog was friendly and the owner would sort it if the dog got scared... sorry you got bitten and are scarred for life, but technically in law it wasn't my fault'?

I'd rather be a responsible parent than be sitting with my child in A&E with a life changing injury.

FOJN · 17/11/2021 17:29

IMO it’s ALWAYS the dog owner’s fault and lack of responsibility if a child gets bitten in public

I think that statement applies in the home, where most children are bitten. There are certainly no shortage of rubbish dog owners but how would I have taken steps to prevent the situation I described in my post at 11.40. My dog didn't bite but he was certainly provoked. I did learn to keep as far away as possible from any children to protect my dog but who would imagine a situation like that could happen. I did absolutely nothing wrong but if my dog had bitten he would have been PTS.

speakout · 17/11/2021 17:27

Dog owners can protest all they like.

If a child is bitten it is legally the owner's fault.

LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 17:23

What do you mean by ‘tormenting’? Most children don’t intend to cause distress to a dog, they’re either too young to understand you shouldn’t approach a dog or they don’t realise some dogs startle and snap.

If they're old enough to understand that you don't approach an unknown animal, the parent needs to teach them this so they don't approach.
If they are too young to understand that you don't approach an unknown animal, surely the parent is a responsible adult and prevents them from approaching unknown animals.

Maybe it's just me, but there's a huge range of dogs and owners out there and a huge range of personalities. There's no way I'd be allowing my DC to run up or grab random animals just based on an idea of what a stranger's dog should be like. Why on earth would I put them at risk?

Replace 'strange unknown animal' with another danger, such as busy roads.
If a child is old enough to be taught not to charge into the road, then parents teach them not to charge into the road. It doesn't matter that the drivers should see them and stop. If a child isn't old enough to be taught not to run into the road, then most responsible parents do all they can to prevent their children running into the road because they're not useless.
Based on the dog logic on this thread from some posters, nobody has any responsibility to teach their children road safety because drivers should stop, and anyway some children are too young so parents can't help allowing their children to run into a main road.

I'd not be putting my child's safety in the hands of a stranger and an unknown animal.

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 17/11/2021 17:21

@Moonface123

The children pick up the anxiety from their parents, my old skinny lurcher used to walk along on her shaky legs, nose to the ground, totally oblivious and uninterested in humans, yet the amount of times, we have had an hysterical young child, or parent to contend with, (so very wearing trying to recall a dog that has gone deaf, and actively trying to avoid any form of human contact) l have even told the parents straight up they need to educate themselves regarding dogs. Yet another fear the media has manufactured, demonising dogs.
Please tell me this is a reverse or a windup...
PlanDeRaccordement · 17/11/2021 17:18

I think the only things schools should teach children about dogs is that owning one is worse for the environment than driving two Range Rovers.

XenoBitch · 17/11/2021 17:16

@speakout

*What do you mean by ‘tormenting’? Most children don’t intend to cause distress to a dog, they’re either too young to understand you shouldn’t approach a dog or they don’t realise some dogs startle and snap.

IMO it’s ALWAYS the dog owner’s fault and lack of responsibility if a child gets bitten in public.*

Totally agree.

I said upthread that a child approached my dog and tried to kick her in the face. Had she bitten him, how would that have been my fault?
speakout · 17/11/2021 17:12

*What do you mean by ‘tormenting’? Most children don’t intend to cause distress to a dog, they’re either too young to understand you shouldn’t approach a dog or they don’t realise some dogs startle and snap.

IMO it’s ALWAYS the dog owner’s fault and lack of responsibility if a child gets bitten in public.*

Totally agree.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 17/11/2021 16:50

If a child is harmed because their parent allows them to approach and torment an unknown animal, as far as I'm concerned that is the parent's fault and they are negligent. No responsible parent would put their child in that situation.

What do you mean by ‘tormenting’? Most children don’t intend to cause distress to a dog, they’re either too young to understand you shouldn’t approach a dog or they don’t realise some dogs startle and snap.

IMO it’s ALWAYS the dog owner’s fault and lack of responsibility if a child gets bitten in public. If your dog is nervous of children and likely to snap, you muzzle it. I say that as a dog owner. My large breed is fortunately well socialised with children and tolerant. But I’ve lost count of the toddlers and just-walking babies who’ve tottered into him, stepped on his paws, grabbed his fur. A small child once tried to climb on his back while we were in a queue, another time a baby leaned out of a buggy and grabbed his ear on the bus. It only takes a split second for a parent to look away and an infant to grab at your dog or walk straight into it.

Any dog taken to a public place un-muzzled needs to be unflappable and trustworthy around small humans. Because… children take priority over dogs.

There are no requirements to have your child on a lead in any place, there are no parks or beaches with child bans. Kids may be clumsy, impulsive and inquisitive but they don’t attack people. Even if someone startled them or trips over them, no child attacks out of shock/fear/rage.

Most parents I know and see are responsible, they teach their children how to behave around animals. But some children are too young to understand/remember, or have SEN, or simply forget to look out for nervous dogs when they’re running ahead or playing together. A parent can’t have eyes on constantly, even a helicopter parent can get momentarily distracted.

A child who is harmed by a dog in a public place… do you really think it was the parents responsibility for letting them approach an unknown dog? Did the parent even see the dog, or predict their child might try to touch it?

Public spaces are supposed to be safe for children. Bringing snappy, poorly socialised dogs into these spaces is asking for trouble. As a dog owner you’re responsible for your dog’s behaviour.

LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 15:51

Apologies @Sidehustle99 . The problem is that there's a lot of posters on this thread who seem to think that parents don't have any responsibility to keep their children safe because if their child gets bitten it's the dog owner's fault.

I agree with you that should an attack happen, the likelihood is that it will fall on the dog, but that doesn't actually make the situation the dog owner's fault. It's not the fault of a dog owner if they're minding their own business and some idiot thinks their child should be allowed to run up to any animal it feels like.

If a child is harmed because their parent allows them to approach and torment an unknown animal, as far as I'm concerned that is the parent's fault and they are negligent. No responsible parent would put their child in that situation. It's concerning how many posters on this thread seem to think they have very little responsibility for their child's safety.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/11/2021 15:35

@LampLighter414

YABU

The onus is on the owners to make sure their dogs are on a lead, well trained and properly controlled. And that contact with child family members etc is supervised.

You're nuts.

Don't don't have to be on a lead to be under control
Moonface123 · 17/11/2021 15:31

The children pick up the anxiety from their parents, my old skinny lurcher used to walk along on her shaky legs, nose to the ground, totally oblivious and uninterested in humans, yet the amount of times, we have had an hysterical young child, or parent to contend with, (so very wearing trying to recall a dog that has gone deaf, and actively trying to avoid any form of human contact) l have even told the parents straight up they need to educate themselves regarding dogs.
Yet another fear the media has manufactured, demonising dogs.

LampLighter414 · 17/11/2021 15:31

YABU

The onus is on the owners to make sure their dogs are on a lead, well trained and properly controlled. And that contact with child family members etc is supervised.

You're nuts.

AnneElliott · 17/11/2021 15:29

Definitely not a job for schools and teachers - they have enough to do!

In fact we should reduce the amount of stuff that we expect schools to teach and sort out. Let's make them focus on education and leave it at that. Perhaps then all 11 year olds will leave primary school able to read.

Sidehustle99 · 17/11/2021 15:12

@Maverickess

I am determined to educate - nothing else.

Sidehustle99 · 17/11/2021 15:10

When did I say I'd be happy to let my DC do any of those reckless things?

This is doolally.

Maverickess · 17/11/2021 15:08

@Sidehustle99

https://www.gov.uk/control-dog-public

It doesn't say anywhere here 'if a vicious toddler approaches my dog and I haven't given them the wink'.

It is always the owners fault. You know this so you need to be more vocal/protective to protect your cute (would never bite, until it does) dog from being put in that position. A short lead should keep your dog close enough to you so you can response accordingly.

Where exactly do I say this "cute (would never bite, until it does) dog"

I actually say I can't 100% say if she was hurt she wouldn't. And that's why I am vocal in stopping my dog being put in that situation - so stop reading things that aren't there and twisting things to suit your agenda.
I'm aware of the law, Its why I do what I do and it may be my responsibility to do that because she's my dog, and I do it, that doesn't mean if a toddler (without me giving the wink) decides to try and drop kick her like a rugby ball that it's my fault, fault would mean I've done something wrong - what exactly would that be? Not regularly hurting my dog to ensure she doesn't react should the parents of a child decide to ignore me and circumnavigate my efforts to stop an interaction taking place?
I take all reasonable precautions to prevent it happening, I cannot control other people's children, I control my dog, I physically intervene when this type of situation occurs.
You just seem determined to exempt parents who behave this way from any responsibility for their own children whatsoever.

Sidehustle99 · 17/11/2021 15:08

@LolaSmiles

I never said that. My DC have respect for animals and would always ask a dog owner if it was ok before approaching.

I don't want MN posters to think that they won't be liable if their dog bites as some posters seem to think. They would be.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/11/2021 15:07

@Sidehustle99

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ListofffataldoggattacksinntheUniteddKingdom

UK estimates suggest that 740 people per 100 000 population per year are bitten by dogs with 250,000 people attending minor injury and emergency units each year due to dog bites. Many non-fatal and fatal dog attacks may be preventable.
sciencesearch.defra.gov.uk/Default.aspx?Menu=Menu&Module=More&Location=None&Completed=0&ProjectID=16649

33,000 postmen and postwomen have been attacked by dogs in last decade. Over 80% at the front door, garden path or drive.
www.royalmail.com/personal/dog-awareness

I love my dog and I absolutely take accountability for my dogs behaviour.

If people love their children then maybe they should be accountable for their actions and stop the situation ever arising
Sidehustle99 · 17/11/2021 15:04

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ListofffataldoggattacksinntheUniteddKingdom

UK estimates suggest that 740 people per 100 000 population per year are bitten by dogs with 250,000 people attending minor injury and emergency units each year due to dog bites. Many non-fatal and fatal dog attacks may be preventable.
sciencesearch.defra.gov.uk/Default.aspx?Menu=Menu&Module=More&Location=None&Completed=0&ProjectID=16649

33,000 postmen and postwomen have been attacked by dogs in last decade. Over 80% at the front door, garden path or drive.
www.royalmail.com/personal/dog-awareness

I love my dog and I absolutely take accountability for my dogs behaviour.

LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 14:58

www.gov.uk/control-dog-public

It doesn't say anywhere here 'if a vicious toddler approaches my dog and I haven't given them the wink'.

It is always the owners fault. You know this so you need to be more vocal/protective to protect your cute (would never bite, until it does) dog from being put in that position. A short lead should keep your dog close enough to you so you can response accordingly.

So just to check, you're quite happy to put your child's safety and welfare in the hands of a stranger and an unknown animal, of unknown temperament, put your child into an entirely avoidable, potentially dangerous situation because in the event your child is badly injured you can say 'well it was the owner's fault'?

Do you also allow your children to charge out into roads on the grounds that the driver should stop?

Mrsfrumble · 17/11/2021 14:49

I teach my children to steer clear of all dogs. They are not allowed to approach them and certainly not pet them. I was bitten by the neighbour’s dog as a child - there was no provocation on my part, I was just standing next to my mum while she chatted to the neighbour and ignoring the dog when it bit my hand - and as strange as it sounds, I’m kind of glad it happened because it made me aware that owners assessments of their dog’s friendliness and trustworthiness are not always reliable.

I like dogs, but bloody hell, there are some badly trained ones with shitty owners around here. Including the one who let his two big dogs loose in the (no dogs allowed) children’s play area, then stood there laughing as they chased my terrified, autistic child.

Sidehustle99 · 17/11/2021 14:44

www.gov.uk/control-dog-public

It doesn't say anywhere here 'if a vicious toddler approaches my dog and I haven't given them the wink'.

It is always the owners fault. You know this so you need to be more vocal/protective to protect your cute (would never bite, until it does) dog from being put in that position. A short lead should keep your dog close enough to you so you can response accordingly.

Maverickess · 17/11/2021 14:35

@vivainsomnia

My experience (and I accept this is anecdotal) is that most parents don't let their children run up to strange dogs. A large proportion of parents view dogs as dangerous and dirty and would prefer that their children stay away from them Not my experience either. It might be with large dogs, but cute small dogs seem to be viewed as toys that kids should be allowed to play with. My dog isn't aggressive at all, but is fearful of children. Yet all the time I have children coming to him trying to pet him and parents just make noise how cute his. I then say that he is not good with kids, the kids if ore me and start pestering him and the parent usually just say gently 'sweety, the dog doesn't want to be touched' which is 9 times out of 10 ignored by the child and I have to just pick up my dog and move away.
Yes, this is my experience too with a small 'cute' breed who's never off the lead when other people and dogs are around, I've also been called 'mean' when asking children not to approach my on lead and under control dog. She loves people, she's a friendly mess of wagging body that's desperate to be anyone's friend, but I can't 100% say that if anyone hurt her either by accident or on purpose, she wouldn't respond by snapping because she's a dog and in light of that I keep her on the lead, by my side and give people a bit of distance, I've still had children keep running at her, grab for her etc and parents get annoyed with me when I prevent the interaction by picking her up. One kicked a football straight at her, she yelped because it hurt. I accept that not all dog owners keep their dogs under control, I've met them often enough when their off lead dog bounds up to my on lead one with shouts of "He's friendly". But children do it too and parents allow it, and when they allow or even encourage it and attempt to circumnavigate my attempts to stop the interaction, it's annoying and dangerous and they need to start respecting my boundaries, just because I have a small and cute dog does not mean she's public property and should be available for anyone to do with what they want and then blame me for any outcome.
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/11/2021 14:34

[quote Sidehustle99]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

@Sidehustle99
So you think it's the child's fault if they end up in A&E?

No it's the owners fault 100%

No dog with aggressive behavioural problems should ever be around children.

If the child has ran up to a stranger's dog and hurt it or hugged it without permission?

Yes my statement stands. I am a big dog owner and always have been. It would be my responsibility. How would a dog understand permission to a child?

Aggressive dogs should be muzzled to stop them biting children and other dogs.

How do you stand on babies in car steats/Parma etc being mauled? My DC have many times been licked by dogs off the lead. Fortunately nothing bad happened. My aunt was very badly bitten as a 3YO and nearly lost an eye and has severe facial disfigurement. She was in her own garden at the time. The dog barged through the hedge to get her.

So as a devout dog lover I say again. It is always the owners fault.
[/quote]
Completely different situations. If a child is allowed to approach a dog they don't know and scare or hurt it it is not the fault of the bloody dog.

Swipe left for the next trending thread