Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think learning how to behave around dogs should be part of the national curriculum

665 replies

Itsadogsworld · 15/11/2021 21:58

I think schools should teach children how to behave around dogs, canine body language and so on. I think it would significantly reduce the number of children that end up in A&E each year due to dogs bites. I’ve seen some dreadful behaviour in my local park where children will run up to my dog and one child was continually trying to bear hug her own dog. Children clearly aren’t being taught this at home so I think they should include it in schools. I welcome your thoughts on this.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 01/01/2023 09:25

How to care for animals would be a better thing to do. And how to respond when their behaviour is wrong.

paintitallover · 01/01/2023 09:23

No, @Totallysuper is right. Entitlement is owning an animal capable of biting, but objecting to putting it on a lead, or expecting schools to manage the issue for you. Jeez indeed.

Melsy88 · 01/01/2023 09:02

TotallySuper · 15/11/2021 22:12

Whilst they're teaching kids this maybe they could also teach the adults how to own a dog and actually restrain it properly. No dogs should be allowed off leads and owners should take more responsibility. If you think a dog might react badly to a child running up to it then you should muzzle the dog or take it out at times when children aren't around
YABU and the reason why so many kids get bitten etc - dog owner attitude and their entitlement is the problem.

You can't seriously think it's ok to let a child run up to a dog?! Jeez. The sense of entitlement of you is astounding. The world does not revolve around you and your precious children. You teach your child not to run up to my dog and I'll teach my dog to not run up to your children. Then we are all happy.

tigger1001 · 19/11/2021 11:10

[quote chillicrackers]@tigger1001 some people are so daft. Either you are terrified of dogs or you're not. It's not something you get over just because a dog is coming at you. I am such a parent, I am absolutely terrified. I've never taught my dc to be terrified but obviously they see it. I know not to run with arms flailing away from a scary dog but it's a joke that anyone would be put in that position in the U.K. and the owner doesn't face consequences tbh how will that kind of thing ever stop otherwise,

@Loopyloulou007 as you describe the boy as POC his parents may have a background where they have stray dogs in their country, it's natural to be terrified, dogs in some countries will literally rip you apart. I went to a third world country when I was younger and was walking up a hill and two massive dogs came bolting down snarling and bearing their teeth, I was so so terrified my body took over and ran eventually hiding in a bush, my knees literally didn't stop shaking until the next day! A lot of people can't seem to think the way they think should apply to everyone when there are simple things like putting a dog on a lead when there are scared people that resolves this for everyone. [/quote]
Exactly. People who think all they have to do is tell the terrified person to stand still when being faced with the thing they are terrified, have never been phobic about something.

I am arachnophobic. Now I know spiders in this country will not hurt me, and they will be more scared of me etc, however faced with a spider that knowledge deserts me.

My eldest is scared of dogs. I am not. He developed his fear as a direct result of some muppet owner not controlling their dog and allowing it to jump up onto his buggy and stick his nose in. Can you imagine being strapped into a chair unable to get away while a massive (he was a big dog but even more so to an 18 month old) sticks his nose in your face? The dog was friendly but that was not the point.

As a younger child I could (and did) explain he shouldn't run, however that logic left him when dog ran up to him.

I blamed the owners who inevitably shout "oh he's friendly he just wants to play" while not bothering to call their dog off.

We were in the woods walking one day when same thing happens. Stupid woman did nothing about her dog then lectured me to say I shouldn't have my child in the woods if he's scared of dogs. No, love, he is allowed in the woods but none of us should have to put up with your out of control dog jumping on us and chasing us.

I genuinely don't think people understand that there is a difference between not liking something and being terrified of it. Rational thinking leaves us in the face of genuine fear. The flight or fight reflex is really there.

Poppins2016 · 19/11/2021 10:01

Hmm. It would be great if schools could teach children everything, but you have to draw the line somewhere... The way I see it, as a parent I'd struggle to teach maths and science, for example, but I'm more than capable of teaching animal care, DIY, cooking... same with most of the general population. I'd rather schools concentrated on the stuff I can't teach!

CaptainMyCaptain · 19/11/2021 10:00

I haven't RTFT but I don't think it's the responsibility of schools because there isn't the time in the day. Parents, however, should teach their children in the same way they teach them to be wary of traffic and cross the road. Traffic is dangerous but we don't teach children to be terrified of it, we teach them to be careful. Unfortunately, many parents don't know how to behave around dogs themselves

Maverickess · 19/11/2021 09:56

@Whywonttheyhelpme

How about dog owners should have to have a license & prove that they are responsible enough to deal with managing their own dog.

This is coming from a dog owner, who can see the signs in their own dog and would step in before allowing him to be provoked to such an extent that he would hurt a child. I also would never leave him alone with ANY small children or even older children that I do not 100% trust.

Bad owners are the problem here.

Totally agree, as a dog owner I'm on the recieving end of bad ownership from others allowing their out of control dog (s) to approach and interact.

That's still not going to stop parents not supervising their child and either unwittingly or deliberately allowing and advocating their child to approach and interact with dogs even when the owner keeps them on a lead, under control and asks that the child doesn't. That's where the parental responsibility comes into it - teaching children to respect others boundaries, it's a two way street.

chillicrackers · 19/11/2021 09:53

@tigger1001 some people are so daft. Either you are terrified of dogs or you're not. It's not something you get over just because a dog is coming at you. I am such a parent, I am absolutely terrified. I've never taught my dc to be terrified but obviously they see it. I know not to run with arms flailing away from a scary dog but it's a joke that anyone would be put in that position in the U.K. and the owner doesn't face consequences tbh how will that kind of thing ever stop otherwise,

@Loopyloulou007 as you describe the boy as POC his parents may have a background where they have stray dogs in their country, it's natural to be terrified, dogs in some countries will literally rip you apart. I went to a third world country when I was younger and was walking up a hill and two massive dogs came bolting down snarling and bearing their teeth, I was so so terrified my body took over and ran eventually hiding in a bush, my knees literally didn't stop shaking until the next day! A lot of people can't seem to think the way they think should apply to everyone when there are simple things like putting a dog on a lead when there are scared people that resolves this for everyone.

tigger1001 · 18/11/2021 22:49

@Loopyloulou007

I agree. Some parents are absolutely terrified of dogs, so never teach, just scream, jump and panic, this transfers onto the kids and just excites the dog further. My story - I was dropping off my boy at school, waiting for the gates to open. A dog (Staffie) had escaped its owner and was running freely in the park adjacent, owner yelling at it to come back, dog running for freedom, two kids walking to school together alone (brother and sister about 10 & 7 I would say) were scared and started running, arms flaring, screaming. They split up and the dog obviously then took chase, it had 4 legs, boy had 2, dog jumping up at his arms etc, turning at every turn the boy did, no matter what he did, the dog was on his tail. I ran up to the boy who the dog was chasing and just told him to stand still, fold his arms, no eye contact and just to keep moving his body away from the dog. The dog wasn't aggressive, was only young, but just thought it was play time, but the boy was absolutely petrified. The dog just got bored and walked off. When I tell you how petrified the boy was, he was a POC, but he was as white as a sheet, sweaty, hypo-ventilating, not nice to witness or see. I calmed him down and then handed this poor kid to the teacher who opened the gate.

I called the office to ask if they could do a lesson, where a dog handler comes in for a talk, to explain what to do in situations as running really isn't the best one.

It's all well and good telling kids (or adults for that matter) in a safe environment what to do when the object of your fear approaches. However in the real situation fear takes over.

My son had a phobia of dogs. I could explain until I was blue in the face to not run, but in the park when over enthusiastic dogs would bound towards him, flight or fight took over and he would run.

In the scenario you have painted where was the dog owner? It was their fault that the poor lad was terrified. They were pretty lucky that they were not reported for their dog being out of control.

Aberteifi · 18/11/2021 19:55

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Loopyloulou007 · 18/11/2021 19:08

I agree. Some parents are absolutely terrified of dogs, so never teach, just scream, jump and panic, this transfers onto the kids and just excites the dog further. My story - I was dropping off my boy at school, waiting for the gates to open. A dog (Staffie) had escaped its owner and was running freely in the park adjacent, owner yelling at it to come back, dog running for freedom, two kids walking to school together alone (brother and sister about 10 & 7 I would say) were scared and started running, arms flaring, screaming. They split up and the dog obviously then took chase, it had 4 legs, boy had 2, dog jumping up at his arms etc, turning at every turn the boy did, no matter what he did, the dog was on his tail. I ran up to the boy who the dog was chasing and just told him to stand still, fold his arms, no eye contact and just to keep moving his body away from the dog. The dog wasn't aggressive, was only young, but just thought it was play time, but the boy was absolutely petrified. The dog just got bored and walked off. When I tell you how petrified the boy was, he was a POC, but he was as white as a sheet, sweaty, hypo-ventilating, not nice to witness or see. I calmed him down and then handed this poor kid to the teacher who opened the gate.

I called the office to ask if they could do a lesson, where a dog handler comes in for a talk, to explain what to do in situations as running really isn't the best one.

Robin60 · 18/11/2021 18:44

Clearly you have no idea whatsoever the pressure that is on teaching staff - do you not read the teachers posts on mumsnet??.
Any other bright ideas what teachers should do instead of actual teaching?

UndertonesOfCake · 18/11/2021 17:09

@Whywonttheyhelpme

How about dog owners should have to have a license & prove that they are responsible enough to deal with managing their own dog.

This is coming from a dog owner, who can see the signs in their own dog and would step in before allowing him to be provoked to such an extent that he would hurt a child. I also would never leave him alone with ANY small children or even older children that I do not 100% trust.

Bad owners are the problem here.

Can we also have a licence - perhaps linked to compulsory parenting classes - for those wishing to become parents?

The standard of parenting that I frequently see is so incredibly low. Perhaps it would encourage responsible procreation...

Whywonttheyhelpme · 18/11/2021 16:45

How about dog owners should have to have a license & prove that they are responsible enough to deal with managing their own dog.

This is coming from a dog owner, who can see the signs in their own dog and would step in before allowing him to be provoked to such an extent that he would hurt a child. I also would never leave him alone with ANY small children or even older children that I do not 100% trust.

Bad owners are the problem here.

FOJN · 18/11/2021 15:59

AudacityBaby

I agree with every word of your post.

My dog is trained because it's in his interests for me to make sure he is, I consider it essential for his safety and well being. I would always put his safety before a showdown over the rights and wrongs of someone else's behaviour towards him.

I simply cannot get my head around parents who think that because the law is on their side they do not have a responsibility to educate their child about safe behaviour around dogs. It does not remove responsibility from dog owners but it may decrease the risk of your child being killed or injured.

I suppose some people cannot understand it's better to be safe than right.

rrhuth · 18/11/2021 15:26

Although it is highly unlikely my child would do those things, because I taught them that some dogs are horrible and you can't trust dog owners to control them!

rrhuth · 18/11/2021 15:25

@Snowcloud92 You can think what you like but the law disagrees with you.

Dog owners are responsible for their dog's behaviour with regard to humans. If a dog bites a human, the owner is responsible.

The dog is at fault in the eyes of the law and I agree with that.

Snowcloud92 · 18/11/2021 14:39

@rrhuth

Biscuit

It is not a child's fault if a dog attacks them.

Owners need to take more responsibility - including not buying bloody dogs in the first place if they are not going to a) train them and b) use a lead.

It is not schools' job to put right every problem in society.

I think you are wrong. There are some instances of dog bites to children which are not the fault of the dog/owner.

If I am walking my dog on a lead who is very well behaved and your child runs up to my dog and without asking and jumps straight in their face/grabs them/bear hugs them/climbs on them then it is not my fault if your child is hurt. it would be your fault for not looking after/keeping control of your child.

All of the above situations have happened to me before and i'm very lucky my dog had been brought up around children and is very very tolerant of children. Ofc there is no excuse for offlead dogs causing dog bites or dogs biting anyone when not provoked.

Gliderx · 18/11/2021 14:10

I can see that the dog owner might think it's the child's "fault" (even if not legally so) if the child runs up to the dog and kicks, hits, hugs or otherwise "assaults" the dog without permission from the owner.

But when the dog owner goes beyond this and blames small children for "startling" or "scaring" the dog by doing things like screaming or shrieking, tripping over the dog, running around the dog or away from the dog, being nervous and backing away or having food or a ball near the dog... my sympathy ends at that point!

In any case, dogs maim children not the other way round. If a child hits a child who hits back, the injury is unlikely to be severe. If an aggressive dog attacks, the child may end up dead or scarred for life. Hence why dogs who don't have placid temperaments shouldn't be off the lead in places open to the general public where children can come to play.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 18/11/2021 13:49

@rrhuth

Biscuit

It is not a child's fault if a dog attacks them.

Owners need to take more responsibility - including not buying bloody dogs in the first place if they are not going to a) train them and b) use a lead.

It is not schools' job to put right every problem in society.

Absolutely agree.

Children need to know not to run up to dogs and stroke them without asking the owner first, but beyond that it's 100% down to the dog owner.

Really what they should do is ban dangerous breeds and stop breeding them.

AudacityBaby · 18/11/2021 12:56

This argument will never go anywhere. Some dog owners and some parents are about as much use as a chocolate teapot. Some dog owners haven't worked out that the consequence of Fido not being trained is that Fido may end up being PTS, and some parents haven't worked out that the consequence of Jemima not being trained is that Jemima may end up being injured.

The law is on Jemima's parents' side, which for some bizarre reason seems to make parents think they have the upper hand. For me, I'd rather do anything I could to ensure Jemima didn't end up being injured, but from all of the threads on here about kids running around in coffee shops, I recognise that my risk assessment process is different from a lot of people's.

LolaSmiles · 18/11/2021 12:46

No one says dogs are imaginary. What is manufactured and whipped up is the fear of dogs and it seems some posters fall for that.
Is it manufactured fear to exercise caution around strange animals that you don't know?

It's common sense not to approach unknown animals and it's common sense not to allow your animal to bound up to other people.

Mrsfrumble · 18/11/2021 12:35

If “fear” manifests as reasonable caution around strange dogs, what’s the problem? Obviously screaming and running away isn’t great as it will likely excite the dog and make the situation worse, but after the chasing in the dog-free area I mentioned, I’ve taught my children to stand perfectly still with their arms crossed and staring into middle distance when approached, until the dog loses interest and goes away.

Any owner who objects to a response that is calm but makes clear that we don’t want to engage with their dog is a dick.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 18/11/2021 12:14

@ColinTheKoala

Yet another fear the media has manufactured, demonising dogs

Complete nonsense. Dogs are everywhere, they're not imaginary.

No one says dogs are imaginary. What is manufactured and whipped up is the fear of dogs and it seems some posters fall for that.
ColinTheKoala · 18/11/2021 10:59

Yet another fear the media has manufactured, demonising dogs

Complete nonsense. Dogs are everywhere, they're not imaginary.