Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think learning how to behave around dogs should be part of the national curriculum

665 replies

Itsadogsworld · 15/11/2021 21:58

I think schools should teach children how to behave around dogs, canine body language and so on. I think it would significantly reduce the number of children that end up in A&E each year due to dogs bites. I’ve seen some dreadful behaviour in my local park where children will run up to my dog and one child was continually trying to bear hug her own dog. Children clearly aren’t being taught this at home so I think they should include it in schools. I welcome your thoughts on this.

OP posts:
Draineddraineddrained · 16/11/2021 20:10

No the OP is saying kids need to know about dog body language and all sorts of rubbish, and that this bollocks should be taught IN SCHOOL. By the teachers who are meant to be teaching our kids to read and write and apply critical thinking (clearly woefully lacking at the national level judging by some on this thread).

If the title of the thread was "parents should teach their kids not to approach strange dogs" I don't imagine it would be fifteen contentious pages long by now.

Fomofo · 16/11/2021 20:09

And what about schools with mixed ethnicities, pretty sure dogs are not owned by some cultures

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 16/11/2021 20:07

[quote rrhuth]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

No you don't have to say it slowly Hmm I just disagree with you.

Whatever you say, if your dog would bite a child that strokes it, that dog is not welcome in society.

That is why the law is framed the way it is - because the majority of people care more about people than dogs. That is not going to change.

A small niche of dog-obsessed people want it to be different, but it isn't different and it will not be different.

FYI: my children would not have touched your dog because I taught them not to stroke dogs because some dogs bite.[/quote]
I disagree being you're wrong. I am not denying my dog is my responsibility that is why I am responsible. What I am saying is I am not responsible for a child hurting him. That is the responsibility of the parents.

You've done right by your kids. Well done you. I have taught my kids the same. They must always ask permission to stroke or approach a dog they don't know. Common sense. Shame not everyone has it

XenoBitch · 16/11/2021 20:07

[quote rrhuth]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

No you don't have to say it slowly Hmm I just disagree with you.

Whatever you say, if your dog would bite a child that strokes it, that dog is not welcome in society.

That is why the law is framed the way it is - because the majority of people care more about people than dogs. That is not going to change.

A small niche of dog-obsessed people want it to be different, but it isn't different and it will not be different.

FYI: my children would not have touched your dog because I taught them not to stroke dogs because some dogs bite.[/quote]
Your last sentence is literally what OP is trying to say.

Teach your kids not to approach strange dogs.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 20:03

@AllThingsServeTheBeam

No you don't have to say it slowly Hmm I just disagree with you.

Whatever you say, if your dog would bite a child that strokes it, that dog is not welcome in society.

That is why the law is framed the way it is - because the majority of people care more about people than dogs. That is not going to change.

A small niche of dog-obsessed people want it to be different, but it isn't different and it will not be different.

FYI: my children would not have touched your dog because I taught them not to stroke dogs because some dogs bite.

lemonlimon · 16/11/2021 20:01

A better skill would be compulsory adult college course for dog owners. Skills to include: how to put a lead on your dog when in a busy place full of dc with an untrained dog.
How to notice if your dog has never been trained.
How to see that allowing your dog to jump up at someone whilst simultaneously muttering its ok he's only friendly is not appropriate
How to ensure your stinky dog house smells fresh or in the very least not suggest you're one of the only dog owners who has managed to keep your house from being stinky. You just have polite friends...

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 16/11/2021 19:55

@rrhuth

Explain to me why it's the parents responsibility to stop their kids hurting my kid but not the parents responsibility to stop their kids coming up to my dog minding its own business to hurt him? Which will then 'stop their face getting ripped'?

Unless you have never met a human child you will presumably know that some of them have poor impulse control until the age of ten at least - that is why the age of criminal responsibility is what it is (and many argue it is too low in the UK, most European countries set a higher age).

If child A pushes child B, child B may push them back. If both are e.g. age 6, likely no serious harm will be done on either side and there is no crime here, they are both children.

If child A pushes a dog and the dog bites their face, serious harm may be done AND the owner of the dog has committed an offence.

That is the legal reality and that is the correct situation - only somebody pretty wacky thinks a dog should be treated the same way as a child in law.

Do I need to speak slowly for you to understand? It is the parents responsibility to stop any child coming up to a strange dog and hurting it or even stroking it without the owners permission. That is what I am saying. The parents of the child should not even allow that situation to even arise. I have had children put my dog in a headlock or stroke him and then kiss him. Not dangerous with my dog no, but it could be and it should not be up to me to stop children doing this. This is the parents responsibility. My kids wouldn't dream of doing it. Even to our dog who has been a member of our family since our kids were babies
rrhuth · 16/11/2021 19:52

@Snaketime

Yes a child can legally touch a dog, but they can't legally hurt a dog. Hurting an animal is animal abuse and illegal. I really don't get why all these 'little darlings' can get away with anything and a dog that defends itself is evil.
A child can not be criminally responsible until age 10.

So it would not be 'animal abuse' - it would be a child hurting an animal.

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 19:51

Explain to me why it's the parents responsibility to stop their kids hurting my kid but not the parents responsibility to stop their kids coming up to my dog minding its own business to hurt him? Which will then 'stop their face getting ripped'?

Unless you have never met a human child you will presumably know that some of them have poor impulse control until the age of ten at least - that is why the age of criminal responsibility is what it is (and many argue it is too low in the UK, most European countries set a higher age).

If child A pushes child B, child B may push them back. If both are e.g. age 6, likely no serious harm will be done on either side and there is no crime here, they are both children.

If child A pushes a dog and the dog bites their face, serious harm may be done AND the owner of the dog has committed an offence.

That is the legal reality and that is the correct situation - only somebody pretty wacky thinks a dog should be treated the same way as a child in law.

Snaketime · 16/11/2021 19:50

Yes a child can legally touch a dog, but they can't legally hurt a dog. Hurting an animal is animal abuse and illegal. I really don't get why all these 'little darlings' can get away with anything and a dog that defends itself is evil.

XenoBitch · 16/11/2021 19:49

@TSSDNCOP

I suppose it could be quite a quick lesson. Can't see how it would be a practical after all.

"Children today's first lesson. Do not kick dogs in the face unless you want them to bite you really hard. Now, get your maths books out..."

I am an 80s kid so it might be different now.. we got lessons on railway safety, stranger danger, power stations, playing with matches/fireworks etc. We were shown terrifying things to hammer the message home. I am certain things like online safety is taught now too. How would adding information about dogs be difficult?
TSSDNCOP · 16/11/2021 19:44

I suppose it could be quite a quick lesson. Can't see how it would be a practical after all.

"Children today's first lesson. Do not kick dogs in the face unless you want them to bite you really hard. Now, get your maths books out..."

Fomofo · 16/11/2021 19:39

Parents with weak bladders?

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 16/11/2021 19:37

@Gliderx

In the pecking order, humans come first, I'm afraid. You might not like it but that's the way it is.

That's why dog owners need to watch their dogs like hawks. Because a dog which poses an obvious danger to humans (even if provoked) is likely be destroyed. The reverse is not true... we don't PTS humans (including young children) who hurt dogs.

That may seem unfair if you view your dog as being on a par with humans, but most people (and the law) don't see it that way. They prioritise human life over animal life, including that of your dog.

Not arguing that. I am arguing children should be taught how to be responsible around all dogs by their pissing parents.
Mammyloveswine · 16/11/2021 19:37

I've enough to fit in each day getting children to read and write (and use the toilet!).

TSSDNCOP · 16/11/2021 19:36

Great, another optional life choice schools need to prepare kids for.

They could give up swimming lessons, drama or cycling proficiency to fit it in.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 16/11/2021 19:34

@rrhuth

Same applies if it's my kid another child hurts? Or is that different? The onus is on the bloody parents

Grin humans and dogs are different species, so yeah, a bit different.

But also - unlikely for a child to reciprocate by ripping a kid's face with their teeth. So a bit different.

Explain to me why it's the parents responsibility to stop their kids hurting my kid but not the parents responsibility to stop their kids coming up to my dog minding its own business to hurt him? Which will then 'stop their face getting ripped'?

Your logic makes absolutely no sense and you're making yoursen look awful silly

Gliderx · 16/11/2021 19:33

In the pecking order, humans come first, I'm afraid. You might not like it but that's the way it is.

That's why dog owners need to watch their dogs like hawks. Because a dog which poses an obvious danger to humans (even if provoked) is likely be destroyed. The reverse is not true... we don't PTS humans (including young children) who hurt dogs.

That may seem unfair if you view your dog as being on a par with humans, but most people (and the law) don't see it that way. They prioritise human life over animal life, including that of your dog.

speakout · 16/11/2021 19:32

Lets not pretend the we are wildlife warriors by keeping dogs- domestic dogs are bred to amuse humans, complex playthings.
They deserve respect, decent lives, but are an indulgence for the owner.

Fomofo · 16/11/2021 19:31

I think kids should also be taught at school how to avoid stepping in dog shit, to be light of foot, dance delicately around those steaming little turds, left by all those entitled dog owners who think the world revolves around them and rufus

rrhuth · 16/11/2021 19:30

Why do you think they should be allowed to hurt a living creature?
Biscuit
No one said they should be allowed.

speakout · 16/11/2021 19:30

How is having children a requirement? Why do you think they should be allowed to hurt a living creature? What does this teach your child?

Childdren dont always have to hurt a dog in order to get bitten.
I am not suggesting it is Ok for a child to hurt an animal.
Often a child will be bitten by moving erratically or in a nervous way.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 16/11/2021 19:29

Parents should teach this, schools have enough to do.

XenoBitch · 16/11/2021 19:28

@rrhuth

Biting is their only way to say "I told you so", often after they have already displayed the signs of being uncomfortable, such as licking lips, whale eye etc. Hmm

Do you really think we'll have trials for dogs, with their owner saying 'he clearly warned the child by licking his lips, but the child ignored him' and then they'll acquit the dog due to mitigating circumstances??

No. In the real world, dogs need to not bite, or their owners need to accept the legal consequences.

Exactly why children need to be taught how to behave around dogs. Just like they get taught not to play on railway lines, power stations, not go off with strangers etc.
rrhuth · 16/11/2021 19:28

Same applies if it's my kid another child hurts? Or is that different? The onus is on the bloody parents

Grin humans and dogs are different species, so yeah, a bit different.

But also - unlikely for a child to reciprocate by ripping a kid's face with their teeth. So a bit different.