Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think learning how to behave around dogs should be part of the national curriculum

665 replies

Itsadogsworld · 15/11/2021 21:58

I think schools should teach children how to behave around dogs, canine body language and so on. I think it would significantly reduce the number of children that end up in A&E each year due to dogs bites. I’ve seen some dreadful behaviour in my local park where children will run up to my dog and one child was continually trying to bear hug her own dog. Children clearly aren’t being taught this at home so I think they should include it in schools. I welcome your thoughts on this.

OP posts:
UndertonesOfCake · 17/11/2021 14:33

@Flipflopblowout

Shouldn't the responsibility be on the dog owner to train the dog on how to behave in public and around children?
It is also the responsibility of the parent to train teach the child how to behave around dogs.

I have a dog who would really just prefer to be left in peace by strangers. He'll walk straight past strangers because he has no interest in them. According to many on this thread this is perfect.

Yet I've had a parent put their toddler down and tell them to go and stroke my dog without asking. I've had primary aged children chase him as he walks away even when I've told them not to; the parents didn't intervene.

A friend of a friend had a child walk up to their dog and give it a hard kick; frankly the child deserved to be bitten. The dog had always been fine with kids before that, but unfortunately the dog developed an entirely understandable fear of children after tthat and felt that the best form of defence was attack.

Wouldn't it be lovely if people could just totally abdicate responsibility and think that it's other people's job to keep them safe? Real life isn't like that.

XenoBitch · 17/11/2021 14:27

@vivainsomnia

My experience (and I accept this is anecdotal) is that most parents don't let their children run up to strange dogs. A large proportion of parents view dogs as dangerous and dirty and would prefer that their children stay away from them Not my experience either. It might be with large dogs, but cute small dogs seem to be viewed as toys that kids should be allowed to play with. My dog isn't aggressive at all, but is fearful of children. Yet all the time I have children coming to him trying to pet him and parents just make noise how cute his. I then say that he is not good with kids, the kids if ore me and start pestering him and the parent usually just say gently 'sweety, the dog doesn't want to be touched' which is 9 times out of 10 ignored by the child and I have to just pick up my dog and move away.
That has been my experience too. Small dogs/puppies seem to be fair game for kids to approach. I have been in a cafe with a friend who had a puppy sat at her feet. We heard a noise, and saw a little girl led on her stomach under our table, trying to play with the dog. She was told twice to leave the dog alone, and even her mum said we had to let her pet the puppy. FFS.
XenoBitch · 17/11/2021 14:22

@Flipflopblowout

Shouldn't the responsibility be on the dog owner to train the dog on how to behave in public and around children?
There should be responsibility on parents to teach their children not to approach strange dogs, and definitely not tug on their ears, bear hug them or try to kick them.
vivainsomnia · 17/11/2021 14:18

My experience (and I accept this is anecdotal) is that most parents don't let their children run up to strange dogs. A large proportion of parents view dogs as dangerous and dirty and would prefer that their children stay away from them
Not my experience either. It might be with large dogs, but cute small dogs seem to be viewed as toys that kids should be allowed to play with. My dog isn't aggressive at all, but is fearful of children. Yet all the time I have children coming to him trying to pet him and parents just make noise how cute his. I then say that he is not good with kids, the kids if ore me and start pestering him and the parent usually just say gently 'sweety, the dog doesn't want to be touched' which is 9 times out of 10 ignored by the child and I have to just pick up my dog and move away.

LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 14:11

Shouldn't the responsibility be on the dog owner to train the dog on how to behave in public and around children?
Of course there is a responsibility for the dog owner to appropriately train their dog. That doesn't remove responsibility for parents to apply a shred of common sense and take responsibility for their child.

It doesn't mean it's acceptable for irresponsible parents to allow their precious children to approach, run at, hit, grab, touch and generally scare dogs who are minding their own business.

Any responsible parent would not be putting their child's safety and welfare in the hands of a stranger and an unknown animal.

Flipflopblowout · 17/11/2021 14:01

Shouldn't the responsibility be on the dog owner to train the dog on how to behave in public and around children?

Sidehustle99 · 17/11/2021 13:58

@AllThingsServeTheBeam

@Sidehustle99
So you think it's the child's fault if they end up in A&E?

No it's the owners fault 100%

No dog with aggressive behavioural problems should ever be around children.

If the child has ran up to a stranger's dog and hurt it or hugged it without permission?

Yes my statement stands. I am a big dog owner and always have been. It would be my responsibility. How would a dog understand permission to a child?

Aggressive dogs should be muzzled to stop them biting children and other dogs.

How do you stand on babies in car steats/Parma etc being mauled? My DC have many times been licked by dogs off the lead. Fortunately nothing bad happened. My aunt was very badly bitten as a 3YO and nearly lost an eye and has severe facial disfigurement. She was in her own garden at the time. The dog barged through the hedge to get her.

So as a devout dog lover I say again. It is always the owners fault.

tintodeverano2 · 17/11/2021 11:57

I was attacked by a Rottweiler when I was waiting outside of a shop when I was a small child. In no way did I provoke the dog, I didn't even see it until it's teeth were in me.

No amount of education can prepare a child for that. It is, perhaps the owners that should be educated on how to control their animals and not expect everyone else to love their pet.

takealettermsjones · 17/11/2021 11:49

There is responsibility on both sides, but equally, I'm not a dog owner and likely never will be. I tell any DC in my care not to approach a dog without asking, but apart from that, I don't know what a dog's signs/triggers are. I shouldn't have to. The owner should be able to regulate this; if the dog is uncomfortable, they should say no to the child stroking it. Of course if the child ignores this I will step in.

But I've seen incidents where owners have either said yes to the attention but then the dog has snapped, or (far more common) the dog is off lead and simply runs to the child, so there's no opportunity to check in with the owner. Often owners will shout, "it's okay! He's friendly!" But why does that mean it's okay? The child at that point might react to a strange dog running up by lashing out with hands/feet etc, which is understandable. And then of course the dog snaps, and the owner is aghast that the child "hit" their dog etc.

I despise dog owners who think everyone else wants to interact with their dog.

FOJN · 17/11/2021 11:42

does not not does it

FOJN · 17/11/2021 11:40

The idea that a well trained dog wouldn't bite is incredibly naive.

I was walking my dog along the seafront a couple of years ago. He was on a short, fixed lead, walking to heel; completely under my control as the law requires and minding his own business. I passed a picnic table with a family sitting at it, as we approached the little boy (possibly 7 ot 8) got up from the table, jumped in front of my dog with his arms outstretched, bent down and screamed in my dogs face. My dog didn't react and I was too shocked to say anything, in fact it was so sudden I was frightened by the behaviour. The little boy thought it was very funny and the parents said nothing. I reassured my dog, moved round the little boy and we went on our way.

How exactly does someone think I could train my dog to either anticipate or deal with that situation? Should I practice jumping out on him at home, screaming in his face and then rewarding him for not biting? The only thing that would accomplish is to make my dog fearful of people and more likely to be aggressive. Effective training does it include frightening your dog to prepare them for unpredictable people.

I get the impression posters here think it would have been mine or my dogs fault if the child had been bitten in that situation. We were minding our own business and doing everything in accordance with the law. Did the parents, who were no doubt as shocked as I was, not have a responsibility to use the opportunity to reprimand the child and highlight the dangers of their behaviour?

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 17/11/2021 11:36

A large proportion of parents view dogs as dangerous and dirty and would prefer that their children stay away from them. There is a big anti-dog contingent amongst the parents I know who would never dream of having dogs in the house

Blimey! This is nothing like my experience.

Gliderx · 17/11/2021 11:28

My experience (and I accept this is anecdotal) is that most parents don't let their children run up to strange dogs. A large proportion of parents view dogs as dangerous and dirty and would prefer that their children stay away from them. There is a big anti-dog contingent amongst the parents I know who would never dream of having dogs in the house.

Some parents no doubt do let their children accost passing dogs, but ime that small number is far outweighed by the number of dog owners who allow their dogs to run up to, sniff around and jump on people (including very small children) and think it's fine because they shout "he's friendly!"

I accept it's probably worse for small, "cute" dogs as they're the most likely to attract attention from children and parents are going to be less frantic (and therefore less quick to intervene) than if they saw a huge, out of control mutt bounding towards their kids.

I would agree education is needed on both sides. Dog owners need to understand that it is unacceptable for their dogs to approach and bother strangers (even if they're 'friendly' Hmm) and parents need to return the favour.

LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 11:09

If the child has ran up to a stranger's dog and hurt it or hugged it without permission?
You're probably flogging a dead horse by asking that question.

It would seem some parents genuinely think it's acceptable to place their child in entirely avoidable, potentially dangerous situations.

Why any parent would play roulette with their child's safety by allowing them to approach unknown animals is beyond me. Maybe they also let their children run into dual carriageways or cross on blind bends, or play in the middle of main roads because the drivers have to stop.

ColinTheKoala · 17/11/2021 11:06

@rrhuth

There are 12.5 million dogs in the UK

I never understand pets fullstop, we had them when I was young, including dogs, but it is just horrible for them really.

Being an owned dog is a pretty unnatural life, I think if people did really care about dogs they would not want to keep them captive.

I agree - the so-called dog lovers don't seem to love them very much at all, especially those who have breeds who have problems bred into them so they look pretty.
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/11/2021 11:05

@Sidehustle99

So you think it's the child's fault if they end up in A&E?

No it's the owners fault 100%

No dog with aggressive behavioural problems should ever be around children.

If the child has ran up to a stranger's dog and hurt it or hugged it without permission?
LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 11:04

Saraclara
There was a thread along those lines ages ago. People were genuinely arguing that they should walk out into the road because if they get hit then it's the driver's fault.

I always thought it was stupidity in action. What use is being right if you're dead or severely injured?

Same on this thread. What sort of parent would allow their child to charge up to unknown animals, risk being attacked or bitten and then sit in A&E when their poor child is badly injured and genuinely think to themselves that they're a brilliant and responsible parent?

Sidehustle99 · 17/11/2021 11:03

So you think it's the child's fault if they end up in A&E?

No it's the owners fault 100%

No dog with aggressive behavioural problems should ever be around children.

UndertonesOfCake · 17/11/2021 11:03

[quote rrhuth]@AllThingsServeTheBeam

Yes, they are just captives. I feel sorry for them.[/quote]
I keep trying to set my dog free from captivity every day at the park.

He just keeps following me home though.

Perhaps he has Stockholm syndrome?

MysteryFog60 · 17/11/2021 10:59

There are many irresponsible dog owners around and it's got worse since all the lockdown dogs have been bought. People have bought dogs and they don't realise the responsibility that comes with them.

UndertonesOfCake · 17/11/2021 10:57

YANBU in principle, but in reality, school teaching time is limited - and if everything people say should be taught in schools was included, we wouldn't leave school until we were about 30.

What would you remove from the curriculum to make way for this proposal?

saraclara · 17/11/2021 10:55

My FIL used to walk straight out over zebra crossings without looking or even if a car was almost on top of him "because they have to stop".

He seemed to have no concept that the law didn't empower the driver with a kind of magic that could make their car grind to a halt in a fraction of a second.

This thread reminds me of him.

LolaSmiles · 17/11/2021 10:44

A question for all the people who think it's unreasonable for parents to teach their children not to approach unknown dogs because (to paraphrase) 'humans come first, children are more important than dogs, if my child gets bitten then it's the dog owner's fault, in court the owner would be responsible', why on earth would you allow your child to put themselves into a potentially dangerous situation?

As a parent I have a duty of care to my DC and love them dearly. I'm also a responsible dog owner and know that not all dogs want to be engaged with strangers. Because I love them and don't want them to come to harm, I teach DC not to approach unknown dogs. I'd be negligent and an idiot to allow my DC to run up to assorted unknown animals on the grounds that if they get bitten it's technically the dog owner's fault. Surely a responsible parent would want to avoid their child being in the situation in the first place?

Or do you all allow your children to run into roads, and on the edge of reservoirs, or be curious on river banks as well in the name of being children and a bit inquisitive?

speakout · 17/11/2021 07:44

I had those lessons, they originated in the 70's. I distinctly recall the salient detail that was common. Children were playing alone and in no instance were any adults present.

I agree- I was a "street runner" from the age of 3 or 4.
Injuries caused by lack of supervision were very common- and education was needed.

The idea of "stranger danger" hasn't been taught for decades- it is a dangersous message.
Most attacks on children are carried out by someone they know or a family member.
Implicit in the stranger danger message is the idea that people kids know are safe- which isn;t the case.
The whole educational approach has changed on this one with more focus on body safety, secrets, sharing concerns etc. Stranger danger has not been the best accepted approach for 20 years.

Hesma · 17/11/2021 07:40

Parental responsibility like learning manners or how to wipe your bum. Schools have enough on their plate, you are totally ridiculous. My DC know how to behave around dogs because I taught them, it’s not rocket science

Swipe left for the next trending thread