Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dealing with colleagues that ask intrusive questions

94 replies

Quirkyme · 15/11/2021 20:03

Good evening,

Recently started a new role, and I have a colleague that asks me intrusive personal questions. I understand that people may usually ask a new person questions, however, when she does it it is like the Spanish Inquisition!

In my experiences, I've noticed that it is older women who tend to do this, people often old enough to me my mother - I'm in my late twenties. In the past, I've literally had to tell a colleague to mind her business (not quite in those words)because she would ask questions and then give her unsolicited opinion every time we came in contact with each other.

I feel there's a difference between people asking questions to be friendly within reason, and someone asking question after question, to delve deeper in my personal life .

I'm quite assertive, and have no issue not sharing information that I don't want to, or that may be sensitive, however, it is still annoying as hell.

OP posts:
Iloveallofthem · 15/11/2021 23:00

@fourminutestosavetheworld

I'm old enough to be your mum but I wouldn't ask you any questions because I don't give a shit what the answers might be.
😆
StoneofDestiny · 15/11/2021 22:53

Have you come far?
Have you?

Squeezedtillipop · 15/11/2021 22:52

“Have you come far?”

“keep your beak out, Liz.”

AntiHop · 15/11/2021 22:46

You need to give us an example of the questions.

StoneofDestiny · 15/11/2021 22:44

I got this OP when I moved area from a city to a small town. I'd never been asked so many personal questions in my life by anybody. Took a lot of getting used to - I thought they were nosey sods but I imagine they thought they were being friendly. Didn't feel friendly to me, just plain intrusive. I couldn't imagine what they did with the answers unless to gossip.

You do need to have stock responses as some have mentioned above - 'why do you ask?' (It stumps them). 'I'm sure you don't want me to bore you with my personal life', 'you do ask a lot of personal questions'.

Gwlondon · 15/11/2021 22:23

You need to figure out why she is asking the questions.
If she is making conversation, then just change the topic and steer it to what you are interested in.
If she is being nosy, then you could be nosy back, or just say “I don’t think that’s an appropriate thing to talk about” if you want to put a stop to it.
Some people just like asking questions and once they have asked all that they are interested in they just stop. In some cultures it’s normal to be forward and ask questions. If you travel abroad sometimes complete strangers ask questions. So if she isn’t from the same culture as you it might be that. Once you notice these things it makes relations much easier.

Thwackit · 15/11/2021 22:22

Open your eyes wide, say “Gosh, you ask a lot of questions, don’t you?” Or “I don’t want to get into all of that at work.” Then pointedly don’t answer.

She’d have to have the skin of a very thick crocodile to not receive that message.

MauraandLaura · 15/11/2021 22:21

I have this at the school gate!

'Ah have you just finished work?' "what do you do"? "ah where do you do that?' "how long did you have to train to do that?'

These are off women trying to figure me out.(Nosey fuckers)

Grida · 15/11/2021 22:19

@TannyFickler

You are not abnormal for thinking it isn’t a hate crime. It isn’t a hate crime.

BlackAmericanoNoSugar · 15/11/2021 22:11

@WorraLiberty

Pesky older women should be sent to bed with a mug of cocoa and a good knitting pattern.
That sounds like heaven, and I'm technically still middle-aged. Grin Can I self-identify as a pesky older woman?
Ohhgreat · 15/11/2021 22:11

@GADDay

Your post shouts out that you have a massive chip on your shoulder - bundled with an ageist attitude to your colleagues you are going to have a lot of fraught times in years to come.

To answer the question - there are a few approaches you could employ:

  1. Be assertive rude and tell the old woman to fuck off and mind her own business.
  2. Consider she might just be an old gimmer being friendly. Deploy option 1 - as you clearly don't feel the need to engage in office pleasantries.
  3. You could just do what most of us do if asked a question about our labia or vaginal discharge and tell the offender not to ask such a personal question.
  4. If the question was more related to where you buy your shoes from or what you did on the weekend, ot might be that you should lighten up.
Your response made me spit my drink out!! Love it Grin
Cosmos123 · 15/11/2021 22:06

@TillyTopper

There are 2 ways round this that I use, depending on my mood: Either I give non-committal and unspecific answers if they ask anything and carry on with my work or be shocking with the answer.

I went to the office a few weeks ago and there is a new lady there, she was nattering away to the person opposite me and I couldn't concentrate so I already had the hump. She was talking about her daughter who might be having twins (doesn't know yet) someone mentioned "Oh Tilly has twins!". Later when I was waiting for a meeting to start she came into the room where I was (literally opened the door even though she could see on screen I was waiting for a meeting" and started asking me about twins... "Yes I do have twins, but I'd better get on with my meeting now..." then she said "Did you have IVF?" I mean wtf? I replied "No, but I do like fucking. A lot". She left. She didn't say anything to me when I went in last week. Job done.

That's nice....
Cosmos123 · 15/11/2021 22:04

@fourminutestosavetheworld

I'm old enough to be your mum but I wouldn't ask you any questions because I don't give a shit what the answers might be.
😄 haha.

Me me me

TractorAndHeadphones · 15/11/2021 21:56

I agree - prime examples being my own mother (I've been there when she's interrogated total strangers) and DP's!
The age is very relevant because if anybody else asked it would be seen as intrusive - but these people think they're showing care and taking an interest in other people's lives (not my words, my mother's!). Can you imagine a young man asking a woman all these things?

I just give clearly rubbish answers or start asking even more intrusive questions which usually shuts them up.

MajorCarolDanvers · 15/11/2021 21:52

Just tell them you don't feel comfortable.

But no heed for the ageism.

TillyTopper · 15/11/2021 21:46

There are 2 ways round this that I use, depending on my mood: Either I give non-committal and unspecific answers if they ask anything and carry on with my work or be shocking with the answer.

I went to the office a few weeks ago and there is a new lady there, she was nattering away to the person opposite me and I couldn't concentrate so I already had the hump. She was talking about her daughter who might be having twins (doesn't know yet) someone mentioned "Oh Tilly has twins!". Later when I was waiting for a meeting to start she came into the room where I was (literally opened the door even though she could see on screen I was waiting for a meeting" and started asking me about twins... "Yes I do have twins, but I'd better get on with my meeting now..." then she said "Did you have IVF?" I mean wtf? I replied "No, but I do like fucking. A lot". She left. She didn't say anything to me when I went in last week. Job done.

TannyFickler · 15/11/2021 21:45

@Grida The mention of an age category seems to have really bothered you and some others. Why? I’m genuinely trying to understand.

Also it seems like a few of the “you’re an ageist” replies have then gone on to implicitly mock younger people, like OP, with sarcastic comments about how “fascinating” they are, for example. Seems slightly hypocritical.

It has never crossed my mind that describing the age of a person/people who have participated in a behaviour is a type of hate crime. Am I vastly abnormal for this?

MiniPumpkin · 15/11/2021 21:44

A woman in my work seemed obsessed with asking me when I was going to have a baby, she openly would ask me ‘are you trying’ holy sh*t I got so sick of it I ended up saying to her Sandra shall I bring in a diary of when my husband and I have had sex, Jesus it’s pretty much what your asking 🤣 anyway I did have a child to her excitement.. I got a whole bunch of knitting.. kinda cute afterwards but some people have no filter..
Don’t answer what you are unsure of or uncomfortable with.. you can also try putting it back on to them to see what they say .. I do that quite often with the real nosey ones

Grida · 15/11/2021 21:37

What kind of things do you ask people when you are trying to make conversation? Could they just be going for polite interest.

Of course, if they are old enough to be your mum, their lives are practically over and their only hope is to live vicariously through their fascinating twenty something colleagues.

entropynow · 15/11/2021 21:33

@Brefugee

YABU because of the casual ageism.

Grow a backbone: "that's personal" and get on with your work

This.
TannyFickler · 15/11/2021 21:24

Seriously??!!! Why is everyone so outraged that the approximate age range of the people in question has been indicated? Old/older isn’t a dirty word. It would be different if OP said “all older women do X Y Z”. Surely people can tell the difference?

In order to deal with the problem at hand, my suggestion is to do the mysterious wizard act. Any time you are confronted with an intrusive question, do a wistful Gandalf smile and look sideways, sigh, and say “Ah, who can say?/Well, there’s a question for another time and place/Interesting, interesting…I will have to get back to you with my answer” then swoosh your cloak and drift away with dignity.

You definitely don’t have to answer questions that make you uncomfortable because you will benefit from the wisdom of the elders. It’s for you to decide if you have a connection with someone and want to talk about your personal life.

Mellowyellow222 · 15/11/2021 21:21

I worked with both male and females colleagues who did this.

Mainly one man and one woman who were baffled by the fat that I was single and childless in my thirties.

I was asked if I wanted children, if I planned to have them alone, if I had ever had a relationship and why my last relationship ended,

Each and every time I looked at them puzzled and said - why do you ask?

They said just curious (or something to that effect) I said oh and walked away.

It stopped pretty quickly

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 15/11/2021 21:13

Those older women! Seriously, what a horrible attitude you have. They are being nice - if you dont want to answer, divert them by asking them about themselves. Or figure out a phrase like I dont want to keep banging on about myself and trot it out when the questions go too far. But get over yourself with the comments about the older women.

Ariela · 15/11/2021 21:11

I tend to deflect and ask questions back - open ended questions: how what where when why
ones that can't be answered yes or no and then I'd have control of the conversation so I am the questioner and in control of the conversation

SO (NL = nosey lady)
NL : tell me, how long have you lived in x town then?
Me : Oh a fair while, how about you?
NL: uh, all my life
Me : So you grew up here, which school did you go to?
NL: Hetty High School
Me: Oh I've heard that's a really good school, what were your favourite subjects?
NL : um German and Chemistry

etc

A useful phrase of mine is 'that's an interesting question' and I also like to use 'I could answer that a number of ways' or 'I'm not sure you'd be interested in my somewhat boring reply'

WeatherwaxOn · 15/11/2021 21:04

I'm easily old enough to be your mother but I don't ever ask anyone intrusive personal questions. I don't know how people can be so insensitive/tone deaf as to how what they say sounds.