Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dealing with colleagues that ask intrusive questions

94 replies

Quirkyme · 15/11/2021 20:03

Good evening,

Recently started a new role, and I have a colleague that asks me intrusive personal questions. I understand that people may usually ask a new person questions, however, when she does it it is like the Spanish Inquisition!

In my experiences, I've noticed that it is older women who tend to do this, people often old enough to me my mother - I'm in my late twenties. In the past, I've literally had to tell a colleague to mind her business (not quite in those words)because she would ask questions and then give her unsolicited opinion every time we came in contact with each other.

I feel there's a difference between people asking questions to be friendly within reason, and someone asking question after question, to delve deeper in my personal life .

I'm quite assertive, and have no issue not sharing information that I don't want to, or that may be sensitive, however, it is still annoying as hell.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RockinHorseShit · 24/11/2021 10:16

YABU because of the casual ageism.

Grow a backbone: "that's personal" and get on with your work

⏫⏫⏫⏫⏫ this

You should also be old enough & wise enough at your age to deal with such a non event from such annoying old biddies 😘

Triffid1 · 24/11/2021 10:14

I am not certain that OP's idea of "personal questions" and mine are the same. Ditto some PP. Someone at the school gate asking what you do for a living doesn't seem like a personal question.

Also interested in people who say they don't ask questions because it's intrusive. There is nothing I hate more than going to a social event or whatever and when attempting to make conversation the other person makes zero effort and asks no questions. To me, it shows a complete lack of interest in the person in front of you.

Butchyrestingface · 24/11/2021 10:03

All these older women just desperate to know the finer points of your young strapping life...

Do any of them have a goat? 🐐

Offmyfence · 24/11/2021 09:59

@Quirkyme

.
That's an extremely personal question, no wonder you're upset! 🙄
Taytocrisps · 23/11/2021 19:58

I've a very nosy colleague. He asked me one time (in a rather roundabout way) how much I earn. I looked at him, raised my eyebrows and said, "Are you actually asking me how much I earn? Because that's a very personal question".

Another colleague said she would be off work for a few weeks because she was having surgery. He asked her what it was. She's rather brazen and told him she was having a boob job (the truth was far less interesting). Apparently he looked her up and down and said, "I don't think you need a boob job". He went off and told lots of people. She left it a few months and then told him the truth (I can't remember if he brought it up again).

LemonDrizzles · 23/11/2021 18:16

Practise your answers. "I hadn't really thought about it but I'd love to hear what you are doing"
So if it's having kids "I hadn't thought about it. What are you kids like"
Or reverse the question. So "are you from x?" No, but where are you and your parents from?
This sort of thing,
All the best

Quirkyme · 16/11/2021 18:15

.

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 16/11/2021 13:27

I would agree with you there @TannyFickler

TannyFickler · 16/11/2021 13:02

@RampantIvy Obviously not answering for OP, but in a similar situation I’ve resented being asked things like “Do you live with your parents?” And “How come you don’t have a boyfriend?” And “What religion are you?” And “ audible gasp How did your [white British] mum’s parents react when she brought your [middle Eastern] dad home?”

I don’t mind being asked many other things, but these have overstepped the mark/have not been worded tactfully.

RampantIvy · 16/11/2021 12:29

I'm still curious to know what kind of questions the OP considers are personal.

Questions like what part of town do you live in or where did you go to school are not, IMO, personal, any more than asking what kind of music or films you like. Those are the sort of questions you ask when getting to know someone.

EerieSilence · 16/11/2021 10:55

Always listen and speak to the older generation. They are full of wisdom. They aren't afraid of the truth. And they actively take an interest because they have wisdom and truth to share.
You can learn a lot by opening up.

They can also be just nosy and full of shitty advice and dated wisdom. I am slowly becoming the older generation and honestly, I don't consider myself some old priestess of eternal wisdom and knowledge. Let's stop with the venerating of the old as some gurus who are there to share their experience and we need to learn from them. There's that and there's people full of shit or stupidity.

LaBellina · 16/11/2021 10:48

@TillyTopper

There are 2 ways round this that I use, depending on my mood: Either I give non-committal and unspecific answers if they ask anything and carry on with my work or be shocking with the answer.

I went to the office a few weeks ago and there is a new lady there, she was nattering away to the person opposite me and I couldn't concentrate so I already had the hump. She was talking about her daughter who might be having twins (doesn't know yet) someone mentioned "Oh Tilly has twins!". Later when I was waiting for a meeting to start she came into the room where I was (literally opened the door even though she could see on screen I was waiting for a meeting" and started asking me about twins... "Yes I do have twins, but I'd better get on with my meeting now..." then she said "Did you have IVF?" I mean wtf? I replied "No, but I do like fucking. A lot". She left. She didn't say anything to me when I went in last week. Job done.

You’re amazing @TillyTopper ShockGrin
DarlingFell · 16/11/2021 10:46

@TillyTopper

There are 2 ways round this that I use, depending on my mood: Either I give non-committal and unspecific answers if they ask anything and carry on with my work or be shocking with the answer.

I went to the office a few weeks ago and there is a new lady there, she was nattering away to the person opposite me and I couldn't concentrate so I already had the hump. She was talking about her daughter who might be having twins (doesn't know yet) someone mentioned "Oh Tilly has twins!". Later when I was waiting for a meeting to start she came into the room where I was (literally opened the door even though she could see on screen I was waiting for a meeting" and started asking me about twins... "Yes I do have twins, but I'd better get on with my meeting now..." then she said "Did you have IVF?" I mean wtf? I replied "No, but I do like fucking. A lot". She left. She didn't say anything to me when I went in last week. Job done.

You're hard Grin
LaBellina · 16/11/2021 10:37

My DH taught me an interesting trick. Whenever someone asks him a question that he considers as ‘too personal’ he replies with ‘I don’t know’. Most people get confused, then understand they went too far and shut up about it.

TractorAndHeadphones · 16/11/2021 10:36

Also to add I actually get a lot more out of people who hate being asked questions. They tell me all sorts of things because I don’t ask 😂😂😂

TractorAndHeadphones · 16/11/2021 10:34

@Snoken

It's really hard to answer when we don't know what type of questions she is asking. I am a bit of an open book, and I enjoy sharing and listening to other peoples stories. It's kind of how you get to know people and build relationships. She is probably just interested in getting to know you because she likes you, there doesn't need to be anything more sinister than that. If you really don't want to get to know her, I guess you just give vague answers until she gives up, or tell her that you are a private person who do not like to share your thoughts/experiences with her.
There’s a difference between interrogating and getting to know people. It’s called ‘reading the room’.

My mother asks question after question. For example if someone says they have children she asks how old they are, what are they doing now, where did they go to school/uni etc it’s like filling out a form with specific answers.

I don’t do that. I may ask a couple of questions but I tend towards being open ended - e.g if people have children of a certain age make a general observation about school/kids/relevant item. That gets them talking about and the conversation flows from there. If they give short, polite answers I get the hint and change topic or leave them alone.

It’s really not difficult.

Snoken · 16/11/2021 09:08

It's really hard to answer when we don't know what type of questions she is asking. I am a bit of an open book, and I enjoy sharing and listening to other peoples stories. It's kind of how you get to know people and build relationships. She is probably just interested in getting to know you because she likes you, there doesn't need to be anything more sinister than that. If you really don't want to get to know her, I guess you just give vague answers until she gives up, or tell her that you are a private person who do not like to share your thoughts/experiences with her.

ginslinger · 16/11/2021 09:07

@fourminutestosavetheworld

I'm old enough to be your mum but I wouldn't ask you any questions because I don't give a shit what the answers might be.
I'm with you
godmum56 · 16/11/2021 08:40

@fourminutestosavetheworld

I'm old enough to be your mum but I wouldn't ask you any questions because I don't give a shit what the answers might be.
lol I was going to say this....and as an old enough to be your mum person I would suggest that you smile and change the subject, rinse and repeat.
Idony · 16/11/2021 08:32

I thought we were long beyond not knowing how to say no to a question. Didn't you young UN's learn this in school?

Do you have a boyfriend? Make slightly cross eyebrows and leave a pause of awkward silence. "I don't talk about my personal life at work."

Did you vote Brexit? Let's leave politics out of work.

Which vibrator do you use? That's a very inappropriate question for work.

She's not a dotty gran you need to tiptoe around, she's just a dull workplace gossip with no boundaries. Put her in her place and get on with things. Don't fall for her trap, either.

Thought you youngsters had had all your assertiveness training and shit.

Ragwort · 16/11/2021 08:30

What sort of questions?

I am an 'older woman' at 63 and I have a few younger women working with me (actually they are volunteering so they don't have to be with me at all). We do tend to chat and I might ask the about A level choices, Uni applications etc ... I don't ask about their love life of course. None of them seem to object, they all come back for more volunteering- including those who have left for Uni Confused.

Some people are very prickly about making general social chit chat ... and are often the first to complain that they 'can't make friends'. I am pleased to say that as an older woman I have plenty of friends Grin.

However if you are being asked about IVF, why you don't have DC, your sex life etc that is totally inappropriate

KaptainKaveman · 16/11/2021 08:29

@Nietzschethehiker

Bloody hell to the poster who says that young people should ask their elders questions, don't say that I don't want anyone asking me questions! I just want to be left alone. Not to mention someone trotting up to me seeking the wisdom of my years ....I mean I know quite a lot about zombie Canon in films? I've also read quite a lot about fungi, outside of that my wisdom is not particularly helpful if I'm honest, and certainly not forthcoming.

OP you were a bit silly to comment on age, I mean did you not read the name of the forum ? Hardly likely to go down well.

That said it really is nothing to do with age, nosy arses are just that. They witter on all over the place. I'm not a fan of being asked ....well pretty much anything, so just raise an eyebrow roll your eyes and give a vague answer. They get the message after a while.

For goodness sake don't bugger about with the ifs ands and buts. Some will insist that they are just being interested or nice but noone is after the first hint. If they were nice , the first time you socially batted them away they would shut up and respect your privacy.

What did you think to Black Summer?
KaptainKaveman · 16/11/2021 08:28

@Ifyoudontlikeitdosomethingelse

Always listen and speak to the older generation. They are full of wisdom. They aren't afraid of the truth. And they actively take an interest because they have wisdom and truth to share. You can learn a lot by opening up.

Your in your 20s. You're young. Either tell her you don't want her to know or open up and let go of the ego.

Yeah, right. Hmm
Platax · 16/11/2021 08:24

Seriously??!!! Why is everyone so outraged that the approximate age range of the people in question has been indicated? Old/older isn’t a dirty word. It would be different if OP said “all older women do X Y Z”. Surely people can tell the difference?

Nor are "black", "woman", or "disabled" dirty words, but if they were constantly being used when they aren't particularly relevant to the thread and keep being used in a pejorative context, they become discriminatory. The age and sex of the people asking weren't relevant to OP's question, we all know perfectly well that it certainly isn't just older women who ask lots of questions, but she chose to have a little dig at them anyway. And it doesn't make it any better that she didn't claim that all older women do this. Think about it - suppose I posted something saying "I've noticed it's mostly members of XYZ minority group who steal" it would be just as offensive as saying "all XYZ people steal".

Lotusmonster · 16/11/2021 08:18

Just say….”well, that’s a verrry long story and we don’t have the time right now…work and all that 🙄”
Suggests to me these people are a bit lonely and need to get a life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread