Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that my husband said he has 3 kids when he has 4?

632 replies

LaGauchiste · 15/11/2021 16:05

I haven't spoke to my husband for 2 days He thinks I am being unfair, and making a big deal out of nothing. I keep thinking about it, and do not feel like I am being unfair at all.

Friday night, we went to the pub with his 2 new colleagues and their partners. We were just chatting, when one of the ladies asked him " So how many kids do you have?" He replied by saying that he had 3 sons. The woman proceeded to say " So all boys no girls?"
He laughed and said "yup".

At that point I wanted to cry and punch the table so badly. WE HAVE A DAUGHTER. My 20 yo daughter passed away in 2019. I am so angry and upset that he said that.

I confronted him at home , and he saw nothing wrong with it : " Well she's dead, we don't have 4 children anymore".

I grabbed my purse and went to my sister's house. Haven't talked to him since. He keeps messaging me telling me how much he loves me, that I need to get over my, OUR, daughter's death.

Aibu? I never want to see him again.

OP posts:
Malibuismysecrethome · 16/11/2021 06:38

@Multistorey there is no correct way to grieve and you can’t tell someone how they should do it.

Nyxly · 16/11/2021 06:28

@MultiStorey

This is one of the saddest most disturbing threads I’ve ever seen on Mumsnet, and could be used as a case study on dysfunctional death rituals in the UK.

It is appalling how many people prioritize the supposed discomfort of strangers. If you are an adult you should be able to cope with “we lost our daughter”. The reply is “I’m so so sorry, that is just awful.” Which leaves it open to the grieving parents to move the conversation on, or not.

Those who would say “you have no daughter” are as emotionally mature as the school yard bully chanting “your mother’s dead” to a grieving child. They should hang their heads in shame, at the ghastliness of saying that to a grieving mother.

How dare you, tell people how they should grieve. There's people on this thread who are in ops position and deal with it this way. Who are you to tell them that's not ok and they aren't 'adult' enough. And wrong.

Firstly, it's not often about prioritising strangers. It's about prioritising yourself. It's about what you need.

And some people do, do it (in part) for the comfort of strangers. But, really, usually it's because of the impact on themselves that comes our of the uncomfortableness. Sometimes, it's just nor a subject you want to bring up , sometimes you just can't. Sometimes you want sometime where ots nor dominating the immediate converstation.

And no, many adults don't want to say 'we lost our daughter' especially so early on.

There is no one way to deal with this. You have no right to tell anyone they are wrong. Or not they should be able to cope with saying X. That's your emotional immaturity. Because you believe, the way you think it should be is the only way.

My family is Irish. We talk about people we have lost all the time. They are still here and death isn't something taht isn't mentioned. But in those first few years, people all react differently. Some get comfort from taking about in the same way they did before. Some do not. Further down the line some do find comfort is talking about them. Grieving is a changeable state. People change how they deal with it.

I do agree, that people telling the op she doesn't have a daughter are wrong and vile, even if you feel that way from your loss. Its clear op does not.

But I don't think your post is any better.

Malibuismysecrethome · 16/11/2021 06:26

I’m sure he doesn’t mean that your daughter never existed. It’s probably too painful for him to explain her death to strangers and have their condolences and pity. You both live with losing your daughter and I can see why he wouldn’t want to explain the circumstances to randoms.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 16/11/2021 06:20

@MultiStorey

Great post. Some of the comments on here have made me properly angry

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/11/2021 06:17

I don’t want any counselling, I am probably going to sound crazy, but I want to be sad forever, I would feel like I am betraying her if I ever felt OK again.

My husband never really talks about his feelings. I am the one always pushing for discussion.

What you are describing here is a total mismatch of the way you both deal with your respective grief. You want to think and talk about your dd constantly, to submerge yourself in your identity of who she was, who you were when she was alive.

Your dh is dealing with it by never talking about her because it is too painful. Too painful and scary to even talk about her to you. Yet you expect him to talk about her to two new colleagues. And when he doesn’t, you have concluded he doesn’t care or care enough when in reality just mentioning her for him is too scary.

Unable to cope with talking about your dd to you, he shut down. She is dead… you need to get over it because this is how he deals with it.

Your ways of dealing with your grief could not be more opposing. The way I’m reading this is that your husband loves and cares deeply about you; he just can’t do and be the person you want him to be because he’s him. I can totally understand why it feels so cruel to you and I can only imagine your pain. Flowers.

But you are not ever going to get him to grieve the way you want him to grieve. Or to be the support that you need because he’s not really able to even support himself.

Rather like your dh is too scared to talk about your dd, I think you’re actually too scared to start living again and staying submerged in your grief feels more comfortable however strange that sounds. One day, you will perhaps make another choice, such as to find strength in living in the belief that living will also honour your dd.

You have both reached a stalemate. Your dh is too frightened and overwhelmed to talk about your dd and you’re too frightened and overwhelmed to have counselling.

If you ever do reach a point of both going to grief counselling together, a good counsellor will unpick this and give you both strength to support one another an ultimately be able to talk about your dd to one another. This is actually what you want, isn’t it? To be able to lean on your dh. Because right now, you’re doing the opposite. Tearing strips out of each other as neither can understand why the other is reacting in such a strange and alien want.

I feel so very sad for you. I’ve had a deep deep depression when my dad died when I was a child and I received no comfort or love to deal with my grief. There was something strangely comforting in staying in that place in a way and it took me so many years to get out of it. I feel as though you are in that place right now. At the bottom of that well, snuggling up in your pain and using it to comfort you. Flowers

TirednWorried · 16/11/2021 06:16

It is appalling how many people prioritize the supposed discomfort of strangers.
I dont think anyone is saying that its rhe strangers discomfort keeping the ops dh from mentioning his dds death, more that thr conversations is too raw and painful for him. I dont tbink its up to anyone on here, to say how a father who has recently buried his child, ought to grieve. He, like the op, has to get through life the best he can

CatonMat · 16/11/2021 06:15

Disturbing is right.
I find it hard to fathom what makes people like that tick, and to imagine how they function and presumably thrive, in normal society.

MultiStorey · 16/11/2021 06:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Saoirse82 · 16/11/2021 05:48

Some of the posters on here are lower than a snakes belly. Always the same horrible bastards but even this is a new low for them. I'm so sorry for your loss OP, I am 100% with you, just because your daughter isn't here anymore she's still your daughter and your husband not acknowledging that I would find very painful too. Some people on here are bullies plain and simple, sad fuckers. I'm sorry that you've had to read some of their comments Flowers

TirednWorried · 16/11/2021 05:32

However, I want my husband to get better and manage to live with the grief.
With the greatest respect, i don't tbink you do. You are punishing him for coping with it in a way ypu don't deem acceptable. Please stop the silent treatment, it is childish and unproductive You need to talk. Fundamentally you are in very different places. Neither of you is right or wrong, just different. If you don't respect that, i think staying together is going to destroy you both

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 16/11/2021 05:25

*But you don't have 4 children, you only have 3.

You used to have 4*

You are a horrible, horrible person @Slippy78 hope you got the sick little kick you wanted out of upsetting an already grieving mother (of 4) more.

Staryflight445 · 16/11/2021 04:16

I thought he was being unreasonable with how he was treating you until I read this ‘ I don't want any counselling, I am probably going to sound crazy, but I want to be sad forever, I would feel like I am betraying her if I ever felt OK again. I want to die sad. However, I want my husband to get better and manage to live with the grief.’

I’ve lost both my dad and brother recently and I look at it like this- I can either be sad forever, which is pointless really since life is so valuable and they lost theirs prematurely, my brother spending nearly a year fighting for his life.

Or I can realise that I can’t change what’s happened, I was very lucky to have them in my life and I don’t have to feel sad for the rest of my life and it is ok to move on and enjoy what I have, since it’s what they wanted so much and couldn’t have it.

When someone has lost their life so young, do you really think they’d want someone to spend their life not getting help for their grief and wanting to feel sad forever? Or do you think they’d want you to enjoy what they couldn’t have op?

Please, get yourself some support with this. It really can’t be good for the other 3 to go through what they have and then see you like this.

HoppingPavlova · 16/11/2021 02:56

I don’t think he was in the wrong when he initially gave the answer. I have a friend whose child died and they give a different answer for number of kids depending on where they are and who they are with. I guess it’s because there is a chance of follow up questions and with some people they are comfortable with that, and not with others. It’s understandable.

I do think his response to you at home was unreasonable but it seems you both have different grieving and coping mechanisms and can’t let the other do it their way.

PurpleOkapi · 16/11/2021 02:39

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

Oh, I know. I can understand the strong emotions that drove her to react in that way. I just can't understand the posters telling her that what he did was so heinous that she's right to never want to speak to him again, as though he's 100% of the problem here. If she deserves the benefit of the doubt for being overwhelmed by grief, then it seems to me like he does, too.

Wooky8 · 16/11/2021 02:11

I'm so sorry for your loss. I do, however, understand why your husband said what he said. Easier than discussing what happened to your daughter. It must be horrible having to bring it up to everyone who asks about children. Please, please try to forgive him for dealing with it differently to you.

AcrossthePond55 · 16/11/2021 01:57

@LaGauchiste

Thank you to all the sympathetic people who took their time to give me advice.

I don't want any counselling, I am probably going to sound crazy, but I want to be sad forever, I would feel like I am betraying her if I ever felt OK again. I want to die sad. However, I want my husband to get better and manage to live with the grief.

Let me preface by saying that I respect your right to deal with this tragic loss in any way you deem fit. My sister hasn't mentioned the son she lost since his funeral over 40 years ago. Any mention of him is verboten. My niece visits her son's grave weekly, talks about him freely, and I think feels much the same way as you do.

But I also think that your husband loves you and that he will not be able to 'get better and manage to live with the grief' when you have chosen not to do so, yourself. And so he is being pulled in two directions; wanting to heal himself but yet not wanting to 'leave you behind' in your grief. This may be at the root of his what seem to be uncaring remarks.

Do your two ways of handling grief present an insurmountable problem? I don't know. But I do know that counseling can help. Not to change your feelings if you don't want to, but to help each of you to understand the other and to find a path that both of you can walk together.

gogohm · 16/11/2021 01:43

I understand why you are so upset but I also see his point of view, he didn't want to discuss it with new colleagues in the pub. It doesn't mean he doesn't miss her but he chooses to deal with it differently to you. You need to sit down and talk calmly about how you deal with similar situations in the future so you aren't upset by his method of dealing with such an upsetting situation

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 16/11/2021 01:32

@PurpleOkapi

I still don't understand how him telling her that she doesn't have three children anymore is unforgivable, but her threatening to divorce him for not telling his new colleagues that he had a child who died is perfectly fine.
Grief is such a complicated emotion. It isn't always rational.

I made some really questionable decisions, and definitely took my anger at the death of my children out on pretty innocent things because it was a tangible reason to be angry in the early days, and two years in is still very early days.

It was probably somewhere between 5-8 years that I actually began dealing with things in a more 'traditional' (for want of a better word) way.

PurpleOkapi · 16/11/2021 01:26

I still don't understand how him telling her that she doesn't have three children anymore is unforgivable, but her threatening to divorce him for not telling his new colleagues that he had a child who died is perfectly fine.

MajorNeville · 16/11/2021 01:25

My dh has 4 dc, he says to most people he has 3 as he'll do anything to avoid talking to people who aren't close about his eldest a ds, who died. Believe me, he never stops thinking of him and loves him every day of his life.

I'd be very upset at the "get over it" comment though.

I also agree with @ABCeasyasdohrayme that comment was disgusting.

JackieChiles · 16/11/2021 01:18

@BrokenLampShade

There’s no reason he couldn’t have said 4 children and also not had to mention that your DD had died aswell if he didn’t want to make anyone uncomfortable The next thing the colleagues were going to say was hardly going to be ‘and are they all alive?’ Was it?! He just had to say, ‘4 and you?’ And kept the conversation moving
You might not ask more but not everyone is the same. People usually love talking about their kids so if I’m making small talk with might follow it up with something like oh four, how lovely, are they local? Or do you get to see much of them? Etc. Usually people will then say well my oldest lives in the same village, the next one is living in Canada and the twins are at uni. Or whatever. I can see the OP’s point but I don’t think there’s any right or wrong here. We also have no idea how the OP and her DH have been dealing with their loss separately and together thus far.
Hont1986 · 16/11/2021 01:14

I see a lot of posts saying that his reasoning for saying 3 is because he doesn't want to get into it, it's too painful, he's in denial, etc... maybe he says 3 because he really does feel the answer is 3. It isn't denial or avoidance, it's just his honest answer. And OP feels like the honest answer is 4. Grammatically, I think his answer is more correct, but I don't think this issue can be solved with a grammar textbook.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 16/11/2021 01:13

@Slippy78

But you don't have 4 children, you only have 3.

You used to have 4.

Do you think the op doesn't know her own situation.

What sort of person reads an emotional post from a bereaved mother and their first thought is to write that sort of utterly heartless statement.

Absolutely disgusting.

CatonMat · 16/11/2021 01:09

I sincerely (despite how vile you're being) hope you never have cause to listen to this kind of statement aimed at you slippy.

TaraR2020 · 16/11/2021 01:08

That almost makes the insensitivity worse - that you couldn't wait to read further without making such a comment.