Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that my husband said he has 3 kids when he has 4?

632 replies

LaGauchiste · 15/11/2021 16:05

I haven't spoke to my husband for 2 days He thinks I am being unfair, and making a big deal out of nothing. I keep thinking about it, and do not feel like I am being unfair at all.

Friday night, we went to the pub with his 2 new colleagues and their partners. We were just chatting, when one of the ladies asked him " So how many kids do you have?" He replied by saying that he had 3 sons. The woman proceeded to say " So all boys no girls?"
He laughed and said "yup".

At that point I wanted to cry and punch the table so badly. WE HAVE A DAUGHTER. My 20 yo daughter passed away in 2019. I am so angry and upset that he said that.

I confronted him at home , and he saw nothing wrong with it : " Well she's dead, we don't have 4 children anymore".

I grabbed my purse and went to my sister's house. Haven't talked to him since. He keeps messaging me telling me how much he loves me, that I need to get over my, OUR, daughter's death.

Aibu? I never want to see him again.

OP posts:
Nyxly · 16/11/2021 10:34

[quote MultiStorey]@Nyxly How dare I? Really easily- I just type the words.

I think the core point I made, and am now repeating is that the whole culture surrounding death and grief is dysfunctional.
It is dysfunctional that none of the other work colleagues/manager explained the husbands loss to the new colleagues so that they would be aware and considerate.
It is dysfunctional that grief has to be hidden and is seen as embarrassing or inappropriate.
It is dysfunctional that banishing the dead or forgetting them is seen as appropriate, normal or helpful.
It is dysfunctional that speaking about death or dying or the dead is seen as not normal or beyond what others should expect to have to listen to.

Just because OP’s husband is grieving to these dysfunctional rules, in no way reduces the dysfunctionality.
And the OP’s (metaphorical and literal) standing at the graveside because Society rejects her right to grieve within Society is another measure of the dysfunction. No wonder when she wants to die sad, because the culture and society dictate that if she wants to grieve, it must be done in the grieving equivalent of a Period-Hut.

You are a builder of Period Huts, and someone that sends women to them. Shame on you.[/quote]
No the shame is on you.

Yes you can type words. Well done. You can't have any empathy for people who think and feel differently. The level on entitlement you have is astounding.

I have said several times that the OP should be able to grieve how she wants. So should the husband. Then, hopefully, some how find a way to support eachother.

I am not rejecting her right to grieve. I am simply not rejecting people who choose to grieve in a different way. Callling people 'not adult enough' or 'disfunctional' is vile. Its not better than forcing the OP to grieve in a certain way.

You are doing to other people exactly what you are complaining people are doing to the op.

I feel no shame, for understand different people have different needs.

You should feel shame, for the way you are talking about people in this thread and the way they have found their way through.

drpet49 · 16/11/2021 10:31

@MultiStorey

Of course you would be… keeping death ‘private’ hidden (in the period hut) is part of the culture.

Hmm It isn’t about keeping death hidden. It is about my private business being told to new colleagues. They have no need to know.

HariboMuncher · 16/11/2021 09:34

OP, I'm not sure if you're reading or not still and I hope you're ok.

My sibling died when I was a teenager. It was obviously really terrible for my DM and everyone rallied around her for a long time. However, she became very angry that everyone else was going at a different pace to her - I and my remaining siblings had their lives to live.

She had very elaborate, all encompassing and ongoing grief rituals which impacted on everyone else and if we didn't agree with some of the things she did or said she would lash out at us saying that nobody else cared about my sibling dying.

I was very relieved to leave home and went off the rails a bit for a while when I started Uni, largely as a way of processing everything. I've had MH problems since. DM unfortunately can be quite unsympathetic about other people's losses, including a pregnancy losses.

The whole situation was also really terrible for my siblings, one became an alcoholic and also died before her time.

It has had a lasting impact as unfortunately and inevitably there have been other family bereavements and I'm very cautious about how much support I offer DM now.

To echo previous posters, I think some counselling or formal support may help you. I realise that nothing will make your DD's loss better. However, people aren't naturally wired to deal with catastrophic, out-of-order loss, and it might help you and your family for years if you get some advice and support now.

MaxNormal · 16/11/2021 08:58

You need help OP. You don’t sound as if you’re dealing very well with grief

OP lost her daughter quite recently. I don't think many would be "dealing well" with that.
Person after person berating her both for not respecting her husband's way of grieving, but also telling her she's doing hers wrong.

Easy to infer that according to society, the correct way is to not speak about it and move on as quickly as possible lest it cause someone discomfort.

Budapestdreams · 16/11/2021 08:52

OP, my heart is breaking for you. I understand that you want to stay sad forever, it helps you to feel connected to your daughter. You may be worried that if you start to feel happy again that means you are forgetting her or that you don't love her as much.

The intensity of your grief reflects the intensity of your love for her. However, you can still love her deeply and profoundly without this level of suffering.

I know you don't want grief counselling but it won't dampen your feelings for her. You won't feel less connected to her.

I hear you that you want to suffer, but your DH and sons don't want that for you and I'm sure you wouldn't want them to still be in the amount of pain you are in.

Please reconsider specialist grief counseling. It will be an opportunity to talk about your daughter at length and discuss how much your DHs comments hurt you, how you want to stay in pain etc. It would be better to take to a professional about it than ask all of us unqualified mumsnetters.
It won't stop you loving her and it won't stop your pain, but it will be someone to talk to about all your feelings.

💐

Lochroy · 16/11/2021 08:28

FGS @MultiStorey who put you in charge of how everyone should behave? When my Dad died, I was MORE than happy to talk about it with friends and family. I needed to. I grieved and talking was part of that process.

But work was MY ESCAPE. Of course my close colleagues knew, but they had the decency to take the lead from me and carry on as normal. I would have been FURIOUS if someone had decided they knew better me as to what should happen.

Some of your arguments are reasonable but your die on a hill attitude that it should be blanket applied to everyone is skewed.

wombat1a · 16/11/2021 08:28

OP you need help, real professional help and it sound like your DH knows that too and is trying to make you realise that. Just because you visit her grave daily in your grief doesn't mean his way of dealing with grief is any less than yours.

WRT to the 4 vs 3, I would have answered the same as your DH, as in I have 3, later on if I knew them well I might tell them I did had 4 but one passed away to avoid confusion.

Ricetwisty · 16/11/2021 08:18

Anyway, I have work so can’t get back until this evening.

That's a real shame, how is anyone going to cope without you dictating how they should feel.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 08:13

Then you look at the distress of the OP, and her husband do you think “Well that’s one thing we’re doing a good job of?

Ah, so you think that it's society's handling of bereavement and not the loss of their beloved daughter that's causing their distress? And, if only we marked death like the Victorians/ancient Egyptians/Mexicans (insert whichever glib cultural reference you've just Googled), they would be just fine? You're not very bright, are you? People who want to dictate how everyone else should behave rarely are.

MultiStorey · 16/11/2021 08:07

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MultiStorey · 16/11/2021 08:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 07:55

[quote MultiStorey]@Nyxly How dare I? Really easily- I just type the words.

I think the core point I made, and am now repeating is that the whole culture surrounding death and grief is dysfunctional.
It is dysfunctional that none of the other work colleagues/manager explained the husbands loss to the new colleagues so that they would be aware and considerate.
It is dysfunctional that grief has to be hidden and is seen as embarrassing or inappropriate.
It is dysfunctional that banishing the dead or forgetting them is seen as appropriate, normal or helpful.
It is dysfunctional that speaking about death or dying or the dead is seen as not normal or beyond what others should expect to have to listen to.

Just because OP’s husband is grieving to these dysfunctional rules, in no way reduces the dysfunctionality.
And the OP’s (metaphorical and literal) standing at the graveside because Society rejects her right to grieve within Society is another measure of the dysfunction. No wonder when she wants to die sad, because the culture and society dictate that if she wants to grieve, it must be done in the grieving equivalent of a Period-Hut.

You are a builder of Period Huts, and someone that sends women to them. Shame on you.[/quote]
You are a builder of Period Huts, and someone that sends women to them. Shame on you

You've heard her, bereaved parents. Be ashamed if you don't want to grieve the way @multistorey dictates 🙄

There are many, many different cultures of grieving. Some traditional societies never mention the dead person's name. Others take their dead relatives' bodies out of the tomb and dress them up once a year. No doubt you know better than all these people, too, @Multistorey? Why not pop over to Polynesia and give them the benefit of your wisdom? Don't hurry back.

Guavaf1sh · 16/11/2021 07:55

You need help OP. You don’t sound as if you’re dealing very well with grief and are making things worse. I hope you get the help you need

drpet49 · 16/11/2021 07:55

@MultiStorey

* It is dysfunctional that none of the other work colleagues/manager explained the husbands loss to the new colleagues so that they would be aware and considerate.*

^Are you for real? I would be furious if my manager did this.

drpet49 · 16/11/2021 07:53

** I think him saying he has 3 sons is probably much easier to cope with than him having to tell 2 very new colleagues about the sad loss of your daughter in a social situation.
I can totally see why he did it.**

^This. YABU

Malibuismysecrethome · 16/11/2021 07:52

multistorey the husband has the right to feel and process his daughters death however he wishes. Some people don’t fall apart. They carry on.
This is equally true of men and women not everyone is locked in to grief and their own feelings they have to consider the wellbeing of others.

RedHelenB · 16/11/2021 07:50

The important thing is that he loved your daughter and showed her that while she was living. I think you are being unfair to him, but I do understand your upset.

Ricetwisty · 16/11/2021 07:48

because the culture and society dictate that if she wants to grieve, it must be done in the grieving equivalent of a Period-Hut.

No they don't, but in this situation there were 2 grieving parents, one didn't want to talk about it and one did, why should the one who did (to people who weren't their workmates) have divine right to without the other getting annoyed, because you feel it smashes the status quo?

Ricetwisty · 16/11/2021 07:47

It is dysfunctional that none of the other work colleagues/manager explained the husbands loss to the new colleagues so that they would be aware and considerate

I'd be furious if someone at work took it upon themselves to tell others about my personal life, it's up to me to do that if I feel comfortable. It's also not helpful to have people tiptoe round, feel awkward about what to say, apologise profousley if they feel they have put their foot in it; again, stop dictating what you think people want.

MultiStorey · 16/11/2021 07:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Ricetwisty · 16/11/2021 07:36

@MultiStorey

This is one of the saddest most disturbing threads I’ve ever seen on Mumsnet, and could be used as a case study on dysfunctional death rituals in the UK.

It is appalling how many people prioritize the supposed discomfort of strangers. If you are an adult you should be able to cope with “we lost our daughter”. The reply is “I’m so so sorry, that is just awful.” Which leaves it open to the grieving parents to move the conversation on, or not.

Those who would say “you have no daughter” are as emotionally mature as the school yard bully chanting “your mother’s dead” to a grieving child. They should hang their heads in shame, at the ghastliness of saying that to a grieving mother.

Grieving parents aren't some homogenous group of people with a hive mind, they are still individuals who all behave, think and feel differently. Who are you to say what people should or shouldn't do?
Rainbowsew · 16/11/2021 07:23

I think in this situation it's hard, I can see why he wouldn't want to get into a conversation about his daughters death with new colleague in a pub.

However yanbu to be upset and certainly he shouldn't be telling you to get over it. You'll always have 4 kids.

How you move on I don't know, I suppose this is why some relationships break down after the death of a child, because of different ways of grieving.

My heart goes out to you both.

gofg · 16/11/2021 07:13

I can understand why he said three, it avoids further questioning which may lead to him having to explain that your DD has died.

YABU in your reaction, it is really OTT.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 16/11/2021 07:00

@MultiStorey

This is one of the saddest most disturbing threads I’ve ever seen on Mumsnet, and could be used as a case study on dysfunctional death rituals in the UK.

It is appalling how many people prioritize the supposed discomfort of strangers. If you are an adult you should be able to cope with “we lost our daughter”. The reply is “I’m so so sorry, that is just awful.” Which leaves it open to the grieving parents to move the conversation on, or not.

Those who would say “you have no daughter” are as emotionally mature as the school yard bully chanting “your mother’s dead” to a grieving child. They should hang their heads in shame, at the ghastliness of saying that to a grieving mother.

How dare you lecture bereaved people on how to handle their bereavement? What gives you the right to decide what is dysfunctional?

Maybe it would be nice if we lived in a society where devastating bereavements could be dropped into casual conversation without dropping a beat. But that’s not the world we live in.

Poster after poster on here has described how they prefer to not to mention their dead child to casual acquaintances. And you think you have the right to tell them that they are doing it wrong?

chocolateorangeinhaler · 16/11/2021 06:42

Oh my goodness. That's so sad for the pair of you I'm really sorry. What an awful way to be put on the spot. Why didn't you say anything at the time?

What's he like emotionally in other circumstances? I only ask because in our society men have been expected to not show and hold in emotions at all times. Drummed into them by parent, teachers and the like ever since they were children. It's really sad that showing emotions is seen as a sign of weakness in men but normal for women.

Maybe at that moment he just didn't want to say as it would lead to more questions - how old was she, when did it happen etc. - a conversation that he didn't want to have as it's so personal.

Cut him a bit of slack. He's hurting but probably doesn't know what to do about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread