Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that my husband said he has 3 kids when he has 4?

632 replies

LaGauchiste · 15/11/2021 16:05

I haven't spoke to my husband for 2 days He thinks I am being unfair, and making a big deal out of nothing. I keep thinking about it, and do not feel like I am being unfair at all.

Friday night, we went to the pub with his 2 new colleagues and their partners. We were just chatting, when one of the ladies asked him " So how many kids do you have?" He replied by saying that he had 3 sons. The woman proceeded to say " So all boys no girls?"
He laughed and said "yup".

At that point I wanted to cry and punch the table so badly. WE HAVE A DAUGHTER. My 20 yo daughter passed away in 2019. I am so angry and upset that he said that.

I confronted him at home , and he saw nothing wrong with it : " Well she's dead, we don't have 4 children anymore".

I grabbed my purse and went to my sister's house. Haven't talked to him since. He keeps messaging me telling me how much he loves me, that I need to get over my, OUR, daughter's death.

Aibu? I never want to see him again.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 15/11/2021 16:38

@LaGauchiste

I never wanted him to explain anything. A simple " I have 4 kids" would have been more than enough.

Thank you for your support and for those who tell me " Technically he's right you have 3 now". No. I don't.

You’re both in the right - you have every right to feel that you have 4 kids, and he has every right to feel like he had 4 and that you (joint you) now have 3.

This is one of the situations that there’s no right or wrong.

He’s entitled to deal with that in his way, just as you are yours.

Peanutbuttercupisyum · 15/11/2021 16:38

Different people deal in different ways. I know of 2 people in your situation - one always counts the child that passed away, and actually seems to talk about them as if they’re alive, and the other completely omits to mention them
if asked how many children they have. I don’t think either response is wrong, I think allow your DH to explain things in his own way

mumsie8 · 15/11/2021 16:38

I see everybody's point of view but personally if i had had a child who had died and my husband discounted their existance i would find that incredibly hard to accept.

My child existed, they were real, they lived, breathed, took up a much loved space in my life. Death doesn't change that. Yes, of course it changes the dynamic of my ongoing living life but they would continue to be one of my children and loved just as much as my living ones.

I think OP's H handled the whole thing with about as much sensitivity as a bull in a china shop. And while i'm not saying he isn't grieving/hurting the degree of callousness in his comments is breathtaking.

OP only you can decide how you want things to move forward.

I'm so, so sorry for the loss of your DD. She was real, she lived and i'm sure she was a typical bright, breezy, caring, infuriating, much loved and now missed young woman. Flowers

Aderyn21 · 15/11/2021 16:37

Losing a child doesn’t mean that they cease to be your child.
I can understand wanting to dodge the question in the pub but what ge said at home is utterly unforgivable imo

SelfIdentifiedRightsHoarder · 15/11/2021 16:35

As others have said, my brother died, and completely depending on who I'm talking to and what the situation is, I would just say I have a sister, or mention both. It's not something I feel comfortable discussing in every scenario. Because there's always follow up questions, and then the awkward apologies and silence after you say it. And it's upsetting for me too. However, I do think he was out of line to say that technically its true, because of course it isn't. Your daughter will always be your daughter. Is he usually clumsy with words? Or bad at expressing these kinds if emotions? I'm sorry for your loss 💐

lockdownalli · 15/11/2021 16:35

I think it was insensitive of him to tell you to "get over" your daughter's death. However, I also think it was insensitive of you not to consider that your DH may not want to share such personal information with new colleagues and their partners. I certainly would not.

I hope you can reach some agreement Flowers

Irishfarmer · 15/11/2021 16:35

I didn't vote as I don't think you are even slightly unreasonable about how you feel, but I also don't think he isn't unreasonable either, he might not want a question about her to bring up the inevitable she has passed away. I think maybe it is time to have a conversation with your husband? Ask his side. He probably feels awful for upsetting you even though he didn't mean to or understand why it did.
The "we don't have 4 children any more" comment to me sounds just like some of his hurt coming out

SickAndTiredAgain · 15/11/2021 16:35

I never wanted him to explain anything. A simple "I have 4 kids" would have been more than enough.

The reason my mum doesn’t include her late son in the number of children she has when asked by people she doesn’t know that well is to avoid the chance they’ll ask follow up questions. She knows it’s unlikely that if she says she has four that someone will ask her what all four do, or where they all live etc. But she still doesn’t like to say it. Especially as if they ask about boys/girls and she says 3 girls and a boy, they may say something like “oh must’ve been tough for your son, growing up with so many sisters!” in a lighthearted way and she either nods along, or says actually no, he didn’t grow up with three sisters, he didn’t even meet two of them. Or “oh gosh four kids, must’ve been a handful” and again she either nods along with it, or says she never had four children to look after at once. So she says three.

MilduraS · 15/11/2021 16:34

I lost my daughter when she was 3. If people ask me if I have any children I say no. It not because I'm pretending she didn't exist, i just feel awkward speaking about her with complete strangers. They don't know what to say and I don't know what to say so I find it easier to just say no, I don't have any.

Iwab82 · 15/11/2021 16:34

So sorry for your loss. I would feel the same as you. No one gets over losing a child, I don't know how he can say that.

GoodnessGraciousMeOMy · 15/11/2021 16:33

I do think you are being unreasonable, I'm sorry. If your husband had mentioned a daughter, it could have well led into conversations about children and then a more awkward conversation when your husband has to clarify the situation. It doesn't mean your husband has forgotten her or doesn't care. He has dealt with it differently to you.

washingmachines4 · 15/11/2021 16:33

He is not wrong to find a way around not talking about it at the pub in a light hearted setting if he doesn't want to. I do this.
I would overlook this as his way of coping.

His way of defending it at home I would say is off. But we each cope differently with grief.

I would say try to make peace openly with his dismissal of a discussion around her death with others, it is difficult.
Between you at home you need to be able to discuss, grieve, and smile at memories in a way that bonds you rather than divides you. I have seen grief split too many couples, if you can find a way through it together to help one another - this is the better option.

Sending love.

Porcupineintherough · 15/11/2021 16:32

I can see why that remark must have cut you to the core. But I also see why he said it, and think that it was his choice. I'm not sure there is a "right" or "wrong" way to answer this question when you've suffered such a devastating loss. Flowers

SusieBob · 15/11/2021 16:32

@LaGauchiste

I never wanted him to explain anything. A simple " I have 4 kids" would have been more than enough.

Thank you for your support and for those who tell me " Technically he's right you have 3 now". No. I don't.

The thing is though, saying he has 4 children including your daughter invites follow up questions like "how old are they" and "are they at university" and so forth.

For people he has just met I can totally understand why he would not want to deal with questions like that.

Neither of you are wrong, you are just dealing with an unthinkable situation in your own ways.

FlowersNoScent · 15/11/2021 16:32

I'm sorry for your loss but your husband did nothing wrong. I think you're taking your pain (understandably) out on him. If you felt strongly about it, I'd have chipped in to say 'actually we have 4 but we lost her/she died (or however way you'd want to say it)'. Then you can talk about it if you want.

It's not something to leave him about or expect him to say what he doesn't want to say. Perhaps he didn't want to upset you by bringing her up, unless he already knows you'd want him to say 4 instead of 3?

Think about it, take time and calm down. I hope you'll see things differently later on. Sorry about your loss.Flowers

AmyDudley · 15/11/2021 16:32

I understand why you think that is hurtful, but it seems you each deal with it in different way, and neither way is right or wrong. I lost a brother and whenever people asked about siblings I used to say ' I have two sisters, I used to have a brother but he died' That was my way of handling that situation.

What I do think is very wrong is him telling you you need to get over it. No one should try to tell you how long you grieve for, in fact I imagine no one 'gets over' the death of a child. Perhaps you get used to living with the loss, but you don't get over it, It is much too profound a loss. I think that is what you need to talk about with your DH, he doesn't get to tell you what is right or wrong in grief, there is no right or wrong.

Sally872 · 15/11/2021 16:32

If he is normally a decent person I suspect he was defensive/embarrassed at hurting you and reacted badly.

If I genuinely felt he had forgotten dd or didn't care about her death I would not he able to forgive.

However more likely he was trying to keep conversation light and doesn't talk about dd unless it's a space where he would want to answer more questions if asked. If his apology is genuine I would listen.

girlmom21 · 15/11/2021 16:31

In the context of the question though, no, she has three.

The question was how many children do you have, not how many living children do you have.
They have 4 children. One of them sadly died. That doesn't mean she's not their child.

Rubadubdub21 · 15/11/2021 16:31

I'm so sorry. Yes he was being unreasonable! He didn't have to mention anything about her passing, could have just said 3 boys and one girl and that's it. Moved the conversation on.

alphasox · 15/11/2021 16:31

I’m so sorry for your loss. I can see both sides of this as my brother died young and how I respond to questions like “do you have any siblings” varies depends on my mood and who i’m talking to/who well I know them.

Sometimes it’s easier to say “no it’s just me”, as I don’t want to share and get upset myself or make people uncomfortable. But he’s definitely still my brother and when I’m brave enough I reply that I had a brother who sadly died. So I think your husband probably didn’t feel comfortable with new colleagues discussing something so personal and painful. It’s very recent. I hope you are getting some support with your loss x

queenMab99 · 15/11/2021 16:30

I also agree that to discount the son who died would seem disloyal to me, I still have 2 sons in my heart, and although it is 12 years since he died, never a day passes without me thinking of him. We talk about him cheerfully, as a family sometimes, even to his nephew who never met him, but has his name.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 15/11/2021 16:30

@Aderyn21

Telling a mother that she she needs to get over the death of her child is never acceptable. And the OP categorically does have 4 children - that one of them has died does not negate that fact. I wouldn’t be talking to him either.
In the context of the question though, no, she has three.
WindyWindsor · 15/11/2021 16:30

I'm so sorry OP I can understand why you're upset. I wonder if he's dealing with the grief journey differently. It must have been so horrific for both of you.

Thehop · 15/11/2021 16:30

I agree with @Maulstick

AryaStarkWolf · 15/11/2021 16:29

@LaGauchiste

I never wanted him to explain anything. A simple " I have 4 kids" would have been more than enough.

Thank you for your support and for those who tell me " Technically he's right you have 3 now". No. I don't.

Saying he had a daughter may have invited questions about her that he didn't want to get in to though OP, not on a night out in the Pub with work colleagues
Swipe left for the next trending thread