Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that my husband said he has 3 kids when he has 4?

632 replies

LaGauchiste · 15/11/2021 16:05

I haven't spoke to my husband for 2 days He thinks I am being unfair, and making a big deal out of nothing. I keep thinking about it, and do not feel like I am being unfair at all.

Friday night, we went to the pub with his 2 new colleagues and their partners. We were just chatting, when one of the ladies asked him " So how many kids do you have?" He replied by saying that he had 3 sons. The woman proceeded to say " So all boys no girls?"
He laughed and said "yup".

At that point I wanted to cry and punch the table so badly. WE HAVE A DAUGHTER. My 20 yo daughter passed away in 2019. I am so angry and upset that he said that.

I confronted him at home , and he saw nothing wrong with it : " Well she's dead, we don't have 4 children anymore".

I grabbed my purse and went to my sister's house. Haven't talked to him since. He keeps messaging me telling me how much he loves me, that I need to get over my, OUR, daughter's death.

Aibu? I never want to see him again.

OP posts:
StuffYouAllInTheCrust · 15/11/2021 18:00

I get it OP. I lost my brother at a young age many years ago, but despite the worry of what comes next, if anyone asks me I always say I have an older brother. I just can’t not. I’d feel disrespectful if I didn’t.

People deal with things differently but I’d feel exactly as you do. So sorry about your daughter. It’s still so very new and I know you’ll feel like he’s pretending she never existed. I’m sure that isn’t the case but I know it hurts just the same. Flowers

DreamerSeven · 15/11/2021 18:00

I’m so sorry for your loss first of all. But I can see why he replied in the way he did, I know a couple of people who sadly lost a child and how they answer the question of “how many kids do you have?” depends entirely on who they’re with, what sort of occasion it is, how fragile they’re feeling that day etc. I hope you can sort this out with him xx

Ricetwisty · 15/11/2021 17:59

He probably didn't feel ready to talk about it with new colleagues who were just making polite small talk. Everyone reacts differently after a loss, and he shouldn't feel pressured to say x because that's what you feel is the right thing to say. Being upset at the get over it comment is harsh, but overall you can't police someone's reactions.

callmeadoctor · 15/11/2021 17:59

I could forgive what he said in the pub (although laughing about having no girls is a bit weird). But I would be leaving him for him saying that you should get over it.

Lightisnotwhite · 15/11/2021 17:59

Horrible to lose your child. Not sure how you get over that.

However if your husband dies will you still say you’re married?
Would you want your boys to say we “have” a sister rather than saying “had” a sister?

tiltedworld · 15/11/2021 17:58

@Skeumorph

So for all those being all understanding, what's the explain-away for him then shrugging at home and saying he sees nothing wrong with it and OP should just shut up, get over it, and come back home and get on with the wifing? Rather than saying, I'm sorry, I probably handled that wrong, I didn't mean to bring things up for you, I know how you feel'?

How bloody hard would it be for him to react like that? I mean especially as he's the OTHER PARENT?

Jeeez.

But he didn't handle it wrong. He said what many would say. And he's now being used as a punchbag by the OP because she is not getting the help to deal with her grief and prefers to make him the bad guy. It's not fair on him

It does make me wonder about the dynamics of their relationship generally

SleepingStandingUp · 15/11/2021 17:58

@LaGauchiste

I never wanted him to explain anything. A simple " I have 4 kids" would have been more than enough.

Thank you for your support and for those who tell me " Technically he's right you have 3 now". No. I don't.

I'm sorry OP, no one should be telling you to "get over it" and I'm terribly sorry for your loss.

The problem with "just say 4" is it leads in, like it did when he said 3. Oh so one girl? Is she the oldest / youngest? Are they really protective? Do they get in well?

At which point he has to lie or talk about his daughters death, something it doesn't sound like he's fully processed, just pushed into a locked box. People grieve differently and there has to be some acceptance on both sides or it will be the bed of your marriage

SueSaid · 15/11/2021 17:58

Totally understandable why he said that then in the pub but utterly appalling that when you confronted him about it later he bluntly said 'well we do only have 3, she's dead' seriously who says stuff like that.

'Yabu It’s not a light easy thing to say in a pub conversation so it’s easier to say three Did you have some counselling? It sounds really difficult for you still'

Confused

I am so sorry for your loss Flowers.

Holdingontonothing · 15/11/2021 17:55

So sorry for your loss OP.

YANBU to be upset, but it feels like your DH has - as others have said - tried to avoid a painful, upsetting and difficult conversation with new colleagues on a social evening. And his 'get over it' comment is probably clumsy language around compartmentising feelings, which rightly or wrongly is a coping strategy many men do have to rely on as there's not the same support structure or acceptance of them showing emotion.

Please do talk to him and consider the pair of you getting some grief support together, if nothing else to help you understand each others point on the grief journey and 'grief lamguage'. Sending you love ❤

weebarra · 15/11/2021 17:53

I'm so sorry, it's such a difficult one.
My younger sister died in 2019 and the question about children was the reason that my mum didn't go out for ages.
She and my dad will never get over losing their DD and my brother and I will never get over losing DSis.
I don't know what they would answer.
I don't know what I would answer. We talk about her all the time but it's safe to do it among ourselves.

WonderfulYou · 15/11/2021 17:53

I voted YABU simply because if I had been through something so tragic I wouldn’t be able to talk about it to strangers. Chances are they would have asked how old she is and what she does for a living etc and that would kill me.

However you are obviously not BU to be upset over it.

EverdeRose · 15/11/2021 17:53

You're both dealing with your loss in different ways.

Neither is wrong. Neither love her more or less.

Don't let your daughters death lead to the death of your marriage. Accept that you both grieve differently.

MyAnacondaMight · 15/11/2021 17:53

I am so sorry for your loss. Your desire to recognise your daughter in conversation does not trump your husband’s desire to avoid talking to his colleagues about his daughter’s death. I’m afraid I think you were being unreasonable.

SusieBob · 15/11/2021 17:50

@supremelybaffled

So many people on this thread who have no comprehension of what it's like to lose a child.
Completely untrue.

OP has recieved pretty much the same advice from every poster - many of whom have experience of losing kids too.

User2638483 · 15/11/2021 17:48

I can see why you’re upset but people handle things differently. I can also see why he’d say three because otherwise it could lead to questions about your daughter where he’d then be in a position where he’d have to talk about it/tell them he died, which he may well not have wanted to do.

So neither of you are being unreasonable.

supremelybaffled · 15/11/2021 17:48

So many people on this thread who have no comprehension of what it's like to lose a child.

EdenFlower · 15/11/2021 17:48

YABU!

If you said to someone you have a daughter, then you are mis-leading them. What are you going to say when they answer, "oh really, and how old is your daughter?", or "what does your daughter do for a living?" etc.

Poor DH!

BurntO · 15/11/2021 17:47

He didn’t want to open up to his colleagues. YANBU to be upset by the conversation up I had afterwards but I think he was likely to be feeling guilty and defensive about it. I cannot image how hard it must be for the both of you

Tee20x · 15/11/2021 17:45

No one is wrong. Well he is for telling you you need to get over it as you never will. But as for saying he has 3 children at - right now he does.

I think for the setting, I would also choose that answer - people ask follow up questions. And then it's like how far do you go with acting as if she is still here.

He could say yeah I have 4 kids, 3 boys and a girl. Then conversation could flow to their ages etc etc what they do for a living - he would then have to explain well actually he has 3 boys but daughter sadly passed away.

Depending on his relationship with these people it may just be something he wanted to avoid.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 15/11/2021 17:45

I lost my brother and it's very awkward when people ask how many siblings I have. There was 5 of us and only 1 boy. When I say 3 sisters it normally follows with wow! All girls eh. It never fails to make me feel a horrible feeling as my brother was closest to me in age and we were best friends. However, I got sick of making conversations awkward and it's just easier to say 3 sisters. He probably didn't enjoy saying that.

You're allowed to feel these feelings but I think you are being very unreasonable not allowing your husband to also grieve. It's horrible when people follow that answer with questions like: what do they do etc. It is a very very difficult time for everyone when a child dies. So many couples don't make it. I think you both need to sit down and make up. You need each other more than you may realise and he is likely to be one of few others who loved your child as you do and understands your pain.
FWIW my brother was the same age as your daughter when he died. The next couple of years will be tough as you watch their friends create adult lives.
You need each other for that OP.

HeyFloof · 15/11/2021 17:44

You don't stop being a parent to a child that has passed, you stop actively parenting them, but they are always your child.

And I can never "get over" my grief at cremating one of my children. It's just got further away, and less raw.

DH doesn't talk about our DS really either. He died just after birth so it's a different situation, but sometimes he'll say "I have two living sons" other times "I have 2 boys" depending on who he is with. He's very private and wouldn't discuss DS2 with people as a rule.

I could forgive your dh for not discussing her in the context your talking about, public place, new colleagues etc. I would struggle to forgive what your dh said to you once you got home. He is the person who knows best how broken you are, it was callous of him to say what he said to you knowing how you feel.

I am so sorry for the loss of your precious girl Flowers

Skeumorph · 15/11/2021 17:44

@FlowersNoScent

Skeumorph I get what you mean but I think you're weaving a tale based on assumptions and getting worked up about it. OP seems understandably upset still about her loss but we don't know exactly what happened, how it happened, what was said and wasn't said, the tone and intent, etc besides what OP has told us. We don't know if he hugged her and tried to apologise but OP wasn't having it and was telling him how much he's forgotten their child. Then he too decided to throw it right back at the OP (See, we can weave different scenarios here).

So I won't join in alienating OP further from her dh by adding to an incomplete scenario.

Yes, I do see what you mean. Fair point.
ivegotthisyeah · 15/11/2021 17:42

Tricky one and I get why your hurt. I have four children however one is no longer with me and if I was in that circumstance in the pub I would of said the same as your husband as it's a private thing that I wouldn't then feel comfortable explaining to strangers. If I am in my own home with family and friends then that is different
💐

Fran2508 · 15/11/2021 17:41

This is a really hard situation. I, too, lost a child and I dread the how many children question. I now say “ I have two boys living at home” as then I don’t feel I have betrayed my precious child but I also know that it is a lot for someone to take on board if it is only a casual conversation and the memory of my child is somehow too precious to share with people who I don’t know and trust yet. My husband and I weren’t always on the same page in our grief; we grieved deeply but differently and for a time it blew us apart. I am so sorry for your loss- it is an awful time. X

FlowersNoScent · 15/11/2021 17:40

Does OP's husband literally have, in their 'possession', four children? No, I guess technically not, if you want to go by the definition of a physical person you can touch. But how does one 'have' a child? Do you still have a child if they're in prison for the rest of their life, for example, and you'll never be able to physically see them again? What if they don't talk to you any more, so you can't even talk to them, do you cease to 'have' the child then?

Surely we can see that having a child is not physically being able to see them, or audibly hearing them, or being geographically close to them - it's about the shift in your mindset from non-parent to parent (or parent of 2, 3, 4). That's why women who have miscarriages or stillborn babies often still regard themselves as parents. Parenthood isn't an on/off switch - once it's happened, you're a parent. A grieving parent, yes, but you still 'have' parenthood. Therefore 'having' a child is not about the physical number of children you could round up into one place.

I disagree with those examples being the same as someone dying. Completely different. Otherwise, we may as well scrap talking about people who died in the past tense. We can try to make it sound as correct as we like but there's a difference between 'how many children you have (currently)' and 'how many children you've had'.

However, people who lost someone can choose to speak about them however they want. So I won't be telling someone how to describe their situation. It doesn't mean they're technically or literally correct but it's not hurting anyone.