Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that my husband said he has 3 kids when he has 4?

632 replies

LaGauchiste · 15/11/2021 16:05

I haven't spoke to my husband for 2 days He thinks I am being unfair, and making a big deal out of nothing. I keep thinking about it, and do not feel like I am being unfair at all.

Friday night, we went to the pub with his 2 new colleagues and their partners. We were just chatting, when one of the ladies asked him " So how many kids do you have?" He replied by saying that he had 3 sons. The woman proceeded to say " So all boys no girls?"
He laughed and said "yup".

At that point I wanted to cry and punch the table so badly. WE HAVE A DAUGHTER. My 20 yo daughter passed away in 2019. I am so angry and upset that he said that.

I confronted him at home , and he saw nothing wrong with it : " Well she's dead, we don't have 4 children anymore".

I grabbed my purse and went to my sister's house. Haven't talked to him since. He keeps messaging me telling me how much he loves me, that I need to get over my, OUR, daughter's death.

Aibu? I never want to see him again.

OP posts:
Bobsyer · 15/11/2021 21:35

How does that transforms to " He doesn't want to discuss his daughter's death front of XY AND Z" ?

Oh love. You are blinded by your grief.

He is thinking that it's not true to say he has four children, when for him, it's an important distinction that he has 3 but had four. It's important to him to acknowledge her death, and he realises that if he says the above it invites questions he really doesn't want to answer and a conversation he doesn't want to have.

It's important to you to acknowledge her as a child of yours in a different way. Neither of you are wrong. Please don't break up your marriage over this. Please speak to someone Flowers. There is no wrong way to grieve but there is a wrong way to deal with related events and you need an impartial person to talk this through with.

Tailendofsummer · 15/11/2021 21:35

OP you must see that a comment about the four children you share could have easily led to further comments and questions (especially about your daughter as the only girl with several brothers). There is no way you can control what happens next when you tell someone something about your family. Not mentioning his dd was one way not to risk being asked about her.
It's such a shame you're not able to be the support for each other that you each need. Maybe time will improve your relationship - it is still such early days for your loss. Have you decided to return home Op?

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 15/11/2021 21:34

@LaGauchiste

Where is everyone getting that I wanted him to tell his coworkers about your daughter's death ???! I never ever said that. Stop. All I said is that I would have preferred if he said that he had 4 children. How does that transforms to " He doesn't want to discuss his daughter's death front of XY AND Z" ?

First of all, when I confronted him. I was crying and did ask him why he said that. As I said before, had he said he didn't want to discuss it. I would have respected it. I was crying, and he was angry. My husband never really talks about his feeling. I am always the one pushing for discussion. My 3 sons are adults and do not longer live with us. But I know they often speak about their sister, we visit her grave all together once a month. I go there every day. So I can understand that it might be too much for my husband. But I never force him to do anything.

Some comments are really cruel. I perfectly know that talking about her won't make her "less dead".

Gently op, the conversation may have moved on to ages and then what they are doing for work etc. It's not a leap to imagine that they would have wanted more information about what your children are doing.

I totally understand your feeling, I don't think there was a good way for it to be handled, you may have felt just as awful had he got into the situation where he mentioned her and then had to mention her death.

Its easy to say that you should have had a discussion rather than a confrontation, because its done now. A conversation about managing expectations in public and what to say would be a good way forward, you both have to listen and adapt if it's going to work because this will happen again unfortunately.

123ZYX · 15/11/2021 21:34

Where is everyone getting that I wanted him to tell his coworkers about your daughter's death ???! I never ever said that. Stop. All I said is that I would have preferred if he said that he had 4 children. How does that transforms to " He doesn't want to discuss his daughter's death front of XY AND Z" ?

You DH will be working with these people. At some point, if he had mentioned your DD, someone will ask about her while he's at work. Then he'd be faced with explaining that she'd died at a time he wasn't prepared for it. He was just trying to protect himself from a conversation he didn't feel prepared to have.

Hope478 · 15/11/2021 21:33

@LaGauchiste

Where is everyone getting that I wanted him to tell his coworkers about your daughter's death ???! I never ever said that. Stop. All I said is that I would have preferred if he said that he had 4 children. How does that transforms to " He doesn't want to discuss his daughter's death front of XY AND Z" ?

First of all, when I confronted him. I was crying and did ask him why he said that. As I said before, had he said he didn't want to discuss it. I would have respected it. I was crying, and he was angry. My husband never really talks about his feeling. I am always the one pushing for discussion. My 3 sons are adults and do not longer live with us. But I know they often speak about their sister, we visit her grave all together once a month. I go there every day. So I can understand that it might be too much for my husband. But I never force him to do anything.

Some comments are really cruel. I perfectly know that talking about her won't make her "less dead".

It COULD turn into a conversation about your daughters death though, which is probably why he didn't mention her. He has three alive children that it isn't painful to speak about in conversation. You don't know how a conversation is going to go. I understand why he wouldn't say 'four', just in case.

I'm sorry you lost your daughter, I couldn't imagine x

NeverChange · 15/11/2021 21:28

OP, my hear goes out to you. Losing a child is difficult but it's even harder when a couple grieve differently.

You way is your way and his way is his way. Both are the best way for each of you but neither is better.

Please don't let grief destroy your relationship. Have either of you received bereavement counselling, perhaps it can help you both individually but also to see that each others way of dealing with it is not intended to hurt or distress the other.

LaGauchiste · 15/11/2021 21:28

Where is everyone getting that I wanted him to tell his coworkers about your daughter's death ???! I never ever said that. Stop. All I said is that I would have preferred if he said that he had 4 children. How does that transforms to " He doesn't want to discuss his daughter's death front of XY AND Z" ?

First of all, when I confronted him. I was crying and did ask him why he said that. As I said before, had he said he didn't want to discuss it. I would have respected it. I was crying, and he was angry. My husband never really talks about his feeling. I am always the one pushing for discussion. My 3 sons are adults and do not longer live with us. But I know they often speak about their sister, we visit her grave all together once a month. I go there every day. So I can understand that it might be too much for my husband. But I never force him to do anything.

Some comments are really cruel. I perfectly know that talking about her won't make her "less dead".

OP posts:
EvenRosesHaveThorns · 15/11/2021 21:26

I'm sorry. Maybe he didn't want to mention it in a blasé way to a stranger when it runs so much deeper for you both

ThorsLeftNut · 15/11/2021 21:22

I feel like YABU for the initial situation, but YANBU to be upset and angry with him about his follow up comments after the fact.
In a private conversation those are quite awful things to say, even if your grieving processes are completely different.

Tailendofsummer · 15/11/2021 21:22

But @ballsdeep plenty of people have said exactly that - they had a mum or a brother or a child or a husband but they don't have them anymore, they lost them.
You're responding like saying that means to my didn't matter! I don't understand that at all. It hurts because you had them and you lost them.

AveryGoodlay · 15/11/2021 21:16

I never wanted him to explain anything. A simple " I have 4 kids" would have been more than enough. It isn't enough for some people though. When I can't face the questions I sometimes say I have four children. At other times I say I have three. At other times I say "four, three surviving". Sometimes I just can't face the pain of the questions, or even the thought of the questions.

I'd say neither of you are being unreasonable. But you both need to communicate in order to move past the argument and understand how each other feels. Then you can move forward together.

ballsdeep · 15/11/2021 21:14

@SoniaFouler

Oh wow. I can understand why you’re upset. YANBU but he is also right tbh.
He's right to say they don't have a diaghter anymore??? Because she died. What a terrible way to think
saraclara · 15/11/2021 21:14

He said that those people didn’t matter enough to share our precious girl with. He neither needed their acknowledgment or their sympathy, because with that he runs the risk of being hurt or angered

Perfectly put by him.

OP, I can't help but feel that It could be your reaction over the last couple of days that's driven him to send that horrible message.

You simply won't let go and you're threatening divorce. You've left home. Clearly you have not accepted anything that he had said to explain why he did what he did (and which many many people have explained is a totally reasonable way to approach grief) and give just got more and more angry.

I hate the way that even mentioning that I'm widowed derails conversations and leads to awkward exchanges. It must be many times worse to been pushed into mentioning that you had a child that died. I completely understand why he took steps to avoid that with random new work colleagues in a pub setting.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 15/11/2021 21:12

@Hairobsessed123

Big hugs op ! I totally understand and your husband is in the wrong and very insensitive! I lost my brother I still have a brother thou he’s passed I would never ever say I didn’t have a brother same if it was your mum dad sister she is your daughter but she is no longer with u only in your heart ❤️ xx
He really isn't insensitive to not mention her.

She is his daughter too and he is allowed to make decisions about who he feels able to talk to as well.

These are his colleagues and he really should be able to decide how much they know about his life as its him that will have to deal with them at work.

Bobsyer · 15/11/2021 21:09

I'm really and truly sorry for your loss @LaGauchiste, I can't imagine your pain.

"had he not been laughing then sending me texts " X She is dead, get over it[...] You need to stop making it a big deal[...] don't ruin our marriage just because you can't accept the truth."

Is this really how it played out? Or how it made you feel? I find it hard to understand that a man could be this unfeeling but the marriage is otherwise ok? Laughing at your response (which is how it reads to me) is sociopathic.

I don't think you're wrong to want to mention her as your 4th child; I don't think your husband is wrong not to.

Flowers
Holdingontonothing · 15/11/2021 21:09

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

Do you think it was ok for him to repeatedly tell her to get over it? They lost an adult child two years ago. I don’t think I’d ever get over that

It’s more likely that he meant get over what happened in the pub- that make more sense in the context of repeatedly telling her that he loves her - something all the PPs slagging him off are glossing over because god forbid we see any man in a positive light when it’s so much more satisfying to stir up the pain of a recently bereaved couple.

This was my thoughts too.
Londontown12 · 15/11/2021 21:01

Big hugs op ! I totally understand and your husband is in the wrong and very insensitive!
I lost my brother I still have a brother thou he’s passed I would never ever say I didn’t have a brother same if it was your mum dad sister she is your daughter but she is no longer with u only in your heart ❤️ xx

KitKat1985 · 15/11/2021 20:55

I can see why you are upset but I suspect he just didn't want to have that conversation at that moment with people he presumably didn't know that well (I'm assuming that since they were asking about his family and obviously didn't already know).

However I can understand why him messaging you saying you need to get over her death has made you angry.

I think you need to meet in person and discuss it really.

GatoradeMeBitch · 15/11/2021 20:55

I can't imagine how hurtful that must have been, and your reaction is very understandable. I'm assuming he's grieving for his daughter too, unless there's some backstory we don't know about. But losing her only two years ago must still feel brand new. It's only natural you'd be shocked by his behaviour.

Saying "people grieve differently" is very trite, but is it possible that he needs to feel like he is "over it" to be able to function in life? I know people who have lost loved ones who need to talk about them as though they are still with us, and others who can't stand to talk about them at all because it's too painful.

Maybe you'd benefit from (separate) grief counselling, so that you can see his viewpoint and he can see yours? Unless there's more to it.

But what you should not do is let someone tell you how you should feel. I notice a lot of commenters telling you to respect his view, but perhaps they need to remember you're a human being with feelings too.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 15/11/2021 20:41

Do you think it was ok for him to repeatedly tell her to get over it? They lost an adult child two years ago. I don’t think I’d ever get over that

It’s more likely that he meant get over what happened in the pub- that make more sense in the context of repeatedly telling her that he loves her - something all the PPs slagging him off are glossing over because god forbid we see any man in a positive light when it’s so much more satisfying to stir up the pain of a recently bereaved couple.

SnoopyLights · 15/11/2021 20:37

OP I am so sorry for your loss.

I have lost two children, and I have one living son. I've been in the position of being asked do you have children. If I don't feel that I can go into things, I usually say "We have a son who is X years old" and the conversation goes from there.

Sometimes someone will push "did you only want one" or "do you have any more" and at that point I will usually say "we had two more before him but we lost them."

My husband and I didn't grieve in the same way and he has struggled with the loss in ways that I haven't, and vice versa. But the one thing neither of us has ever done or ever tolerated is being told to "get over" or "forget" or "move on" from our losses, and we've never said those things to each other.

You have four children. That doesn't change. I was a mother as soon as I gave birth to our first child and I stayed a mother even though he died. I will always have three children.

People here who are saying they have lost their parents or their spouse, they might not say they have parents or are married now, but would they say they never had parents or were never married?

I don't think AIBU is the right place for this thread OP, and I'm sorry you've had some of the replies that you have. I think it sounds like you could both do with some sort of grief counselling (separately) to help you process what has just happened and the ways you have both dealt with your loss and the situation in the pub.

Corcory · 15/11/2021 20:35

I've been in this type of situation but not because a child of our's has passed away, and I have to say I'm more with your DH in this scenario given these are new work colleagues.
I am a step mother of 2 and the adoptive mother of two with special needs, who's birth mother subsequently took her own life. My brother was killed in an accident at 30 and I have relatives who took their own lives. None of these things would I want to necessarily discuss with new acquaintances so I tend to brush over them. It keeps the conversation light, many people have no idea how to react at all.
My Bil bust out laughing when I told him my cousin had taken his own life by jumping off a bridge! So no I very rarely discuss such things with anyone other than close friends.

Northernparent68 · 15/11/2021 20:32

As kite22 says, he have said or meant get over the fact I said it and not get over the fact your daughter died.

When he laughed in the pub that could have been nerves.

521Jeanie · 15/11/2021 20:30

Very probably he didn't want to talk about your daughter because it's upsetting for him, and not something he wants to have to go into with near-strangers (also would be very embarrassing for them). Just a different way of dealing with an awful loss.

Helenahandbasketbing · 15/11/2021 20:26

@PoppyMonth

I think his response is completely logical.

You are entitled to phrase it your way - but he is entitled to his way too.

Do you think it was ok for him to repeatedly tell her to get over it? They lost an adult child two years ago. I don’t think I’d ever get over that.