Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why France is being blamed for allowing migrants to cross the English channel to uk?

233 replies

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:14

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

OP posts:
EvenRosesHaveThorns · 15/11/2021 15:26

France is a safe country..but they don't fancy the economic cost of hosting thousands of extra people,.so cast a blind eye while pocketing a tidy sum.

thereisonlyoneofme · 15/11/2021 15:24

The idea that we could process asylum in Rwanda or similar. How do you think we would get the refugees there. We cant even manage to deport the ones that have been refused . The Human Rights people would be apoplectic.

thereisonlyoneofme · 15/11/2021 15:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 15:21

Yes! And that applies to every country back up the line @MRex

France, Italy, all across mainlaind Europe.

The UK has the geographic disadvanatages of being an island and the furthest you can go West! So it becomes more our problem than not at some point.

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 15:20

@Wackaday

I think that the UK has a responsibility to do their fair share in helping asylum seekers who have come from desperate situations. Obviously no one wants people to risk their lives crossing seas in difficult conditions. I am quite sure that France could do more to prevent it, but it is not in their interests to do so and their commitment to do this will never be there.

OP posts:
MRex · 15/11/2021 15:17

in reality it is not in their interests to police the France/UK border effectively
Yes it is in their interests; criminals use the route, criminals create issues by running the boats, and belief in the ability to cross leads to more migrants crossing France with the additional support and issues that entails for the French. Individual border guards might not perceive the wider picture (or might be paid to turn to the side), but it suits the French government nationally and locally to stop this. Sometimes it is used as a political pawn and the accountability for how the money is spent could be argued, but if the French could easily stop it then they would.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 15:17

These are all very valid points. I am therefore wondering why the UK government doesn't police the UK border directly instead of paying the French to do this. I'm not really understanding why policing of the border must be down to France.

Because we are an island

Because the rules are that each country returns refugees back over the nearest border

Because France does not police the border into the UK, but is quite good about slamming doors shut when anyone here suggests they do what they are legally obliged to, let alone what they aggreed to be paid for.

You must remember the horrendous 'camps' at Calais? Fucking awful places but here the media and bleeding hearts whinged about the 'concentration camp/prisons' refugees are kept in here in the UK.

And now we have the idea of 'offshore' camps, e.g. Rwanda!!!

It's been the same throught out history. The UK is the last outpost of the West of Europe. Anyone fleeing stops here cos the next step is too big.

Tal45 · 15/11/2021 15:17

Because France should be processing them when they arrive there - but they'd rather let them take their chances and possibly drown trying to get to England.

ChippyChipper · 15/11/2021 15:13

However, I also feel that it is simplistic to blame France for "allowing" asylum seekers to reach the UK by boat, when in reality it is not in their interests to police the France/UK border effectively.

They are coming from France. France allowed them into entry into their country as they elected to have no borders. They should be the ones dealing with them.

Kendodd · 15/11/2021 15:12

TBH I'm amazed that we (the rich world as a whole) don't see a lot more of this sort of determined migration. They have the internet, they see the disparity of wealth (or a curated view of it) even setting aside people fleeing ISIS or the Taliban and thinking of the people just wanting a better life, who can blame them rocking up wanting their fair share of the worlds riches. Probably the best (but hardest) way to end this sort of migration is to make a fairer world for people.

Wackaday · 15/11/2021 15:05

@Rebbecia1234

"These are all very valid points. I am therefore wondering why the UK government doesn't police the UK border directly instead of paying the French to do this. I'm not really understanding why policing of the border must be down to France."

Because once the boats have left France they are on their way to the UK, you can't really turn them back and tell them to go back to France..
It's also a very dangerous route with a high death risk, you want to stop the departure from France - not have an army of border control enforcers at the UK coast refusing to let a beat up rubber dingy full of desperate migrants through. It's a terrible situation for these people, but they will risk their life to flee and it's irresponsible to not stop this journey from starting in the first place and that is down to France to manage the borders well enough so they don't have a chance to make the trip in the first place.

OP, I'm not sure why you think France shouldn't help here?

Ozanj · 15/11/2021 15:00

It’s not just asylum seekers coming in this way. Criminals do it too.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 14:58

I agree that I do have a simplistic view of the issues. However, I also feel that it is simplistic to blame France for "allowing" asylum seekers to reach the UK by boat, when in reality it is not in their interests to police the France/UK border effectively.

But it's fine to imagine sneering at the Brits for the exact same imagined behaviour if the migrants were heading to Ireland?

Of course it's logical for France to ship as many over as they can so it's "our problem" - but in practice both countries need a role in dealing with the legal and humanitarian issues. If, for example, France could be more effective at preventing people leaving their shores in unsuitable vessels for a risky crossing of one of the world's busiest shipping lanes, they'd be helping to prevent the inevitable tragedy we all know is coming.
People are entitled to ask why France can't be more effective - and why in particular they are apparently powerless to enforce some of their own immigration laws - and people are entitled to ask if we're getting value for money for the payments we are making to France.

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:50

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

These are all very valid points. I am therefore wondering why the UK government doesn't police the UK border directly instead of paying the French to do this. I'm not really understanding why policing of the border must be down to France. It's not "all down to France". We have a shared problem with France in that there are numbers of people who wish to come here and France is the last place on their mainland journey.

As others have said, we pay France to help us, and as an encouragement to take action to prevent people leaving the French coast in small overloaded unsuitable boats.

I am therefore wondering why the UK government doesn't police the UK border directly
It does - but once boats are in the channel they cannot be easily turned back to France - it's risky for everyone concerned, most notably of course, the people heading to the UK.
Once people arrive here they cannot be simply returned to France - the French will not accept them and they generally have destroyed any identity documents they have by then.

Of course we have obligations to help people fleeing persecution - but we have to try to prevent a steady large flow across the channel for the safety of everyone - not least the people in the boats.

OP you seem to have a very simplistic view of the issues.

I agree that I do have a simplistic view of the issues. However, I also feel that it is simplistic to blame France for "allowing" asylum seekers to reach the UK by boat, when in reality it is not in their interests to police the France/UK border effectively.
OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 14:43

These are all very valid points. I am therefore wondering why the UK government doesn't police the UK border directly instead of paying the French to do this. I'm not really understanding why policing of the border must be down to France.
It's not "all down to France". We have a shared problem with France in that there are numbers of people who wish to come here and France is the last place on their mainland journey.

As others have said, we pay France to help us, and as an encouragement to take action to prevent people leaving the French coast in small overloaded unsuitable boats.

I am therefore wondering why the UK government doesn't police the UK border directly
It does - but once boats are in the channel they cannot be easily turned back to France - it's risky for everyone concerned, most notably of course, the people heading to the UK.
Once people arrive here they cannot be simply returned to France - the French will not accept them and they generally have destroyed any identity documents they have by then.

Of course we have obligations to help people fleeing persecution - but we have to try to prevent a steady large flow across the channel for the safety of everyone - not least the people in the boats.

OP you seem to have a very simplistic view of the issues.

TheVeryDoggyDogperson · 15/11/2021 14:42

If it were ever proposed that the asylum process should be changed so that anyone who wished to come here should have to endure an obstacle course in order to ensure that only the fittest, most resourceful and most ruthless would be able to get here in order to request asylum, then people would rightly ask what on earth would happen to the most vulnerable, the women and the children.

Those who propose that we should simply accept anybody who has made it to the channel is proposing exactly this.

thereisonlyoneofme · 15/11/2021 14:39

Well over a 1000 got over this weekend, surely the French must have noticed ! Beginning to feel as if we are being invaded here in Kent.
Surely its not beyond the French authorities capabilities to find out where the boats are being sourced. However suppose its in their interests to move the people on out of France.

supremelybaffled · 15/11/2021 14:39

The French are doing everything they can to look the other way while the migrants leave their shores. They don't want the migrants to stay in France, they are thrilled to see the back of them.

MRex · 15/11/2021 14:37

@Rebbecia1234 - the British border force can't patrol French beaches, make arrests etc; all that would be able to do is shoo boats back into French water. At which point, presumably if they weren't being paid then the French would pop them back into British waters again.

CloudPop · 15/11/2021 14:33

@AnneLovesGilbert

The U.K. pays France a shit load of money to stop them. If they don’t want to they could stop accepting the cash.
What do you expect them to do? Build a wall along the entire coast line ? I don't think it is fair to assume they are doing nothing !
Ozanj · 15/11/2021 14:32

The problem is caused by European countries like France and Italy not taking care of refugees, so they don’t want to register there & try their luck elsewhere. The UK will always be a popular choice as English is spoken so widely. But actually Turkey (and to a lesser extent Egypt and Morocco) is the country that not only accepts the most refugees, it is also the country where most refugees register to stay, so don’t believe the propaganda. Europe doesn’t accept nearly as many refugees as it should.

CloudPop · 15/11/2021 14:31

@tanstaafl

Putting aside the human tragedy for a moment, paying France millions (£53 million for the last payment?) is like paying a double glazing company money to stop people throwing stones at your windows.
Well put.
CloudPop · 15/11/2021 14:31

I think the term was "taking back control of our borders"

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:31

@tanstaafl

Putting aside the human tragedy for a moment, paying France millions (£53 million for the last payment?) is like paying a double glazing company money to stop people throwing stones at your windows.
Exactly.
OP posts:
CloudPop · 15/11/2021 14:30

Also bear in mind coming to the UK is now way more attractive - no longer an EU member so the Dublin agreement is no longer valid in the UK. So once the migrants are here, they are here to stay.

Swipe left for the next trending thread