Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why France is being blamed for allowing migrants to cross the English channel to uk?

233 replies

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:14

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

OP posts:
Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 16:58

@Chloemol

I havent read all your posts as the first shows you don’t understand

The agreement is asylum seekers are looked after by the first country they arrive at, so France, or another European country, not that they are then shoved across the North Sea to us

France however doesn’t want them, therefore doesn’t deal with them as they should, allows them and economic refugees to set up camps in Calais

As there are no borders in the EU no one is stopping them leaving whatever country they arrived at to travel to France and then onto us.

They should automatically be sent back to France, who can send them back to whatever country they arrived at so they can be dealt with there

@Chloemol

Seems like you were wrong with the information in your post. Maybe you should have read the full thread after all!

OP posts:
Fairylights25 · 15/11/2021 16:54

France are being paid millions and millions to police the border. They have been filmed repeatedly standing around watching the boats launch from the beaches. The UK have a team in Calais, but obviously we can not police the border INSIDE another country.

France are using migrants (not unlike other European countries I might add looking at you Belarus) to barter over fishing rights. The fact that actual human beings, children and babies are drowning daily does not seem to faze them. Over the last few months France have become a hostile nation towards the UK, cranked up considerably now ready for the election and Macron is fighting for his political life. Expect things to get worse not better. I hope you have your Christmas shopping stocked up because for sure that is coming next in time for Christmas.

What we are seeing now is the true colours of our 'allies' and neighbours the French, threatening to cut off electricity, blockade the channel tunnel and the ports. What this really tells us is that we they were very happy when we footing the bill to the tune of tens of billions every year so their agricultural department could receive huge EU handouts, but now that easy money has run dry they will find another way via demanding and blackmailing us over people trafficking.

My French friends are embarrassed and mortified, and now also pretty terrified at the prospect of having their first far right President in the shape of Monsieur Zemmour.

Dontbeamugallyourlifesucker · 15/11/2021 16:54

I sail and have a boat! The English Channel UK is the worst stretch of water I would want to be at the moment November/December!

theleafandnotthetree · 15/11/2021 16:52

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

Yes! And that applies to every country back up the line *@MRex*

France, Italy, all across mainlaind Europe.

The UK has the geographic disadvanatages of being an island and the furthest you can go West! So it becomes more our problem than not at some point.

There's this place called Ireland to the west of Britain. Or maybe you consider it part of Britain? Hmm
ImJustADaddy · 15/11/2021 16:49

If they are crossing from France to UK then they are not seeking asylum because they are perfectly safe in France.

They are not asylum seekers, but rather they are financial migrants

Chloemol · 15/11/2021 16:46

I havent read all your posts as the first shows you don’t understand

The agreement is asylum seekers are looked after by the first country they arrive at, so France, or another European country, not that they are then shoved across the North Sea to us

France however doesn’t want them, therefore doesn’t deal with them as they should, allows them and economic refugees to set up camps in Calais

As there are no borders in the EU no one is stopping them leaving whatever country they arrived at to travel to France and then onto us.

They should automatically be sent back to France, who can send them back to whatever country they arrived at so they can be dealt with there

RobotValkyrie · 15/11/2021 16:40

"1) There are official routes for asylum seekers to be placed; they are supposed to register for asylum in the first safe country rather than continue travelling (a sort of queue jumping argument; you can argue how many spaces there should be but systems do exist to take in asylum seekers)"

People have pointed this out already, but worth repeating...
THIS IS NOT TRUE!
It used to be true when the UK was in the EU (because of the Dublin regulations), but since Brexit, the UK has made itself even more of a magnet for asylum seekers, since it can no longer legally return people who managed to cross the Channel. A bit of an own goal, eh?

Also note: these people crossing the Channel do so because they really want to.
E.g. they have family here already. Some (not all) have in fact very legitimate cases to apply for asylum in the UK specifically. But in practice, there is currently no mechanism to do so, unless they manage to cross the Channel. The impossibility for genuine refugees (including children trying to reunite with relatives) to apply from abroad creates this horrendous situation.
Again, there was mechanisms to deal with this before Brexit, but not anymore...

notimagain · 15/11/2021 16:37

…and with regard to the French not stopping them:

france3-regions.francetvinfo.fr/occitanie/pyrenees-orientales/temoignage-pyrenees-orientales-entre-cerbere-et-le-perthus-l-afflux-de-migrants-inquiete-2313985.html

We’re well down south and it’s not unusual to hear of groups being rounded up either at road side checks or even being found (sadly sometimes dead) in the mountains having tried to walk across from Spain….

I don’t know WTF the answer is but the idea that nothing is done on the French side to try and stop the flow is erroneous.

notimagain · 15/11/2021 16:32

@SantaClausIsMyHero

But they’re not actually asylum seekers any more are they? They’re fleeing from France, not a war torn country where they’ll be starved and murdered? I have no issues at all with true asylum seekers, but these people are being sent from France, a country that receives a lot of money to help them properly, not let them board boats and risk their lives further by travelling here?
The problem some migrants have is the French asylum process, or even just gaining the right to permanent residency for any reason, is pretty robust…..it’s a fine tooth comb affair - fail the process and you are deported/denied residency….even a few Brits have fallen foul of that recently.

Rightly or wrongly, for whatever reason, many migrants seem to think the best thing to do is to try and get through France undetected, get onto a boat and then hopefully take their chances with the UK system

Oblomov21 · 15/11/2021 16:28

It's not in the French's interest you stop them. Why would they want to? They don't.

FatCatThinCat · 15/11/2021 16:23

@AssemblySquare

The asylum rules and the Geneva Convention are absolutely clear on that a person seeking asylum is expected to do so in the first safe country. Geography means that a little island off the north coast of Europe is not the first safe Geneva convention country from pretty much anywhere!

However, I do think anyone who is willing to travel across the Channel in a tiny little boat must be absolutely desperate! For that reason alone I think many are being trafficked/exploited.

This is incorrect. International rules allow refugees to claim asylum in ANY safe country. 'First safe country' is an EU rule which no longer applies to the UK.
notimagain · 15/11/2021 16:22

@Wackaday

It's also a very dangerous route with a high death risk,

It is, and it catches a few on the mainland before they get anywhere near the channel…this lot (happened near us) were possibly either trying to get to Paris to disappear or perhaps further north.

france3-regions.francetvinfo.fr/nouvelle-aquitaine/pyrenees-atlantiques/accident-de-train-a-saint-jean-de-luz-les-migrants-etaient-endormis-sur-la-voie-ferree-2294356.html

It’s believed a lot of migrants are taking to walking the railways rather than by road because they fear police checks (which do happen).

thereisonlyoneofme · 15/11/2021 16:15

sorry thats a ridiculous thing to say.Are you suggesting they just hand over their properties

SantaClausIsMyHero · 15/11/2021 16:15

But they’re not actually asylum seekers any more are they? They’re fleeing from France, not a war torn country where they’ll be starved and murdered? I have no issues at all with true asylum seekers, but these people are being sent from France, a country that receives a lot of money to help them properly, not let them board boats and risk their lives further by travelling here?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 16:14

@notimagain

FWIW France has well over 300,000 registered refugees….we’re in southern France and there are several centers near us, and has a dedicated department in the local Prefecture that handles applications from those who literally walk in through their doors.

Problem for the UK appears to be there’s a large number who clandestinely push north through France to the Channel because they really don’t want to get “caught” in the French system - they really want to get to the UK…

One POV on what goes on up north ..

www.lemonde.fr/international/article/2021/10/10/immigration-au-royaume-uni-plus-d-un-millier-de-migrants-tentant-de-traverser-la-manche-secourus-en-deux-jours_6097825_3210.html

Despite the impression given in some parts of the MSM the French authorities do intercept migrants either on the beach and off shore but numbers have been such that some will make to or close to the UK side…. Without putting the whole of the Gendarmerie National on the beaches 24/7/365 I’m not sure what the answer is.

The standard comment here is a wish that somehow the UK could reduce the “pull”, that might make it easier for authorities on both side of the Channel. It’s certainly has always appeared to us that it’s harder to stay below the radar in France than it is in the UK…(e.g. access to work is much more difficult without national qualifications, access to healthcare is more regulated at the point of delivery)…

Great insights.

Most of the actions suggested to reduce the pull would be expensive or disruptive, or both though. We are so used to things being as they are and there doesn't seem to be any appetite for major (and expensive) changes.

The French laws on "working on the black" (or more correctly on employing people) are much tougher than ours - but the major difference is in having anyone prepared and resourced to enforce them.

Samcro · 15/11/2021 16:13

@aarrgghhhhh yep
the BBC have been doing a thing about people living in terrible conditions in rental and SH. terrible conditions.
surely that also has to be fixed.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 16:13

@daimbarsatemydogsbone Oh! Don't apologise. I'll take it on board and be more careful how I phrase things. Smile

aarrgghhhhh · 15/11/2021 16:08

Samcro

thereisonlyoneofme
I just wonder how we are expected to find accommodation for all these people. I understand that its hard to find homes for the Afghan refugees that came here legally recently. Not to mention the people who already live here that are homeless and not being put up in hotels I dont think

I wonder that too

Well if the liberal elite all gave up their 2nd homes, there might be enough.

notimagain · 15/11/2021 16:05

FWIW France has well over 300,000 registered refugees….we’re in southern France and there are several centers near us, and has a dedicated department in the local Prefecture that handles applications from those who literally walk in through their doors.

Problem for the UK appears to be there’s a large number who clandestinely push north through France to the Channel because they really don’t want to get “caught” in the French system - they really want to get to the UK…

One POV on what goes on up north ..

www.lemonde.fr/international/article/2021/10/10/immigration-au-royaume-uni-plus-d-un-millier-de-migrants-tentant-de-traverser-la-manche-secourus-en-deux-jours_6097825_3210.html

Despite the impression given in some parts of the MSM the French authorities do intercept migrants either on the beach and off shore but numbers have been such that some will make to or close to the UK side…. Without putting the whole of the Gendarmerie National on the beaches 24/7/365 I’m not sure what the answer is.

The standard comment here is a wish that somehow the UK could reduce the “pull”, that might make it easier for authorities on both side of the Channel. It’s certainly has always appeared to us that it’s harder to stay below the radar in France than it is in the UK…(e.g. access to work is much more difficult without national qualifications, access to healthcare is more regulated at the point of delivery)…

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 16:03

Also, as the UK does not have an ID card system it is far easier to get work in the black economy than it is in France.
That's actually not due to ID cards - it's due to enforcement and much more stringent penalties in France and many other European countries.

Samcro · 15/11/2021 16:02

@thereisonlyoneofme

I just wonder how we are expected to find accommodation for all these people. I understand that its hard to find homes for the Afghan refugees that came here legally recently. Not to mention the people who already live here that are homeless and not being put up in hotels I dont think.
i wonder that too
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 15:58

[quote HoardingSamphireSaurus]@daimbarsatemydogsbone sorry?

This is the problem with these issues, sooner or later someone gets called a racist or a xenophobe and then any reasoned debate is over. Did it read as though I was being racist or calling anyone xenophobic?

As in my previous post (and no, I don't check usernames so wouldn't expect you to either) I was pointing out the same as you, the UK is, all the shouting nothwithstanding, much more tolerant than many other places.[/quote]
Fair enough - it was the reference to lies and fearmongering I was talking about. It's hard to distinguish lies and fearmongering from reality when we don't have reliable information. I apologise.

Brainwave89 · 15/11/2021 15:58

In many cases migrant boats will refuse help in French waters so that they are picked up in UK waters- and then have to be landed in the UK. In some cases migrants threaten to jump into the water, or throw children to prevent being boarded before they are in UK waters. In international law there is no requirement for an asylum seeker to seek asylum in the first country they come to. Many do speak English, have UK based relatives and therefore head to the UK. Also, as the UK does not have an ID card system it is far easier to get work in the black economy than it is in France. Once here, the UK has an extremely poor record of removal, so most of the people currently landing in Kent will still be with us in ten years time irrespective of having a well founded fear of persecution. There is no easy solution. The UK has no real appetite to turn boats back (some will sink if this is done), and it has no appetite to set up a remote processing area (for example an internment camp on a remote island) whilst claims are considered. The UK could agree unilaterally to return migrants landing to France, but this is unlikely.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 15:55

@Iflyaway

I assume that UK is seen as a better destination for asylum speakers who speak English or already have relatives here

Also, UK doesn't have ID cards that need to be shown to get any kind of government or healthcare help here in my country.

The great thing is I can also use it to traverse borders within the EU and including Morocco, Turkey, Switzerland, Norway etc.
It's the size of a credit card.

I can see the advantages of that - but introducing such a system here would be massively expensive and complex now we've done without one for so long.
ChippyChipper · 15/11/2021 15:55

By the way, France grants about double the number of people a year asylum than the UK does. The UK should take more.

This stupid argument is constantly trotted out.

We have almost the same population as France but less than half the land mass.