Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why France is being blamed for allowing migrants to cross the English channel to uk?

233 replies

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:14

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

OP posts:
DroopyClematis · 15/11/2021 19:57

To be fair, migrants are asked what their destination is.
If they say UK then they will be passed onto UK and France, realistically shouldn't stop them.
If migrants say that they have family here then France will let them pass.

The fact that the UK has a paltry system in place to get migrants is the government's fault, not the migrants' fault.

That we have a benefit system that is relatively easy to access ( apart from UK citizens) means that the UK is a desirable place to settle.

Before anyone asks, my parents were not born in UK.

DeepaBeesKit · 15/11/2021 19:57

1) There are official routes for asylum seekers to be placed; they are supposed to register for asylum in the first safe country rather than continue travelling (a sort of queue jumping argument; you can argue how many spaces there should be but systems do exist to take in asylum seekers)
2) The boats are run by criminal organisations of people traffickers and the French border force are paid by the UK government to stop them operating
3) It's incredibly unsafe for individuals to cross with all the shipping and in unsafe overcrowded boats; lots of people have drowned trying to make the crossing, including children, that is why it should not be encouraged as a route.

Mrex for the win.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 15/11/2021 19:56

It's not a thread about Ireland, either part of it. And I don't see why I need to apologise for not giving a monkey's about soemthing that the thread isn't about.

Obviously you don't. But your argument tends to be stronger if it's factually correct...

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 19:56

@ShinyHappyPoster

It really depends whether your concern is the health and safety of refugees or putting blame on England rather than France. France is failing refugees. Lots of organisations working on the ground with refugees have pointed out that the French system has obvious gaps that enable people traffickers and criminal gangs to exploit refugees and put them at risk. The English system is also too slow and too bureaucratic but one of the biggest points of risk for refugees is leaving France and crossing the Channel. England can't stop that. It has to be controlled in France. The problem is a global one, not just an European one. And there are definite failings across different countries. You should Google it OP . There are lots of articles and research papers available about it. Assuming that you are interested in the issues and not just wanting to start a bunfight on MN.
Careful now - your post is a bit measured and factual for AIBU :)
ShinyHappyPoster · 15/11/2021 19:54

It really depends whether your concern is the health and safety of refugees or putting blame on England rather than France.
France is failing refugees. Lots of organisations working on the ground with refugees have pointed out that the French system has obvious gaps that enable people traffickers and criminal gangs to exploit refugees and put them at risk.
The English system is also too slow and too bureaucratic but one of the biggest points of risk for refugees is leaving France and crossing the Channel. England can't stop that. It has to be controlled in France.
The problem is a global one, not just an European one. And there are definite failings across different countries. You should Google it OP . There are lots of articles and research papers available about it. Assuming that you are interested in the issues and not just wanting to start a bunfight on MN.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 15/11/2021 19:53

I don't know why we seem to have a continuing narrative that we should be more like France, Belgium etc

It's not necessarily that the UK should be like France etc but rather you can't have it both ways. A lack of regulation and enforcement of what is there and a lack of rigour in employment requirements will make the UK attractive to those who wish to take advantage of those circumstances. It's a statement of fact, rather than a judgement. There are benefits and disadvantages to both approaches.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 19:51

Basically, I am short tempered with the intorduction of "Oh but what about Ireland?"

It's not a thread about Ireland, either part of it. And I don't see why I need to apologise for not giving a monkey's about soemthing that the thread isn't about.

Start a thread about Ireland the English. I'll happily ignore it!

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 19:49

Earlier posts... not the one that was a response to something else being introduced.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 15/11/2021 19:47

@HoardingSamphireSaurus - sorry to hear about your arthritis. I suffer from it too and it's not fun.

And had you read me properly you would see that you are mistaken.

I did read you properly and I stand by my comment on the froth.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 19:44

@workwoes123

Gerard Darmanin (French interior minister) says that one of the main problems is that the UK makes itself so attractive to migrants - whether economic or refugees - that they actively want to get to the UK and they are not interested in stopping in France or any of the other countries that they pass through.

His point is that the UK has a massive illegal / informal economy, very lax enforcement of employment laws, and a health service that is free to all at the point of service. So migrants can work and receive medical care in a way that is not open to them in more tightly regulated countries. This is certainly true in France.

It's very hard to stop the flow of migrants from the east / south access points into Europe to the north of France: there are very few actively managed borders in the Schengen area.

The UK pays around £54M a year for this service. It's peanuts for the work that they are expecting to be done. What Darmanin is saying is that if the UK made itself less attractive to migrants by tightening up on the black economy / exploitation of migrants, and made access to the health / education / benefits systems more restricted, the driving force behind the migration would be reduced to a level that could be managed better.

Yeah - if only we were more tightly regulated like France.........er no thanks.

I am all for better enforcement than we have - but I can do without the crazy levels of French State intervention and regulation that make it so hard to get a start in any job. Some of my French colleagues over the years actually came here to escape it.

I don't know why we seem to have a continuing narrative that we should be more like France, Belgium etc

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 19:42

Yes, chronic arthritis does that to my typing.

And you could just stop with the personal insults.

And had you read me properly you would see that you are mistaken. But don't let that stop your fun!

Fairylights25 · 15/11/2021 19:41

It is up to the French to address their people smugglers, I (nor anyone else) should be having to tell them the obvious that people are dying due to their game playing. This has not been a big problem in the past, so it is obvious that a choice is being made to let people attempt the crossing and die in the process. France seem to be turning into Belarus.

workwoes123 · 15/11/2021 19:40

Gerard Darmanin (French interior minister) says that one of the main problems is that the UK makes itself so attractive to migrants - whether economic or refugees - that they actively want to get to the UK and they are not interested in stopping in France or any of the other countries that they pass through.

His point is that the UK has a massive illegal / informal economy, very lax enforcement of employment laws, and a health service that is free to all at the point of service. So migrants can work and receive medical care in a way that is not open to them in more tightly regulated countries. This is certainly true in France.

It's very hard to stop the flow of migrants from the east / south access points into Europe to the north of France: there are very few actively managed borders in the Schengen area.

The UK pays around £54M a year for this service. It's peanuts for the work that they are expecting to be done. What Darmanin is saying is that if the UK made itself less attractive to migrants by tightening up on the black economy / exploitation of migrants, and made access to the health / education / benefits systems more restricted, the driving force behind the migration would be reduced to a level that could be managed better.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 15/11/2021 19:38

@HoardingSamphireSaurus - the first two paragraphs of your last post are unintellible due to, what I assume are, typos. The rest is classic Daily Mail style xenophobic froth Grin

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/11/2021 19:36

France doesn’t want them, and they’re pissed off with the U.K. anyway, so regardless of how much they’re being paid, they’re hardly going to put themselves out too much to stop them.

Did anyone else see a recent Saving Lives At Sea, where the RNLI rescued 34 migrants packed into a dinghy in mid channel, with the engine packed up?
It was freezing, and most of them had totally inadequate clothing.

One of the lifeboat crew was in tears as he told how he said something like ‘OK mate?’ to a young boy migrant, who replied, ‘You my friend.’
It was very moving.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 19:34

Given the deletion.... no comment !!

Abhannmor · 15/11/2021 19:29

We'll just have to lump it then I guess. Seems you can't get on with anyone on either side of a watery gap. Grin

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 19:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 15/11/2021 19:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 15/11/2021 19:16

The British Isles is a contentious term that is used by the British, not the Irish, to describe the Islands.

You stated "the UK is the last outpost of the west of Europe" and "the UK has the geographic disadvantages of being an island and the furthest you can go west".

Firstly, the UK is not an island. Secondly, the discussion is about migrants/refugees arriving in the UK, not in these islands. If it was about them arriving in these islands, then it would be considerably more complex as the Dublin Rules apply to Ireland but don't apply to the UK. There are also different governments dealing with the issues and different laws in each jurisdiction.

As I said, can we retrun tot he subject of the thread rather than insist of centering anyine ekses politics?

To be honest anyone who feels the need to tytpoe that out, on a UK/British Isles focussed board might want to check why?

I am a fully functioning adult of a certain age. I am fully aware that we are ' a collection of islands' and that many areas have devolved governments and even that part of the British Isles are not in the UK. However on many threads, like many people, I will use "the UK" as a loose approximation of here, not the European mainland etc. And, to be honest, I couldn't care if some do find it offensive, I am British. I can't help it if you find that offensive.

We are an island nation, we are as far West as is possible to go before the big watery gap. That obviously includes both parts of the island of Ireland. Like it, lump it. I am not bothered!

ItsSnotFair · 15/11/2021 19:14

@notimagain thank you for your posts, I'm finding them really interesting
I live right where the boats come in to land so its very enlightening to hear it from another perspective and what France is doing

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 19:07

The reason many migrants can’t work in France, or find it very difficult to do so straight off the boat/train is not just language skills, it is that most jobs (possibly right through from serving in restaurants through to running a Government Department) require formal qualifications…so not only has the migrant got to brush up on language skills, they might also have to go through two or three years of Lycee pro or similar before getting anywhere near a day job. Compare and contrast with the UK …

I would have thought such a regime might be possible in the Uk and might well reduce some of the “pull”, and all of course something entirely in the gift of Westminster, not the EU or Macron.

So Westminster needs to make us more like France, and that'll stop the "pull"?

OchonAgusOchonOh · 15/11/2021 19:01

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

There's this place called Ireland to the west of Britain. Or maybe you consider it part of Britain?

Huh?

Are you looking to be insulted?

British Isles, if it make you feel happier!

The British Isles is a contentious term that is used by the British, not the Irish, to describe the Islands.

You stated "the UK is the last outpost of the west of Europe" and "the UK has the geographic disadvantages of being an island and the furthest you can go west".

Firstly, the UK is not an island. Secondly, the discussion is about migrants/refugees arriving in the UK, not in these islands. If it was about them arriving in these islands, then it would be considerably more complex as the Dublin Rules apply to Ireland but don't apply to the UK. There are also different governments dealing with the issues and different laws in each jurisdiction.

notimagain · 15/11/2021 19:00

I am sorry but things have turned ugly in France

Thing is they haven’t, though I do sense in the last few days, for reasons that passéth understanding (actually that’s wrong, they are perfectly understandable) some in the UK MSM have started to blame the EU,/Macron/France for everything from the next wave of Covid to the price of fuel…

The idea that the migrants' pigeon English is the reason why they can't work in France is quite frankly ridiculous when most countries run language courses for those that are resettling.

The reason many migrants can’t work in France, or find it very difficult to do so straight off the boat/train is not just language skills, it is that most jobs (possibly right through from serving in restaurants through to running a Government Department) require formal qualifications…so not only has the migrant got to brush up on language skills, they might also have to go through two or three years of Lycee pro or similar before getting anywhere near a day job. Compare and contrast with the UK …

I would have thought such a regime might be possible in the Uk and might well reduce some of the “pull”, and all of course something entirely in the gift of Westminster, not the EU or Macron.

Clavinova · 15/11/2021 18:58

since Brexit, the UK has made itself even more of a magnet for asylum seekers, since it can no longer legally return people who managed to cross the Channel. A bit of an own goal, eh?

According to this report in the House of Commons Library our success rate under the Dublin regulation was only 7% between 2015 and 2018;

How many incoming and outgoing transfers are there under Dublin III?
According to Home Office figures, between 2015 and 2018, 7,365 incoming requests were made to transfer people into the UK under the Dublin regulation, from which 2,365 people were transferred to the UK (some requests may still be pending).

This means that the UK accepted around 33% of requests. During the same period, the UK made 18,953 outgoing requests to transfer people to other Member States, from which 1,395 people were transferred abroad. This amounts to around 7% of outgoing requests by the UK resulting in a transfer.

In 2018, the UK received a total of 37,453 asylum applications, and made 5,510 outgoing transfer requests under Dublin III. Of these 5,510 requests, 209 migrants were transferred out of the UK under Dublin III, whilst 1,215 came in, making the UK a net recipient in 2018.

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/what-is-the-dublin-iii-regulation-will-it-be-affected-by-brexit/

Swipe left for the next trending thread