Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why France is being blamed for allowing migrants to cross the English channel to uk?

233 replies

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:14

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

OP posts:
notimagain · 15/11/2021 21:56

@Fairylights25

user the key point of the European Union was supposed to a friendly trading bloc, it has since morphed into a political superstate. It’s higher purpose hijacked long ago, but the point of the thread is about France’s disgraceful decision to continue to allow people smuggling in broad daylight, operating in plain sight knowing how many poor souls will lose their lives in one of the busiest choppiest shipping lanes in the world simply to score political points. It’s an outrage, and if you are not horrified by it then perhaps ask yourself why not? These are real people losing their lives every day.
Despite the frequent claims that the French are doing nothing that really isn’t the case…but when they do it can all very ugly and one issue appears to be that the minute the French authorities start taking robust action to dissuade the migrants from congregating in the embarkment areas there is kick back from charities/NGOs…..

www.rfi.fr/en/france/20211007-rights-group-reports-that-french-police-cause-misery-for-migrants-in-calais

www.infomigrants.net/en/post/33065/france-unpredictable-raids-target-migrants-in-calais

Fairylights25 · 15/11/2021 21:44

user the key point of the European Union was supposed to a friendly trading bloc, it has since morphed into a political superstate. It’s higher purpose hijacked long ago, but the point of the thread is about France’s disgraceful decision to continue to allow people smuggling in broad daylight, operating in plain sight knowing how many poor souls will lose their lives in one of the busiest choppiest shipping lanes in the world simply to score political points. It’s an outrage, and if you are not horrified by it then perhaps ask yourself why not? These are real people losing their lives every day.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 21:32

It’s quite funny reading further upthread all the grumbling about France becoming supposedly more hostile…..another POV is the UK has become the more belligerent party, typified by Lord Frost’s various antics and statements.

Neither country has anything to gain from our leaders acting like kids in a playground.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 21:27

[quote luckylavender]@daimbarsatemydogsbone - where do you get this rubbish from? The total population of Southall is c. 70,000[/quote]
It came from the Times of India

m.timesofindia.com/world/uk/Indian-faujis-faking-their-way-into-UK/articleshow/3247571.cms

I did caveat it because no-one can know the actual figures. Where is your 70k from?

notimagain · 15/11/2021 21:22

@OhWhyNot

There is an election next year it’s good for votes for the issue to look more like the UK problem

Don’t forget over a third voted for Le Pen

Too early to predict but Le Pen does seem to be on the wane as she shifts to a more centralist POV…..quite possible the hard right vote will get split by Zemmour.

foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/10/france-eric-zemmour-president-election/

It’s quite funny reading further upthread all the grumbling about France becoming supposedly more hostile…..another POV is the UK has become the more belligerent party, typified by Lord Frost’s various antics and statements.

frumpety · 15/11/2021 21:17

It would be interesting to see the figures for the migrants prevented from travelling across the Channel in France ?
There are very few news stories about it over here, which of course doesn't mean the French aren't doing their best, there is a lot of coast to cover after all, on both sides of the Channel.

DeeCeeCherry · 15/11/2021 21:12

MaskingForIt
YANBU. If the migrants were carrying on through Britain to Ireland we’d be pumping their life jackets up and giving them sandwiches, not stopping them

Exactly.

& its not illegal for them to claim asylum in the UK either; refugees can claim asylum wherever they want, never mind what anyone else thinks theyre "supposed" to do.

I go to France quite a bit. Its changed so much in recent years. Last time I was in Paris I ate at a cafe, left a little food on my plate and was so shocked to see people swarming from over the road, fighting for leftover food. They were desperate.

Cafe owner shooed them away. Said theyre asylum seekers and he wants to help them but cant allow them to hang around as it puts other customers off.

I wouldnt want to claim asylum there either.

This country would collapse without foreigners, asylum seekers are no more a burden than Amazon et al tax dodgers taking the piss and not paying their dues.

Leave them alone.

OhWhyNot · 15/11/2021 21:11

There is an election next year it’s good for votes for the issue to look more like the UK problem

Don’t forget over a third voted for Le Pen

User135644 · 15/11/2021 20:53

@CorrBlimeyGG

They are not asylum seekers, but rather they are financial migrants

Over 60% are, after the arduous application process, accepted as asylum seekers. Categorical proof that you're actually wrong.

Is that before or after all the human rights lawyers get involved? They appeal for years when actually refused and liberal/soft judges are bamboozled by hotshot lawyers.
User135644 · 15/11/2021 20:48

@Fairylights25

France are being paid millions and millions to police the border. They have been filmed repeatedly standing around watching the boats launch from the beaches. The UK have a team in Calais, but obviously we can not police the border INSIDE another country.

France are using migrants (not unlike other European countries I might add looking at you Belarus) to barter over fishing rights. The fact that actual human beings, children and babies are drowning daily does not seem to faze them. Over the last few months France have become a hostile nation towards the UK, cranked up considerably now ready for the election and Macron is fighting for his political life. Expect things to get worse not better. I hope you have your Christmas shopping stocked up because for sure that is coming next in time for Christmas.

What we are seeing now is the true colours of our 'allies' and neighbours the French, threatening to cut off electricity, blockade the channel tunnel and the ports. What this really tells us is that we they were very happy when we footing the bill to the tune of tens of billions every year so their agricultural department could receive huge EU handouts, but now that easy money has run dry they will find another way via demanding and blackmailing us over people trafficking.

My French friends are embarrassed and mortified, and now also pretty terrified at the prospect of having their first far right President in the shape of Monsieur Zemmour.

Wasn't that ultimately the point/key benefit of a European Union though? To keep the peace. Take that away and it's every one for themselves and that's what UK voted for with Brexit.
HarveySchlumpfenburger · 15/11/2021 20:47

@Fairylights25

Macron is sad, he is sad because the UK left the bloc, and they are now saddled with a massive financial black hole and can't control what the UK go on to do next, and could become a major competitor on the doorstep. He is aggrieved that we are still fully functioning and doing rather well, and this spills out in the form of abusing companies that make vaccines in the UK, stealing vaccines and stopping production, blocking ports and the tunnel at a moment's notice, stopping food and medicine deliveries on a whim, threatening to cut the electricity, allowing French fishing boats to ram UK boats in the channel, threatening war and other hostile actions.

And then some hopeful soul on here pops up and says 'ah but if we ask nicely'.....just seriously deluded and out of touch.

That's quite some fantasy world you've created there.

Whoever asked upthread about whether we'd paid the bill yet, as far as I'm aware we paid some of it about £20million out of the £60million after a lot of cajoling. I'm imagining that given the general level of trustworthiness of Boris and the UK at the moment they aren't confident about seeing the rest.

Possibly France could do more, but since it never has been and likely never will be necessary for people to claim asylum in the first safe country they can't exactly force people who don't want to be there to stay there. So while the UK is doing its absolute utmost to close of as many safe and legal doors to asylum as possible people will find unsafe ways of trying to make the journey.

User135644 · 15/11/2021 20:40

Europe doesn’t accept nearly as many refugees as it should.

Countries like the UK are already heavily overpopulated.

ItsSnotFair · 15/11/2021 20:39

@Fairylight25 it has been a big problem for years and years
It wasn’t unusual to see them jumping from lorries and running across the fields
Now they come by boat . Some run when they land others wait for the authorities to turn up

luckylavender · 15/11/2021 20:36

@daimbarsatemydogsbone - where do you get this rubbish from? The total population of Southall is c. 70,000

luckylavender · 15/11/2021 20:32

@MRex - the law states that refugees DO NOT have to seek asylum in the first country they reach.

Also France accepts far more refugees a year than the U.K. does.

willstarttomorrow · 15/11/2021 20:29

@54ShinyHappyPoster - absolutely, you are my internet star of the week! I think lots of people in the UK have forgotten that it was not that long ago that the UK welcomed persecuted people during WW2 who have gone on to make the UK their home and contributed lots to our society. In my case Jews fleeing central Europe and my amazing late mother in law whose family left all their wealth behind to flee Burma and whose children have gone on to be higher rate tax payers and just amazing people who call UK home. My job means that I often have to support families who have sacrificed and risked every thing to bring their family to safety- doctors, scientists and engineers who are not allowed to work and contribute but desperately want to. It is a cliche but their children are in school, having arrived with no English, desperately wanting to go on to do medicine, engineering etc with no garantee they will remain. This is a global issue and I think people need to rediscover empathy. We live in a global society and it is not okay just to take the bits you like and ignore the responsibility that goes with it.

ShinyHappyPoster · 15/11/2021 20:24

I'm sure you can rehash your Brexit arguments and compare biased sources on one of the many thread devoted to just that. This is supposed to be about refugees.

whoopsnomore · 15/11/2021 20:20

@Fairylights25

Macron is sad, he is sad because the UK left the bloc, and they are now saddled with a massive financial black hole and can't control what the UK go on to do next, and could become a major competitor on the doorstep. He is aggrieved that we are still fully functioning and doing rather well, and this spills out in the form of abusing companies that make vaccines in the UK, stealing vaccines and stopping production, blocking ports and the tunnel at a moment's notice, stopping food and medicine deliveries on a whim, threatening to cut the electricity, allowing French fishing boats to ram UK boats in the channel, threatening war and other hostile actions.

And then some hopeful soul on here pops up and says 'ah but if we ask nicely'.....just seriously deluded and out of touch.

Goodness me, what a lovely fiction! Like many other foreign leaders, they are aghast at the folly of the British leaving EU. UK incidentally has also left the Dublin agreement which meant EU member states agreed an equitable system of accepting refugees. Did you hear this story on GB news?
ShaneTheThird · 15/11/2021 20:18

Have you already forgotten that gut wrenching photo of Alan kurdi found face down on the beach drowned in Greece?! By not stopping these boats before they leave shores that country is responsible for them people's lives. France is responsible for a hell of a lot of refugees at the moment and has placed them in shitty camps where they are paying criminal gangs to go on dangerous dingeys and inside bloody freezer trucks to get to the UK. Their safety and the safety of everyone else is key to what safe country they have arrived in first. France is not only putting migrants in danger, it is allowing a developing criminal underworld and putting the national security of the UK in danger by not taking care of people as they should be.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 15/11/2021 20:10

@Fairylights25

Macron is sad, he is sad because the UK left the bloc, and they are now saddled with a massive financial black hole and can't control what the UK go on to do next, and could become a major competitor on the doorstep. He is aggrieved that we are still fully functioning and doing rather well, and this spills out in the form of abusing companies that make vaccines in the UK, stealing vaccines and stopping production, blocking ports and the tunnel at a moment's notice, stopping food and medicine deliveries on a whim, threatening to cut the electricity, allowing French fishing boats to ram UK boats in the channel, threatening war and other hostile actions.

And then some hopeful soul on here pops up and says 'ah but if we ask nicely'.....just seriously deluded and out of touch.

What is your solution then, start bombing Paris or something? I am reading a lot of ranting about the French (most of it fair comment to a point) but nothing about your better plan.
Fairylights25 · 15/11/2021 20:06

Macron is sad, he is sad because the UK left the bloc, and they are now saddled with a massive financial black hole and can't control what the UK go on to do next, and could become a major competitor on the doorstep. He is aggrieved that we are still fully functioning and doing rather well, and this spills out in the form of abusing companies that make vaccines in the UK, stealing vaccines and stopping production, blocking ports and the tunnel at a moment's notice, stopping food and medicine deliveries on a whim, threatening to cut the electricity, allowing French fishing boats to ram UK boats in the channel, threatening war and other hostile actions.

And then some hopeful soul on here pops up and says 'ah but if we ask nicely'.....just seriously deluded and out of touch.

Fairylights25 · 15/11/2021 20:01

The hideous red tape around employment in France is hardly a shining example to the rest of the world?! I think not.

ShinyHappyPoster · 15/11/2021 20:00

@daimbarsatemydogsbone thanks Grin I have friends who work in this area. I hate the political footballing and faux concern that are so commonplace in these discussions.

LavenderAskew · 15/11/2021 20:00

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

The British Isles is a contentious term that is used by the British, not the Irish, to describe the Islands.

You stated "the UK is the last outpost of the west of Europe" and "the UK has the geographic disadvantages of being an island and the furthest you can go west".

Firstly, the UK is not an island. Secondly, the discussion is about migrants/refugees arriving in the UK, not in these islands. If it was about them arriving in these islands, then it would be considerably more complex as the Dublin Rules apply to Ireland but don't apply to the UK. There are also different governments dealing with the issues and different laws in each jurisdiction.

As I said, can we retrun tot he subject of the thread rather than insist of centering anyine ekses politics?

To be honest anyone who feels the need to tytpoe that out, on a UK/British Isles focussed board might want to check why?

I am a fully functioning adult of a certain age. I am fully aware that we are ' a collection of islands' and that many areas have devolved governments and even that part of the British Isles are not in the UK. However on many threads, like many people, I will use "the UK" as a loose approximation of here, not the European mainland etc. And, to be honest, I couldn't care if some do find it offensive, I am British. I can't help it if you find that offensive.

We are an island nation, we are as far West as is possible to go before the big watery gap. That obviously includes both parts of the island of Ireland. Like it, lump it. I am not bothered!

At this point you'd do better to pretend you were are a flat earther and believed that Britain was on the western edge. (Ireland being on the easten edge)

You'd seem less ignorantly and idiotically arrogant.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 15/11/2021 19:58

@ShinyHappyPoster - that is one of the most sensible posts I've seen. I agree that every country is failing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread