Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why France is being blamed for allowing migrants to cross the English channel to uk?

233 replies

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:14

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

OP posts:
FreeBritnee · 16/11/2021 09:40

@Fairylights25

The UK can make its own laws now, so if the government wants to get very tough on immigration (or anything else) It now can, and they do seem very committed to doing so. So from that point of view brexit is a good thing, as now we can hold our own government accountable.

Not to say we are going to become like Saudi, but we can definitely do much more to improve the situation significantly.

I’m intrigued what you think we can do?
Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 09:31

The UK can make its own laws now, so if the government wants to get very tough on immigration (or anything else) It now can, and they do seem very committed to doing so. So from that point of view brexit is a good thing, as now we can hold our own government accountable.

Not to say we are going to become like Saudi, but we can definitely do much more to improve the situation significantly.

Ryannah · 16/11/2021 09:26

Also bear in mind coming to the UK is now way more attractive - no longer an EU member so the Dublin agreement is no longer valid in the UK. So once the migrants are here, they are here to stay.
Wondering why the Remain campaign didn’t mention this, seeing as a huge amount of people voted Leave because they thought it would allow us to close our borders and prevent the EU forcing us to take a quota of migrants!

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 09:25

If the migrants want to cross to get to the UK, france can’t physically restrain them

Of course they can restrain them! They could bloody deport them if they are illegal immigrants for one. They could house them properly point two. They could monitor the beaches properly as they are supposed to do point three. They could imprison smugglers I could go on and on.

France contained this situation really rather well for years up until six months ago, and suddenly Macron decided he would rather make things difficult for the brits in his words to show that brexit failed. Well sending boat loads of immigrant is only going to plunge relations into further decline, but I guess Zemmour can succeed perhaps where Macron has failed?

That is the way it is looking to me. France is in terminal decline of epic proportions, someone has to stop the rot.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 16/11/2021 09:21

@MLMshouldbeillegal- But international law/convention is that the asylum seekers should seek asylum in the FIRST SAFE country they get to. France is safe. Why are they not claiming asylum in France? Or for those who arrive overland in France, in any of the other number of countries they pass through first? (yes I know there are all sorts of reasons why people want to get to the UK because of family links and language, but the law doesn't really take account of that)

That is not the case. Have a read of this -
fullfact.org/immigration/refugees-first-safe-country/

The Dublin rules apply to the EU only. Under those rules, they must apply for asylum in the first EU country they are registered in. However, if they leave the EU, that doesn't apply.

Rosiiiiie · 16/11/2021 09:12

@Moonmelodies how can they though? What solutions are available to them? If the migrants want to cross to get to the UK, france can’t physically restrain them. They’ll cross eventually even if it’s not via boat.

Moonmelodies · 16/11/2021 09:05

How can anyone other than France physically stop people leaving their shores in unseaworthy boats to sail across one of the world's most dangerous shipping lanes?

lonelyapple · 16/11/2021 09:01

@Fairylights25

They do deport, but it takes ages with a long spiral process. We should really become much more efficiently . A two week window - fixed process - change the law so it’s easier to do. Anyone refusing ID is automatically deported immediately due to security concerns. Turn around is super fast and non contentious. The starting point is deportation not resettlement. Anyone with a criminal record automatically deported. Anyone caught smuggling human beings gets life in prison no ifs or buts. Until we get tough on this we will continue to see the trade of people and exploitation drag on for decades. Put me in charge I’d have this done in 12 months or less.
We have a Conservative Government with a big majority. Why the hell aren't they doing this? How does it help anyone to have potentially hundreds of thousands entering the country each year that will cost taxpayers millions, use up vital housing when there is already a housing crisis, already stretched NHS resources and increase threat of crime and terrorism. I don't understand why the Government isn't clamping down. I guess it doesn't really affect the rich very much so they don't care.
Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 08:50

Appeal

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 08:50

They do deport, but it takes ages with a long spiral process. We should really become much more efficiently . A two week window - fixed process - change the law so it’s easier to do. Anyone refusing ID is automatically deported immediately due to security concerns. Turn around is super fast and non contentious. The starting point is deportation not resettlement. Anyone with a criminal record automatically deported. Anyone caught smuggling human beings gets life in prison no ifs or buts.
Until we get tough on this we will continue to see the trade of people and exploitation drag on for decades.
Put me in charge I’d have this done in 12 months or less.

Rosiiiiie · 16/11/2021 08:47

@notimagain

I’ll add this link as well…

www.infomigrants.net/en/post/35518/allegations-of-rubber-bullets-fired-at-migrants-on-french-beach

But of course the French are sitting back and doing nothing…

This!!

They don’t do enough, they get blamed by UK. They try a bit harder, they get slammed with human rights criticisms.

They’re doing the best they can with limited resources. I don’t think france has the space/money to house everyone. Even if they did, many asylum seekers are desperate to get to the UK and will reject assistance from the French.

There’s no magic solution 😕

lonelyapple · 16/11/2021 08:43

Does the UK actually deport anyone? It seems that even if you commit a crime you can basically just stay here unhindered. Why bother being law abiding or doing things the legal way to become a British citizen when even if your claim is rejected you still get housing and financial support (more in total than most pensioners get) per week.

RustyBear · 16/11/2021 08:37

@daimbarsatemydogsbone - That link doesn't say there are 800,000 in Southall.
It says "With at least 800,000 illegal Indian immigrants here and just "one square mile" of 'Little Punjab' aka Southall in west London chock full of houses packed with people who should rightfully be deported to India" 'Here' is referring to the UK, it doesn't say how many of the 800,000 are in Southall, just that one square mile is 'packed'

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 08:36

Not for much longer lonely

lonelyapple · 16/11/2021 08:30

They are economic migrants. They have travelled through numerous safe countries to get to the promised land of the UK. 90% of them are able bodied young men, very few elderly, women or children. France could stop them but it is easier to pass the buck to the UK as why would the French want to be responsible for a load of angry young men who are going to cost them millions over the years whilst potentially being a dangerous threat to the existing population. On top of that the UK is paying France millions to do nothing. It's win-win for France.

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 08:26

It is human nature to seek a better life.

MLMshouldbeillegal · 16/11/2021 08:25

@Rebbecia1234

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?
Yes we should be accepting asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations. But international law/convention is that the asylum seekers should seek asylum in the FIRST SAFE country they get to. France is safe. Why are they not claiming asylum in France? Or for those who arrive overland in France, in any of the other number of countries they pass through first? (yes I know there are all sorts of reasons why people want to get to the UK because of family links and language, but the law doesn't really take account of that)

Also, the French aren't doing much about stopping them leaving their shores. Not tracking down the despicable people traffickers who charge $$$ for a place on an unsuitable boat.

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 08:24

Why does it have to be rubber bullets or standing around doing nothing? What we need, what we have always needed is a Europe wide consensus to remove migrants back to their home countries that works quickly, efficiently and with dignity. If we were returning 1000s a week then it would quickly become a deterrent to those attempting the journey. We could then set up an orderly system for application.

Ultimately the argument that the west should be offering refuge to all and sundry now needs to be seriously explored, because anyone can argue that their needs are greater because of x,y & z but really we need to become much tougher full stop. People will also want a better life/more money

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 08:21

Fair enough the 800k is obviously wrong. I assume it must be a National estimate incorrectly attributed in the Times of India and other sources.

luckylavender · 16/11/2021 07:00

@daimbarsatemydogsbone - 2011 census

Bagamoyo1 · 16/11/2021 00:08

[quote Rebbecia1234]@Wackaday

I think that the UK has a responsibility to do their fair share in helping asylum seekers who have come from desperate situations. Obviously no one wants people to risk their lives crossing seas in difficult conditions. I am quite sure that France could do more to prevent it, but it is not in their interests to do so and their commitment to do this will never be there.[/quote]
The UK does do its fair share.

Courtier · 15/11/2021 23:49

@Rebbecia1234 I'd imagine the U.K. doesn't police it's own waters in this way because we are an island. Unlike France who can stop them and turn them back from crossing what can we do mid-water? Shoot them? Bring them in anyway - thus defeating the point of stopping them?

We don't want to hurt people. So we don't want them to try the crossing. Either way they're only coming because of colonialist attitudes that taught them the streets are paved with bloody gold. I'm sure they'd rather have chosen Germany if they do make it.

notimagain · 15/11/2021 22:43

@mumda

We have no migration camps here. Do France not house their migrants in Le Premier Inns?
We have a centre with “proper” buildings, not far from us in southern France that provides accommodation and assistance for migrants who want to seek asylum in France.

Those intent on staying off the French authorities radar and instead are heading for the UK generally make their own (often grim) arrangements, though they do sometimes get help from charities.

mumda · 15/11/2021 22:32

We have no migration camps here. Do France not house their migrants in Le Premier Inns?

notimagain · 15/11/2021 21:59

I’ll add this link as well…

www.infomigrants.net/en/post/35518/allegations-of-rubber-bullets-fired-at-migrants-on-french-beach

But of course the French are sitting back and doing nothing…

Swipe left for the next trending thread