Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why France is being blamed for allowing migrants to cross the English channel to uk?

233 replies

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:14

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

OP posts:
LINABE · 16/11/2021 11:20

@Ozanj

The problem is caused by European countries like France and Italy not taking care of refugees, so they don’t want to register there & try their luck elsewhere. The UK will always be a popular choice as English is spoken so widely. But actually Turkey (and to a lesser extent Egypt and Morocco) is the country that not only accepts the most refugees, it is also the country where most refugees register to stay, so don’t believe the propaganda. Europe doesn’t accept nearly as many refugees as it should.
This.
FreeBritnee · 16/11/2021 11:11

I have a theory that the government is actively allowing it to wildly accelerate so public tolerance for it dwindles and then when they bring in something entirely draconian hardly anyone will protest.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 10:57

[quote luckylavender]@Fairylights25 - France accepts many more refugees than we do already. [/quote]
France has much less population density than us - a similar population in a Country about twice the size - this has all been discussed fully upthread.

luckylavender · 16/11/2021 10:54

@Fairylights25 - France accepts many more refugees than we do already.

luckylavender · 16/11/2021 10:52

@MLMshouldbeillegal - that's not true. International law does not say that an asylum seeker has to seek asylum in the first country they reach.

Standstheclockattentothree · 16/11/2021 10:44

@supremelybaffled

The French are doing everything they can to look the other way while the migrants leave their shores. They don't want the migrants to stay in France, they are thrilled to see the back of them.
That's true. We travel regularly by motorhome. Ouistreham has migrant camps all over the place - all large groups of young men. They hang about by traffic lights and at roundabouts, and chase after your vehicle to try to get on it. It's very intimidating. The advice to motorhome owners if you have to stay overnight is to be well away from the area as it's just not safe. It's astonishing that it's allowed to continue.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 10:40

You do realize Dublin rules mean the country of arrival in the EU takes responsibility? Which would very very rarely have been France but rather, Greece, Italy, Spain or Bulgaria. Not France's job to take back migrants from the UK anymore than say Austria's from Germany or Denmark from Sweden.
Or indeed Libya. My point was to @Fairylights25 that you can't just "deport" people as they seem to think.
This is not a simple issue @Fairylights25 says they can fix it if put in charge for 12 months - that's as ridiculous as it is arrogant - but after 12 months in charge they might at least understand the actual problem.

GrumpyPanda · 16/11/2021 10:30

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

And why on earth would France accept them? Dublin rules no longer apply to the UK...

Exactly - France wouldn't take them back when we were in the EU and they were legally obliged to, they aren't going to now.

I suspect Libya may not be terribly cooperative either.
Indeed that idea was just bonkers

You do realize Dublin rules mean the country of arrival in the EU takes responsibility? Which would very very rarely have been France but rather, Greece, Italy, Spain or Bulgaria. Not France's job to take back migrants from the UK anymore than say Austria's from Germany or Denmark from Sweden.
fournonblondes · 16/11/2021 10:23
  • Once they are here they do not get deported, legal challenges draw the process out for years. Every time the Government try to do something, there is an outcry that its illegal, inhumane, against human rights. Unless something is done, like Australia, things will not change. They made a controversial decision and it seems to have worked. Many lives could be saved in the future if we made a hard decision. We cant absorb thousands of people every year who need support and housing. Also, Im going to get flamed for this, the man who set off the bomb in Liverpool is reportedly a failed asylum seeker. How many other people like this are flooding into the country undetected ?*

This

While most people are happy to accept this situation the government will not do much because they have not pressure. Also, there is a trend to shame the people who question the consequences of this situation.

Duckrace · 16/11/2021 10:17

France did offer to do exactly this in the past, as long as the uk shares the cost, but that was refused.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 10:16

@HarrietsChariot

France are in a better position to prevent the vessels launching - they can interfere with the process on land as well as being able to use their ships to intercept them in the water.

If anyone tries to intercept them they sink their own boats so they have to be rescued. There is no practical way for any vessels to be turned back.

Abhannmor · 16/11/2021 10:14

It's all a bit pathetic isn't it. Britain bungs the French a few quid. The EU throws a few bob at Greece and Turkey. Blah blah as Greta says. Trouble is Europe and USA have no interest in seeing developing countries actually improve their living standards. They just want raw materials and cheap labour. Oh and war , lots of war. Most refugees live in countries adjacent to their place of origin. Countries which , through some oversight, Britain and the USA have not bombed back to the Stone Age. States like Jordan , Egypt and Iran host a lot of refugees. After the Berlin Wall came down there was lots of talk about developing North Africa - which is ideal for solar power. But talk is cheap. To actually accomplish anything you'd have to take on the 1%.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 10:13

And why on earth would France accept them? Dublin rules no longer apply to the UK...

Exactly - France wouldn't take them back when we were in the EU and they were legally obliged to, they aren't going to now.

I suspect Libya may not be terribly cooperative either.
Indeed that idea was just bonkers

sashh · 16/11/2021 10:12

These are all very valid points. I am therefore wondering why the UK government doesn't police the UK border directly instead of paying the French to do this. I'm not really understanding why policing of the border must be down to France.

If a UK border force employee finds an asylum seeker on a beach they they are in Britain and our responsibility.

If they are in France, then France is responsible for them.

Wondering why the Remain campaign didn’t mention this, seeing as a huge amount of people voted Leave because they thought it would allow us to close our borders and prevent the EU forcing us to take a quota of migrants!

Because they earned a fortune and said anything remainers said was 'project fear'.

lonelyapple · 16/11/2021 10:10

@Fairylights25

The UK can make its own laws now, so if the government wants to get very tough on immigration (or anything else) It now can, and they do seem very committed to doing so. So from that point of view brexit is a good thing, as now we can hold our own government accountable.

Not to say we are going to become like Saudi, but we can definitely do much more to improve the situation significantly.

Yes, the Government is so committed to doing so that the new Borders Bill is progressing at snail's pace through Parliament, yet when it suits them they can bring in new (Covid-related bills) in the space of a week or so. Surely this is now an emergency situation and should be dealt with with utmost urgency for the safety and benefit of both the migrants and the UK population. It's almost like the Government don't want to stop this...
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 10:09

@Fairylights25

A dental check can immediately offer age range and is already used - and unless the migrant is willing to offer ID and home country information then they will be immediately be deported back to France first choice, or Libya as a second choice. We need to get much tougher.
France won't take them, nor Libya - what are you going to do about that? You are not thinking this through at all.
HarrietsChariot · 16/11/2021 10:08

Not sure why the UK should be more responsible for sending boats out to rescue migrants in unseaworthy vessels than France.

France are in a better position to prevent the vessels launching - they can interfere with the process on land as well as being able to use their ships to intercept them in the water.

France are the problem here - (understandably) they don't want the illegal migrants on their turf, they are happy for them to go to sea because it removes the problem from their shores.

The migrants who arrive on Britain's shores or have to be rescued by our ships, who don't have a legal right to be here, should certainly be given shelter and security by us. We've still got overseas territories like South Georgia or Inaccessible Island, the migrants could be given free passage to those locations and be given the basics for growing their own food and making their own shelter. They'd be free from whatever persecution they were fleeing, those places are so remote nobody would bother going after them there.

thereisonlyoneofme · 16/11/2021 10:06

Once they are here they do not get deported, legal challenges draw the process out for years. Every time the Government try to do something, there is an outcry that its illegal, inhumane, against human rights.
Unless something is done, like Australia, things will not change.
They made a controversial decision and it seems to have worked.
Many lives could be saved in the future if we made a hard decision.
We cant absorb thousands of people every year who need support and housing.
Also, Im going to get flamed for this, the man who set off the bomb in Liverpool is reportedly a failed asylum seeker. How many other
people like this are flooding into the country undetected ?

Rosiiiiie · 16/11/2021 10:03

Ok so say you could deport them. How would you define an ‘illegal immigrant’ as you call them?
And even if you could define such term, how would you prove they’re ‘illegal immigrant’ as opposed to asylum seeker?
Lastly, how would you find out their country of origin or which EU country they originally arrived in to send them back to?
Countries blaming each other is never going to work. The UK also needs to take accountability for migrants.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 16/11/2021 10:00

@Fairylights25

A dental check can immediately offer age range and is already used - and unless the migrant is willing to offer ID and home country information then they will be immediately be deported back to France first choice, or Libya as a second choice. We need to get much tougher.
And why on earth would France accept them? Dublin rules no longer apply to the UK...

I suspect Libya may not be terribly cooperative either.

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 09:53

There is a wild difference between leakage, and thousands of boats launching from France, a big difference.

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 09:52

A dental check can immediately offer age range and is already used - and unless the migrant is willing to offer ID and home country information then they will be immediately be deported back to France first choice, or Libya as a second choice. We need to get much tougher.

notimagain · 16/11/2021 09:52

France contained this situation really rather well for years up until six months ago, and suddenly Macron decided he would rather make things difficult for the brits in his words to show that brexit failed

There have been problems around Calais and “leakage” across the Channel by way of stowing away in lorries/car trailers/for years… the fashion for boats/dinghies is relatively recent and may well be down to the fact that the French have been making getting into the tunnel/tunnel infra-structure harder….

Pretty much every time you see a crowd of intercepted migrants interviewed on French TV a sizable proportion speak English and make the point that their intended destination is the UK..always the UK…they are not interested in putting down routes in accommodation in France.

The French POV is that they are doing what they can, with the resources they have but they do wish the UK would make efforts to reduce the “pull”…

Meanwhile from late last night:

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/nov/15/france-uk-migrant-crisis-priti-patel

Rosiiiiie · 16/11/2021 09:51

@Fairylights25 deport them to where? These people don’t just travel with paperwork lol and they certainly aren’t going to tell you where they travelled from.
Also most smugglers are actually British?
And why can’t UK house asylum seekers properly too? Why does the blame fall back on France everytime?

FreeBritnee · 16/11/2021 09:43

@Fairylights25

They do deport, but it takes ages with a long spiral process. We should really become much more efficiently . A two week window - fixed process - change the law so it’s easier to do. Anyone refusing ID is automatically deported immediately due to security concerns. Turn around is super fast and non contentious. The starting point is deportation not resettlement. Anyone with a criminal record automatically deported. Anyone caught smuggling human beings gets life in prison no ifs or buts. Until we get tough on this we will continue to see the trade of people and exploitation drag on for decades. Put me in charge I’d have this done in 12 months or less.
Where are they meant to depart to? They have no way of knowing where the people have come from, nor how old they are.
Swipe left for the next trending thread