Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why France is being blamed for allowing migrants to cross the English channel to uk?

233 replies

Rebbecia1234 · 15/11/2021 14:14

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kendodd · 17/11/2021 10:54

I think immigrants are lied to about life in the UK. A family saves up to send an adult child here in the hope of a better life and money sent home. That 'better life' isn't quite what was imagined but child has to pretend they're doing great so as not to disappoint family or feel a failure. This lie paints a picture for the next hopeful migrant wanting to make the journey.

Rebbecia1234 · 16/11/2021 19:00

@Alondra

Answering the original post...

France is being blamed by your very conservative and mouth piece from government press because after Brexit and the controlling borders slogan, the whole thing has gone to shit.

Reality is not about slogans. The whole first world is under pressure from illegal immigration, from the USA with the border to Mexico, Spain with crossings from Morocco, Germany from Eastern Europe, Italy and Greece from Syria...etc, etc...

Whoever sold the slogan to the UK about protecting borders LIED. The reality is that the UK was protected from illegal migrants thanks to be an island with many borders in Europe who stopped illegals before they got to you. The UK is now a third country and Europe doesn't give a fuck who gets to you. The EU is fighting an illegal war without thinking about how it affects third countries including the UK.

If you don't like it tough. It's the choice you voted for.

This post makes a lot of sense to me.
OP posts:
whoopsnomore · 16/11/2021 18:02

@luckylavender

This is so depressing and so inevitable. Blame the French, blame lazy teachers, blame lazy doctors, blame people for dying of Covid. If this government spent less time on spin and more time doing its job, the U.K. would a far better place currently.
Sadly it seems to be working (judging by many of the posts on this thread) - 1930's playbook classic deflection tactics.
whoopsnomore · 16/11/2021 17:58

@Fairylights25

The UK can make its own laws now, so if the government wants to get very tough on immigration (or anything else) It now can, and they do seem very committed to doing so. So from that point of view brexit is a good thing, as now we can hold our own government accountable.

Not to say we are going to become like Saudi, but we can definitely do much more to improve the situation significantly.

Not this nonsense again! Britain has always been able to make its own laws. Britain has always controlled its own borders. "Now we can hold our own government accountable" - you have literally swallowed hook line and sinker the mistruths that were spread to make people fear and hate. I bet you believed Turkey was on the brink of joining the EU too.
IsleofRum · 16/11/2021 13:40

This was, I believe seriously considered by the captain of the liner taking Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany to Cuba (I maybe wrong) in 1938, when the country who had offered to take them reneged on the deal. They were then forced to head back to Germany. As it was, other European countries including the UK took a share. Needless to say it ended badly for those accommodated in mainland Europe..

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 13:39

@Fairylights25

Turning them back before they reach British waters would be a good option
And who will do that? And what will happen when they sink their own vessels?
Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 13:35

Turning them back before they reach British waters would be a good option

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 13:33

@Fairylights25

How will your plan to deport people to France work?

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 13:29

Also worth noting that it is impossible to get benefits, housing, access to doctors/schools without paperwork. The same as France and anywhere else. We still treat ill people in hospital of course, but they are also checked but not before treatment as we are a civilised country.

So it’s a nonsense that people come here because they can live under the radar, is that how you comfort yourself that people would rather live in the U.K.? Perhaps it’s more to do with excellent employment opportunities, good education, kind people that aren’t racist on the whole and true opportunity to advance if talented. I’d say that was the bigger draw personally

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 13:26

@Fairylights25

Well why not? Because we can’t house everyone here, so they either provide home country details or they are repatriated to a country paid by us to resettle them. Libya might be an option as they seem open to negotiation. It’s already being explored - similar to the set up Australia have. Would you be so willing to travel thousands of miles across perfectly safe countries paying huge amounts to people smugglers to end up being deported to Libya? Thought not. It’s this kind of exploratory solutions that are needed if we are to continue to offer a free national health service, council housing, benefits to the poor, free doctors and schools and something approaching an equal society. We can’t house and feed the world.
And your plan to deport people to France?

How will that work?

Still no answer. Because it won't.

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 13:21

Well why not? Because we can’t house everyone here, so they either provide home country details or they are repatriated to a country paid by us to resettle them. Libya might be an option as they seem open to negotiation. It’s already being explored - similar to the set up Australia have.
Would you be so willing to travel thousands of miles across perfectly safe countries paying huge amounts to people smugglers to end up being deported to Libya? Thought not.
It’s this kind of exploratory solutions that are needed if we are to continue to offer a free national health service, council housing, benefits to the poor, free doctors and schools and something approaching an equal society. We can’t house and feed the world.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 13:11

@Fairylights25

One feels sorry for the posters that are caught up in the hostility. I don’t think it’s helpful to swear or to lament that France is the victim here. It will take joint cooperation and tougher regimes on both sides of the channel to fix this.

I am very glad the U.K. government is now free to make changes unencumbered by the bureaucracy of the EU commission, and that we now stand a far better chance of getting on top of this now we are out.
The situation is going to turn very ugly on the polish/Belarus border with macron threatening war - which basically means Russia as this action is orchestrated by Putin - I think we have been here before no? Some time back in history. It didn’t end well then either. Still, at least it helps Macrons stance for a European army….

You really are hilarious

It will take joint cooperation

Which is what I said several pages back - and you then said I was deluded to expect cooperation from the French.

You still haven't explained how your plan to deport people to France and/or Libya (why there?) will work - clearly you are dodging that question as you've been rumbled.

luckylavender · 16/11/2021 13:07

This is so depressing and so inevitable. Blame the French, blame lazy teachers, blame lazy doctors, blame people for dying of Covid. If this government spent less time on spin and more time doing its job, the U.K. would a far better place currently.

Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 12:51

One feels sorry for the posters that are caught up in the hostility. I don’t think it’s helpful to swear or to lament that France is the victim here. It will take joint cooperation and tougher regimes on both sides of the channel to fix this.

I am very glad the U.K. government is now free to make changes unencumbered by the bureaucracy of the EU commission, and that we now stand a far better chance of getting on top of this now we are out.
The situation is going to turn very ugly on the polish/Belarus border with macron threatening war - which basically means Russia as this action is orchestrated by Putin - I think we have been here before no? Some time back in history. It didn’t end well then either. Still, at least it helps Macrons stance for a European army….

Alondra · 16/11/2021 12:42

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

Which is apparently the same thing according to your government.

I wasn't asking what they meant - I asked what you meant.
No-one dislikes our government more than me - I was trying to clarify what you were saying.

Apologies if I misunderstood your answer....

The EU is Europe, it's a reality that aside from geography, the UK doesn't belong to politically, economically or in trade. Brexit was about being British and controlling borders to stop freedom of movement with the EU. It also means the UK has the responsibility to control illegals coming from Europe/EU which they have a sea border with. Blaming France or Timbuktu is simply another way to deflect from that responsibility.

notimagain · 16/11/2021 12:39

[quote luckylavender]@Fairylights25 - France accepts many more refugees than we do already. [/quote]
Yep..what gets forgotten ignored is that a lot of the migrants coming up out of Africa have French as their second language..so lots of them do try to claim asylum or somehow settle in France.

The English speakers tend to try and get to the Channel.

Talking of which the CRS (who aren’t known to be cuddly, feely or charitable) went through another camp near the north coast this AM, cleared it out and “insisted” the residents left on coaches to have their status checked….

I’m sure the likes of the DM and other parts of the MSM in the UK will cover the story eventually.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 12:32

Which is apparently the same thing according to your government.

I wasn't asking what they meant - I asked what you meant.
No-one dislikes our government more than me - I was trying to clarify what you were saying.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 16/11/2021 12:31

Surely, UK has as much responsibility as any other country to accept asylum seekers fleeing from desperate situations? Why should France be tasked with the responsibility of preventing asylum seekers to cross the English channel in boats to the UK?

If that’s the case then why are we blaming Belarus fir allowing immigrants to cross into Poland? Surely it’s Poland’s responsibility to take them in?

Alondra · 16/11/2021 12:28

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

The UK is now a third country and Europe doesn't give a fuck who gets to you.

I assume by "Europe" you mean the EU?

Which is apparently the same thing according to your government.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 12:21

The UK is now a third country and Europe doesn't give a fuck who gets to you.

I assume by "Europe" you mean the EU?

Alondra · 16/11/2021 11:47

Answering the original post...

France is being blamed by your very conservative and mouth piece from government press because after Brexit and the controlling borders slogan, the whole thing has gone to shit.

Reality is not about slogans. The whole first world is under pressure from illegal immigration, from the USA with the border to Mexico, Spain with crossings from Morocco, Germany from Eastern Europe, Italy and Greece from Syria...etc, etc...

Whoever sold the slogan to the UK about protecting borders LIED. The reality is that the UK was protected from illegal migrants thanks to be an island with many borders in Europe who stopped illegals before they got to you. The UK is now a third country and Europe doesn't give a fuck who gets to you. The EU is fighting an illegal war without thinking about how it affects third countries including the UK.

If you don't like it tough. It's the choice you voted for.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 11:43

@Fairylights25

If France is just such an incredible country why on earth do so many want to come here anyway?! Perhaps it hurts the national pride of France to see so many thousands camped out to try and get to the country next door, maybe it is an affront?
I see you have not a single answer to any of the practical issues people have pointed out in your ridiculous proposals.

Now you're just engaging in some weird and pointless jingoism - are you Boris Johnson?

OchonAgusOchonOh · 16/11/2021 11:35

@Fairylights25

If France is just such an incredible country why on earth do so many want to come here anyway?! Perhaps it hurts the national pride of France to see so many thousands camped out to try and get to the country next door, maybe it is an affront?
Don't be ridiculous. The reason the UK is more attractive than France is because it is much easier to stay under the radar in the UK but still be able to access health, work, education, housing etc.
Fairylights25 · 16/11/2021 11:25

If France is just such an incredible country why on earth do so many want to come here anyway?! Perhaps it hurts the national pride of France to see so many thousands camped out to try and get to the country next door, maybe it is an affront?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 16/11/2021 11:21

@FreeBritnee

I have a theory that the government is actively allowing it to wildly accelerate so public tolerance for it dwindles and then when they bring in something entirely draconian hardly anyone will protest.
That theory suggests a level of forethought and planning which is beyond our current government I think.