Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

if your DC has ASD did you go on to have more children?

85 replies

23bumblebee · 15/11/2021 13:58

DC has ASD with PDA and we are currently discussing having a second. Both are unsure and are concerned that another child might also have ASD - due to the genetic links (lots of ASD in my husband's family so definitely genetic), whether we'd have enough energy for both, what will happen to DC in the future. We dont have anyone to ask in RL but if you did have a child with ASD - did you have any of the same questions, how did you make a decision them?

OP posts:
mehface · 15/11/2021 21:45

I'm pretty sure my DS has PDA and he over reacts a lot to his younger sister. He had had many developmental issues, but I was obsessed and somethings did work themselves out. I do find it hard to be patient with DC1 if DC2 is crying. I did consider whether I could take having another child like DS. It turned out my second was a girl and whilst she's a tricky fish too, at least the obsessions aren't the same.

I absolutely adore my DS but he is easier solo, but having a sister is good for him too. Not good for me 😬

Dazedandconfused28 · 15/11/2021 21:45

I'm in exactly the same boat - DC1 has ASD, Im trying to come to terms with it. Currently fighting to get him support & scared of having a second, but also desperately want another. Ultimately we will have another (if fertility allows) as we're already in it, is that makes sense? but it will be tainted with fear that our 2nd might also struggle. It's very hard.

If i took my darling boy out of the equation & someone told me I would have autistic children, I wouldn't have done it.

But he's here now & I love him almost more than I can bear.

WellTidy · 15/11/2021 21:39

I’d toyed with having another (DH would have been on board at the drop of a hat) but wasn’t sure. And then DS2’s difficulties became apparent at just before 2yo and that sealed the deal - I decided absolutely not. Ds2 has autism (lower functioning) and other co-morbidities.

Having a third would have had too much impact on both DS1 and DS2, plus the r impact that ds2’s difficulties would have had on the third, plus the extra work and ‘burden’ that another child (neurotypical or neurodiverse) puts on parents. It was just way, way too much to contemplate.

I do see some other families having a third and feel a twinge, but that’s not because I regret the decision I made, more than I’m sad that the decision was made for me.

Theyellowflamingo · 15/11/2021 21:33

We were offered a referral for genetic testing by the NHS paediatric team that assessed DC1 for autism as they apparently offer it to every child diagnosed. In DC case though we were told it was unlikely they’d find anything definitive (DC doesn’t have any typical comorbidities that might suggest a particular syndrome for example) and we declined.

We were told if at any point, even years later, we decided we did want it we could contact them and ask for a referral - you could try whichever service provided your diagnosis and ask if they offer it.

BlueHydroponicCarpet · 15/11/2021 21:32

Oh dear - that sounds so exactly like my ds. I'm guessing yours is much younger and you have a massive start in having the diagnosis young which means you can do the right things and there is more chance of success. My own ds was not diagnosed until age 10 and the first decade of basically being seen as the naughty boy and the problem by almost everyone has been massively damaging for him.

Thanks
nanbread · 15/11/2021 21:21

We both thought we'd like 3 kids but stopped at 2 partly because of DC's ND and the challenges it brings. We are already on our knees dealing with it (they've both had other medical problems) and would really struggle to cope with another child that wasn't "easy" / found life easy. I'm sad about it, but my two existing DC need all I have to give.

They can play brilliantly, and DC1 has found a way to play with DC2 and accommodate his quirks, but mostly they fight and trigger each other due to their differing profiles, and it's exhausting.

LJAKS · 15/11/2021 21:19

I guess it would depend on where on the spectrum they fell and how able I thought they would be to live independently as adults. I've known people with children with complex needs who've gone on to have more children with the plan that they could care for the complex child in adulthood when the parents were no longer able to. In some cases second children have been NT and in some equally complex.

I don't think it's an easy decision to make. People who have healthy babies with no disabilities decide whether to have more children or not without having to consider any of these factors. I had genetic testing done to see if we had "caused" my DDs condition, they came back clear but even then my ExH wouldn't "risk" having another child.
So a big ramble there with no real conclusions, it's really difficult Thanks

23bumblebee · 15/11/2021 21:14

@BlueHydroponicCarpet - no, not yet. Everything has been a bit overwhelming to be honest. I get why he struggles with friends but nothing seems to help. I have no idea how to make him understand why it doesnt work - I try but it doesnt get through. But kids around him dont want to be bossed around, plus DC is so fragile that anything goes wrong and he is in floods of tears. So he comes across both as a bossy boots and completely fragile. So kids kind of avoid him now, in turn, he seems to gravitate towards the bullies. No idea whether it will get any better as he gets older. I mean even at home, he is totally focused on myself and is really rude to his dad whenever am around. They are totally fine when am out and DH does as much with him as I do.

OP posts:
BlueHydroponicCarpet · 15/11/2021 21:04

Heart wrenching - heart breaking. I don't know how many times I have sat with ds1 while he has sobbed his heart out because he desperately wants friends but can never make it work. It is so desperately hard to watch someone you love and feel helpless to help them Sad

Are you in any pda fb groups? I find them quite helpful and a good source for a specific discussion/advice about pda which is so different in many ways to other parts of the spectrum.

AuntieObnoxious · 15/11/2021 20:55

My DS had his diagnosis just before he turned 4, although it was apparent there were ‘issues’ from 2 1/2. There is 21 months between him & our DD so we didn’t have any choice. The spectrum is so huge it is difficult to compare 1 family situation to another. In our case our family dynamics work perfectly- the kids are very close and complement each other. DS is so organised & precise and DD is completely dippy. DS some learning difficulties and attends a special school while DD is a high achiever academically. Our main concern was ensuring DS didn’t lose self esteem being compared to DS which hasn’t happened. As ASD making life harder, especially with 2, with us it hasn’t an issue.

23bumblebee · 15/11/2021 20:55

@BlueHydroponicCarpet thats exactly how DC is which is heart wrenching. DC wants friends but I can see why other kids find it so difficult. The older they are, the worse it is getting. I almost feel that if DC presented in a more typically autistic way i.e. not as interested in say play with other kids, then we wouldnt even be thinking about another child. As it is - I know DC would love to have a playmate but I just dont know how that would work or whether I have enough in me.

OP posts:
BlueHydroponicCarpet · 15/11/2021 20:49

My ds1 is sociable and wants to have friends but also wants to control everything (pda). He is very focussed on his specific interests, tends to want to play with just one person at a time and isolates them in order to achieve this and loses it as soon as the person he is playing with is no longer happy or willing to do everything ds1 wants.

When his siblings were younger they really idolised him and wanted to play with him but couldn't understand if they were not the person chosen for his 1:1 playing, and generally any game which he organised which involved all of them would go fine for up to 10mins after which there would be tears and massive upset as 1 or more of them failed to follow his rules or didn't understand how to follow his rules.

He has retreated to mainly playing on his computer as he is now a teen - where he used to get the younger ones to play on the computer with him but again would always need to be in charge and as they have got older they have got less and less willing to be dictated to.

It does depend on your own dcs particular presentation and needs, but I understand from various groups I'm in that my dcs experiences are not at all uncommon with pda.

There is also the added complication that parenting a pda child differs massively from ordinary parenting and a NT or even a non-PDA ND child will not flourish if parented in that way so there is a huge struggle for the others to understand why ds1 is treated differently. It has lead them to having a more sophisticated understanding of difference and people getting what they need rather than all getting the same, but I'm not completely convinced that this is a totally positive thing for rather young children to have to come to terms with.

Rosebel · 15/11/2021 20:46

DC2 has ASD although she wasn't diagnosed until she was 9.We had our son 3 years later but I'm beginning to suspect he may have some form of autism.
DD2 has mild ASD and will likely be able to live independently etc but as our son is so young I've no idea how he'll cope.
I don't regret any of my children though and I'd make the same choices again.

23bumblebee · 15/11/2021 20:39

@BlueHydroponicCarpet do you think a diagnosis of PDA makes it harder for them to manage siblings? It's so hard - DC is very sociable but most of the time it ends badly so on the one hand, they would love a sibling but on the other hand, will I just end up having to rescue one while trying to calm the other

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 15/11/2021 20:39

I hadnt realised that you could do genetic testing. How did you guys go about it?

It was part of the assessment for autism when we did it.

TurnUpTurnip · 15/11/2021 20:38

My kids often feel resentful towards dd because there’s a lot of places we can’t go to because of her or she regularly has melt downs or we have to leave places, they often say they wish she didn’t have autism etc which makes me feel bad/guilty. It definitely impacts my other children.

Boulshired · 15/11/2021 20:35

It is such a large spectrum, DS2 was my youngest and we did want one more but it was clear life was going to be difficult. In all honesty my older children lives have been scared and I feel guilty for that. holidays, meals family occasions only happen if one of us stays home. Even watching a movie at home is impossible. Equally my brother who was diagnosed as an adult improved every aspect of my life as a child and an adult.

23bumblebee · 15/11/2021 20:32

I hadnt realised that you could do genetic testing. How did you guys go about it?

OP posts:
ElfDragon · 15/11/2021 20:20

I knew that dc1 wasn’t developing typically by the time I was ttc dc2. I had concerns about dc1 by the time she was 7 months old (such was the severity of her behaviour and deviation from ‘typical’ development). Dc1 was diagnosed when dc2 was 6 weeks old, having been in the system for about 15 months by that time.

Dc1 and dc2 totally played together when they were small. They did (and do) understand each other’s needs - which isn’t to say that the toddler years weren’t fraught and very difficult at times!

By the time dc3 came along, dc1 had an EHCP, and had been in a fabulous SN school for 4 years. Dc2 was getting along ok in mainstream.

Both dc1 and dc2 played with dc3 nicely enough. Dc2 and dc3 are very close now - they are very similar in ASD profile, and in personality (which leads to clashes too). Dc1 is now in 6th form at the same fabulous SN school, and has come so far from the, frankly, isolated, withdrawn and difficult to engage toddler she was.

We have been incredibly fortunate (despite the extreme difficulties), and really are now in a good place. I am now a single mum, and to be blunt, a lot of the calm now is becaus exH is not here anymore. We manage days out, with a reasonable spread of things to enjoy - the hardest part there is finding something that a 15 year old and a preteen want to do, as well as being suitable for dc1 with learning difficulties, but we manage, just about. There is an enormous amount of planning, and an acceptance that our ‘normal’ and way of enjoying things is not necessarily the same as a lot of other families’, but it honestly is ok for us.

I am facing dc1’s transition to adult services with a large amount of trepidation, and of course I fear what the future holds. But there have been some very good times along the way, interspersed with the difficult bits (and a lot of the difficult bits have come from having to deal with admin and battling with local authorities etc, which really should not happen the way it does).

phoenixrosehere · 15/11/2021 20:18

Yes, but because at the time I’d not cottoned on that DC1 had autism. As it turns out DC2 is neurotypical, but I’m glad we didn’t know about DC1 then because I probably wouldn’t have dared have DC2. The two of them are very close, good for each other and I don’t regret DC2 for a second - but a second child with autism would have been difficult for me to cope with, and more importantly I don’t think DC1 would cope with another child like them.

Same with us. DC2 was over 1 before we knew DC1 showed signs of autism. He was an easy, happy child but he was saying few words. It took two years to get a formal diagnosis and by that timehe was 5 and his brother almost 3. They’re 4 and 6 and they play together all the time. They wrestle and my oldest will kiss his brother’s hair or forehead. They don’t know anything else or different. Our oldest is in his first year of a specialist school and he is thriving so we’re doing the wait and see approach with him to see if a third is possible. There were no genetic factors found when they did test us and our son. His siblings don’t have ASD and my sister and I don’t nor do our parents. The only difference they found that they felt was a contributing factor was the birth. I was induced despite no evidence or medical reason for doing so with him leading to an emcs and him blue and not breathing (no idea for how long) whereas my second came into the world of his own accord (me making sure I didn’t go through the same issue again) healthy and no complications.

We have talked about a third but we are doing the wait and see approach to see how our oldest is after his first year at his new school and how our youngest handles his first year of reception next year in case something does come up.

AdditionalCharacter · 15/11/2021 20:08

My DS2 has autism, I was newly pregnant (unplanned) when he was diagnosed. We were told that any further siblings would have a 1:4 chance of having ASD if they were a boy and iirc 1:10 if they were a girl.

At my 20 week scan we found out baby was a boy. I winced as all I thought was the odds are against us, but the sonographer thought I was unhappy because of the sex and told me off.

DS3 does not have ASD.

RunningAtStuff · 15/11/2021 20:07

My eldest of three has ASD although he was diagnosed shortly after my third was born.
Yes, it’s challenging and affects the whole family but I like to think my younger two are more accepting of differences and better able to deal with conflict than they would be if they only had NT siblings. For my son with ASD, someone told us when he was diagnosed that having siblings was really positive for him and that has stuck with me. Yes, it’s challenging, there is shouting and aggression and there are times when I wish his siblings didn’t have to put up with that and I worry about the impact on them, but you deal with what’s in front of you and they love each other to bits and are so close in the good times

TurnUpTurnip · 15/11/2021 20:02

Yes I imagine lots of people had more before their kids were diagnosed or they even knew, I had two born a year apart so I didn’t know, I had 3 kids before she was diagnosed and yes it’s much harder as I imagine I could have put all my effort into her if I only had one, I am a lone parent and I struggle to take them out as I can’t manage them on my own and it’s a struggle having to look after everyone else including my daughter who needs 1:1 support, considering my daughters needs she ideally needs 1:1 and I can’t do that, being the oldest as well also makes it more difficult than if she was the youngest.

Londonwriter · 15/11/2021 19:57

It depends on the kid TBH. We have an autistic DS1 and a probably-neurotypical DS2. We’re preparing for fertility treatment to try to have a DC3.

My DS1 is probably gifted and, as his after-school carer says, he’s not disabled as much as he has an atypical learning style and needs extra support to find his place in the world. I didn’t realise he had ASD until he started having problems in group settings. Under those circumstances, there’s no reason I’d not want a DS3 (shrug).

23bumblebee · 15/11/2021 19:45

I guess we were quite early with the diagnosis. But it doesn't take away from the worry. I don't know DC would cope with another child and their demands or the noise. Or how I would manage if both had PDA. D
For you, do your kids play together?Do they understand each other's demands and needs? How do you cope?

OP posts: