Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why parents lie on social media?

103 replies

saveusernamee · 15/11/2021 13:34

It’s rife, maybe I live/have lived under a rock.

Only recently noticing however that all these cutesy pictures of babies and children and cute captions, having me looking at them thinking how have I lucked out so badly with how difficult I find child rearing?

Then you message them privately and it all pours out, all the same crap you’re going through. Why not say ‘this was the only time my child smiled today so I took a picture’ why say ‘the bestest, most magical day with my precious little smiler’ ?

Every time I post something realistic literally nobody, or maybe an adorning aunt/grand parent engages with it but you post a photo of essentially a lie and everyone and their dog engages. Why?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
saveusernamee · 15/11/2021 21:23

I found your second description more humorous bogof, I’d prefer to read that one because it would have made me laugh as I scrolled. Adding a bit of humour to the reflection changes it completely.

OP posts:
NerrSnerr · 15/11/2021 18:39

I don't live local to any family so put some photos on Facebook of my children. I try and put the nice ones up.

I wouldn't want them to know if I'm having a hard time for various reasons- many have their own, far worse struggles (and others it's none of their business). I don't do the whole 'feeling blessed' thing but may say we've had a nice weekend away and leave out bits about tantrums and lack of sleep.

BogRollBOGOF · 15/11/2021 18:20

None of this was put on SM at all but I went out for a meal yesterday. I could have posted either of the following:

Lovely post-race roast dinner with the family.

or

A saga about DS1's meltdown because he was over-hungry and how DS2 was left at the table while I took DS1 outside because nobody else in the restaurant wants to have their dinner ruined by a 10yo channeling Victor Meldrew crossed with Kevin the Teenager.

Both of which are true.
But which would be nicer to read, and which is more fair on DS1 to an audience who is mostly aquainted with him?

I don't go down the sickly hyperbole route of #bestmealever #makingmemories, nor dwelling on the negative.

I can be self deprecating or comment on the amusing slapstick end of fails. So I might share moments like how my (ironic) #winningatlife moment of getting the school t-shirts dry by 8:30am moment turned into crushing failure by 8:55 in the school playground when it turns out it was fancy-dress. But it would be done with humour and minimal FMAL.

It is honest. It is also edited for preserving the modicum of dignity that we cling on to Grin

saveusernamee · 15/11/2021 18:19

Chikapu I mean as a caption on a photo of me/the meal or whatever. That is what the poster was saying earlier.

Yeah maybe I need to unfollow or delete, that doesn’t really answer the question as to why some do frame things to make it look or seem different.

OP posts:
mindutopia · 15/11/2021 18:00

Everyone presents a different face on social media. My mum and I are NC. She refuses to speak to me. I've tried every possible approach to get her to engage (she won't speak to me because I don't support her choice of partner, he has a history of sexually abusing his own daughter). She posts all sorts of rubbish on social media about how much she loves her daughter and her grandchildren. In fact, behind the scenes, she hasn't seen her grandchildren in years (her friends all know this and know why) and she ignores any of my attempts to be in touch with her. In the past, there were times when we still talked when she would post all sorts of love and kisses shit all over my Facebook, while literally at the same time, messaging me about what a horrible person I am. Hmm People do want to present their best face to others, but some people just literally can't do anything but perform on social media, even when their lives are falling apart behind the scenes.

RiskyCookie · 15/11/2021 17:55

I like to think in quite honest in my posts. None of this blessed or making memories BS. It's relentless.

Social media is not a true reflection of anyone's life.

Chikapu · 15/11/2021 17:53

@saveusernamee

Is it being whiney to acknowledge the difficulties that lie behind a seemingly happy photo?

There obviously an issue because even on this thread some people say that sharing bad stuff is ‘real’ and other say it’s ‘oversharing’ so we’re not going to please everyone.

About the partner thing, if I’d had an argument with DH before an anniversary meal I’d still post yes of course, I’d say probably ‘anniversary meal’ or something boring like that. I wouldn’t… say how blessed I am to be able to call you my husband and how incredibly lucky I am to share life with you, our beautiful life our beautiful children blah blah
See what I mean?

I wouldn't say it's whiny I'd say it's uninteresting. Why would you even bother just posting 'anniversary meal' or something boring? Why is it yes of course I'd post if you're both sat there with a face like a smacked arse seething with each other? Just don't post.
Kite22 · 15/11/2021 17:45

if I’d had an argument with DH before an anniversary meal I’d still post yes of course, I’d say probably ‘anniversary meal’ or something boring like that. I wouldn’t… say how blessed I am to be able to call you my husband and how incredibly lucky I am to share life with you, our beautiful life our beautiful children blah blah

Well, that is more a reflection of who you are friends with on SM.
I am not friends with anyone who posts that sort of stuff.
Maybe other posters have also been answering from the same perspective as me.
I see friends post a nice photo of a meal out or a break away from home or day out or a family gathering, and I am pleased to see they have had a nice day. I don't see things like you have quoted there, so haven't been answering from that perspective.
Maybe, if it annoys you, then it is time to have a bit of a 'cull' of who you are friends with on SM ?

Gardeningcreature · 15/11/2021 17:36

I don’t do much in the way of social media. I don’t have many ‘friends’ on there. Even relatives I don’t have as friends.
I do however have lots of very real friends.

I too find it bizzare seeing posts about how much I love my darling other half, they are the best thing since sliced bread etc etc. yet these are the same people who know their oh has been shagging Laura from across the road.
Madness.

Abitlost2 · 15/11/2021 17:35

Yes, it's good to be positive and not to moan all the time but find it strange ( v v much where I am) to never admit to findng it hard at all.. Another example, a friend went on holidays, both dcs got ill, they had to stay in their campervan a lot as it was chicken pox but it was wonderful all the same and her dcs were just happy to look at the stars every night...a 2 and 3 year old....in a confined space , v sick... I said it must have been tough but no, not at all.
Maybe I am just.weak but I would find that v tricky..

PeppaNeedsToBeWrappedInBacon · 15/11/2021 17:34

Oh mine are usually “it took 25 attempts to get her to smile for this”

“Ignoring me again but having a great time” when she’s got her back turned to the camera.

“The only non-blurry photos I got all day. Does she ever stay still?!”

Always said with some jokey emojis because it’s the bitter sweet truth, my child is having too much of a good time to stop and smile for the camera. No point in sugar coating that online because realistically what child wants to stand posing for the perfect photo for 5 while minutes. I can think of several other things I’d rather do myself.

ESGdance · 15/11/2021 17:29

SM just ain’t for you.

It is what it is.

Save yourself the bother and come off it or restart with an edited list of like minded friends.

Abitlost2 · 15/11/2021 17:29

Even during lockdown where I know parents were trying to work.ft and had v young kids to look after, all I heard was how it was great to spend so much time together , I just didn't believe it tbh.. I remember once saying to my neighbour who had a baby same age as mine how wreaked I was and she looked surprised and said hers slept so well, they were so blessed etc etc. Her dh passes later and told me about how they werent getting a wink ( unprompted ).. I don't get it tbh

Abitlost2 · 15/11/2021 17:24

I generally love being a parent and adore my dcs but have had some v difficult times too. I totally get why not everyone likea to moan and its good to be positive but i feel i can never talk to anyone in rl about how hard I find it sometimes. I think its frowned upon ..

saveusernamee · 15/11/2021 17:18

Is it being whiney to acknowledge the difficulties that lie behind a seemingly happy photo?

There obviously an issue because even on this thread some people say that sharing bad stuff is ‘real’ and other say it’s ‘oversharing’ so we’re not going to please everyone.

About the partner thing, if I’d had an argument with DH before an anniversary meal I’d still post yes of course, I’d say probably ‘anniversary meal’ or something boring like that. I wouldn’t… say how blessed I am to be able to call you my husband and how incredibly lucky I am to share life with you, our beautiful life our beautiful children blah blah
See what I mean?

OP posts:
GTAlogic · 15/11/2021 16:48

I try to be real on facebook (the only social medium I post on apart from this) by sharing the fun and positive things I've done, either alone or with my family, and also sharing some of the mishaps such as when I almost got stuck in a flood or when I fell over in the mud trying to get a decent photo of a local landmark.

It's the same with the people who appear on my newsfeed in between all the adverts in that they mostly post the good things but occasionally also the annoying things.

Steelesauce · 15/11/2021 16:41

Me and my friend were talking about this today. Her sister in law posts lovely family nature walks with the kids in matching outfits. When reality is her and her husband have spent the last 6 months fighting and arguing because she slept with the neighbour Grin

Its all fake and if I didn't laugh, I'd be losing my rag with it. I've had men trying to message me then are tagged in their new baby announcements the next day. Its horrific.

Tilltheend99 · 15/11/2021 16:31

On the one hand I completely agree, and some people go much more over the too with this then other staging everything in the photo etc or some of the people I know will be wearing the same level of makeup I would wear to a wedding for a daytime selfy.

On the other hand many people use things like Instagram in the same way we used to make photo albums. Some times there would be joke photos but mostly people took them at special occasions or holidays with people posing or being told to smile. It is only because we have access to social media daily that we feel we should be daily sharing what we are up too and most people’s lives are mundane on a day to day basis.

I’m not a fan of fake it to you make it and am generally taking the picture of the giant rat I spotted in the street and getting zero interaction.

With regards to ‘my kid had a tantrum today’ I would find it a bit invasive of their privacy to be sharing a moment like that and not really fair to them.

MrsToothyBitch · 15/11/2021 16:23

Well I've only ever shared the highlights reel of life anyway really- in any form. Why share the crap? I keep bad news on a need to know basis and even if I tell quite a few people, it stays off socials. The only exception was when I wrecked my ankle joint and couldn't walk- easiest way to tell everyone I was out of action, and I still made the tone light so as not to seem moany.

Social media for me is the odd nice update or just nice pictures. To me, it really is a photo album, as Pp have said. Hence why I shared my very low key engagement announcement, last week but didn't share a single picture of the many days I spent signed off work in August, sobbing, having been with GAD and a panic problem. Barely anyone knows.

EnidFrighten · 15/11/2021 16:22

Social media feeds on your feelings of inadequacy, that's why.

Here's everyone else having a better life than you. Here are some ads for things that will give you a better life. We know all about you and what you need to be a fulfilled person (and it's not turning your screen off and having a nice walk in the park, it's much more expensive than that)

See how it works?

SerendipitySunshine · 15/11/2021 16:20

No-one likes a whinger.

Also, we filter and post the important stuff, and that stuff is generally positive.

toolazytothinkofausername · 15/11/2021 16:15

Social media: Editing your photos and your entire life to make it appear the most desirable.

This is why I am not on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter etc.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 15/11/2021 16:11

Whenever I see people constantly writing gushing posts about their husbands/partners (it's usually women who do this), I figure their relationship is on the rocks or a very depressing place for the poster. The few 'glimmers' of niceness they get they plaster all over FB, probably to try and make themselves feel better. Sad, really.

momtoboys · 15/11/2021 16:11

I don't think most people intentionally lie. I do think they only show the good bits. I struggled with child rearing too (may have had something to do with the fact that I had 5 kids in 4 years! LOL). It makes you feel like an outlier even before social media putting it in your face all day. Once, while talking to a wise elderly relative about my struggles she said "If any woman tells you that this is the best time in her life then she is a damn liar!" LOL. I don't believe that but I do have to say it made me feel somewhat better at the time.

Thwackit · 15/11/2021 16:05

Because people often keep their difficulties private? Because Facebook isn’t a counsellor’s office and all of their contacts are privy to different levels of info? Should they not be allowed to post any social posts except ones which are absolute transparent representations of the truth? I mean, if it was your birthday and you had an argument with your OP before, would you post a photo of you on your night out with a caption about how you may be smiling but inside you are upset? If you think they are fake and liars or this type of thing feels so false that it bothers you, unfollow them or leave Facebook.