Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my children to be treated as equals to dh sisters children?

183 replies

invisiblezara · 15/11/2021 11:46

Dh and I had a discussion last night over Christmas gifts and budget. When we got to talking about his Niece's and nephew he suggested we spend £25 on each of them which is what we have done ever since we got together some years ago. Now, I usually always agree to this budget and we usually get a few small gifts for each of them rather than one larger present worth £25.

My problem is that every year for Christmas and their birthdays we do so much for his Dsis children and she doesn't put any kind of effort in back for my children.
For example 4 times a year we visit dh sister for every one of her children's birthdays with loads of gifts and spend time down there with them all but my children don't even get a "happy birthday" from her.

I want to make things more fair, we definitely don't give to receive but even though they don't say anything I feel my children will begin to notice they are being treated differently just because they're not family by blood. They are not my dh's biological children and he doesn't have any of his own but we have been in the family long enough to know each other very well and spend a lot of time together.
My dc have absolutely no contact with their biological dad or any family from his side and know Dh's parents as their own grandparents.

This year I suggested we get each of her children a t-shirt from Primark as she does each year for my children. Dh at first thought I was being very unreasonable but then said he sort of understood where I was coming from, but now
I'm starting to doubt myself and feel like I maybe being petty? So I'd like your thoughts, am I being unreasonable? Should I just continue spending what we usually spend or should I match her Christmas gifts?
Of course we will still continue to buy for her children on their birthdays regardless of the fact she doesn't acknowledge mine.

OP posts:
Waahingwashingwashing · 15/11/2021 14:43

@CSJobseeker

I suspect he didn’t do multiple perfect gifts that he had to trail round town for and a balloon as well.

I suspect the same. But whatever it was that he would do if OP wasn't doing it for him - whether it's a voucher in a card or a special parade arranged in the child's honour - that's what he should do now.

Agree. The gift giving should be what it was before the op was on the scene.

She’s giving and feeling hurt because she wants reciprocation but that may not be the family gift style or what her DH or sister generally do. I have to say I think the op is on the makes a lot more effort than I do side of the house. I’ve never done that even for my own kids.

whistleryukon · 15/11/2021 14:43

It might not be anything to do with your DC not being related and more to do with your SIL just being rude/thoughtless? I know that I have relatives who don't bother saying happy birthday to my DC although I make an effort for their DC (and step DC's) birthdays.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/11/2021 14:42

Can you afford it and do the kids open their presents in front of each other?

If you cant afford it I'd say you are scaling back and get them a token (but scale back on all extended family otherwise you will look petty).

If the children are going to open presents infront of each other then I'd probably get your husband to say something along the lines of 'now the kids have started to notice the value of things and how much things cost we thought it would be a good idea to review gift giving as we don't want them to be asking awkward questions and spoil the atmosphere at christmas. Do you think we should set a budget for each child to make sure it seems fair to them going forward? Or do you think they've all got enough stuff and we should tell them we're having a cousins day out to x attraction in the new year instead'

If they dont open infront of each other and arent likely to see each other to talk about it, and you can afford it, I'd maybe just say nothing or scale back slightly, to keep the peace...or ask him to ask his parents to have a quiet word with them about hurting your kids feelings

Waahingwashingwashing · 15/11/2021 14:41

Thank you for your apology.

Your post was still rude though.

CSJobseeker · 15/11/2021 14:40

I suspect he didn’t do multiple perfect gifts that he had to trail round town for and a balloon as well.

I suspect the same. But whatever it was that he would do if OP wasn't doing it for him - whether it's a voucher in a card or a special parade arranged in the child's honour - that's what he should do now.

girlmom21 · 15/11/2021 14:39

@Waahingwashingwashing it's not rude to misunderstand. I apologise to both you and @CSJobseeker for that. But don't call me rude. How bizarre.

Waahingwashingwashing · 15/11/2021 14:37

@girlmom21 you’re wrong. That is not at all what I’m saying. Please don’t misrepresent what I said that’s rude.

I’m asking. What did he do before the op was on the scene. To get a sense of what their traditional gift giving was.

I suspect he didn’t do multiple perfect gifts that he had to trail round town for and a balloon as well.

LittleMysSister · 15/11/2021 14:35

If DH and his sis are close, I'd potentially nudge him to have a word with her and let her know that he regards your children as his and he'd like them to be treated as such.

BUT I'd only do this if there are other children in the family which she openly treats differently, as it may be that she's just crap with birthdays and presents and wouldn't be any different if they were your DH's bio kids.

girlmom21 · 15/11/2021 14:34

@CSJobseeker that's not what @Waahingwashingwashing is suggesting. She's suggesting DH might have done a lot more before me met OP and that SIL's kids might now be losing out by 'only' getting £25 each

CSJobseeker · 15/11/2021 14:32

@Waahingwashingwashing

What did your DH do for her kids before you got together?
I think this is a good question. Your DH should be taking the lead, and he should do the same as he would do if you and your kids weren't around.

If he was single, would he spend £25 and go round with a balloon? Or would he spend £25 and stick it in the post? Or would he just bung a voucher in a birthday card?

Needdoughnuts · 15/11/2021 14:30

Does sil know that her parents treat your dc like their own grandchildren? Also she may treat the rest of her nieces and nephews the same as your dc. If the rest of dh's family treated your children like sil does would you have been as upset? I'm just wondering if it's because there is a marked difference.

CSJobseeker · 15/11/2021 14:29

Am not in the camp that when someone marries an unmarried man then they will never become a relation to his sister nor his nieces and nephews.

They become related, yes, but it's not the same as a blood relationship because it has the potential to be temporary.

I've been with my DH for +20yrs, and I get on really well with his parents and siblings. I do think of them as family (and I hope they think of me that way too - they certainly always welcome me), but I'm under no illusion that if DH and I split, those relationships would almost certainly end with our marriage.

Whereas my dad or my sister will always be my dad or my sister, and nothing can ever change that. Whether we like it or not, there's a difference.

Tbh, I think the most likely explanation here is mismatched giving styles. What the OP describes (going over in person to give multiple presents and a balloon) sounds totally alien to me. Neither I nor any of my relatives have ever felt the need to do that for birthdays.

julieca · 15/11/2021 14:26

@Zilla1

Am not in the camp that when someone marries an unmarried man then they will never become a relation to his sister nor his nieces and nephews. I wonder what the default sequence in a family with several siblings of marriage and having children that previously would have meant family members become technically related to each other. And this prior to the 42% UK divorce with resulting increases in remarriage, step parenting and possible adoption which has caused social relations to evolve.
I dont think they will never become relations. But for me they don't become relations until I can say that if the couples split up, would I see the ex-partner and kids ever again? There are people in my extended family that the answer to this is yes. But they have been around for years. There are others that the answer is no. No-one has seen them for years.
LoveComesQuickly · 15/11/2021 14:26

I'm another person who invested a lot of energy into my brother's step daughter. I even taught her to ride a bike! And my parents did a lot for her too. Then my brother split up with her mum and I haven't seen her since. Whereas of course I would still see her if she was my brother's biological child. So that would make me a bit wary of doing the same thing again in similar circumstances. But at the same time, I can see that's not right either, because if my brother and his ex had stayed together it would have been sad and unfair to have kept his DSD at arm's length just in case of something that may never happen. So I guess I can look back and know I did the right thing, despite how things turned out in the end.

Fleur405 · 15/11/2021 14:26

I do get why you are annoyed but sounds to me like you and DH are a great aunt and uncle to the nieces/nephews. His sister, not so much, but I would just rise above it.

Waahingwashingwashing · 15/11/2021 14:25

What did your DH do for her kids before you got together?

LittleMysSister · 15/11/2021 14:23

I'd just cut down on what you're getting them. Send them a £10 voucher or something.

There's nothing you can do to make her 'better', but you can change your own behaviour so that it won't annoy you so much.

It likely has an extra sting because you know they are not blood family, but the reality is she might be just as crap if they were.

Zilla1 · 15/11/2021 14:21

Am not in the camp that when someone marries an unmarried man then they will never become a relation to his sister nor his nieces and nephews. I wonder what the default sequence in a family with several siblings of marriage and having children that previously would have meant family members become technically related to each other. And this prior to the 42% UK divorce with resulting increases in remarriage, step parenting and possible adoption which has caused social relations to evolve.

CSJobseeker · 15/11/2021 14:21

I'm not trying to push my ways on her at all. I was actually just hoping she may reciprocate some of the effort I put in for her dc each year.

Do you not see the contradiction in this?

If her approach is generally to give minimal gifts to her young relatives (I don't know if it is or not), then you and DH going over there with multiple gifts and balloons is OTT. You shouldn't give gifts for the reciprocation.

Whatinthelord · 15/11/2021 14:21

@CSJobseeker

If he's a man of measure he'll be pointing out to his DSis that he doesn't find her actions acceptable.

What if the DSis takes exactly the same approach with her biological young relatives?

It could just be miss-matched gift giving approaches. We don't know whether these children are singled out to receive cheaper gifts, or whether that's the norm for her.

This is what I’m thinking. I really don’t care about birthdays of extended family members or them acknowledging mine. They’re just not a bit thing to me. I thoughtful and kind in other ways. I’m just not into getting/giving gifts.n
aSofaNearYou · 15/11/2021 14:20

*I didn't say he is incapable of purchasing a few gifts for his family, I chose to do it because that's what works for us.

If I felt in any way put out by this I'm big enough to put my foot down and tell him to get his own!*

OP the very point is it doesn't work for you anymore, because it is making you resentful of how much effort you put in compared to her.

CSJobseeker · 15/11/2021 14:19

If he's a man of measure he'll be pointing out to his DSis that he doesn't find her actions acceptable.

What if the DSis takes exactly the same approach with her biological young relatives?

It could just be miss-matched gift giving approaches. We don't know whether these children are singled out to receive cheaper gifts, or whether that's the norm for her.

julieca · 15/11/2021 14:18

@invisiblezara Yes I understand you see your family role as Auntie. I am just saying that not everyone sees it that way. If you and DP split up the rest of the family would probably never see your kids again.

SunsetSmartmeter · 15/11/2021 14:16

OP, I'm posting in haste as I was just briefly grazing on Mumsnet but felt compelled to reply given some of the responses you've had.

This isn't about managing your emotions and you are not doing anything wrong either by being a SAHM and doing the present buying or having the response that you are having to your SIL's insensitivity/general unpleasantness.

I've been the step-child in this scenario and it's upsetting to think of it years later. Children know when they are being proactively excluded or devalued relative to others. I'd hand this to your DH. If he wants to carry on buying gifts he can but you and your children don't have to live with giving in the widest sense and being isolated in return. If he's a man of measure he'll be pointing out to his DSis that he doesn't find her actions acceptable.

Good luck with adoption if you decide to go for it. It seems to me that you and your children have escaped a violent ex/father and created a warm and loving family with a good man who recognises - as you do - that biology doesn't mean everything and can often mean nothing. All the best to you all.

Waahingwashingwashing · 15/11/2021 14:15

So you give to have reciprocated?

Swipe left for the next trending thread