Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls having to say when they have their period

341 replies

Cliff1975 · 15/11/2021 08:39

My daughter is 13, year 8. On friday she got into trouble for answering a teacher back and arguing (agree totally out of order). However, it was over asking to go to the toilet in PE, 5 minutes after lunch (although it was after they had changed so can't have been 5 minutes. Anyway it all escalated out of proportion but my question is this, is it reasonable for a teacher to say that if agirl says it is her time of the month she will be allowed to go if not no. I mean why should they have to share this? Ho will the teacher know if they are being truthful anyway? My daughter, who is no shrinking violet was mortified that the teacher ended up shouting this with about 5 teachers present. I have told her not to answer back, argue etc but I have to admit part of me is proud of her. Some girls would be mortified being asked if it is the time of the month. Honest opinions please. I was a teacher myself for 20 years so I know kids try it on to get out of lesson but is that worth humiliating girls for who are genuine? I can't help thinking this is a power tri p for the teacher.

OP posts:
Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 11:19

No teacher has the right to refuse. I don’t care how annoying it is trying to manage 30 kids toilet needs

Hmm
claymodels · 15/11/2021 11:19

Why ever not? If the teacher is not letting them go to the loo and they need to because they have literally just come on?

My dd has male teachers and has no issue with it and I doubt the male teachers do either!

Your DD is one person. Just the one. You cannot speak for all based on the experience of one. Even if we were to take one persons experience as the 'base' here we would take the person who doesn't want to discuss their bodily functions with a teacher. Because that's basic fucking humanity. Don't force everyone to share just because some are ok with it. It causes no harm not to discuss this but it caddies some harm to have to.

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 11:15

@mam0918

Pippi1970 - I'm sorry I didn't 'organise' my PCOS well enough for your liking, you'll be furious to know as an adult I have early stage kidney failure and I'm so lazy I don't take the magical time to fix that either.

Do you have any idea how fucking ignorant you sound - Imagine being lucky enough to not have a disability then belittling those who do by claiming its their fault for not being organised enough ffs.

Oh don't be silly.
SomePosters · 15/11/2021 11:15

Literally one of the reasons I home Ed

Imagine raising your kid to believe they need permission to use the toilet or that no is an acceptable answer.
Grim!

I don’t want my kid to learn to deprioritise their body and needs like this.

My mum took the attitude (as someone said above) when I was at school that you ask politely once and then go regardless of the answer and she will pick up the flak after.

I would suggest you do the same op

Access to toilet facilites is a human right.

Children are humans.

No teacher has the right to refuse. I don’t care how annoying it is trying to manage 30 kids toilet needs (which I accept is a nightmare) bit that doesn’t mean you get to take away a childs basic right to empty bladder and bowels as required.

Tittyfilarious81 · 15/11/2021 11:15

@claymodels we shall just have to disagree ,as someone who had horrendous heavy periods and accidents because of not being allowed to go in lessons I wish something had been in place to just let me go instead of having to ask to be told no it would have helped so maybe that's why I don't think they are a bad thing . I do think everyone should be able to go the toilet when they want but the truth is in schools if they allowed that there would be a constant flow of kids in and out of class and there would be loads of disruption in the lessons

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 11:14

[quote DameMaureen]@Pippi1970

There is no question that some girls use it as an excuse to get out of lessons. Otherwise speak to the teacher about it. The OP was saying that her dd shouldn't have to even say she had her period which seems very paranoid

A young girl should have to tell a teacher she has her period - female and male teacher ?[/quote]
Why ever not? If the teacher is not letting them go to the loo and they need to because they have literally just come on? My dd has male teachers and has no issue with it and I doubt the male teachers do either!

mam0918 · 15/11/2021 11:14

Pippi1970 - I'm sorry I didn't 'organise' my PCOS well enough for your liking, you'll be furious to know as an adult I have early stage kidney failure and I'm so lazy I don't take the magical time to fix that either.

Do you have any idea how fucking ignorant you sound - Imagine being lucky enough to not have a disability then belittling those who do by claiming its their fault for not being organised enough ffs.

DameMaureen · 15/11/2021 11:12

@Pippi1970

There is no question that some girls use it as an excuse to get out of lessons. Otherwise speak to the teacher about it. The OP was saying that her dd shouldn't have to even say she had her period which seems very paranoid

A young girl should have to tell a teacher she has her period - female and male teacher ?

SickAndTiredAgain · 15/11/2021 11:11

Well, I was told there was “something wrong” with me because I had an 8 day period

We had a science teacher (specialism of biology) who used to mark in his register when girls used this reason. So if it was used again he could look it up and say “no, you used this excuse x days ago, can’t be on your period again.”
I’m assuming he based this on a purely average cycle of 5 days of bleeding every 28 days. Tough luck if you didn’t fall within that.

KurtWilde · 15/11/2021 11:10

Going for a wee before a lesson seems like a pretty basic standard of life skills. Luckily most kids seem to have worked this out

That's great, if there's room in the toilet at that time. But with the entire school all having to schedule their bladder habits in during the same small window, it's not always doable is it.

And OPs daughter came on AFTER they'd gone back to class after lunch. How exactly would she have known to put a sanitary product in during lunch if she didn't know she was coming on just yet?

Everyone should be allowed use of the toilet when they require it, that's the bottom line really, and they shouldn't have to advertise why.

GaolBhoAlba · 15/11/2021 11:09

Complain about the teacher, in writing, to the school. And escalate the complaint if you're not happy with the school's response.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 11:07

[quote Tittyfilarious81]@claymodels it's not that I'm defending it but without a pass the teacher can and does say no my son has never been allowed other than after her was sick in class 1 time because he wasn't allowed to go , pass means they can't refuse . I honestly didn't think that it was something so many people would be upset about it's just something that was brought in to try and help stop any upsetting incidents[/quote]

You definitely are defending it. What's more it's worthless and pointless as you don't actually need a reason to get one Confused

mam0918 · 15/11/2021 11:06
  • sorry think I quoted the wrong reply
PurBal · 15/11/2021 11:06

Well, I was told there was “something wrong” with me because I had an 8 day period and didn’t want to go swimming in year 8. I duly saw a doctor after pestering my mum and (surprise) all normal. I didn’t use tampons at the time. Some girls were forced to use tampons by the teacher (handed a tampon and teacher stopped outside toilet explaining how to put it in). It was humiliating and “there must be something wrong” stayed with me until I was 21 and I paid to see a gynaecologist. Girls should not be shamed due to their period.

mam0918 · 15/11/2021 11:05

@claymodels

No not lucky. I just go to the loo during breaks. It’s not rocket science.

Just as well really because anyone who can't understand that we are not all the same as them sure ain't going to be breaking record as a rocket scientist.

I am exceptionally lucky in the fact that I next to never get heavy or painful periods.

The problem is though its a trade-off as I have Atypical PCOS (worth mentioning Atypical because the number of times people accuse me of lying because I don't fit the ignorant incorrect outdated stereotype is ridiculous) and my periods are COMPLETELY unpredictable.

I can have a period anywhere from 17 days to 60 days after my last one and because they don't hurt I have zero warning they are coming... its impossible to rely on scheduled breaks because my body doesn't have a schedule.

You don't get to judge or accuse others of lying just because you have it easy than them - The same way I don't tell girls they are 'faking' being in pain just because I'm not.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 11:05

@Pippi1970

Sorry - do you think bodily autonomy is stupid?

Oh dear. No, of course I don't. Have you not read any of my posts? I'm literally advocating for just that Confused

C152 · 15/11/2021 11:04

I've read a few of these type of threads recently and I can't believe how ridiculous schools are about letting kids go to the toilet. What do they want? Kids to wet themselves in class? And why should a girl have to tell anyone she has her period? I have read some teachers saying there are kids who use going to the toilet as an excuse to get out of class, but surely it's better to err on the side of the child telling the truth in this instance? I don't think anyone should have to explain exactly why they need to go to the toilet; saying 'may I got to the toilet please' is enough! It's self explanatory FFS! And if it's the same child asking to go to the toilet several times during the lesson, or always in the same lesson, then if I were the teacher, I would be calling the parents to voice a concern over the issue, not making other children suffer.

Lorw · 15/11/2021 11:02

I understand in a way why they restrict toilet access to be fair. At my school people were abused and jumped in the toilets regularly as there were no cameras, drugs regularly taken, destruction (yes even in the girls toilets-pads, period blood everywhere, flooding being the worst and then the toilets would be completely out of use which was horrific). I also think everyone should have access to a toilet when they need it, male or female, I don’t know what the solution is, maybe schools should have a toilet monitor at all times?

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 11:02

@KurtWilde

Sorry - do you think bodily autonomy is stupid?

Body autonomy would be the student being able to go to the toilet when required. Something you don't think they should be able to do.

Body autonomy ISN'T knowing the exact moment of the day when you'll start your period. And even if it was, it would STILL have been 5 minutes into the lesson unless you've found some way of controlling when you come on??

Going for a wee before a lesson seems like a pretty basic standard of life skills. Luckily most kids seem to have worked this out.
KurtWilde · 15/11/2021 11:01

Sorry - do you think bodily autonomy is stupid?

Body autonomy would be the student being able to go to the toilet when required. Something you don't think they should be able to do.

Body autonomy ISN'T knowing the exact moment of the day when you'll start your period. And even if it was, it would STILL have been 5 minutes into the lesson unless you've found some way of controlling when you come on??

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 11:01

@Bookworm20

As they are older perhaps being organised with their own bodies is important too.

Are you for real?

Do you schedule your periods in on your calendar so you know exactly what time of day you will come on and can plan it around your schedule? And your coffee breaks?

You must be very lucky having that ability. Because I remember being a teenage girl with irregular periods and had no clue from one minute to the next when I might actually come on.

There is no question that some girls use it as an excuse to get out of lessons. Otherwise speak to the teacher about it. The OP was saying that her dd shouldn't have to even say she had her period which seems very paranoid.
CecilieRose · 15/11/2021 11:00

@SickAndTiredAgain

What about women who want equal rights at work but then say they’ll have to keep missing meetings because they’re women and have periods? If you were the employer would you wish you’d just hired a man?

Urgh these women and their rights. They expect equal rights but then have a baby and go on mat leave - much better to hire a man!
There was a thread on here the other week where the OP was worried about going back to work after mat leave because since giving birth she’d been having incidences of awful flooding without warning and going through any protection she had. Maybe she should just quit work forever.

I had a (female) colleague tell me I should just give up work for the rest of my life because I needed a single day off work for a colonoscopy when I was 27. In her mind that meant I was just unsuitable for work and such massive accommodations put too much of a burden on everyone else. One single day off work. She kept going on about why I couldn't just take the afternoon off because it was an afternoon appointment, when I was on laxatives to make me shit every half an hour and hadn't been able to eat since the previous afternoon.

Some people are just vile and unhinged.

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 10:59

@claymodels

As they are older perhaps being organised with their own bodies is important too.

Do you have any idea how absolutely fucking stupid you sound?

Sorry - do you think bodily autonomy is stupid?
Tittyfilarious81 · 15/11/2021 10:58

@claymodels it's not that I'm defending it but without a pass the teacher can and does say no my son has never been allowed other than after her was sick in class 1 time because he wasn't allowed to go , pass means they can't refuse . I honestly didn't think that it was something so many people would be upset about it's just something that was brought in to try and help stop any upsetting incidents

Bookworm20 · 15/11/2021 10:58

As they are older perhaps being organised with their own bodies is important too.

Are you for real?

Do you schedule your periods in on your calendar so you know exactly what time of day you will come on and can plan it around your schedule? And your coffee breaks?

You must be very lucky having that ability. Because I remember being a teenage girl with irregular periods and had no clue from one minute to the next when I might actually come on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread