Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls having to say when they have their period

341 replies

Cliff1975 · 15/11/2021 08:39

My daughter is 13, year 8. On friday she got into trouble for answering a teacher back and arguing (agree totally out of order). However, it was over asking to go to the toilet in PE, 5 minutes after lunch (although it was after they had changed so can't have been 5 minutes. Anyway it all escalated out of proportion but my question is this, is it reasonable for a teacher to say that if agirl says it is her time of the month she will be allowed to go if not no. I mean why should they have to share this? Ho will the teacher know if they are being truthful anyway? My daughter, who is no shrinking violet was mortified that the teacher ended up shouting this with about 5 teachers present. I have told her not to answer back, argue etc but I have to admit part of me is proud of her. Some girls would be mortified being asked if it is the time of the month. Honest opinions please. I was a teacher myself for 20 years so I know kids try it on to get out of lesson but is that worth humiliating girls for who are genuine? I can't help thinking this is a power tri p for the teacher.

OP posts:
claymodels · 15/11/2021 13:17

@Marvellousmadness

Let's be fair here She should have gone during lunch

Also why are there so many pps talking about shame and it being "too personal" when it comes to disclosing your period.

Why tf is this still taboo and why are Daughters still raised like having your period is something you should hide and be ashamed of :(

It's not taboo. It's absolutely wrong to lay the responsibility of normalising periods on the young teens in schools who are just learning about their own bodies themselves though.

Tittyfilarious81 · 15/11/2021 13:15

@claymodels in our high school any pupil the needd to leave a classroom for any reason needss a teachers pass to show that they aren't out of lesson without permission . Tutor pass toilet without question

Marvellousmadness · 15/11/2021 13:14

Let's be fair here
She should have gone during lunch

Also why are there so many pps talking about shame and it being "too personal" when it comes to disclosing your period.

Why tf is this still taboo and why are Daughters still raised like having your period is something you should hide and be ashamed of :(

claymodels · 15/11/2021 13:09

@Laiste

The reason i feel the pass is a step in the right direction is because it's introduction shows that someone in the school is taking notice of the fact that some teachers are routinely saying no and that that is wrong.

One would hope that they will eventually move on again, this time to a more progressive attitude which allows toilet breaks within a structure which stops piss taking by the few.

The pass would not be what i would want to see as an end game.

What i would like to see for starters is the teachers who routinely refuse permission being made to disclose their personal medical details to anyone who says they need to know and then sit in their own mess for a couple of hours.

I do understand what you are saying, however a verbal 'let them go to the toilet if they ask' is every bit as understandable to an adult teacher as a pass is.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 13:07

@Tittyfilarious81

The only reason I am finding it hard to understand is your posts don't explain it very well. You have contradicted yourself and when that was pointed out you added in another pass. I don't even want to understand anymore.

Tittyfilarious81 · 15/11/2021 13:04

@claymodels if you need a pass that lets you go without question it is a tutor pass. Every student who leaves a classroom must have the class teachers pass to say they have permission to be out of the lesson it's really not hard to understand eg girl starts period before school feels shitty so asks tutor can I have a day pass she's given it can go the toilet when she needs no questions. Boy needs the toilet asks teacher can he go gets lucky and he can he uses the class teacher pass to go it's really not hard to understand , you also need the teacher pass to leave the classroom if you a running an errand

Laiste · 15/11/2021 12:51

The reason i feel the pass is a step in the right direction is because it's introduction shows that someone in the school is taking notice of the fact that some teachers are routinely saying no and that that is wrong.

One would hope that they will eventually move on again, this time to a more progressive attitude which allows toilet breaks within a structure which stops piss taking by the few.

The pass would not be what i would want to see as an end game.

What i would like to see for starters is the teachers who routinely refuse permission being made to disclose their personal medical details to anyone who says they need to know and then sit in their own mess for a couple of hours.

KurtWilde · 15/11/2021 12:48

Teacher pass is given to anyone who is lucky enough to get the teacher to say yes

So they have to tell the teacher why they need it and plead their case, just to use the toilet? Or am I misunderstanding?

claymodels · 15/11/2021 12:47

@Tittyfilarious81

Pass by tutor is given to anyone who needs it . Teacher pass is given to anyone who is lucky enough to get the teacher to say yes
Oh so now you have 2 kinds of pass Confused

Goodness. There is no sense to be had here.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 12:46

[quote Tittyfilarious81]@claymodels of course it has to be given to anyone who needs it can you imagine if it was just girls it's not chopping and changing it's just how it is and it's mostly girls who need it for periods[/quote]
I didn't differentiate between boys and girls. My issue is that you do not seem to know whether the pupil has to tell the tutor why they need a pass.

Tittyfilarious81 · 15/11/2021 12:43

Pass by tutor is given to anyone who needs it . Teacher pass is given to anyone who is lucky enough to get the teacher to say yes

Tittyfilarious81 · 15/11/2021 12:41

@claymodels of course it has to be given to anyone who needs it can you imagine if it was just girls it's not chopping and changing it's just how it is and it's mostly girls who need it for periods

claymodels · 15/11/2021 12:38

[quote Laiste]**@claymodels i'm totally on the 'let kids use the loo when they need to' side. (X TA, i always let kids go to the loo when they asked).

But what Tittyfilarious81 has said is that there are some teachers who would always say no and the passes stop them being able to say no.

Personally i think the teachers who routinely refuse should be taken to task, rather than making the kids get a 'toilet pass' to get round them. But i guess it's step in the right direction?[/quote]

I know what they are saying, it just chips and changes a bit to suit. The pass is given to people who need it, the pass is given to anyone, the pass is given to those who need it - there is little consistency in the posts which are essentially defending the use of what seems to be a useless pass.

I don't think a pass is a step in the right direction at all, it's just another way to exercise control over children using the toilet, done at a different level.

spudjulia · 15/11/2021 12:31

Secondary school teacher and only this last year (following a thread on MN) did I start to think - hang on, it's not right to deny a teenager (or anyone) the right to go to the loo. Ten or 20 years ago I'd have told you that teenagers take the piss, that they arrange to meet their mates in the loo, that they're places where safeguarding can be an issue (bullying, sexual assaults, drug taking etc), and it's always the same kids who ask, who just want to get out of doing work and getting up to no good.

But now I think that the issue is that schools can't adequately protect children if they go to the toilet in the middle of the lesson. There are no staff to supervise because they're all in lessons. As a teacher I was used to not drinking so that I didn't have to go to the loo all day, or I'd have to hold it all day. With periods I spent time really worried I'd flooded, or stained the back of my clothes and it was really awkward and unhealthy at times.

Laiste · 15/11/2021 12:28

@claymodels i'm totally on the 'let kids use the loo when they need to' side. (X TA, i always let kids go to the loo when they asked).

But what Tittyfilarious81 has said is that there are some teachers who would always say no and the passes stop them being able to say no.

Personally i think the teachers who routinely refuse should be taken to task, rather than making the kids get a 'toilet pass' to get round them. But i guess it's step in the right direction?

Doggydreaming · 15/11/2021 12:22

Yanbu. It doesn't matter if it was only 5 minites into the lesson. Maybe she was stretvhing/warming up and her tampon/pad started to become unsecured? Perhaps she had a sudden heavy gush. Perhaps she didn't have time to go at lunch because there was a queue for food/she had a lunch time activity to attend etc. Who knows? One of my friends had a miscarriage in a PE lesson at school. Can you imagine if the teacher hadn't let her go? You know what will really disrupt a lesson - even more than someone popping to the loo? The teacher making a song and dance about the situation and dragging other teachers into the debacle!

claymodels · 15/11/2021 12:18

[quote Tittyfilarious81]@claymodels You seem so annoyed about it but in the secondary school my children are in there is no issue with it if even 1 parent said I'm not happy about it they would say fine everyone asks and if told no tough ,they were brought in because parents were upset that their daughters were being refused the toilet when they were on a period .[/quote]

But if anyone can get a pass this makes no sense? Don't you see how contradictory your comments are? And now you say without a pass they may be told they can't go to the toilet?

I'm annoyed about passes in general, yes, because going to the toilet is a basic human right.

Tittyfilarious81 · 15/11/2021 12:14

@claymodels You seem so annoyed about it but in the secondary school my children are in there is no issue with it if even 1 parent said I'm not happy about it they would say fine everyone asks and if told no tough ,they were brought in because parents were upset that their daughters were being refused the toilet when they were on a period .

claymodels · 15/11/2021 12:11

@Pippi1970

If there's repeated vandalism then what other choice did they have Confused

Deal with the issue of vandalism by not punishing innocent pupils who need to use the facilities Confused

I'm struggling to take you seriously at this point. Your posts on this thread display a real worrying attitude.

ChloeCrocodile · 15/11/2021 12:08

If there's repeated vandalism then what other choice did they have

  1. Actually deal with the behaviour problems across the school. Kids don't just decide to vandalise the toilets in isolation. They push boundaries and when they can get away with "low level" poor behaviour it escalates.
  2. Ask teachers to keep a list of students let out of lessons so that the list of potential suspects is low.
  3. Have a key available at the office for students with a real need.
  4. Put CCTV in the toilet corridors so that they can identify suspects.
Laiste · 15/11/2021 12:07

I get that it seems daft that you can get a pass without giving a reason. It makes the pass seems pointless.

However Tittyfilarious81 has said that the point of the passes is in fact to stop certain teachers saying no.

Awful really, that that is necessary.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 12:03

@Lavender1974

Thank you so very much

claymodels · 15/11/2021 12:01

[quote Tittyfilarious81]@claymodels apologies what I meant is if a girl goes to her tutor in the morning and asks for a pass that day the teacher won't ask her which reason she needs it .[/quote]

Tbh I don't think you know what you are saying at all...

in our secondary school the girls if they are on a period tell their tutor in the morning they need a toilet pass that day

you can also ask for a pass if you feel poorly

you can get them for other reasons

These comments indicate they have to tell the tutor why they need the pass

They don't have to tell the tutor though it's a simple case of saying you need a pass that day they don't ask why

This contradicts the above and now you say they do need to tell?

I have no idea what it is now but the idea that anyone needs a pas to use a toilet is ridiculous.

Laiste · 15/11/2021 11:58

@Pippi1970

If there's repeated vandalism then what other choice did they have Confused
All your responses are so bizarre Pippi1970.

Another choice would be not to lock the loos and find a way to deal with the vandalism issue.

CannaeRemember · 15/11/2021 11:52

@Lavender1974 You sound like a lovely teacher, thank you for being understanding and thoughtful. Flowers

Swipe left for the next trending thread