Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls having to say when they have their period

341 replies

Cliff1975 · 15/11/2021 08:39

My daughter is 13, year 8. On friday she got into trouble for answering a teacher back and arguing (agree totally out of order). However, it was over asking to go to the toilet in PE, 5 minutes after lunch (although it was after they had changed so can't have been 5 minutes. Anyway it all escalated out of proportion but my question is this, is it reasonable for a teacher to say that if agirl says it is her time of the month she will be allowed to go if not no. I mean why should they have to share this? Ho will the teacher know if they are being truthful anyway? My daughter, who is no shrinking violet was mortified that the teacher ended up shouting this with about 5 teachers present. I have told her not to answer back, argue etc but I have to admit part of me is proud of her. Some girls would be mortified being asked if it is the time of the month. Honest opinions please. I was a teacher myself for 20 years so I know kids try it on to get out of lesson but is that worth humiliating girls for who are genuine? I can't help thinking this is a power tri p for the teacher.

OP posts:
claymodels · 15/11/2021 16:07

@ChloeCrocodile

It's a basic human right to be able to use a toilet when you need to.

As I said upthread, I'm really anti draconian toilet policies in school. It may be wrong and counter productive to learning to prevent children going to the toilet, but is doesn't breech human rights ffs. Some workplaces limit toilet access too. Teaching, for instance. Bus driving. Some call centres (including government ones).

Actually the UK government does 'recognise sanitation as a human right under international law'

ChloeCrocodile · 15/11/2021 15:48

It's a basic human right to be able to use a toilet when you need to.

As I said upthread, I'm really anti draconian toilet policies in school. It may be wrong and counter productive to learning to prevent children going to the toilet, but is doesn't breech human rights ffs. Some workplaces limit toilet access too. Teaching, for instance. Bus driving. Some call centres (including government ones).

Sweetandsaltycaroline · 15/11/2021 15:12

So do you keep your dd at home when she has a period then?

Hmm No I don't. But I'm trying to explain that while periods are not something to be ashamed of its understandable that they can cause embarrassment.
claymodels · 15/11/2021 15:02

Oh yes, I see a typo, that makes more sense.

Now, what on earth are you talking about?

Even with the typo I haven't said that.

I have said, consistently, that pupils should not have to explain why they need the toilet not should such a request be refused.

I am realise that some people, like your daughter, don't mind mentioning their periods. The issue is you can't realise that some girls don't feel ok to do that. We covered this absolutely ages ago though so I'm not sure why you are raising the same issue?

claymodels · 15/11/2021 14:59

@Pippi1970

It's just claymodels opinion that periods must be mentioned. Others have different opinions, including my dds.

What on earth are you talking about?

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 14:58

*Must Not be mentioned!

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 14:58

It's just claymodels opinion that periods must be mentioned. Others have different opinions, including my dds.

Pippi1970 · 15/11/2021 14:56

@Sweetandsaltycaroline

At home, me or DD have leaked onto the bedding or a cushion, and just put the stained item in to soak and given it a wash etc, had a shower, got changed, no probs . It would be a lot more embarrassing if it had happened at school or a seat on public transport, or at work, or visiting a friends house because it draws attention, and then feel less in control than in a home environment, when I can easily sort out any "period dramas" as we refer to them, without an audience.
So do you keep your dd at home when she has a period then?
Sweetandsaltycaroline · 15/11/2021 14:52

At home, me or DD have leaked onto the bedding or a cushion, and just put the stained item in to soak and given it a wash etc, had a shower, got changed, no probs . It would be a lot more embarrassing if it had happened at school or a seat on public transport, or at work, or visiting a friends house because it draws attention, and then feel less in control than in a home environment, when I can easily sort out any "period dramas" as we refer to them, without an audience.

Terfydactyl · 15/11/2021 14:47

@Tittyfilarious81

As I've said a few times now it was introduced because of understandable upset from the girls ,nobody is allowed to go to the toilet during lessons there are ample toilets and plenty of opportunities during the day to go but obviously on a period girls may need to go at other times . The pass is not just for periods it doesn't mean period, there are several reasons for the pass period , tummy ache ,feeling unwell ,water infection etc some boys have them also but very few so nobody goes oh look she's on a period .
Oh phew, that's just fine then. If it's not a period its something equally as private.

For the record back in the 80s when I was at school I never drank anything. Because of these stupid draconian rules. I always got home almost pissing myself such was my dislike of the girls toilets.

As a knock on effect I have fuck all bladder control, now when I need to go theres no waiting.

You would hope in the intervening years an actual solution would have been found, but it appears many more girls will grow up with similar issues.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 14:44

@Harriet1216

:34claymodels

It is a lack of critical thinking. A huge lack.
So, no proper answer then? You really can't give me a reason why you think it's humiliating if others know that a girl is on her period, can you?

There's no reason to engage with you any further.

I could spend all day explaining this but it would be futile.

Whatinthelord · 15/11/2021 14:43

@Harriet1216 if you were in a work meeting would you say “ I’m going to the toilet” or would you specify what you’re doing in there “I need to defecate”, “I need to urinate” or “ I need to change my sanitary towel”.

Harriet1216 · 15/11/2021 14:41

:34claymodels

It is a lack of critical thinking. A huge lack.
So, no proper answer then? You really can't give me a reason why you think it's humiliating if others know that a girl is on her period, can you?

There's no reason to engage with you any further.

KurtWilde · 15/11/2021 14:39

@Harriet1216 Young girls have a right to basic privacy over what's happening with their bodies. It's really as simple as that.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 14:34

Yes, I am absolutely unable to see why it's a problem if others know that a girl is on their period.

Please explain why you think it's such a problem, instead of lamely repeating that it's somehow a lack of critical thinking.

It is a lack of critical thinking. A huge lack.

Harriet1216 · 15/11/2021 14:31

It is a you problem. You have said you are unable to understand why it can be a problem. That's quite a huge part of thinking ability to be lacking. It's defo you.
Yes, I am absolutely unable to see why it's a problem if others know that a girl is on their period. Please explain why you think it's such a problem, instead of lamely repeating that it's somehow a lack of critical thinking.
Where exactly is the problem for a girl? Girls have periods - everyone knows this. Why is it so apparently 'humiliating' if someone finds out?
Are these shrinking violets equally 'humiliated' if the rest of the class knows they need a wee, or a poo? Somehow I don't think so. Why is a period any different?
I also agree with the poster who pointed out that it's very disruptive for the whole class if more than one child needs the toilet during lessons. Children, even teens, are prone to copycat behaviour, and multiple children asking to go to the toilet can quickly escalate into a discipline problem for the teacher.

KurtWilde · 15/11/2021 14:30

I can't understand why there appear to be so many girls who are frightened of anyone knowing they are on their period. What are the terrible consequences?

I'm assuming you weren't bullied at school? If some of the nastier kids in class - girls and boys - knew someone was on their period they'd make their lives hell for a week. "Watch she doesn't bleed all over you.."

This is why so many girls don't want others to know they're on their period - that, and the fact that it's nobodies business but their own.

I certainly don't tell my clients I need to go change my sanitary product during a meeting, not because I'm ashamed but because it would be just fucking awkward for everyone there Confused

Whatinthelord · 15/11/2021 14:30

@Chasingaftermidnight

I can't understand why there appear to be so many girls who are frightened of anyone knowing they are on their period.

I don’t know what you do for work, but would you be 100% comfortable telling 30 of your colleagues and your boss that you were on your period?

I definitely wouldn’t.

No one would. Anyone who says they do is talking bs. Also none is specifying for others (Otherthan maybe in their intimate relationship) what bodily function they doing in the bathroom either. We’re not all horrifically embarrassed of people knowing we’re having a wee. We just don’t need to justify the specific bodily function we’re exercising in the toilet.
Chasingaftermidnight · 15/11/2021 14:24

I can't understand why there appear to be so many girls who are frightened of anyone knowing they are on their period.

I don’t know what you do for work, but would you be 100% comfortable telling 30 of your colleagues and your boss that you were on your period?

I definitely wouldn’t.

bellsbuss · 15/11/2021 14:23

I've always told my children that if they need to go to the toilet and get told no then to just walk out and go. It's a basic human right to be able to use a toilet when you need to.

claymodels · 15/11/2021 14:18

@Harriet1216

11claymodels

I can't understand why there appear to be so many girls who are frightened of anyone knowing they are on their period.

That's a you problem.
No, actually it isn't. And you're not telling me why you think it's a problem if others know that a girl is on her period. Just saying 'it's a you problem' is no answer at all.

It is a you problem. You have said you are unable to understand why it can be a problem. That's quite a huge part of thinking ability to be lacking. It's defo you.

Harriet1216 · 15/11/2021 14:16

11claymodels

I can't understand why there appear to be so many girls who are frightened of anyone knowing they are on their period.

That's a you problem.
No, actually it isn't. And you're not telling me why you think it's a problem if others know that a girl is on her period. Just saying 'it's a you problem' is no answer at all.

TheLastLonelyBakedBean · 15/11/2021 14:14

I hate school toilet Policy like this so much. I had chronic cystitis, hormonal diarrhoea and menorrhagia (heavy bleeding) as a teenager and school toilet Policy like this made my life hell. I used to walk out and deal with the repercussions, but I was often in trouble for it. I can't believe we haven't moved on, and that teenage girls still either feel too embarrassed or ashamed to vocalise their toiletting needs, or if they do the teacher uses it to humiliate them. You shouldn't need evidence that you need the toilet. Anyone can have sudden bout of diarrhoea, any menstruating girl or women can suddenly flood. Anybody can get a UTI. Anyone can misjudge whether they need the toilet or not, or drink too much on their lunch and need to go when they didn't 10 minutes before.

ancientgran · 15/11/2021 14:13

I used to volunteer at a local primary school, doing 1 to 1 reading with kids in year 5 and 6 who needed some support. I was often amazed at the procession of 10 and 11 year old who would need to go to the loo twice in the 90 minutes I was there, week after week. I used to wonder how the teacher kept their patience with the endless disruptions.

I had to pull GS up on the same thing, 16 year old and no sooner would an online lesson start than he'd disappear to the loo, only to do the same with the next lesson. I pointed out that he was fooling no one and he'd better up his game.

Like so many things the genuine ones suffer for the ones who take the mickey.

Whatinthelord · 15/11/2021 14:13

@Harriet1216

:17claymodels

Marvellousmadness

Let's be fair here
She should have gone during lunch

Also why are there so many pps talking about shame and it being "too personal" when it comes to disclosing your period.

Why tf is this still taboo and why are Daughters still raised like having your period is something you should hide and be ashamed of sad

It's not taboo. It's absolutely wrong to lay the responsibility of normalising periods on the young teens in schools who are just learning about their own bodies themselves though.

Well done for saying so Marvellous.
I can't understand why there appear to be so many girls who are frightened of anyone knowing they are on their period. What are the terrible consequences?

I know people are going to say, 'oh, but it's private don't y'know.'

Well, having a wee is an equally private matter but apparently it doesn't matter if the whole class gets to know about it.

Such an odd comment. Adults, even those not embarrassed by menstration don’t give details of their bodily functions to groups of other adults they barely know.

There’d be no consequences from me telling people I’m off for a shit. Still I just say “ I need the loo” as does everyone else I know.

If you left an important meeting would you say “ I’m just popping to the toilet” or “ I’m having a heavy menstration and need to change my sanitary towel”.