Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Girls having to say when they have their period

341 replies

Cliff1975 · 15/11/2021 08:39

My daughter is 13, year 8. On friday she got into trouble for answering a teacher back and arguing (agree totally out of order). However, it was over asking to go to the toilet in PE, 5 minutes after lunch (although it was after they had changed so can't have been 5 minutes. Anyway it all escalated out of proportion but my question is this, is it reasonable for a teacher to say that if agirl says it is her time of the month she will be allowed to go if not no. I mean why should they have to share this? Ho will the teacher know if they are being truthful anyway? My daughter, who is no shrinking violet was mortified that the teacher ended up shouting this with about 5 teachers present. I have told her not to answer back, argue etc but I have to admit part of me is proud of her. Some girls would be mortified being asked if it is the time of the month. Honest opinions please. I was a teacher myself for 20 years so I know kids try it on to get out of lesson but is that worth humiliating girls for who are genuine? I can't help thinking this is a power tri p for the teacher.

OP posts:
LaDamaDeElche · 16/11/2021 21:01

@Smileyaxolotl1

*clay models’ are you a teacher? If there was no restriction on toilets I would have about 3 kids in the class most of the time.
I am a teacher and I let people to to the toilet if they need it. I haven't had a problem anyone taking the piss. I think the rules about toilet breaks in U.K. schools are pretty draconian actually.
WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 16/11/2021 20:44

Omg my OP thats terrible! I can't believe teachers are still doing this, when you've gotta go you've gotta go.

Something similar happened to me in school when I was 14. I came on and I suffered and still do with heavy periods so it was a bit messy sorry to be graphic. I asked my head of year if I could go home and change (I lived 15 minutes from the school and I would have come back) and her reply to me was "just turn your knickers inside out" 😲😲 I was very shy back then and I would never have dared to answer a teacher back but I was so upset by that comment I went to my form tutor and told her what happened. She was shocked and wrote me a note signed by her saying I could go home and she called my deputy head of year into her office, told him what had happened and he was shocked but he told me of course I can go home and signed the note as well. I did go back to school after and when my mum got home from work I told her what happened she went mad phoned the school and spoke to my head of year and told her in no uncertain terms her "unhelpful suggestion" was disgusting and if she ever did this to me again my mum would be coming down to the school in person to see her and make a complaint! When it happened again my deputy head let me go home but did make the helpful suggestion that I bring in a bag of spare clothes just in case which I did. But I've never forgotten what a twat my head of year was I wish now I had the guts then to tell her to fuck off in response to that comment 🙄🤣

Fatredwitch · 16/11/2021 20:16

Visits to the toilet should be a basic human right and you shouldn't have to explain yourself. Many girls would be horribly embarrassed to have to do so.

Some people have to pee much more frequently than others. Some have problems with flooding or don't realise that their periods are about to start, particularly if they are very young girls. Some may have a bowel problem. When I was 13, I started with symptoms of ulcerative colitis which wasn't properly diagnosed, despite many tests, till I was 23. It meant sudden, cramping pain and diarrhoea. (I remember the PE teacher being generally unsympathetic.) I was extremely shy and would have been mortified to have to explain, in front of people, my sudden need for the loo.

Nobody, whether an adult or a child, should have to justify their need for a toilet break.

Kinko · 16/11/2021 20:02

She's 13yrs - if she wants to go to the toilet there should be no issue. Nothing more than a 'you've just had a lunch break, next time go during lunch'. That is the very most a teacher could have said, without it being entirely unreasonable.

Your daughter was right to stand her ground. Don't punish her or even tell her off for any element of it. She'll come up against people who are more senior than her in work and life and while it's a good opportunity to teach her to stay calm, and composed - do not tell her not to argue back.

Arguing back is what keeps girl safe. If she was offensive, rude etc fine, that's not OK. But at 13yrs old she's well within her right to say - I'm going to the toilet and that's final and I don't need to explain my reasons to you. For all the teacher knew she could have had diarrhoea!

Back your daughter to the top of the hill on this one. She'll remember it next time she faces a senior person she needs to stand up to!

Sometimes the best thing a parent can say is 'good for you' (if the child is generally well behaved and respectful!)

Santina · 16/11/2021 19:59

I was a lecturer for 20 years, never once did I stop any of my students going to the loo, male and female, even if we had just come back from a break. No one has full control of natural bodily functions, especially after eating and drinking. It's also good for preparing them to be work ready and alowing them to make the right choices. Some secondary school teachers are only in the job for the status, I swear, the number of times you had to try and strip down the labels given at secondary school to encourage the student to succeed. The education system is dated and broken in my opinion, it's not fit for purpose any more.

IJoinedJustForThisThread · 16/11/2021 19:41

@LindaEllen

I would never have gone to sort out period problems during break/lunch as the loos would be absolutely packed with people just hanging round in there (why?!) smoking, and they would even sometimes climb onto the loo in the cubicle next to you and look over to see what you were doing. It was absolutely vile, but there was no way I'd be using it when it was busy like that. Luckily for me we had registration after lunch and my form was next to a toilet so my tutor would let me go (or anyone else) and that was perfect as it was quieter.

No student should be barred from using the toilet.

The other girls used to look over the cubicle walls like this when I was at school. I’m nearly 50 and even now when I’m in a work or public toilet I try to use the end cubicle so that there is only one wall to look over and I look up at the top of the other wall in case someone is watching me. I know deep down that it is highly unlikely that one of my female colleagues would do that, but that is how much it affected me as a child.
Raisedbrow · 16/11/2021 19:18

I think its obvious when a child is taking the piss, but you allow the request and resolve it later whatever that looks like. I wouldn't expect a child to flag their monthly for this purpose. Wrong on many levels.

KurtWilde · 16/11/2021 18:52

@FootieMama

13 years old are not so good with planning ahead such as I will change my tanpon now/go to the loo as I have PE soon. I was caught short often even at 15 with my periods. So I think she needs to learn how to plan but teachers shouldn't be asking about periods or denying toilet breaks either
Did you miss the part where she didn't come on until she was in her lesson?
thenovice · 16/11/2021 18:49

Was this a co-ed school?

FootieMama · 16/11/2021 18:32

13 years old are not so good with planning ahead such as I will change my tanpon now/go to the loo as I have PE soon. I was caught short often even at 15 with my periods. So I think she needs to learn how to plan but teachers shouldn't be asking about periods or denying toilet breaks either

TangledNemo · 16/11/2021 18:30

I don’t understand why people are saying she should have gone at lunch. She may not have needed to go then. Or she may not have had time after eating.

At my old school, we weren’t allowed to leave the canteen without asking permission anyway, and if we went on the way to the canteen, we’d be stuck at the back of queue and have to rush eating and/or all the nice food would be gone.
We did have toilets attached to the changing rooms though but I agree with OP that no one should have to tell someone else they’re on their period.

claymodels · 16/11/2021 18:29

@JonSnowIsALoser

Mortifying as it must be for a teenager, I don't think mentioning periods should be a problem in itself. Treating it as a shameful taboo topic doesn't do girls any favours in the long run.

Nobody, literally nobody has said periods should be a taboo subject. The thread is about not being allowed to go to the toilet. The facts are nobody should have to explain why they need to go to the toilet in case the teacher doesn't let them leave class.

KurtWilde · 16/11/2021 18:25

@JonSnowIsALoser

Mortifying as it must be for a teenager, I don't think mentioning periods should be a problem in itself. Treating it as a shameful taboo topic doesn't do girls any favours in the long run.
No one is treating it as a shameful taboo subject, they're treating it as some girls just prefer their privacy, just like some adult women do. And it also gives the bullies plenty of ammunition.
JonSnowIsALoser · 16/11/2021 18:23

Mortifying as it must be for a teenager, I don't think mentioning periods should be a problem in itself. Treating it as a shameful taboo topic doesn't do girls any favours in the long run.

Bobsyer · 16/11/2021 18:13

@gogohm

5 mins (or even 10 mins) is pretty unreasonable unless she's literally just felt it start because she should have gone at lunchtime. If a young lady has specific issues with her periods eg sudden flooding, then the school should be notified and a discreet pass be given to show teachers but it sounds like someone trying to get out of pe to me ... the sort of thing I did!
I totally disagree with this.

I’ve been having periods for nearly 30 years and I still sometimes get caught by a sudden flood, or my pad being slightly misaligned so I can feel it or whatever.

While I get that it’s annoying for the teacher, unless it’s multiple girls at the same time, I can’t see the problem with one girl needing the toilet even if it is just after lunchtime. And so what if she’s trying to get out of PE - it’s only going to affect her so she can deal with the outcomes.

Forsure69 · 16/11/2021 18:11

I have an issue with this, I don't understand how a basic need is controlled by a teacher who gets to decide when you get to go to the toilet or not. I really don't understand it.. it honestly baffles me.

Sorcha1205 · 16/11/2021 17:47

YANBU

I feel like it doesn't matter if it was a false alarm or not, it is the school's duty to allow the child to go and change her pad if need be or whatever else consists of dealing with one's menstrual cycle. End of.

Carriecakes80 · 16/11/2021 17:41

Jesus there are some idiots in here. Toilets are a basic right, I had a really bad flow, so bad that in the end I left school at 14 because after bleeding through to my skirt twice I was subjected to constant bullying, being denied being able to go to the loo when I needed to because some kids took the pi** was the last straw.
Sorry, but school is not the be all and end all in life, calling a kid difficult because she asked to go to the loo and didn't or couldn't go in a preferred time frame, how bloody absurd!

Vinomummyinlockdown · 16/11/2021 17:31

Argh this annoys me so much!!! Our school won’t let pupils fo to the damn toilet EVER. They are year 7s and some are getting used to high school and it’s pathetic rules and some just started periods. I’m sick to death of teachers not letting the children use the toilet!!! No wonder IBS and UTIs are rife. My daughter had to tell her teacher the period issue as it came on in class. It’s awful because teachers won’t let you walk up to the teacher! You have to put your hand and speak from your seat. I’m sick of this nazi regime. Have some sympathy ffs. They’re not naughty year 10s! They’re 11 years old.

IntermittentParps · 16/11/2021 13:41

@Pippi1970

Why didn't she go at lunch? My dd and her friends do this, noone goes in a lesson unless they've had some kind of accident.
the OP says 'In this case it was 5 minutes after lunch because that is when she came on.'
claymodels · 16/11/2021 13:18

I think the best way to handle it is to calmly say - I'm going to the bathroom, it's very urgent and leave before they can argue!

Yes; I'm going to the bathroom is all that should ever be needed.

When they get back say ' I had blood running down my leg, I told you were I was going, I couldn't wait any longer'

No. Absolutely not. Never.

catfunk · 16/11/2021 13:08

It's difficult to manager for schools, as an ex teacher you could easily end up with the whole class popping out and back in and it's very disruptive.
But I've been I situations when I need to go. There and then, could be tampon flooding or bowel related.
I think the best way to handle it is to calmly say - I'm going to the bathroom, it's very urgent and leave before they can argue!
When they get back say ' I had blood running down my leg, I told you were I was going, I couldn't wait any longer'

PlasticCupPolitics · 16/11/2021 10:42

But they clearly aren’t getting the balance right are they, I remember it being the same when I was in school - they used to lock the toilet block during lesson times!

I understand that sometimes, an adult wouldn’t be able to use the toilet just to go for a wee or whatever but what if, 5 minutes after their break, they got sudden stomach cramps and needed to empty their bowels? Who would stop them? Or would they just shit themselves?

This is the difference here, nobody should have to explain why they need to be excused to use the toilet, you wouldn’t expect an adult to do it why do we expect teenagers to?

claymodels · 16/11/2021 10:42

It wasn't appropriate. It was insulting, aggressive and designed to shut down a conversation that you didn't like (girls being active when on their periods).

Then I apologise, it wasn't intended to be aggressive and I absolutely don't want to shut down any discussion - that's the opposite of what we need here

KurtWilde · 16/11/2021 10:40

And actually lots of adults dont have free access to toilets but have to fit their toiletting into to designated break or lunch times, or at least go before an important meeting or site visit or delivery. I guess this is the balance schools are trying to strike with the "use the loo at break and lunch" message.

But at work everyone's break and lunch generally isn't at the same time. And there are far more children in a school per toilet than there are people in the average work place anyway. With only 30 minutes for lunch, it's impossible for hundreds of students to buy lunch, eat lunch, and all use the toilet. So no, it's not just as easy as everyone go at lunch or break.