Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Random-man comments

234 replies

OldieButaGoodie · 15/11/2021 05:40

Wish me luck - I'm going to HR when I get into work tomorrow about a man who works for the same Company, but I don't know him and never had a conversation with him. The other day in the office, I was in the open-plan kitchen which is a bit of a thoroughfare and I was pouring myself a glass of iced coffee from a container I bought in from home. Minding my own business and he pipes up, as he's walking past "you shouldn't be drinking that - you should be drinking green tea".. FFS mate, didn't ask for, and don't care about, your opinion! Angry

I know this topic has been mentioned before, where random men think it's ok to comment on what women are eating/drinking/wearing/etc etc etc. No, it's not.

I've had to scroll through the staff list photos to work out who he is, but it was so fleeting, that I'm going on the hunt tomorrow to ensure it's who I think it is. If it's this dickhead, he's old enough to know better than to speak to women like that - and we work in the public sector and this stuff is drummed into us all the time.

He picked the wrong person to insult - and I'm waiting for the excuses - - - you took it the wrong way - - - you don't have a sense of humour - - - I didn't mean anything by it - - - and yeah, none of them is going to cut it with me. He insulted me and there's no changing it with pissy excuses.

So, I suppose I'm not really asking if I'm being unreasonable..Grin

OP posts:
CecilieRose · 15/11/2021 17:09

@sillysmiles

Yes but if the man (and we have no way of knowing his intentions) didn't mean it as a comment about weight, it is possible/probably that he wouldn't consider that it could be heard that way?

If he meant it is x way, why would it even occur to him that OP could hear it in y way.

We can choose to be offended. So why would you. When the evidence is so ambiguous as to his meaning - why would you choose to be offended?

If he had said - "there's a load of calories in that coffee - with your belly you should drink green tea" that would be offensive. What the OP has written - imo not offensive.

So what did he mean by it? What possible good intention could there be from telling an adult woman stranger she should be drinking a different drink?

I wonder what planet you live on, because on mine that is not an acceptable comment to someone you don't know. It's at best rude, and worst offensive.

Again, what is the need to comment on people's food or drinks? Perhaps you people who clearly do it could explain the thinking behind it because I truly don't get it.

PilesEdgeworth · 15/11/2021 17:00

Never, ever seen a man telling another man he should be eating or drinking something healthier.
I'm a man and for the most part it's not the sort of comment I'd be inclined to remember, but I've certainly had male colleagues tell me I shouldn't drink energy drinks, and in the last month or so I've had a female colleague tell me I shouldn't be getting sandwiches from the convenience store because they're 'full of crap'. I don't think its particularly unusual for men or women to make passing comments on what men eat or drink.

Streetsigntonowhere · 15/11/2021 16:54

[quote CecilieRose]@sillysmiles A comment with could be construed as a jab at someone's weight is of course insulting and offensive. I can't believe so many people here don't understand how devastating it could be for someone with a history of eating disorders to be on the receiving end of a 'joke' about what they're eating. At worst, you could really hurt someone. At best, it's a pointless, inane comment with no value.

How can people just not see that it's completely inappropriate to comment on a stranger's food/drink choices? Is it a lack of empathy? Intelligence?[/quote]
Can’t we just go back to the 00’s where people weren’t offended by every single thing. “What if they have an eating disorder” blah blah. What if ANYTHING could be said about ANYTHING ffs.

Tevion28 · 15/11/2021 16:51

God men are getting a hard time lately

Catsforeverpeoplenever · 15/11/2021 16:46

If it makes the stupid old wind bag think twice before he opens his pie hole then you are doing good. YANBU. Well done you. Glitterball

Squirrelblanket · 15/11/2021 16:41

First time in ages that I've actually laughed out loud at an opening post. Thanks, OP. Grin

Opaljewel · 15/11/2021 16:38

Get a bloody grip crazy person

sillysmiles · 15/11/2021 16:32

Yes but if the man (and we have no way of knowing his intentions) didn't mean it as a comment about weight, it is possible/probably that he wouldn't consider that it could be heard that way?

If he meant it is x way, why would it even occur to him that OP could hear it in y way.

We can choose to be offended. So why would you. When the evidence is so ambiguous as to his meaning - why would you choose to be offended?

If he had said - "there's a load of calories in that coffee - with your belly you should drink green tea" that would be offensive. What the OP has written - imo not offensive.

CecilieRose · 15/11/2021 16:22

@sillysmiles there's no place for a comment that could be construed at a jab at someone's weight in the workplace. It wasn't friendly banter between colleagues, she didn't know the man at all, so it's just bloody weird, and rude.

Perhaps if people kept their trap shut rather than making inane comments about people's food and drink choices, there wouldn't be any offence to find.

sillysmiles · 15/11/2021 16:09

@CecilieRose potentially it could be construed as a joke at someone's weight. But there is nothing in the OP's post to suggest that or to suggest that is why the OP found it offensive.

Maybe it's a Monday thing (for me) but I find the rush to find offense in everything tiring and wearing.

CecilieRose · 15/11/2021 15:51

@sillysmiles A comment with could be construed as a jab at someone's weight is of course insulting and offensive. I can't believe so many people here don't understand how devastating it could be for someone with a history of eating disorders to be on the receiving end of a 'joke' about what they're eating. At worst, you could really hurt someone. At best, it's a pointless, inane comment with no value.

How can people just not see that it's completely inappropriate to comment on a stranger's food/drink choices? Is it a lack of empathy? Intelligence?

user1493494961 · 15/11/2021 15:30

You seem a sensitive soul.

1forAll74 · 15/11/2021 15:28

You obviously don't know how to deal with comments from assorted men folk. You should have worked in offices in the 1960 era, like I did, and got to grips with dealing with men talk. Mostly we could give a good retort to comments, or just laugh at stupidity.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 15/11/2021 15:17

You sound unhinged. I hope I never work in an office with you tbh.

sillysmiles · 15/11/2021 15:11

@supremelybaffled . and it would have offended me too.

I get how it's annoying, but how is it offensive?

supremelybaffled · 15/11/2021 15:09

Actually OP, I don't think you are wrong at all, and it would have offended me too. What you are putting in your body is none of his sodding business.

What he said about not drinking something that looked high-calorie in favour of something obviously 'healthy' is in the same vein as someone telling you that you shouldn't be eating that cream cake, you should be having a salad - ie: an unfavourable remark about your food which could be construed as insinuating that you are overweight and need to go on a diet.

sillysmiles · 15/11/2021 15:04

@OldieButaGoodie

We’ll, looks like I’ve been told I’ve got it wrong. Advice taken.
But how is it insulting?

It may be irritating. but how is it offensive?

SVRT19674 · 15/11/2021 14:40

I am annoyed about stupid comments men and women make. And absolutely think you are overreacting in this case. Yes, HR, the guy actually had the AUDACITY to voice I should drink green tea and not coffee. The INSULT.
That will put you firmly into the category of attention seeker and they won´t take you seriously when you do have something legitimate to bring to their attention.
Pick your battles.

Fizzielove · 15/11/2021 14:08

I think my response to his comment would have been something along the lines of - did I ask for your opinion?

Tavelo · 15/11/2021 14:06

Does he wear a tie? Tell him he should instead opt for a noose that is attached to a ligature point.

tabletennistop · 15/11/2021 13:17

Next time use the, ' Thank you for your comment, random man' response.

I love that. Makes it clear that they are doing something odd and unwelcome, without having to go into lengthy explanations.

Streetsigntonowhere · 15/11/2021 13:11

MN*!

Streetsigntonowhere · 15/11/2021 13:11

Absolutely pathetic OP.
Seriously, you need to get a life mate. If that has bothered you, you really really need a life.
He could easily have said the same to a guy. It’s hardly offensive. Honestly, this is the most pathetic thing I’ve read on MB in ages.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 15/11/2021 13:07

You're going to HR for this? Cringe.

5128gap · 15/11/2021 13:04

People who lecture others on their food and drink aren't thinking the person is incapable of making their own decisions. They generally aren't thinking about them at all. They just want an audience to pontificate to. Anyone who thinks they've given you enough headspace to decide that based on your gender this or that... is deluded. You might as well be the pot plant as long as they have a captive audience.