Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think The Queen should retire?

411 replies

ThinWomansBrain · 14/11/2021 21:09

I am not a monarchist - but given that we have a Royal Family....
Given her age, understandably failing health, and the recent widowhood, is it be reasonable to think the Queen should step down and retire gracefully?
OK, maybe stay in post until the Jubillee next year, but then hand over.

OP posts:
StoneofDestiny · 16/11/2021 17:58

Her death will cause huge changes in everyone’s lives

Her death won't make a blind bit of difference, anymore than Philips death has, Diana's death has or the disappearance of Andrew from public life has.
Nothing in my routine has changed, my life hasn't altered one bit.
I think the overwhelming majority of people will be doing exactly the same thing after her death than they are now.

ilovesooty · 16/11/2021 17:55

Edward VIII was actually called Edward. He was known as David within the family. He had about 7 first names and David was the last of them.

CounsellorTroi · 16/11/2021 17:46

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

I’m friends with key members of the royal family of another country - I’m assuming she feels the same way they do given that she thinks she was put on the earth to rule the UK by god and so is responsible for everyone in the country and the country itself. Just because she doesn’t make rules doesn’t mean she doesn’t feel responsibility 🤷🏻‍♀️
She doesn't rule, she reigns. The government rules.
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 16/11/2021 17:37

I’m friends with key members of the royal family of another country - I’m assuming she feels the same way they do given that she thinks she was put on the earth to rule the UK by god and so is responsible for everyone in the country and the country itself. Just because she doesn’t make rules doesn’t mean she doesn’t feel responsibility 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheGirlCat · 16/11/2021 15:53

[quote Justheretoaskaquestion91]@backtolifebacktoreality

But she literally feels she has the weight of the world on her shoulders. Her job isn’t just smiling and shaking hands![/quote]
How do you know what she 'literally' feels? I honestly doubt she literally feels that she has the weight of the world on her shoulders. Maybe the UK. But even then, since she is politically neutral her job is simply smiling and shaking hands.

HarrisonStickle · 16/11/2021 15:48

That's what's starting to be reported in the media. Albeit just resting for the winter, but I think it'll be permanent.

Voord · 16/11/2021 13:47

I think that her retirement from public duties will probably happen in the very near future, like when Prince Phillip did the same. She’ll remain Queen and might do the odd important event if fit (e.g. Remembrance Sunday) but otherwise the younger ones take over.

user1497207191 · 16/11/2021 13:30

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

Johnson and his cabinet are not of sufficient calibre or integrity to tackle a divisive issue like this, nor do they have any incentive to do it given the size of their majority, so I can't see any reason why this should become a big political issue for many years to come.

Who knows what may happen after a few years of King Charles III, or whatever he decides to be called.

There are far more important/urgent things for the government to deal with at the moment. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it".

I'm sure a lot of people would like to see an end to the monarchy, but are they in the majority? Even if we had a referendum, would there be a clear decision one way or another, or would it be another fiasco like the Brexit vote? Does the average Joe Public even understand the monarchy and constitution enough to be trusted to vote or will a lot of people just vote according to whatever z list sleb posts on Twitter?

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 16/11/2021 13:19

@Platax

So, all the people convinced that they were keeping quiet her death because of Remembrance Sunday and the Glasgow conference, what do you say the reasons are now that both are well and truly over?
Obviously they’re still “putting processes into place”. takes them a day or two. Grin
Platax · 16/11/2021 13:10

So, all the people convinced that they were keeping quiet her death because of Remembrance Sunday and the Glasgow conference, what do you say the reasons are now that both are well and truly over?

backtolifebacktoreality · 16/11/2021 09:55

[quote Justheretoaskaquestion91]@backtolifebacktoreality

But she literally feels she has the weight of the world on her shoulders. Her job isn’t just smiling and shaking hands![/quote]

As far as I can see, the only weight on her shoulders is whether the taxpayer continues to subsidise her family and their excesses, and the issues surrounding Prince Andrew etc.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 16/11/2021 09:19

Johnson and his cabinet are not of sufficient calibre or integrity to tackle a divisive issue like this, nor do they have any incentive to do it given the size of their majority, so I can't see any reason why this should become a big political issue for many years to come.

Who knows what may happen after a few years of King Charles III, or whatever he decides to be called.

CounsellorTroi · 16/11/2021 07:48

While the role stands outside politics, he was a politician, are they always ex-politicians? I’m only asking out of curiosity really.
How long has Ireland had this?
My main issue isn’t with that as a system, I think it sounds good. It’s with how you get from what we have now, to that. Because if this government was in charge of it, while they might say it sits outside politics they’d probably write the laws around the system and the voting in such a way that you’d always end up with a Tory (or a mate of theirs who has donated enough).
If the queen dies soon, I’d far rather have Charles than have Boris and co writing the details of a new system.
Which isn’t to say I think the current system is fair, but when/if we switch from it, that system will probably be in place for a long time. And it shouldn’t be sorted by Johnson. It needs sensible, non-partisan discussion amongst politicians and the public. And right now I don’t think we’d get that..

An act of Parliament agreed by all parties would be necessary. And a written constitution to ensure one political party cannot control the process.

CounsellorTroi · 16/11/2021 07:39

[quote Justheretoaskaquestion91]@backtolifebacktoreality

But she literally feels she has the weight of the world on her shoulders. Her job isn’t just smiling and shaking hands![/quote]
What major issues is she actually responsible for that people expect her to do something about? She doesn’t govern. Her job is pretty much smiling and shaking hands, reading speeches written by her staff and royal assenting legislation.

icedcoffees · 16/11/2021 07:13

Also, The Queen is not 'a stranger.' Not to many MANY people.

Of course she's a stranger. You only know what the Royal Family allow you to know - and that's a very very carefully edited public persona. You don't know a thing about what happens behind closed doors.

I'm sure the Queen is perfectly nice lady but let's be honest here - you don't know her from Adam. You have no idea what she's actually like - you just know that she has a nice public persona and is good at appearing smiley and diplomatic in front of the camera.

She's been around your whole life so she feels like a nice constant presence but she's still someone with a job to do and who benefits hugely from putting on a nice image for the rest of the world.

SickAndTiredAgain · 16/11/2021 06:55

@CounsellorTroi

Ireland manage to have a non hereditary head of state who stands outside politics. Current one is Michael D Higgins.
While the role stands outside politics, he was a politician, are they always ex-politicians? I’m only asking out of curiosity really. How long has Ireland had this? My main issue isn’t with that as a system, I think it sounds good. It’s with how you get from what we have now, to that. Because if this government was in charge of it, while they might say it sits outside politics they’d probably write the laws around the system and the voting in such a way that you’d always end up with a Tory (or a mate of theirs who has donated enough). If the queen dies soon, I’d far rather have Charles than have Boris and co writing the details of a new system. Which isn’t to say I think the current system is fair, but when/if we switch from it, that system will probably be in place for a long time. And it shouldn’t be sorted by Johnson. It needs sensible, non-partisan discussion amongst politicians and the public. And right now I don’t think we’d get that.
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 16/11/2021 06:25

@backtolifebacktoreality

But she literally feels she has the weight of the world on her shoulders. Her job isn’t just smiling and shaking hands!

backtolifebacktoreality · 16/11/2021 00:58

@CallMeNutribullet

The Queen mother had a far more leisurely life after Elizabeth took over the reigns. The Queen's schedule is far too demanding for a woman in her 90s

Do you really think her role is demanding?

She has EVERYTHING done for her. She has a cook, cleaner, chauffeur, dresser, private doctors etc. She has wealth beyond anything we can imagine. Has a choice of homes to stay in.

I have a friend is a similar age. She is suffering as she can't get a hospital appointment. She lives on her own and cooks, does her own cleaning, washing etc! She has worked hard all her life. I'm sorry but the Queen has an easy life in comparison.

TheOriginalEmu · 16/11/2021 00:04

Also, The Queen is not 'a stranger.' Not to many MANY people

But she is, you don’t know her, you know nothing about her other than what carefully arranged publicity allows you to know. You don’t know what she thinks or feels or wants. She IS a stranger.

CounsellorTroi · 15/11/2021 20:00

Ireland manage to have a non hereditary head of state who stands outside politics. Current one is Michael D Higgins.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 15/11/2021 19:59

That was different. Diana’s death was tragic, unexpected and untimely. The queen’s death at 95 or older will be none of those things

Sure but she had been on the scene for 1/9 of the time the queen has and was a lot more divisive. I will be sad when the queen dies. I won’t cry but I will be sad - I have a lot of respect for her and she’s been the queen my entire life. I know it’s clearly not “cool” on MN to say that but people seem quite gleeful saying they don’t care and they don’t see why anyone would.

BasiliskStare · 15/11/2021 19:29

@CounsellorTroi - Fair point - not sure what I would think the best alternative would be. ( French system ? )

Still think I do not want PM being head of state.

ThinWomansBrain · 15/11/2021 19:26

given Charles' track record of trying to influence government policy, he's not going to be neutral in the same way that his mother appears to be.

What, you mean he'd tell Boris he's a twat sort of non-neutrality?
Bring it on Grin

OP posts:
Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 15/11/2021 19:23

It's not the only way, no, but a change now would be the most enormous upheaval and we'd end up with more politics instead of having a Head of State who stands outside party politics. I have no problem with living in a constitutional monarchy. Not sure why, but I suppose I like tradition and find history fascinating, and this is a direct continuation of a tradition going back over a millennium in the British Isles.

CounsellorTroi · 15/11/2021 19:15

I rather like having a head of state different from Prime Minister.

A hereditary monarchy is not the only way or IMO the best way to have that