Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think The Queen should retire?

411 replies

ThinWomansBrain · 14/11/2021 21:09

I am not a monarchist - but given that we have a Royal Family....
Given her age, understandably failing health, and the recent widowhood, is it be reasonable to think the Queen should step down and retire gracefully?
OK, maybe stay in post until the Jubillee next year, but then hand over.

OP posts:
ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 17/11/2021 08:24

There's a possible psychological explanation for the adulation @StoneofDestiny, in Good Housekeeping of all places.

Watching the RF amid all the chaos in the world apparently makes monarchists feel calmer. They are focusing on a vision of familial perfection that physically calms them down.

Disrespectful Republicans and threads like this inflame their amygdalas, apparently.

www.goodhousekeeping.com/uk/lifestyle/a25163969/royal-family-popularity-reason/

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 17/11/2021 08:23

There is a difference between being maternal and being loving and affectionate. Lots of people aren’t maternal but do a perfectly good job of loving and raising well rounded children. Just like lots of people aren’t paternal and manage it too.

Roussette · 17/11/2021 08:21

I would want the Queen to be maternal totally. Given she is raising the next heir to the throne, do we really want that person fucked up from long distance parenting and lack of love/affection?

Personally I'd prefer a rounded person as Monarch, not someone who's childhood was miserable.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 17/11/2021 08:17

Agreed. I also don't like how she has no maternal bone in her body

Regardless of whether this is true or not (you have no idea) why do you need the queen to be maternal?

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 17/11/2021 08:15

The correct form is to bow/curtesy the first time

The correct form for any self-respecting human is to never bow to anyone, particularly those demanding special treatment without a valid reason.

EdithWeston · 17/11/2021 07:07

Agreed. I also don't like how she has no maternal bone in her body

as you profess to be astranfet to her, you cannot possibly know this, and you are not considering the whole public evidence (eg happiness in Malta)l. We know the upshot was that she put duty first, but not what her thoughts were about why,

how she made her own son Charles shake her hand

Taken from that documentary? There's footage of that greeting, and the kisses before the handshake

AND how her own grandchildren have to stand up and bow/curtsey every single time she walks into a room at home behind closed doors even

This is inaccurate. The correct form is to bow/curtesy the first time you meet the person that day. Not every time.

TheGirlCat · 17/11/2021 00:17

@StoneofDestiny

Also, The Queen is not 'a stranger.' Not to many MANY people

Of course she is. She wouldn't recognise any of us on the street.
She won't touch your hands without gloves - and you are not allowed to touch her!
You are told not to speak to her unless she speaks to you.
She won't put any of us in her will, won't share her enormous fortune with us (despite out taxes keeping her and her family in luxury). She won't answer the phone to you, come to your birthday party or attend your funeral.
She has shown an utterly ruthless streak in the way she ostracised her daughters in law while hiding her son from responding to requests from the US police to help investigate human trafficking.
I really don't get the adulation or admiration of any of this. Family.

Agreed. I also don't like how she has no maternal bone in her body, how she made her own son Charles shake her hand, AND how her own grandchildren have to stand up and bow/curtsey every single time she walks into a room at home behind closed doors even. She has always seemed very cold to me, cold as ice and without humanity. She has fucked up her own children. I don't see why people say she is respected, I honestly don't see why she deserves respect. She's not a very nice person in my book.
StoneofDestiny · 16/11/2021 22:47

She sends you a card for your 100th birthday but still has no idea who you are!

She doesn't even do that, her lacking do it for her.

backtolifebacktoreality · 16/11/2021 22:39

@StoneofDestiny

Also, The Queen is not 'a stranger.' Not to many MANY people

Of course she is. She wouldn't recognise any of us on the street.
She won't touch your hands without gloves - and you are not allowed to touch her!
You are told not to speak to her unless she speaks to you.
She won't put any of us in her will, won't share her enormous fortune with us (despite out taxes keeping her and her family in luxury). She won't answer the phone to you, come to your birthday party or attend your funeral.
She has shown an utterly ruthless streak in the way she ostracised her daughters in law while hiding her son from responding to requests from the US police to help investigate human trafficking.
I really don't get the adulation or admiration of any of this. Family.

She sends you a card for your 100th birthday but still has no idea who you are!

StoneofDestiny · 16/11/2021 22:34

Also, The Queen is not 'a stranger.' Not to many MANY people

Of course she is. She wouldn't recognise any of us on the street.
She won't touch your hands without gloves - and you are not allowed to touch her!
You are told not to speak to her unless she speaks to you.
She won't put any of us in her will, won't share her enormous fortune with us (despite out taxes keeping her and her family in luxury). She won't answer the phone to you, come to your birthday party or attend your funeral.
She has shown an utterly ruthless streak in the way she ostracised her daughters in law while hiding her son from responding to requests from the US police to help investigate human trafficking.
I really don't get the adulation or admiration of any of this. Family.

GladAllOver · 16/11/2021 22:10

She said at her coronation that she would serve for her "whole life" and she clearly intends to keep her word. We could do with similar devotion to duty from some other characters in public life.

notanothertakeaway · 16/11/2021 21:46

I like the queen. She's been around all my life, in the background. I like that she takes her role seriously and isn't brought down by allegations of sleaze / impropriety

Not such a fan of the rest, content to wait and see, I think Charles will trim back considerably

EdithWeston · 16/11/2021 21:16

If she wants to die as Queen then that's her prerogative

YY - I can't quite imagine here as HRH Duchess of Somewhere

(No, she wouldn't be Queen Mother, because that's an alternate title for Dowager Queen and only available to widowed Queens Consort)

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 16/11/2021 21:04

This family was never doing to be poor Not according to the RF... remember the one about Philip whining to the Americans about having to give up polo?

Personally I'd rather take the money and run - but they don't

Um. That's basically all they do. Offshore accounts coming out of their ears.

BasiliskStare · 16/11/2021 20:45

Ah - I think there are some unkind comments here .
Of course people can be anti royalist or republican - of course

But I truly believe that woman decided this was her role and she was going to do it.
Of course she is rich but would you really want to be having to get up and do jobs well beyond retirement age when if you were a well off country woman you could tootle around with your dogs and your horses

I can see the point of a constitutional monarchy - the problem I see is the Queen has provided so much continuity & I hope her son & grandson can properly step into her shoes & do a decent job for the country.

This family was never doing to be poor but they do have to do a job for what they have ( & retirement not a real option at the moment ) Personally I'd rather take the money and run - but they don't ( well most of them Grin )

ChurchofLatterDayPaints · 16/11/2021 20:31

YANBU, she should have been faded out years ago like they've done in the other European monarchies with a minimum of self-awareness, but it's too late now. QE obviously preferred the Saudi model: keep milking them dry right to the bitter end.

apnews.com/article/e2dde899efc14a68b885a8747eaf5a89

To be fair though, she does have a pair of spectacular bellends as sons, so may have felt less damage would be done overall by staying put.

Anyway, not long now before we can all cringe along to God Save The King Smile

apnews.com/article/e2dde899efc14a68b885a8747eaf5a89

PurpleFlower1983 · 16/11/2021 19:27

She will never abdicate but I think she is nearing the end of her life. I hope she makes her jubilee next year, what an achievement that is.

amylou8 · 16/11/2021 19:23

Why should she. She's given the best part of her life to this country. If she wants to die as Queen then that's her prerogative. If she's not up to public duties she has plenty of family who can stand in for her.

EdithWeston · 16/11/2021 19:16

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-59304407

Prince Edward represented her at the General Synod today - it's the first time the Queen has missed it.

Interesting that it is him, for he is not a Counsellor of State, but is one of the Magnificent Seven.

The situation re Counsellors of State is a bit of a mess, Harry could be suspended from the role whilst domiciled abroad (and there is provision for that) and someone needs to come up with a cunning plan to remove Andrew (perhaps he could just stand down). But of course then the replacements have to be the next two adults in the line of succession, which means Beatrice and Eugenie. Even though it wouid make far more sense to have Edward and Anne

StoneofDestiny · 16/11/2021 18:32

@justtheretoaskaquestion91

No - she carry's no responsibility and I do not believe she thinks she does either. In fact, none of them have a clue about the drudge of working just to pay bills, the fear of losing your job or the stress of losing it. They have struggled for nothing, earned nothing on their own merits and are pampered and bowed to all their lives. If she thinks she is weighted down by responsibilities it's very insulting to those who genuinely are.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 16/11/2021 18:27

I don’t think she sees it that way! I think she thinks she is responsible for the UK and the commonwealth etc. Its “her” country.

backtolifebacktoreality · 16/11/2021 18:26

@StoneofDestiny

But she literally feels she has the weight of the world on her shoulders

😂😂
The Queen is a member of a family who do not have to worry about employment for themselves or their children, having jobs for life secured. They don't worry about the rising price of food, transport, gas, electricity or clothes. They don't worry about the decoration or repair of their many homes, the price of cars, the length of the queue in a supermarket or at the airport. Even the washing, vacuuming, polishing and ironing is done by others - and millions of people chip in from their hard earned wages to ensure they can continue to live in the luxury they expect. The price of funerals and weddings is taken care of for them as is their security. Nothing but the best is available to them in childcare, medical care and education.
The only thing the Queen is likely to worry about is the appalling behaviour of her own children.

Couldn't agree more!

CounsellorTroi · 16/11/2021 18:23

What responsibilities? I genuinely don't get it. I get that her job is physically onerous at her age, but not that she is weighed down by responsibilities.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 16/11/2021 18:18

@StoneofDestiny

I’m
Not disagreeing with you but I’m telling you more how I think she sees it, not how I see it. Can’t you see from her point of view? The responsibilities she thinks she has?

StoneofDestiny · 16/11/2021 18:08

But she literally feels she has the weight of the world on her shoulders

😂😂
The Queen is a member of a family who do not have to worry about employment for themselves or their children, having jobs for life secured. They don't worry about the rising price of food, transport, gas, electricity or clothes. They don't worry about the decoration or repair of their many homes, the price of cars, the length of the queue in a supermarket or at the airport. Even the washing, vacuuming, polishing and ironing is done by others - and millions of people chip in from their hard earned wages to ensure they can continue to live in the luxury they expect. The price of funerals and weddings is taken care of for them as is their security. Nothing but the best is available to them in childcare, medical care and education.
The only thing the Queen is likely to worry about is the appalling behaviour of her own children.