Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alternate Xmas with each family, did last year count?

65 replies

whyohwhyohwhyohwhywhy · 14/11/2021 20:00

I've name changed because my sister might see this.

We normally alternate at christmas, either my family or husbands family. over the years it has become that our siblings have all aligned so it is a big bash each time.

Last year was my family's turn. At the last-ish minute restrictions changed but we still saw my sister, and other family members didnt come. (I cant remember if my sister was going to host all along)

So this year we think it is husbands family, and so do husbands siblings etc. My family are saying that last year didnt count and they are all doing this year, and we are ruining the system if we dont fall into line with this and we have ruined it now FOREVER.

Before I say any more - i will open it up for views.

so
YANBU - you are right it is your husbands family turn
YABU - you should go to your own family

Before anyone asks, no we wont split up, we have 3 primary kids, for whom christmas is actually designed imo.

OP posts:
Herja · 14/11/2021 21:38

If my mother was declining and had asked me to cook christmas lunch for us all, I would be finding a way to make that happen. If that involves irritating people with time on their side, then so be it. I would let DH lead on this.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 14/11/2021 21:33

Xpost (that will teach me nit to refresh the page…)

In that case, yes Christmas at MIL wo a doubt especially if you still can manage to have a day together for Christmas. NOT Boxing Day though which you will have ‘reserved’ for something really different.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 14/11/2021 21:30

I said YABU because really it doesn’t matter if it’s your family turn or your DH’s.

I think keeping the rhythm of your family all meeting up altogether is more important. Otherwise it will just never happen again.

And yes that means you won’t see your DH fan inly for two years. It happens. Same happened last year with my family (we were supposed to stay with them). This year we will spend with dH family too because his dad just died. So that will be 3 years wo spending Christmas with my side.
I’d rather do that. Adapt to circumstances rather than rigidly keep to a certain schedule.

FizzyTango · 14/11/2021 21:26

I think in light of your update that really changes things. Spend it with your poorly MIL, especially if you are seeing your family on Boxing Day. You can always ‘even’ things out in future years so you fall back in sync with your family. But in your DH position, you really should prioritise his family in my opinion.

Chloemol · 14/11/2021 21:25

Your families turn, no one could meet last year spin effect it was put on hold

GreenClock · 14/11/2021 21:22

Sounds a bit stressful. Do what you want OP, (assuming that no one is alone all day, of course). Now might be a good time to break the “alternating” stuff.

PrincessNutNuts · 14/11/2021 21:21

You saw (some of) your family last year.

You didn't not see DH's family.

Therefore it's DH's family's turn.

TillyTopper · 14/11/2021 21:15

I can't give a YABU or a YANBU OP... but I would not have got into the habit of alternate Xmases with families. I'd be saying it's time to stay at home and have Xmas with you family unit and see others on another day.

ThinWomansBrain · 14/11/2021 21:14

*synch Grin
some typos I ignore - others really make a nonsens of the reply

ThinWomansBrain · 14/11/2021 21:13

does doing this year with your family put you out of stnch with DH family?

BakedBeeeen · 14/11/2021 21:09

Hi OP, we do similar to you, all siblings align so we see all of my family one year and all of DH family the next. We couldn’t do “last year didn’t count” - our fate for this year was decided for us as one sister works for NHS and got Xmas off last year so has to work Xmas this year. So we all had to say to my parents that we won’t be able to see you for Xmas this year, even though we should have seen you last year but didnt. We will organise to see them at New Years weekend instead.
But everyone needs to be in agreement, my parents were not upset about it, and said that they don’t mind when they see us as long as they can see everyone at some point. Sounds like your family need to grow up!! Wink

Landof · 14/11/2021 21:06

To me, last year didn't count and I'd want to spend it with my family.

To those saying Xmas should be just the family unit and can pop to see others on Xmas eve or boxing day, this only really works if people live locally. My siblings are dotted around all over including one a 12 hour flight away. Christmas takes planning and none of us would dream of people being alone on Xmas day.

whyohwhyohwhyohwhywhy · 14/11/2021 21:06

thanks for all the messages.

Im not totally sure my family want to see us, they just want us to fall in with the plans. We feel like characters in their story most of the time, this one being case in point. They made the plans in a conversation without me, and now are annoyed that I can't immediately fall into line.

We hate the drama.

The extra info is that we always do xmas on another day if we dont do it at xmas, so everyone will get a go.

And - on my side:
My ddad died this year, and the wider family are getting together on boxing day to spread his ashes. We will be there for that.

on DH side:
his mother is in very poor health, having gone down hill this year. she has asked us to cook at hers. DH is normally laid back about my family's requirements but really wants to do this for his mum.

OP posts:
Chocoqueen · 14/11/2021 21:03

Although that's for Xmas day - we are all getting together on a different day for a Christmas lunch and present swapping.

Chocoqueen · 14/11/2021 21:02

We've gone with last year didn't count so we're all doing what we would have done last year. Though me and my siblings discussed this a couple of months ago so we were all agreed and means we can align and all be together next year 😆

NorthSouthcatlady · 14/11/2021 20:55

Last year doesn’t count

ShowOfHands · 14/11/2021 20:53

My DC seem a different breed to the MN norm. My oldest is 14, youngest is 10 and if I suggested spending Christmas without seeing their grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins etc, they'd be gutted. Their toys aren't going anywhere. And I know looking back that my Mum's insistence on not seeing grandparents on the day meant that my Grandma had some v lonely Christmases. She said nothing at the time. I inherited her diaries and know that Dec 25th was a v rough day for her and when I was old enough to have her to my house, it was one of the best things to ever happen to her.

It's actually a nice problem to have. Two sets of people love and want to see you. Is there no way you can be honest with both sets and just have two Christmases?

Whereismumhiding3 · 14/11/2021 20:47

I think you should do what you and DH want

If you feel it's right to go to DHs family then you do that.
They'll miss two years in a row otherwise and last year wasn't their fault/ you saw Dsis anyway from your family. Really no one should be pressurising you. I'd be answering "don't be silly snd turn this into a drama".

Each family will have had to make arrangements and she a pattern to fit into. Lots of people missed out last year the whole year.

Christmas is about the children so do what is best for them.

I couldn't be doing with people making a drama out of things & would be tempted to suggest an extra get together at Easter with my family instead if they felt they'd missed out last year on a full Xmas get together, compromise is possible if your family aren't being unreasonable about it.

Whistleforthechoir · 14/11/2021 20:43

I agree with PPs. Once children get to an age where they want to be at home to chill with new gifts etc, Christmas day is our little family unit at home, alone.

We're happy to fit into everyone else's plans on any other day, but Christmas day is for the 4 of us at home. Not had any arguments so far.

dudsville · 14/11/2021 20:39

Last year didn't chubby, not really, not in the true spirit of how you celebrate, but you might have to make exceptions, so things differently for a time until everyone's caught up and back to normal.

Gizmo98765 · 14/11/2021 20:39

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

CalamariGames · 14/11/2021 20:39

Of my family started with the ruined Christmas forever nonsense I would stay away on principle.

AnnoyedByAlfieBear · 14/11/2021 20:38

We're doing what we should have done last year, so we're seeing DH's family.

whyohwhyohwhyohwhywhy · 14/11/2021 20:36

sorry -@ShowOfHands you are right. it would be more precise to say that for us, at this stage in life it is all about the kids, so we wouldnt want to break up our family unit for it.

interesting views so far..

OP posts:
Parky04 · 14/11/2021 20:30

This is why we have spent every Christmas day on our own. Can't be arsed with any of that nonsense!