Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alternate Xmas with each family, did last year count?

65 replies

whyohwhyohwhyohwhywhy · 14/11/2021 20:00

I've name changed because my sister might see this.

We normally alternate at christmas, either my family or husbands family. over the years it has become that our siblings have all aligned so it is a big bash each time.

Last year was my family's turn. At the last-ish minute restrictions changed but we still saw my sister, and other family members didnt come. (I cant remember if my sister was going to host all along)

So this year we think it is husbands family, and so do husbands siblings etc. My family are saying that last year didnt count and they are all doing this year, and we are ruining the system if we dont fall into line with this and we have ruined it now FOREVER.

Before I say any more - i will open it up for views.

so
YANBU - you are right it is your husbands family turn
YABU - you should go to your own family

Before anyone asks, no we wont split up, we have 3 primary kids, for whom christmas is actually designed imo.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
abstractprojection · 16/11/2021 06:41

From what you’ve said I’d do Christmas Day with his family as his mum is unwell and has asked you to cook, and Boxing Day with yours to do the ashes

User4272946730203 · 15/11/2021 11:25

I don't think there's necessarily a right or wrong answer - just what you all decide is right. We're keeping to the original plan - so this year ought to be my family and we are seeing my family, notwithstanding the fact that we didn't see my husband's family last year. Anything else would have been too complicated and would have involved multiple siblings on both sides of the family changing their plans. My husband's parents are sanguine about having missed their year, since someone has to do it, and we're hoping it will all just be normal from now on.

Doomscrolling · 15/11/2021 09:42

With your MIL in poor health you should definitely go to hers. You’ll see your family on Boxing Day anyway.

GrealishHairband · 15/11/2021 09:21

I have to say to the ‘turns are silly, stay at home by yourself’ brigade, our kids would be gutted if it wasn’t a chaotic day with cousins and aunties and uncles. I’d miss it too in all reality.

Sunbeams09 · 15/11/2021 07:45

I think last year didn’t count, particularly for those who ended up in Tier 4. We do the same most years (my family Christmas Day, IL’s Boxing Day) because PIL’s tend to make their own arrangements Christmas Day then have a big dinner Boxing Day, so thankfully it’s irrelevant for us, but I know that my brother & SIL are counting last year as a proper “turn” so I don’t think one way is really right or wrong. If your family are so upset in arms just say you’ll go to MIL’s this year and next then!

Anotherhill · 15/11/2021 06:25

Sounds like you want to go to MILs and your not fussed about being out of sync with your family, so go to MILs. I voted the opposite way initially but your update completely changes things.

Skiptheheartsandflowers · 15/11/2021 06:25

On the 'you'll spoil the alignment of family Christmases FOREVER' point, I would say 'well in that case, we'll do this year AND next year at DH's side, so see you in 2023!'

In practice, as you've said, you will see them on a different day during the whole period anyway.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 15/11/2021 06:11

Your husband's turn of course. You saw your family last year, albeit a limited amount of them, now it's your husband's families turn this year.

HeartvsBrain · 15/11/2021 06:06

Having just read your post about your DF dying this year, and that you are all spreading His Ashes on Boxing Day - many condolences for that OP - and that your MiL is very unwell, I would not even have to think about it (unless your DM was going to be all alone on her first Christmas without your DDad, but you haven't mentioned that, so I presume that isn't a problem). I would go to your MiL on Christmas Day, and your family on Boxing Day, as long as they don't live too far from each.

I have adult children and I was just thinking earlier today (well yesterday now) that if they want to have some sort of arrangement in place annually for Christmas, then they could do the alternates that lots of families do, but I would suggest that they might like to have something like 1 in 3 Christmases to themselves. I would have loved that when my family were younger.
Good luck OP, and I hope that you have a great Christmas in whatever form it takes!

frazzledasarock · 15/11/2021 05:26

Your IL’s turn this year. Have a quiet Xmas day at home next year and see your side the year after and you’ll all be back in sync.

You can’t really refuse your MIL’s request.

PurBal · 15/11/2021 04:55

Husbands turn.

However, my DH put his foot down on “turns”. You have children, every year is your children’s turn. My mum will bleat about it being her turn but we refuse to operate a turn system.

SpringRainbow · 15/11/2021 04:41

This is why I put my foot down early on and said no to all this alternate years stuff. We rarely see anyone to be honest. It’s bliss!

I think if both you and your DH want to see his family, then do so. Don’t worry about who’s ‘turn’ it is.

It’s also fine if you would rather just stay home.

You don’t ‘have’ to do anything

RedHelenB · 15/11/2021 03:46

@whyohwhyohwhyohwhywhy

thanks for all the messages.

Im not totally sure my family want to see us, they just want us to fall in with the plans. We feel like characters in their story most of the time, this one being case in point. They made the plans in a conversation without me, and now are annoyed that I can't immediately fall into line.

We hate the drama.

The extra info is that we always do xmas on another day if we dont do it at xmas, so everyone will get a go.

And - on my side:
My ddad died this year, and the wider family are getting together on boxing day to spread his ashes. We will be there for that.

on DH side:
his mother is in very poor health, having gone down hill this year. she has asked us to cook at hers. DH is normally laid back about my family's requirements but really wants to do this for his mum.

Stick to your plans then. His mother sounds like she needs him.
Ionlydomassiveones · 15/11/2021 02:37

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Yuledo · 15/11/2021 00:28

We are just resetting last year.

GrealishHairband · 15/11/2021 00:25

A similar dilemma has landed in our lap this year OP, it hadn’t occurred to me that it might. Last was my families turn and my brother was hosting for the first time. Then tier 4. Then my mum got cancer and had to isolate so she could have an op so we didn’t see her over Christmas at all. We still went to my sisters but was v low key. This year should be DH’s family turn. Except my mum is now thankfully well and my brother is emigrating in the new year so may be last Christmas at home for a while and they’re wanting a reset.

So no suggestions but masses of sympathy for the difficult decision!

RuggerHug · 15/11/2021 00:09

Ah based on the update, definitely with DHs family. This year will be 'off' for your family anyway (first year after a loss always is) but you're getting together for the ashes so will still have time together for something hugely important. If your MIL is likely to have this the last Christmas with you(especially having not had last year from alternating)then be with that side.

PingedPotato · 14/11/2021 22:54

If its that much of an issue for future Xmases see your husbands family this year, spend next year alone (or with his family again) and then you're in line again. It's too late notice to tell someone you'd rather go somewhere else.

PingedPotato · 14/11/2021 22:52

It's your husbands year

whyohwhyohwhyohwhywhy · 14/11/2021 22:47

@Hmmmm2018 but it did happen. Just in part.

It has just occurred to me that I seem to be somehow less interested in the past than others. I just feel like we spent it with my family last year and so this year it is DHs. If we had gone skiing last year it would still be DHs turn and we did decide how we were going to spend it.

At the end of the day I hate this alternate nonsense as you can possibly tell, so I guess I just feel bound in by a tradition that I would enjoy all the more with an element of freedom of choice. We are an endless disappointment to my family and this just perpetuates it

OP posts:
Macaroni46 · 14/11/2021 22:41

I think in light of your updates OP you should definitely go to DH's family this year.

Hmmmm2018 · 14/11/2021 22:26

I think it is the turn of the people you should have been with last year, as that didn't happen. Saying that, I therefore suggested we should spend Xmas with in-laws as didn't get their turn last year but actually they would prefer to stick to the schedule and are seeing SiL. I rather liked last Christmas, quiet time at home without all the mad dashing about the country trying to appease the different family factions!

CecilieRose · 14/11/2021 22:07

@Scarby9

We are rerunning what should have happened last year, if Boris hadn't put us all into Tier 4 and a Christmas travel ban at the last minute. We are mainly doing this because the apartment we booked for Christmas to allow family to stay nearby (while overnight stays in people's houses were banned) was moved from last year to this.
Because visiting your entire family in the middle of a terrible second wave of a global pandemic when nobody at all was vaccinated was such a great idea? If only Boris hadn't ruined all your fun, eh.

Some people need to be saved from themselves, JFC.

MegaClutterSlut · 14/11/2021 22:04

I voted yanbu before I'd seen your update as you still spent Christmas with some of your side of the family but given your update, I'd 100% be spending it with mil

Cupoftea53 · 14/11/2021 21:40

I think the ‘turn’ thing finishes when you have kids. I think you get to the point then that you are the host and people can come to you if they want. We always just say both sets of parents are welcome at ours if they want to see us.