Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be fuming for DH leaving 11 yo dd alone

138 replies

Myotherface · 14/11/2021 19:45

So I had planned to go and meet a friend for half a day. I do something like this 1-2 times a year so not exactly a lot. DH, his sister and mum decided to take the kids for a swim whilst I'd be away. Win win. Except that 11yo DD got unwell with temp and a cough. Covid pcr plus lateral flow negative so no problem with that but obviously not fit to go swimming. I offered to cancel my plans so rest of the kids could still go swimming with cousins. DH said I should be able to go as my plans had been made weeks ago unlike the last minute swimming plan. He said he'd sort it. So off I went.

I then came back 6 hours later to hear that DH, his mum and sister, 2 DS.s and their cousin had gone swimming and had left the 11 yo DD alone at grandparents house whilst they were out. Apparently she had felt much better once they got to grandparents house. She had asked to go swimming with the rest of them and when told no had suggested she'd stay behind on her own. She had said she'd felt bad that the rest of them were missing out because of her and told them she'd be fine. She said she had watched a film and only got scared once when the doorbell rang. She had hidden behind the sofa and had thought someone had come to kidnap her. She had been scared and tried calling granddad who had gone for a bike ride (bike ride more important than DD). Granddad didn't pick up but later texted to reassure her that the caller was a nice neighbour. She said after that she was fine again.

The swimming pool is an hour away. I was an hour and a half away. Granddad was miles away on his bike. Dd had only been left with mine and DH.s numbers. I was not told she was left alone. If something would have happened it would have taken us an hour to get back.

AIBU to be fuming?!!! DH is upset because I calmly stated that I wouldn't have gone to meet a friend had I known that poorly DD was going to be left alone. He thinks it's extremely hurtful for me to question his judgement around this. I can't believe I'm being made out to be the bad guy for saying I think he made a bad decision and I think leaving dd alone for the first time should have been a joint decision.

OP posts:
MushMonster · 14/11/2021 21:39

I was ready to say you are unreasonable, because 11 years olds are ok to be left alone for a while, like popping to the shops, or to give a lift to someone. But.... poorly! No way! He should have stayed with her. Or if he was the only one driving, then the grandfather or grandmother. It is not reasonable for your DH to go swimming! And on top of that 1 hour away!
If he had popped to the swimming pool 15 minutes away to drop the rest of them, and then get back, no issue with me. But such a distance, on a busy day of the year, including Parades and road closures, to be gone for hours, with no way to be contacted ( at least he was swimming with his waterproof phone!), and not even the GF could postpone his time out. I would not be happy.

Topseyt · 14/11/2021 21:37

11 is normally fine to be left alone for a few hours.

However, I don't like the sound of your DH's attitude towards your DD. That is awful. You need to tackle that and think on it. He may need a kick up the arse.

Myotherface · 14/11/2021 21:34

@icedcoffees

Why are you married to a man who treats your DD so harshly compared to your DS's?
I've asked this question of myself for years and years. The answer is a complex mixture of "I'm a coward" and "I'm not sure what to do". I've told DH for years that I'd like a divorce.. He then let hell loose.. Cries and howls uncontrollably in the garage and walks around the house like someone is dying and begs me not to leave him. He says he'd rather kill himself than not be with the kids every day. He says the kids would be messed up from the divorce. And I'm not brave enough to go for it and see whether he's right. Our family life is generally fairly settled apart from his occasional outbursts and my bouts of depression. I had these episodes of severe depression before I met him so not sure if my marriage is to blame or not. I don't feel anything towards him but am so terrified of kids' being distressed from the divorce that I don't dare to leave. He also once asks me how I could leave dd with him without me present post divorce. I sometimes do feel like I almost want to be there to make sure he is not too hard on her. He is in therapy and has started seeing his harshness and preferential treatment. He has changed a lot but not enough. I doubt I'll ever love him or even have respect for him as a person. I also know I'm no better and am failing my children for not divorcing him or managing to make him stop. I would end my life if I knew it wouldn't be disastrous for the children.

People seem to always assume these things are so simple. They aren't. We tried couples counselling. I was hoping the therapist would realise we would need to split up and would help us work towards that. The therapist told me she didn't understand why I didn't leave and said she wouldn't be able to help us as I chose to stay in a marriage that clearly had no hope. My therapist is working with me to enable me to leave. I'm not sure I can see anything ever changing. Maybe the kids have lives ahead of them as depressed as I am. If they do me and dh are 100% to blame for it. I would do the right thing if I knew what it was.

OP posts:
zukiecat · 14/11/2021 21:31

My DDs are both adults now, and I'm a single parent, no way would I have left them alone at that age, far too young.

Eleven is still Primary School age here in Scotland, and I would be fuming too OP if I had left them with a family member (which almost never happened) and they were left alone at that age. YANBU

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 14/11/2021 21:29

@billy1966

Is your husband her father?

Why is he allowed to be so harsh with her.

It sounds like she is coping with a lot.

11 is still very young IMO.

This.

Tbh I’d worry much more about her having to live in the same house with that man, than two hours alone.

alexdgr8 · 14/11/2021 21:29

dear OP, as often occurs here, the issue is revealed to be different from first presented.
why do you allow your husband to treat your daughter differently.
no wonder she acts up/ has anxiety issues.
this is a much bigger issue.
and who does she sleep with if he is never alone.
are the sons younger.
i can't imagine a father behaving like this, esp nowadays.
i could understand more if he was over-protective to your daughter.
could it be some kind of referred hostility to you, to females, for being ill, having psychological problems, esp when he wasn't allowed to be.
i think you need family therapy.
good luck.

TheGirlCat · 14/11/2021 21:29

@Myotherface

DD is in secondary school and a very independent and confident child. She has been into town with friends a couple of times on her own and has been alone at home for around 40 minutes when I've been to the shops. I'm not 100% sure she actually thought she was going to be kidnapped. She has a bit of a problem with adding quite a lot of dramatic turns to stories and I'm guessing this is one of those occasions.

The problem for me was leaving a child who has not yet been alone loads on her own for 2 hours when she had temperature and wasn't feeling well. Also with doing something behind my back he knew I wouldn't be happy about.

DD is in secondary school and a very independent and confident child.

All evidence to the contrary! An independent and confident child is able to sleep on her own and is able to be alone for a few hours (at that age she should be able to get herself to and from school and start on making dinner when she gets home from school) alone. I am sorry about how her father treats her (and why haven't you spoken to him about it and given him an ultimatum to change?) but she sounds very disturbed imo and needs help. I don't say this to be mean or judgemental - please believe me. I say this because she truly does need help. At 11 years old she shouldn't be afraid to sleep alone or answer the doorbell. She's in high school, she should be independent and confident, neither of which she is. Please, please get her some help.

MrsSkylerWhite · 14/11/2021 21:25

I know without a shadow of a doubt that my husband would not have left either of our 11 year olds alone at home.

Krakenchorus · 14/11/2021 21:23

Yanbu. There were 4 adults and 4 children, if I counted correctly. There was no reason or excuse to leave her alone. One of those 4 adults should have prioritised her.

At 11, I would not leave a child for more than an hour if it was not necessary to do so. And it wasn't necessary in this case.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 14/11/2021 21:22

I think an 11yo can be left on their own for a few hours.
I also agree with you that it would have been better if that has been a joint decision AND something planned ahaead rather than dumped on your dd.

However, I think you have bigger problems with your DH tbh. His attitude towards girls is atrocious and not helpful at all in the context of your illness etc…
Seeing his attitude tI illness and girls (women?) how I she taking on you having some MH issues?

TheGirlCat · 14/11/2021 21:21

Of course it's ok to leave an 11 year old alone for a few hours! Wtf is wrong with people these days that basically a high schooler needs a babysitter! I'd be more worried about her reaction, hiding behind a sofa because the doorbell rang? That's not normal! She seems to have severe developmental and psychological problems. Probably because of being babied. I would get some help for her, I'd be very worried about her, her behaviour is very concerning.

ShaneTheThird · 14/11/2021 21:17

11 year old at secondary school is perfectly fine to be left alone for a few hours.

The issue now is that your husband treats your daughter different to her brothers.

Brownpigeon · 14/11/2021 21:16

People saying that the 11 year old overreacted.... My ten and a half year old would be the same.
She has anxiety, according to CAHMS.
She won't be left in the car while I nip into a shop. I can just about take the dog to have a wee on the field a few houses along.
She panics about everything.
I can understand why the OP is cross.

icedcoffees · 14/11/2021 21:14

Why are you married to a man who treats your DD so harshly compared to your DS's?

billy1966 · 14/11/2021 21:11

Is your husband her father?

Why is he allowed to be so harsh with her.

It sounds like she is coping with a lot.

11 is still very young IMO.

Pinkandpink · 14/11/2021 21:10

I leave my 11 year old son, primary 7. For a few hours occasionally. He’s happy playing his Xbox. He has his phone. I tell him not to touch the oven/ cooker or answer the door. He’s fine.

Nicknacky · 14/11/2021 21:07

@Almostmenopausal What was different when we were kids?

maddiemookins16mum · 14/11/2021 21:06

Sounds to me she’s added a lot of drama to the story as she was narked about the swimming and is trying to get people into trouble.

BetsyBigNose · 14/11/2021 21:05

I voted YANBU as I think 3 hours (you said the pool was an hour away, so 1 hr there, 1 hour for swimming then 1 hr to travel home), not in her own home and with no adult able to get to her in under an hour was just too much for a child who is unused to being left alone. I happily left my DC when they were 11 but only for a short time and I/DH could have got home to them within 15 mins.

Additionally, I don't think it was right that your DH made this decision without consulting you. As this was a relatively new situation and with the added complication that your DD had been feeling ill, then you absolutely should have been asked for your opinion and you should have then made the decision together.

Myotherface · 14/11/2021 21:03

Thanks for the replies everyone. Maybe there isn't a right or wrong answer to this one. It was helpful to post here to see lots of different opinions.

To those who picked up some inconsistencies (not quite sure what they were).. I'm quite surprised by the hostile tone in those messages. Why be unkind to a stranger online? I hope you are kinder towards yourselves and your loved ones..

The swimmers left at the same time as granddad left for his bike ride. Grandad had said he was only going to go for a short ride but everyone in the family knows that still means 2-3 hours. Granddad had been gone for 2 hours and was back before the swimmers. DH had thought granddad would have been back sooner although don't quite believe this.. He knows his dad's bike rides as well as I do.

Perhaps this is also connected with mine and dh.s long term differences around how illness is viewed and treated. Dh was never off school with illness. He thinks vomiting or temp of over 38 is an acceptable reason for missing school. Otherwise kids should go to school however unwell they feel. An unwell child at home will only get fussed over if the unwell child is a boy. In case of DD it's tough love. I was allowed to be off school when I felt too unwell to go. No questions asked. I was rarely off as I loved school. When unwell at home I got fussed over. I'd like to treat my children with compassion and teach them to be compassionate towards themselves. We do have to keep working through mild colds but it's also important to learn how to rest and look after ourselves when needed.

A lot of people picked up on the anxiety of DD. I'm not sure if the anxiety of kidnappers was real or not. We are a complex family. Dh gives boys preferential treatment and treats DD harshly. I have recurrent depression, have been hospitalised with it an am currently unwell. Kids have had to live with my illness and fear another admission despite us regularly talking about things openly and reassuring them on an age appropriate way. DD has a problem with lying and regular made up illnesses. This is her way of seeking care. I not quite sure why as she gets lots of love and attention from me. Not as much from dh. DD has never slept alone at night. She still gets hysterical whenever we attempt this. Only some of the anxiety is genuine, some of it an attempt to control us. We're not a united front and I don't want to let her sit up for hours on a school night, which is what she does when asked to sleep by herself. We've asked for help for this but been always dismissed. Separate issue but connected to the anxiety.

To those judgemental.. Perhaps it makes you feel better about yourselves. It does little to help parents with perhaps poorer coping or parenting skills from yours.

OP posts:
TheOccupier · 14/11/2021 21:01

11 years old?
In secondary school?
Not actually that ill?
For only 2 hours?

YABVVVVU.

XelaM · 14/11/2021 21:01

I have an 11-year-old. There is absolutely no problem leaving an 11-year-old home alone for a few hours. You're totally OTT!

11-year-olds travel to school on the own by public transport all over the country. You're wayyyy over protective

fourminutestosavetheworld · 14/11/2021 21:00

I don't see a problem with this either - 11yo in secondary school, minor illness, happy to stay behind, 2 hours, phone.

You left her with her dad so it was his call. It sounds like a changing situation, and he made the appropriate decisions imo. She was left with her grandad, who then did go out for a bike ride - with his phone - since dd seemed well enough to do so.

I don't think your opinion counts for more than that of the other parent, other adults present, grandad, dd herself. Perhaps dh didn't ring to discuss it with you because he just felt confident it was a perfectly acceptable decision.

icedcoffees · 14/11/2021 21:00

[quote Almostmenopausal]@Myotherface I'm with you. In fact I wouldn't be leaving any child alone until 13 personally. In my personal opinion, they need those two years of high school to mature a bit.

It was totally different when we were kids! Also, when I was left home alone at 12, I burnt the house down!!!!! [/quote]
So what would you do with your 11-12 year old after school while you worked?

There's no after school care!

AlohaMolly · 14/11/2021 20:59

I was definitely left alone once a week for two hours when I was in year six because my parents both went to the supermarket together. I think it’s fine op!