Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Planning Breach by the neighbour and the council allowed it

132 replies

compkeen · 14/11/2021 18:06

I have had lot of problems with the council Planning department where I ended up dealing with whole of the planning department members including the senior planner , head of the department and the director of the planning , council members, Local MP . My local councillor stood by me since the last 1 year.
I will put a few bullet points so you get some idea in a nutshell bearing in mind that lot has happened before I got to an unsatisfactory end. Reigate and Banstead council needs to be exposed.

• 2013 – neighbour replaced the window without planning permission. I complained immediately. I was pushed by the senior planners to go to mediation, Citizens advice bureau and various legal bodies. Nothing came out of it. They insisted no law was broken and the neighbour is within his right.

• During the course of 3 years a lot of correspondence took place between the council and myself. The head of the planning insisted the matter came under general planning Development Order and kept dismissing me . I took the advice from a planning consultant and Royal Institute of the Town planning . Both of them concluded that a planning breach has taken place and the council should enforce the window to be replaced with non-opening, glazed ,frosted glass. The opening should be ONLY fanlight opening 1.7 meter above the floor on the neighbour's landing .

• Finally in the end the head of the planning admitted that he got confused and did not interpret the law correctly and apologised.

• The neighbour refused to change the window and the council refuses to enforce the replacement despite the planning breach. The neighbour says he was misguided by the council.

• Meanwhile his window being in the upper elevation of his property, facing my property which is only 3 meters away, and he can look into throughout of my accommodation. There is no privacy in the bedrooms, kitchen, all the living areas , garden, driveway.

• I have been living behind closed curtains , with no privacy anywhere, no light, and spending time at work from 7.30am to 11pm until the neighbours have gone to bed every day. This is obviously is affecting my health, my work, and my mental health. The impact is huge.

• Finally the council, after persuasion by me , offered to pay for the replacement of the window but the neighbour disputed and demanded the council pay for all the decorating , that would be disturbed and the whole hall way and the landing.

• The council decided that the damage to the neighbour’s decoration was more important and as a result his suffering was more serious at my cost and decided to withdraw the offer.

• The head of the planning in the council manipulated the issue by holding a private committee meeting between the councillors and the planning committee members. The planning committee was briefed what to say by him. This way they closed the doors on me and my own local councillor , who was ignored and public was not allowed to listen. There was no planning appeal or any enforcement notice ,thus blocking me to go to any institution with my plea.

• The council chose to action the option which was to tell the neighbour to put restrictors which can be moved or taken out and put opaque film on the window panes. Due to the restrictors, a wide gap would be created in the whole length of the middle of the window . Again I was dismissed when I objected saying that this is absolutely unworkable option because the neighbour can still overlook ‘head on’ into my whole property.

• The council has locked the door on me , thus stopping me going to any institution for complain. I despair that I have to spend rest of my days in my own home overlooked with closed curtains and no light. All my human rights are taken away by the Council. If the head of the planning cannot understand the law or understand how to uphold the law, and mitigate the consequences as a result of it, who can we trust in this borough and where can we go.

OP posts:
Derbee · 15/11/2021 08:32

What is the point of spending thousands of pounds and more years of wasted life by fighting something that has a relatively simple solution? Even if you’re “right” there has to be a certain point where you decide your financial and mental health are more important.

SafeMove · 15/11/2021 08:32

YABVU

LookItsMeAgain · 15/11/2021 08:26

I think, while the suggestions for getting privacy film or net curtains are probably more practical in the long run for the OP, why should the OP have to do this when it was her neighbour that has broken planning laws?
Surely it is up to the neighbour to remedy the issue that they caused?

I'd consider going down the legal route at this point @compkeen. Speak with a solicitor and see if they can guide the planning department to make the 'right' decision by getting the neighbour to fix their issue. It seems like the neighbour was chancing their arm when they were looking for interior decorating to be done following remedy works being carried out but the council kowtowed to them. They don't appear to have taken the fact that you should be able to live in your house without having to have your curtains closed all the time and without the fear of a neighbour looking in all the time.

Best of luck with whatever you decide to do.

PissyMum · 15/11/2021 08:23

@EnidFrighten don’t tell OP to get out of the house more! She’s already out 8am-11pm because she doesn’t want to be seen in her house.

SplodgeWaddler · 15/11/2021 08:19

What an arseachetosspot. Play him at his own game. Get net curtains so he can’t look in then set up “security” cameras between the nets and the window.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 15/11/2021 08:15

You can put nets, or frosted film or a combination.
You are probably in the right but it's only you that are suffering.
Or sell the house. It is highly unlikely to bother another person so much.

VioletPetals · 15/11/2021 08:09

I think the issue is we can all look at this and think…
7 years, you’ve been letting this rule your life for 7 years…. Human rights, pfft, ok 🤔….. everyone can see into someone’s windows, you are making this a bigger deal than it really is…..

The thing is if you are living with a situation like this it does become all consuming.

We lived with nosy neighbours, they has a window on their upstairs landing at the side that faces the front of our house, I’m pretty sure they had a chair set up there so that they could take it in turns to just sit and watch our house.
Every time we left the house, even to go to the bin one of them would appear and start questioning us about something we had been doing that day.
Whenever we had anyone at the house, a friend family member or a plumber they would be knocking on the door with some random question or request just so they could get a look and try to figure out who the visitor was, we even caught them going through our wheelie bins on more than one occasion “just checking the right stuff was in the right bins”
It felt suffocating and although we knew they weren’t always watching you always feel on edge because they could be watching.

We only let it go on for a couple of months before we put up the window film and planted some privacy screening plants, eventually they lost interest because we weren’t as interesting when they couldn’t see much going on.

So I do see why the OP is so distraught.

Sugarandtime · 15/11/2021 08:08

@garlictwist

It's unfortunate but I think you have really made this a bigger deal than it needs to be.

A lot of houses stare straight into their neighbours - we are on a row of terraces and look right across into the houses opposite and yes, I see my neighbours living their lives.

So what?

If you're bothered about them seeing you naked close the curtains when you change but other than that I'm not sure your neighbours care that much.

I’m assuming you knew that there were already windows looking straight into each other’s homes when you chose to live in your home.

That’s a completely different situation to the OP

AChickenCalledDaal · 15/11/2021 08:04

Even when there is a breach of planning control, the Council is perfectly entitled to decide that there isn't enough harm to justify enforcing against it. In fact, they are required to make that judgement. Councils are heavily criticised at appeal - and potentially penalised financially - if they enforce against something that isn't actually causing a great deal of harm.

That does not mean anyone is corrupt, related to the neighbour or making dodgy decisions behind closed doors. It does sound like someone may have made a mistake at the beginning of the process, but eight years in, it doesn't sound as if there is any chance that mistake is going to be fixed in the way you would like.

Eight years of fighting will undoubtedly be contributing to your mental health issues - please find a way of learning to live with the situation.

EnidFrighten · 15/11/2021 08:02

I understand how this sort of thing can get under your skin, I lived somewhere with noise issues from adjoining businesses once and it really took over my head.

But - we live for about 80 years OP, if we're lucky. You've spent almost ten on this. Even if you're in the right and they're in the wrong, you need to find a way to not let it dominate your life. Nets, trees, whatever. Get out of your house more as well. Move house if that's the only thing that will work.

If the window was put back to how it used to be tomorrow, would all this anxiety go away? Would you be happy living by your neighbour then? If not, cut your losses and move on.

PissyMum · 15/11/2021 08:02

I’d put up something like a basketball ring with a massive back board in front of his window. But equally I wouldn’t spend 7 years of my life out of my house in case my neighbour saw my in there. Loads of houses look directly in to other houses and most people manage to live their lives in a completely normal, boring manner.

Derbee · 15/11/2021 07:55

I think you need to cover your windows with that privacy film. You won’t even notice it, and it will give you total protection.

Sitting in your house, with all your windows closed, feeling like your neighbour is spending 16hrs per day watching you, is no way to live. If it’s really only about the window, buy and install the film. If not, see your GP because you might need a bit of help

Ozanj · 15/11/2021 07:55

@Yusanaim

This is appalling - how many other illegal plans is that planner passing - are brown envelopes changing hands?. No wonder they get a bad reputation. Can you afford a private investigator to see if he is relative /friend of neighbour?
Yes do this. Local planning department passed a similar thing with my friend and in her desperation she hired a PI to find that the family were close relations of the mayor & he had personally intervened to ensure nothing was investigated. My friend wrote a detailed letter outlining the findings and made it clear she would go to the media if the council did not reopen her complaint. Within a year of this the structure was demolished. So it does work.
user1491404899 · 15/11/2021 07:54

The op doesn't sound well.....

Platax · 15/11/2021 07:49

OP, have you taken this to the Local Government Ombudsman?

BettyBag · 15/11/2021 07:38

Fucking hell, I'd hate to see OPs reaction to a real problem.

Every single window in my house can be looked into by a neighbouring house. The back used to be okay until a developer threw up some house round there. It's just part of living in the world. We have a different window set up in each room depending on the light and how much we care about people being able to look into that particular area.

Is this a middle class thing? The expectation that nobody can see into your Windows?

Tubs11 · 15/11/2021 07:23

And I agree with pp, you sound like very hard work hence why your neighbors digging his heels in.

Tubs11 · 15/11/2021 07:21

Why don't you get that mirrored film for glass windows. That way he's looking at himself when he looks out, you get full use of your windows and it's a cheap solution

Littlecaf · 15/11/2021 07:17

@Yusanaim a bribe what for a window? That’s PD now (8 years later) anyway? Don’t be so silly.

Instagram · 15/11/2021 07:16

I would contact a council ombudsman and if not helpful and finances allow a civil court proceeding.
It may affect you when you goto sell the house so do bear in mind.
I’m not overly familiar with English law but surely your local MP could escalate this possible conflict of interest/loophole in council competence/discretion to parliament.
You can also email to number 10 Downing Street and get a personal written response.

EveningOverRooftops · 15/11/2021 06:45

You plant a tree. A big fuck of tree. Then move.

Yusanaim · 15/11/2021 06:18

This is appalling - how many other illegal plans is that planner passing - are brown envelopes changing hands?. No wonder they get a bad reputation.
Can you afford a private investigator to see if he is relative /friend of neighbour?

Selttan · 15/11/2021 06:16

See I'm petty so I'd probably do something like put a mirror in the window so the sun hit it just right and reflected it into the neighbours window.

Penners99 · 15/11/2021 05:53

OP, you are a perfect example of the neighbour from hell.

Twocrabs30 · 15/11/2021 05:16

Go the the ombudsman:

www.lgo.org.uk/