Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend refusing to share bottle of spirit at party

257 replies

IreneSmith · 14/11/2021 13:22

So, I want some opinions, who is right, me or my friend?

A group of friends get together for a party, we then move onto drinking games.

Now usually whenever anyone brings spirits or anything to a party (myself included) its for everyone to drink...at least I thought.

So, I start pouring the next drink to be used in the game when one of my friends grabs the bottle out of my hand forcefully (literally).

This one friend refused to allow her bottle of spirit to be used in drinking games, as according to her it was a gift to the host (another friend) and not for wasting in drinking games.

My issue it 3 fold:

  1. It was outside on the main table and open, so I thought its fair for anyone to drink/use it. (If host wanted to keep it, they would have out it away)
  1. It was a bottle of Jack Daniel...which imo is only good as a mixer or for drinking games. (I.e. it wasn't a proper whisky, brandy, cognac or fine wine)
  1. It was very rude to just grab the bottle out of my hand forcefully. She could have let me finish pouring the drink, then explained how she felt and asked if we could use something else / another bottle going forward.

The host looked perplexed when this happened and didnt say anything, they didnt care either way / it got awkward.

Imo, I think my friend was being awkward and rude (the bottle grabbing really annoyed me). Am I wrong, is she wrong?

OP posts:
drpet49 · 14/11/2021 16:56

** Your friend is being unreasonable for the fact it no longer belonged to her. It was a gift for the host so it wasn't up to her to dictate how the JD would be drunk.

It was the hosts' place to say something and she didn't. Thus, your friend is bu.**

^This

IreneSmith · 14/11/2021 16:56

@Bumblenums1234

All but 2 people

OP posts:
me4real · 14/11/2021 16:55

Twice, someone has given me something good and i've put it away, but as the night went on they suggested cracking it open / bringing it out. And guess what, I brought it out and poured it for everyone, and left it out after.

That's you and the person who gave you the gift @IreneSmith . Someone else might do something else or feel something else should be done. and that's fine.

The gift-giver might've felt that they'd want the person who'd received the gift to say it was ok before iit was used.

You went to use a present someone had given without asking the person who'd been given it. And even if the host was ok with it, the (maybe drunk) giver thought it shouldn't be used, at least without the receiver agreeing to it beforehand.

It being out on the side might just be where it happened to be put.

IreneSmith · 14/11/2021 16:53

@TractorAndHeadphones

That could well have been the case

OP posts:
Tilltheend99 · 14/11/2021 16:52

Maybe as we are all here we should say what we consider posh booze to be Grin I have no taste so would be happy if someone brought Sours or Aftershock or some tequila. If I’m imagining something posh it’s a flavoured Absolute Vodka or any kind of champagne without the name of a supermarket on it GrinGrin

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 16:50

@IreneSmith

Just to clarify a few things:

This isnt a BYOB party. Its 1 friend inviting everyone for drinks at theirs for their birthday, and providing 90% of the alcohol (even if nobody brought anything, there would be plenty of alcohol left outside provided by the host). E.g. the drinking games were 90% done using the hosts provided alcohol.

Im not sure why people find the above surprising. Whenever I host, I provide the booze for everyone as well.

If someone gives me something in my hand (i.e. a bottle) and its good, I might keep it safe, or if its normal leave it outside for everyone.

Or if the attendee, brings a bottle of spirit or wine and leaves it outside, Ill leave it outside, as im guessing they brought it for everyone to share.

Twice, someone has given me something good and i've put it away, but as the night went on they suggested cracking it open / bringing it out. And guess what, I brought it out and poured it for everyone, and left it out after.

I just cant understand what some people are saying in terms of you can only play drinking games if your bottle is being used, etc...

Yeah this is exactly what I thought happened Honestly OP maybe she thought the bottle of JD was supposed to be a gift and wasn't happy with the host leaving it out to begin with, or everyone else's bottle got taken to the back except hers, or she had some other beef with you. I don't know.

To me table all table opened alcohol is equal

IreneSmith · 14/11/2021 16:50

@TractorAndHeadphones

Well put Grin

(And yes, I did pick JD on purpose, as I wanted to use a strong drink/spirit, but also pick one where it wouldn't have been a waste of a "good" spirit/drink. I guess the latter aspect is very subjective depending on your POV of Jack Daniels.)

OP posts:
Bumblenums1234 · 14/11/2021 16:49

Op, can you clarify if everyone at the party was playing the game?

Tilltheend99 · 14/11/2021 16:46

*any

Tilltheend99 · 14/11/2021 16:46

I wouldn’t describe and bottle of spirits as cheap (except maybe some Asda own brand vodka) but neither would I think of Jack Daniels as a ‘luxury’ drink (this doesn’t mean I don’t appreciate that many people can’t afford a bottle) It would literally have to be some special aged version bought at duty free in America or something to get super worked up about it.

IreneSmith · 14/11/2021 16:45

Just to clarify a few things:

This isnt a BYOB party. Its 1 friend inviting everyone for drinks at theirs for their birthday, and providing 90% of the alcohol (even if nobody brought anything, there would be plenty of alcohol left outside provided by the host). E.g. the drinking games were 90% done using the hosts provided alcohol.

Im not sure why people find the above surprising. Whenever I host, I provide the booze for everyone as well.

If someone gives me something in my hand (i.e. a bottle) and its good, I might keep it safe, or if its normal leave it outside for everyone.

Or if the attendee, brings a bottle of spirit or wine and leaves it outside, Ill leave it outside, as im guessing they brought it for everyone to share.

Twice, someone has given me something good and i've put it away, but as the night went on they suggested cracking it open / bringing it out. And guess what, I brought it out and poured it for everyone, and left it out after.

I just cant understand what some people are saying in terms of you can only play drinking games if your bottle is being used, etc...

OP posts:
me4real · 14/11/2021 16:45

It sounds like she really values alcohol- or maybe she doesn't have much money so that was a significant gift for her to have given to someone (it probably would be to me.) Jack Daniels isn't that crap, it's a nice present.

It was very rude to just grab the bottle out of my hand forcefully. She could have let me finish pouring the drink, then explained how she felt and asked if we could use something else / another bottle going forward.

Yes but she was trying to stop you using it at all, not wanting you to use it once and then her say 'I'd rather you didn't, old chum.' The present that she had brought she valued and meant for the host, whether the host realized that or not.

And she'd probably had a few drinks.

PrescriptionOnlyMedicine · 14/11/2021 16:40

I’m really pleased you started this thread, OP. I’m loving the booze snobbery.

ROFL

Tilltheend99 · 14/11/2021 16:40

@KittenCatcher

JD is the USA oldest whisky, its 40% proof and expensive, I wouldnt use it for a drinking game unless I wanted to be unconscious.
I don’t think we get the good stuff over here. Might be a trade deal thing that protects the scotch whiskey as I think there is a limit on what Scottish whiskey can be imported to US too.
Bumblenums1234 · 14/11/2021 16:37

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

Well from the OP, it sounds like everyone I'm attendance was playing the game and the op was just the one to pour the next round. I imagine that includes the friend in question. If everyone is playing, all drinks are fair game as far as I'm concerned.

Why didn't the op offer up the bottle she took over then? Confused

Sounds like she gave it to the host, same as he friend did. The host put out the JD and kept OP's bottle out back. How is that the OP's fault?
TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 16:36

[quote ABCeasyasdohrayme]@TractorAndHeadphones it's true that the value is subjective. However the op has decided the JD her friend took over was cheap and crap and only good for using in a game. She is putting her own, particularly arrogant, view on what the friends alcohol is good for, while not contributing anything herself.

I don't care what anyone drinks, I don't care how much it costs, but I certainly wouldn't look down my nose at anyone's choices and make a decision about what their contribution should be used for based on my personal taste.

The op was rude.[/quote]
The OP seems to have 2 categories : luxury alcohols, and everything else. From what she said JD is not in the former category. We don't know that she picked the JD in particular. She might have just picked the nearest open bottle.

We also don't know what the party's expectations were. Was everyone supposed to bring a bottle? Had the host provided enough alcohol - but decided to put some brought by guests out anyway? So the OP's not being shared didn't matter because it wasn't the point. She wasn't told to bring what she'd drink.

You're right that nobody's contributions should be looked down upon but in my experience anything that's on the table is fair game. I would find anybody protesting that 'their' contribution was too special to be used for X purpose strange because if the bottle was a host gift it's the host's to do what they like. And the host opened it and left it on a table. It's not the contributor's anymore!

Tilltheend99 · 14/11/2021 16:35

I mean, isn’t the point of bringing a bottle for the host that it is used as part of drinks for the party?

Some people squirrel these away if they are particularly posh but usually it’s some old shit that nobody wants.

Also, people sometimes bring a bottle if it’s something they drink but they know the host won’t have and then they open it themselves and leave whatever is left for the host. Maybe this was your friends plan.

JD is really not all that, and if it was open then someone must have already had some which makes it more odd.

If it was a present for the host because it was their favourite then maybe. How old were all the people involved? People my age and older tend to share/bring drinks and buy rounds in pubs but we have noticed that people 25 and under don’t really do this anymore and just buy their own.

Skysblue · 14/11/2021 16:27

I can’t believe you’re playing drinking games in your thirties 🤣

I can’t believe you’re arguing about whose booze is whose at a party in your thirties 🤣🤣

Total respect to you all for having a lot more fun than me though.

Anyway - if you all get on fine then she was unreasonable, but my guess is she has some kind of problem with you eg thinks you drink more than you contribute and that this was why she grabbed the bottle…

Itsnotallaboutyoubaby · 14/11/2021 16:26

If we were having drinking games we would generally use something like tequila, sambuca or some kind of vodka sour.

Can’t ever remember using JD as a shot.

Also can’t remember the last time we played a drinking game but that’s neither here nor there.

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 14/11/2021 16:21

Well from the OP, it sounds like everyone I'm attendance was playing the game and the op was just the one to pour the next round. I imagine that includes the friend in question. If everyone is playing, all drinks are fair game as far as I'm concerned.

Why didn't the op offer up the bottle she took over then? Confused

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 14/11/2021 16:19

@TractorAndHeadphones it's true that the value is subjective. However the op has decided the JD her friend took over was cheap and crap and only good for using in a game. She is putting her own, particularly arrogant, view on what the friends alcohol is good for, while not contributing anything herself.

I don't care what anyone drinks, I don't care how much it costs, but I certainly wouldn't look down my nose at anyone's choices and make a decision about what their contribution should be used for based on my personal taste.

The op was rude.

Bumblenums1234 · 14/11/2021 16:18

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

When I host I lay out booze on the table for people to drink. I would be irritated by someone asking me if they could have some every 5 minutes.

Do you do that with buffets or bring a dish meals too? If not, what's the difference?

There's a huge difference between people pouring the odd drink from a bottle you took over, and your whole bottle of alcohol being polished off in 10 minutes of doing shots and leaving none of the bottle at all for the rest of the evening.

Well from the OP, it sounds like everyone I'm attendance was playing the game and the op was just the one to pour the next round. I imagine that includes the friend in question. If everyone is playing, all drinks are fair game as far as I'm concerned.
Neurodiversitydoctor · 14/11/2021 16:15

YABU for playing drinking games in your 30's and drinking Jack Daniels. Grow up.

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/11/2021 16:07

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

I still can't believe that people think £20 wine or a bottle of JD isn't expensive.

I drink the cheap aldi version of peach schnapps when I have a drink, and consider spending a tenner on archers a huge treat 😂😂

The value of alcohol is subjective. I don't consider £20 wine expensive on the basis that a 'treat myself' bottle would cost more. £15 - £20 is what I'd bring for a host gift/serve at a dinner I host if wine is expected with the meal. If I wanted to get red wine drunk (which I rarely do nowadays) then £5 is the max.

Lots of people consider the above pretentious, but don't mind paying £6 for a pint or £10 for a cocktail (this is the price in a lot of 'ordinary' Manchester bars, the fancier ones cost more). I consider this expensive but then I don't like going out for drinks anyway.

mam0918 · 14/11/2021 16:07

RosieGuacamosie - this is a great point... I had never heard of Lansons (as I'm clearly common as shit and don't sip champaign at parties) but I just googled it - it costs the same as a bottle of Jack Daniels lol.