Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

6 year old saying she loves Granny as much as me

82 replies

Cantfindthatgrip · 14/11/2021 09:53

Hello! Just as the title says really. My 6 year old says I love you and granny the same. I find this so upsetting. My mum was an awful, emotionally neglectful parent and is no better towards me now. She is just totally disinterested in my life, always has been. She treated my brother totally differently. She is good with my children but constantly mentions my brothers children (who she sees daily) and my DD does comment on this. We live far away from each other and she visits every couple or months. This is too much for me but she is so demanding, forceful and overrides anything I say. For example, she wanted to visit, I had had COVID, was still unwell and asked if we could postpone her visit. She refused and I felt totally powerless to stop her coming. She came and it was horrible as usual. I feel like I should allow her contact with my child because she loves my DD and my DD has fun when she visits (showered with gifts, fun days out). I feel guilty and selfish for the way I feel but it absolutely broke my heart when she said I love Granny the same as you. All the feelings of rejection came back, of never being good enough. I can't shake this feeling. I've tried my absolute best with my DD to give her all the love, stability, security that I didn't have. We have a wonderful relationship and I love the absolute bones of her. How to I get over this hurt? I wish I could go NC with my mother but it would break my grandparents hearts. My partner is completely supportive of me and despises my mother for the way she has behaved (which has had a long term impact on me) and her complete disregard for anyone but herself. I would say she is a narcissist but I know I am not placed to diagnose this! Why would mu 6 year old say this? Where have I gone wrong? Thanks!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AmyDudley · 14/11/2021 16:34

I is hurtful and I understand your feelings, but i would take it as your DD not actually making a comparison, just in the moment of getting a toy saying thats he really loves granny (because she got her a toy). Also kid talk total nonsense a lot of the time - with no concept that what they say may be hrtful - they just aren't that nuanced to make distinctions, love is love. You love your Mum your Dad your Barbie, next doors dog, Granny and batman.
I remember saying to my Dad about that age 'I don't love you as much as I love Uncle Tom, he's my real dad' I adored my Dad, absolutely adored him, I was very fond of my Uncle Tom but he wasn't in the same league!Grin I was just spouting rubbish.

My only cautionary note would be, as your Mum treated you badly and still favours your DB's kids, just watch out for her playing with your DD's affections or saying anything negative about her or hurting her. Abusive people can play all sorts of games as I'm sure you know.

Cantfindthatgrip · 14/11/2021 15:56

Thanks so much everyone for all the kind and considered replies, lots of good advice too. To answer re the context, my DD was playing with a toy that Granny had sent in the post and she sighed and said I love granny sooo much. I love her just the same as you. I just replied, that's lovely and I know granny loves you very much. I have never and would never push my own feelings on my DD. I really think I need therapy with this as I can't go on like this, it's just too painful. I would give anything to go NC with mother but my children have a relationship with her and I have a very close and supportive (and normal) extended family that I would be clueless how to manage if I was nc with mother. Thanks again for all the words of wisdom!

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 14/11/2021 14:06

I think this is just kids TBH as above PP have said."Out of the mouths of babes" as they say .She probably loves her DGM as she is made a big fuss of and spoilt. She loves you ,but just enjoys seeing Granny! Maybe you could arrange some counselling as to how to manage your DMs behaviour going forwards .There was a lady who had felt scared of her DM for 55 years ,and is now 60! Dont let that be you. She needs to accept some boundaries now .If you are ill ,then she cant come round till you are better .simple as that.

1forAll74 · 14/11/2021 13:14

I think that you need to take a more realistic view of children and their grandparents, and not base it on your own views of your Mother.

Bluetrews25 · 14/11/2021 12:54

Ouch. That was a stinger! But she will love you most, no doubt at all.

At what age does it become acceptable to say 'granny wasn't very kind to mummy when mummy was little, and can still be a bit unkind now. So we will not be seeing as much of her going forwards because we don't want her to be unkind to you at some point' (Or is this not the way to go at all?)

I hope you are able to self preserve, OP. Flowers

NoSquirrels · 14/11/2021 12:53

How did it come up? What was the surrounding conversation?

Cordeliathecat · 14/11/2021 12:51

What would you rather? That your mum and daughter don’t get along and that your daughter doesn’t like her grandmother? Or that your daughter is happy and loves all her family deeply?

I don’t like my mother (do love her though) or my MIL but I am very pleased that both my children adore their grandparents and are adored in return. I am grateful that they don’t have the complicated feelings that I have towards my family and I pray that continues into adulthood.

KlaraSun · 14/11/2021 12:50

I was you op and now my girl is 14. I have mixed feelings about the whole thing. My daughter has really benefited from a loving relationship with her granny and her auntie (both toxic people) and I like that. However I now realise that she would/ will be devastated if I tell her what happened during my childhood. And she'll probably be angry with me rather than them. I'm not so sure that I was right to cultivate these relationships

CreepySpider · 14/11/2021 12:46

Your six year old has no concept of what your mum has put you through or a full understanding of her own emotions. I imagine one day she has a best friend and the next she hates them and is never playing with them again, whereas the reality is she really likes her friend and doesn’t mean it at all.

It’s hard to hear what she has said but the reality is that most young children love their primary care giver more than anyone.

TurnUpTurnip · 14/11/2021 12:41

@Wheresmywoolyjumpers

I think your mother has been coaching her. She’s too young to understand what she is saying.
Yet many on this thread say their 6 year olds say the same thing?
Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 14/11/2021 12:34

I think your mother has been coaching her. She’s too young to understand what she is saying.

WoolyMammoth55 · 14/11/2021 12:32

Haven't RTFT apologies but - OP there's 2 issues in your post.

  1. your DD said a cute thing - she doesn't understand what it means but she's just being loving and adorable. This is all good and nothing to worry about. You're her mum, if she's ill she wants you, if she has a nightmare she wants you - you don't have to question this. Take a breath, relax.

  2. your own mother is abusive and controlling and disrespecting your boundaries. This has nothing to do with your DD and it is up to you how you are going to deal with it. Personally I'd go NC if I were you. Your mental health is important and it's great to model to your DD that you have put a healthy boundary in place to take care of yourself.

These 2 things seem related but they really aren't. You don't have a DD problem, you have a problem with your own mum. You're putting your needs at the back of a line, behind your GPs, your mum, your DD - this is wrong. I really encourage you to show your DD what self-care looks like by modelling it to her. Best of luck Flowers

JojobaFromOctober · 14/11/2021 12:26

My 6 year old loves Granny more than me. My 4 year old wants his friend's mum to be his mum, but he kindly told me that I could be his spare mum.

Artichokeleaves · 14/11/2021 12:24

Flowers From your OP this has hit all sorts of buttons for you. I agree with PP, this is a good time to find a counsellor and get some help with what you're carrying around and to work through what boundaries might work.

At six, dd is saying things she doesn't really understand the content of yet, and what happens to be in her head in the moment, she's far too little to say this kind of thing with any real belief or meaning. She might be having a lovely time with granny, but her instincts and bond with you is something primal and if she was afraid or hurt she would have no trouble at all in knowing the difference between you and anyone else on the planet.

You need support to get this insecurity managed so it hurts you a whole lot less.

Cherrysoup · 14/11/2021 12:16

You need to put boundaries in place. You don’t want her coming, you tell her no, on repeat. If she turns up, tell her you said no.

Mybalconyiscracking · 14/11/2021 12:15

Also, anyone remember the
“Daddy or Chips?” adverts?

Mybalconyiscracking · 14/11/2021 12:14

I once accused my 6yo of loving her teacher more than me.
She replied very primly “Mummy, I love you both the same.”

TurnUpTurnip · 14/11/2021 12:14

Gosh I wish my kids loved my mum as much as me, they don’t ever want to go anywhere with her or spend time with her or go to her house 😬

Ellie56 · 14/11/2021 12:11

You haven't gone wrong anywhere. She is just being 6. Unless your mother is somehow coaching her to say these things?

The dynamic with your mother sounds very unhealthy. I would start being less available when she wants to visit.

5keletor · 14/11/2021 12:08

I'm pretty sure my toddler would tell you he loves food more than me or his dad, he did also go through a phase of wanting dad all the time and not being that fussed about me. 😅
Although if it's true, it is nice that she loves her grandma so much, I wouldn't worry about it.

Itsjustrenee · 14/11/2021 12:07

Are you being serious. How on earth is a six year old supposed to know all that. She’s simply speaking as she feels.

Your mother sounds similar to mine. I went no contact about 15 years ago. It was the best thing I ever did. I can’t recommend it highly enough. Don’t allow her to control how you feel now 💐

TherapistInATabard · 14/11/2021 12:06

@insancerre

You haven’t gone wrong You’ve raised a child who is loving and sees the best in people- you’ve done a good job
That is an absolutely lovely response and I completely agree.
Kitkat151 · 14/11/2021 11:56

@Cocovivid

She's 6. She doesn't understand whats gone on in your past.

Just smile and say 'that's lovely'

Don't take it to heart.

This My GC say they love me more than their Mum when she has told them off ..... Kids are fickle
Peanutbuttercupisyum · 14/11/2021 11:48

A 6yo doesn’t even really understand the concept of love!! She just means she really really likes hanging out with her granny!
My 6yo loves her teacher, her dog, her toy cat more than me...whatevs

amsadandconfused · 14/11/2021 11:42

How does a child or anyone actually measure love? The love I feel for my children is a different love that I had for my darling Mum . I really genuinely wouldn’t be too bothered. You have done a fantastic job fascilitating a relationship between your Mother and Child💐